It is shown that the condition for the occurrence of reduction of wave packet formulated in the Machida-Namiki theory generally differs from the one for the operation of measuring apparatus. And we present some of the physical phenomena which result from the difference.
Recent paper by S. Machida and T. Namiki proposed a very interesting idea of the generalization of quantum mechanics to macroscopic systems. Using this formalism, they have shown that the so-called “reduction of wave packet” in measuring process is explained without having the observer outside the measuring apparatus in the theory itself. H. Araki proposed a framework of general theory of physics, which is in accord with the idea of Machida and Namiki. Following these ideas, together with the experimental evidence of Bell's inequalities, we have now a strong feeling that the nature has in principle a structure which allows us to formulate the physical theory which is general enough to include hitherto existing theories both in microscopic and macroscopic scales. Some fundamental problems on these ideas are discussed.
A critical review of the theory of measurement in quantum mechanics is presented first, which is focused on the recent controversy between the von Neumann-Wigner theory and the ergodic amplification theory. Making the point clear through discussions on the controversy, we then describe a new version of the Machida-Namiki-Araki theory, as a solution of the problem, in which the macroscopic nature of measuring apparatus is explicitly formulated in a continuous direct sum of many Hilbert spaces and the unitarity of S -matrix of elementary interaction processes between object and apparatus systems is maintained. Within the framework of their theory, it is explicitly shown that the reduction of wave packet takes place even in the negative result measurement.
The theory of measurement is reasonably interpreted without any abrupt and noncausal change of a state, namely, with no “reduction of a wave packet”, in the framework of quantum mechanics. Though a process of measurement is causal in the usual quantum-mechanical sense, it is possible to utilize the concept of the “reduction of a wave packet” without any loss of compatibility. The Stern-Gerlach experiment is put to a careful study to show that the present interpretation is consistent with experiment.
New theory of measurement is presented to show that quantum mechanics can describe the whole processes of quantum-mechanical measurement leading to the so-called reduction of wave packet if applied properly to the total system of object and apparatus. We introduce a simple model, where momenta of particles are measured using a perfect rigid mirror, to yield the reduction of wave packet in a clear-cut way. Microscopic uncertainties of macroscopic quantities and the dynamical scattering theory play the essential roles. Before entering into the main part, we briefly summarize the controversial points in the theory of measurement.