Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Canadian Journal of Physics

A phase space moment method for classical and quantal dynamics

Ralph Eric Turner, Robert F. Snider

Published Mar 1, 1981• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A hierarchy of translational moment equations for the position and momentum observables is considered. The resulting set of equations is truncated in a manner that includes only first and second order moments. This closure procedure is consistent with the conservation of energy and, for spherically symmetric potentials, with the conservation of angular momentum. The method is valid for both classical and quantal mechanics with the only difference being that for quantal systems, the dispersions in momentum and position must satisfy Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. With finite dispersion in the position, the average position and momentum do not satisfy Hamilton's equations of motion since the average acceleration is modulated by the variance–covariance in the position. For classical systems, the second order moments may be taken to zero in which case Hamilton's equations are obtained. For quantal systems, a comparision is made with Heller's Gaussian wave packet approach. The moment method is illustrated by applying it to the reflection of a phase space packet from a one dimensional repulsive inverse square potential. Applications to the calculation of collision cross sections are envisaged.

DOI
10.1139/p81-057

Related papers

On a Lagrange-Hamilton formalism describing position and momentum uncertainties

Dieter Schuch

According to Heisenberg's uncertainty relation, in quantum mechanics it is not possible to determine, simultaneously, exact values for the position and the momentum of a material system. Calculating the mean value of the Hamiltonian operator with the aid of exact analytic Gaussian wave packet solutions, these uncertainties cause an energy contribution additional to the classical energy of the system. For the harmonic oscillator, e.g., this nonclassical energy represents the ground state energy. It will be shown that this additional energy contribution can be considered as a Hamiltonian function, if it is written in appropriate variables. With the help of the usual Lagrange-Hamilton formalism known from classical particle mechanics, but now considering this new Hamiltonian function, it is possible to obtain the equations of motion for position and momentum uncertainties.

•Jan 1, 1993•0 citations

Superoperator methods of calculating cross sections: III. Unified description of classical and quantal scattering

Ralph Eric Turner, Robert F. Snider

It is shown how differential cross sections can be obtained from the time dependence of phase space packets. This procedure is valid both for classical and quantum mechanics. Two methods are described. In one the trajectory of the packet is emphasized, while in the second the packet is appropriately spread to infinite size. Both methods are applicable to either mechanics. It is shown how the quantal results agree with those of the stationary state approach as formulated in terms of the density operator. The description is also used to elucidate the difference between the scattered flux and the generalized flux that arises naturally in the superoperator formulation.

Canadian Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1980•13 citations

Quantized Hamilton dynamics for a general potential

Oleg V. Prezhdo, Yu. V. Pereverzev

The quantization of Hamilton dynamics (QHD) [J. Chem. Phys. 113, 6557 (2000)] that efficiently generalizes classical mechanics to include quantum tunneling and zero-point energy effects is extended to a general position dependent potential. A Taylor series expansion of the potential is considered both around a fixed point and around the moving instantaneous value of the position variable. The equations-of-motion obtained for the moving frame are significantly simpler than for the fixed frame, while still satisfying the classical limit. The number of the QHD variables and the order of the Taylor expansion of the potential constitute two independent approximation parameters. Conservation of the total energy and the Heisenberg commutator relationship is established for the second-order QHD that includes linear and quadratic variables. The formal results are illustrated by examples, including the harmonic oscillator, tunneling in a doublewell potential, and energy exchange between coupled Morse oscillators representing the stretching vibrations of the SPC-F water molecule commonly used in molecular dynamics simulations. QHD provides an improvement over classical mechanics in all cases. The QHD data agree with the exact data in the large ℏ quantum limit and in the ℏ=0 classical limit, with deviations observed for the intermediate ℏ values, depending on the system and initial conditions. QHD provides a quantitative short time approximation. The second-order QHD becomes inappropriate when quantum wave packets split. Higher-order QHD approximations are required in such cases. The second-order QHD is particularly suitable for the description of zero-point energy effects and properly treats moderate tunneling events.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 15, 2002•59 citations

A comparison of local and global single Gaussian approximations to time dynamics: One-dimensional systems

