Applying a radio-frequency electric field to an expanding ultracold neutral plasma leads to the observation of as many as six peaks in the emission of electrons from the plasma. These are identified as collective modes of the plasma and are in qualitative agreement with a model of Tonks-Dattner resonances, electron sound waves propagating in a finite-sized, inhomogeneous plasma. Such modes may provide an accurate method to determine the time-dependent electron temperature.
Applying a radio-frequency electric field to an expanding ultracold neutral plasma leads to the observation of as many as six peaks in the emission of electrons from the plasma. These are identified as collective modes of the plasma and are in qualitative agreement with a model of Tonks-Dattner resonances, electron sound waves propagating in a finite-sized, inhomogeneous plasma. Such modes may provide an accurate method to determine the time-dependent electron temperature.
We discuss a theoretical interpretation of the experiment by Fletcher, Zhang, and Rolston [PRL, 96, 105003 (2006)], who revealed a number of subharmonics of the electron emission under external irradiation of the freely-expanding clouds of ultracold plasmas. The original interpretation of these subharmonics as standing waves of plasma oscillations (the so-called Tonks-Dattner resonances) encounters a number of problems, such as the lack of adequate boundary conditions and incorrect dependence on the plasma temperature and the degree of neutrality. It is the aim of the present comment to mention that a more promising interpretation may be based on the peaks in the efficiency of ionization of the secondary Rydberg atoms, formed during the plasma cloud expansion and cooling. The presence of the last-mentioned peaks is well supported by the independent experiment by Maeda and Gallagher [PRL, 93, 193002 (2004)].
One of the most interesting phenomena in the ultracold plasmas is multiple subharmonics of the electron emission observed after its irradiation by the monochromatic radio waves. Unfortunately, the early interpretation of this phenomenon as the so-called Tonks–Dattner resonances (i.e., actually the standing Langmuir waves) encountered many serious obstacles, such as a lack of adequate boundary conditions, an incorrect dependence on the electron temperature, and an insensitivity to the shape of the cloud. Here, we suggest an alternative interpretation based on the quasi-classical multiphoton ionization of the “secondary” Rydberg atoms formed in the expanding and cooling plasma clouds. As follows from our numerical simulations, the efficiency of such ionization exhibits a series of well-expressed peaks. Moreover, this process is irrelevant to the boundary conditions and global shape of the cloud. Therefore, this should be a viable alternative to the earlier idea of Tonks–Dattner resonances.
Ultracold neutral plasmas, created by photoionizing samples of laser-cooled atoms, have well-controlled initial density and temperature parameters. With initial particle peak densities of ~10^15 m^-3, initial ion temperatures in the tens of micro-Kelvin range, and initial electron temperatures with a controllable range of 1-1000 K, these systems provide a means to study otherwise laboratory-inaccessible parameter ranges for plasma research. Furthermore, these plasmas are inhomogeneous, unconfined, and freely expanding into a vacuum. Despite the extraordinarily low electron temperatures, the electron system remains weakly coupled, although the ion system exhibits strong coupling behavior. While the initial electron temperatures are very low in ultracold plasmas, the temperature evolution has only been measured indirectly, in the earliest ~5% of the plasma lifetime, and often with large uncertainties. We present a technique that, with further theoretical support, can provide straightforward temperature measurements throughout the first fifth of the plasma lifetime. By making use of collective modes of the plasma, we fit a model of Tonks-Dattner resonances (electron sound wave propagating in the plasma) to measurements of these resonances and obtain a time-dependent electron temperature measurement for the ultracold plasma. Three-body recombination, a plasma loss process that has a rate scaling with the -9/2 power of the electron temperature, is of obvious interest in these ultracold plasma systems. Several theoretical works have predicted that the three-body recombination rate expression would need to be modified at these low electron temperatures, although the validity of these changes often hinges on the electron system being strongly coupled. We have performed the lowest temperature measurements of three-body recombination rates in a plasma and show that these measurements potentially provide a low-uncertainty means to calculate electron temperatures.
Calculations of the spectrum of eigen oscillations of an inhomogeneous ultracold plasma are presented both in the absence and in the presence of charge imbalance. The collective modes of these plasma oscillations are recorded in experiments as absorption resonances of a radio frequency electric field. It is shown that in the presence of friction of the electronic component, a discrete spectrum of plasma eigen oscillations is formed. The dependence of the frequency of these resonances on the plasma expansion time in the presence of a charge imbalance is obtained. There is good agreement with the experiments of different authors.
Using a new technique to directly detect current induced on a nearby electrode, we measure plasma oscillations in ultracold plasmas, which are influenced by the inhomogeneous and time-varying density and changing neutrality. Electronic detection avoids heating and evaporation dynamics associated with previous measurements and allows us to test the importance of the plasma neutrality. We apply dc and pulsed electric fields to control the electron loss rate and find that the charge imbalance of the plasma has a significant effect on the resonant frequency, in excellent agreement with recent predictions suggesting coupling to an edge mode.
We report the observation of plasma oscillations in an ultracold neutral plasma. With this collective mode we probe the electron density distribution and study the expansion of the plasma as a function of time. For classical plasma conditions, i.e., weak Coulomb coupling, the expansion is dominated by the pressure of the electron gas and is described by a hydrodynamic model. Discrepancies between the model and observations at low temperature and high density may be due to strong coupling of the electrons.