Ralph Eric Turner, Robert F. Snider

The detailed calculation of the dynamics of a chemical system is usually not considered due to the size and cost of the computation. It is thus useful to examine various approximation methods. Such methods first need to be tried out on simple systems, like one-dimensional motion. Here two approaches to approximating the solutions of the Schrödinger and von Neumann equations by single time-dependent Gaussians are explored and contrasted, explicitly for one-dimensional barrier penetration. The first approach, in which no tunneling occurs, is local in nature and characterized by an expansion of the equations of motion to second order about the average position of the Gaussian wave packet or about the average position and momentum of the Gaussian Wigner function. This approach was first introduced by Heller [E. J. Heller, J. Chem. Phys. 62, 1544 (1975)]. Here both Heller’s approach and a more general truncation method are considered. Indeed tunneling can be incorporated if second-order terms in the quantal von Neumann equation are included. However, the resulting dynamics is unstable for kinetic energies where the exact wavepacket (and Wigner function) splits into nonnegligible parts that represent reflection and transmission. In contrast, the second approach is a global method which is obtained by applying appropriate closure approximations to the equations of motion for the first- and second-order position and momentum expectation values. This method allows tunneling and is stable at all kinetic energies. It is also possible to approximate the global equations in such a way that the local equations are obtained.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 15, 1987•8 citations

Time-dependent approach to semiclassical dynamics

Eric J. Heller

In this paper we develop a new approach to semiclassical dynamics which exploits the fact that extended wavefunctions for heavy particles (or particles in harmonic potentials) may be decomposed into time−dependent wave packets, which spread minimally and which execute classical or nearly classical trajectories. A Gaussian form for the wave packets is assumed and equations of motion are derived for the parameters characterizing the Gaussians. If the potential (which may be nonseparable in many coordinates) is expanded in a Taylor series about the instantaneous center of the (many−particle) wave packet, and up to quadratic terms are kept, we find the classical parameters of the wave packet (positions, momenta) obey Hamilton’s equation of motion. Quantum parameters (wave packet spread, phase factor, correlation terms, etc.) obey similar first order quantum equations. The center of the wave packet is shown to acquire a phase equal to the action integral along the classical path. State−specific quantum information is obtained from the wave packet trajectories by use of the superposition principle and projection techniques. Successful numerical application is made to the collinear He + H2 system widely used as a test case. Classically forbidden transitions are accounted for and obtained in the same manner as the classically allowed transitions; turning points present no difficulties and flux is very nearly conserved.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 15, 1975•1,626 citations

Geometry and symmetry of quantum and classical-quantum dynamics

Esther Bonet-Luz

The symmetry properties of quantum variational principles are considered. Euler-Poincaré reduction theory is applied to the Dirac-Frenkel variational principle for Schrödinger's dynamics producing new variational principles for the different pictures of quantum mechanics (Schrödinger's, Heisenberg's and Dirac's) as well as for the Wigner-Moyal formulation. In addition, new variational principles for mixed states dynamics have been formulated. The already known geometric characterization of quantum mechanics on the complex projective space is shown to emerge naturally from the Euler-Poincaré variational principle. Semidirect-product structures are seen to produce new variational principles for Dirac's picture. \n \nOn the other hand, the variational and Hamiltonian approach to Ehrenfest expectation values dynamics is proposed. In the Lagrangian framework, the quantum variational principle for Schrödinger's dynamics is extended to account for both classical and quantum degrees of freedom. First, it is shown that the mean field model of any quantum mechanical system can be derived from a classical-quantum Euler-Poincaré Lagrangian on the direct sum Lie algebra of the Heisenberg and unitary groups. Then, the semidirect-product structure (named Ehrenfest group), is constructed using the displacement operator from the theory of coherent quantum states ( the unitary action of the Heisenberg group on the space of wavefunctions). New classical-quantum equations for Ehrenfest's expectation values dynamics are derived redefining the mean-field model Euler-Poincaré Lagrangian on the Lie algebra of the Ehrenfest group. In the Hamiltonian framework, first expectation values of the canonical observables are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the unitary action of the Heisenberg group on quantum states. Then, the Hamiltonian structure for Ehrenfest's dynamics is shown to be Lie-Poisson for the Ehrenfest group. The variational formulation is then given a corresponding Hamiltonian structure. The classical-quantum Ehrenfest dynamics equations produce classical and quantum dynamics as special limit cases. \n \nIn the particular case of Gaussian states, expectation values couple to second order moments, so that GS are completely characterized by first and second moments. When the total energy is computed with respect to a Gaussian state, higher moments can be expressed in terms of the first two, so that the moment hierarchy closes for Gaussian states. Second moments are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the action of the symplectic group on the space of Wigner functions. Eventually, Gaussian states are shown to possess a Lie-Poisson structure on the Jacobi group. This structure produces an energy-conserving variant of a class of Gaussian moment models that have appeared in the chemical physics literature.

•Feb 28, 2017•0 citations
A hierarchy of translational moment equations for the position and momentum observables is considered. The resulting set of equations is truncated in a manner that includes only first and second order moments. This closure procedure is consistent with the conservation of energy and, for spherically symmetric potentials, with the conservation of angular momentum. The method is valid for both classical and quantal mechanics with the only difference being that for quantal systems, the dispersions in momentum and position must satisfy Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. With finite dispersion in the position, the average position and momentum do not satisfy Hamilton's equations of motion since the average acceleration is modulated by the variance–covariance in the position. For classical systems, the second order moments may be taken to zero in which case Hamilton's equations are obtained. For quantal systems, a comparision is made with Heller's Gaussian wave packet approach. The moment method is illustrated by applying it to the reflection of a phase space packet from a one dimensional repulsive inverse square potential. Applications to the calculation of collision cross sections are envisaged.
According to Heisenberg's uncertainty relation, in quantum mechanics it is not possible to determine, simultaneously, exact values for the position and the momentum of a material system. Calculating the mean value of the Hamiltonian operator with the aid of exact analytic Gaussian wave packet solutions, these uncertainties cause an energy contribution additional to the classical energy of the system. For the harmonic oscillator, e.g., this nonclassical energy represents the ground state energy. It will be shown that this additional energy contribution can be considered as a Hamiltonian function, if it is written in appropriate variables. With the help of the usual Lagrange-Hamilton formalism known from classical particle mechanics, but now considering this new Hamiltonian function, it is possible to obtain the equations of motion for position and momentum uncertainties.
It is shown how differential cross sections can be obtained from the time dependence of phase space packets. This procedure is valid both for classical and quantum mechanics. Two methods are described. In one the trajectory of the packet is emphasized, while in the second the packet is appropriately spread to infinite size. Both methods are applicable to either mechanics. It is shown how the quantal results agree with those of the stationary state approach as formulated in terms of the density operator. The description is also used to elucidate the difference between the scattered flux and the generalized flux that arises naturally in the superoperator formulation.
The quantization of Hamilton dynamics (QHD) [J. Chem. Phys. 113, 6557 (2000)] that efficiently generalizes classical mechanics to include quantum tunneling and zero-point energy effects is extended to a general position dependent potential. A Taylor series expansion of the potential is considered both around a fixed point and around the moving instantaneous value of the position variable. The equations-of-motion obtained for the moving frame are significantly simpler than for the fixed frame, while still satisfying the classical limit. The number of the QHD variables and the order of the Taylor expansion of the potential constitute two independent approximation parameters. Conservation of the total energy and the Heisenberg commutator relationship is established for the second-order QHD that includes linear and quadratic variables. The formal results are illustrated by examples, including the harmonic oscillator, tunneling in a doublewell potential, and energy exchange between coupled Morse oscillators representing the stretching vibrations of the SPC-F water molecule commonly used in molecular dynamics simulations. QHD provides an improvement over classical mechanics in all cases. The QHD data agree with the exact data in the large ℏ quantum limit and in the ℏ=0 classical limit, with deviations observed for the intermediate ℏ values, depending on the system and initial conditions. QHD provides a quantitative short time approximation. The second-order QHD becomes inappropriate when quantum wave packets split. Higher-order QHD approximations are required in such cases. The second-order QHD is particularly suitable for the description of zero-point energy effects and properly treats moderate tunneling events.
The detailed calculation of the dynamics of a chemical system is usually not considered due to the size and cost of the computation. It is thus useful to examine various approximation methods. Such methods first need to be tried out on simple systems, like one-dimensional motion. Here two approaches to approximating the solutions of the Schrödinger and von Neumann equations by single time-dependent Gaussians are explored and contrasted, explicitly for one-dimensional barrier penetration. The first approach, in which no tunneling occurs, is local in nature and characterized by an expansion of the equations of motion to second order about the average position of the Gaussian wave packet or about the average position and momentum of the Gaussian Wigner function. This approach was first introduced by Heller [E. J. Heller, J. Chem. Phys. 62, 1544 (1975)]. Here both Heller’s approach and a more general truncation method are considered. Indeed tunneling can be incorporated if second-order terms in the quantal von Neumann equation are included. However, the resulting dynamics is unstable for kinetic energies where the exact wavepacket (and Wigner function) splits into nonnegligible parts that represent reflection and transmission. In contrast, the second approach is a global method which is obtained by applying appropriate closure approximations to the equations of motion for the first- and second-order position and momentum expectation values. This method allows tunneling and is stable at all kinetic energies. It is also possible to approximate the global equations in such a way that the local equations are obtained.
In this paper we develop a new approach to semiclassical dynamics which exploits the fact that extended wavefunctions for heavy particles (or particles in harmonic potentials) may be decomposed into time−dependent wave packets, which spread minimally and which execute classical or nearly classical trajectories. A Gaussian form for the wave packets is assumed and equations of motion are derived for the parameters characterizing the Gaussians. If the potential (which may be nonseparable in many coordinates) is expanded in a Taylor series about the instantaneous center of the (many−particle) wave packet, and up to quadratic terms are kept, we find the classical parameters of the wave packet (positions, momenta) obey Hamilton’s equation of motion. Quantum parameters (wave packet spread, phase factor, correlation terms, etc.) obey similar first order quantum equations. The center of the wave packet is shown to acquire a phase equal to the action integral along the classical path. State−specific quantum information is obtained from the wave packet trajectories by use of the superposition principle and projection techniques. Successful numerical application is made to the collinear He + H2 system widely used as a test case. Classically forbidden transitions are accounted for and obtained in the same manner as the classically allowed transitions; turning points present no difficulties and flux is very nearly conserved.
The symmetry properties of quantum variational principles are considered. Euler-Poincaré reduction theory is applied to the Dirac-Frenkel variational principle for Schrödinger's dynamics producing new variational principles for the different pictures of quantum mechanics (Schrödinger's, Heisenberg's and Dirac's) as well as for the Wigner-Moyal formulation. In addition, new variational principles for mixed states dynamics have been formulated. The already known geometric characterization of quantum mechanics on the complex projective space is shown to emerge naturally from the Euler-Poincaré variational principle. Semidirect-product structures are seen to produce new variational principles for Dirac's picture. \n \nOn the other hand, the variational and Hamiltonian approach to Ehrenfest expectation values dynamics is proposed. In the Lagrangian framework, the quantum variational principle for Schrödinger's dynamics is extended to account for both classical and quantum degrees of freedom. First, it is shown that the mean field model of any quantum mechanical system can be derived from a classical-quantum Euler-Poincaré Lagrangian on the direct sum Lie algebra of the Heisenberg and unitary groups. Then, the semidirect-product structure (named Ehrenfest group), is constructed using the displacement operator from the theory of coherent quantum states ( the unitary action of the Heisenberg group on the space of wavefunctions). New classical-quantum equations for Ehrenfest's expectation values dynamics are derived redefining the mean-field model Euler-Poincaré Lagrangian on the Lie algebra of the Ehrenfest group. In the Hamiltonian framework, first expectation values of the canonical observables are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the unitary action of the Heisenberg group on quantum states. Then, the Hamiltonian structure for Ehrenfest's dynamics is shown to be Lie-Poisson for the Ehrenfest group. The variational formulation is then given a corresponding Hamiltonian structure. The classical-quantum Ehrenfest dynamics equations produce classical and quantum dynamics as special limit cases. \n \nIn the particular case of Gaussian states, expectation values couple to second order moments, so that GS are completely characterized by first and second moments. When the total energy is computed with respect to a Gaussian state, higher moments can be expressed in terms of the first two, so that the moment hierarchy closes for Gaussian states. Second moments are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the action of the symplectic group on the space of Wigner functions. Eventually, Gaussian states are shown to possess a Lie-Poisson structure on the Jacobi group. This structure produces an energy-conserving variant of a class of Gaussian moment models that have appeared in the chemical physics literature.