Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

A quantum-mechanical theory of distant correlations

Milan Vujičić, Fedor Herbut

Published Jul 1, 1984• 28 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A composite quantum system consisting of two distant subsystems and described by a correlated state vector φ12 is considered. It was shown in a previous work by the authors [Ann. Phys. 96, 382 (1976)] that such a system can be equivalently described in terms of the reduced statistical operators ρ1 and ρ2 of φ12 applying to the subsystems and a correlation operator Ua between them. It is argued that this description has a firm physical foundation for the system considered in view of the fact that, on account of the subsystems being distant, one can only measure pairs of subsystem observables A1, B2 in coincidence. The direct measurement of A1 such that [A1,ρ1]=0 on the ensemble of first subsystems performs distantly (without interaction) an orthogonal decomposition of the ensemble of second subsystems ρ2, that amounts to the measurement of the twin observable A2 (A2≡UaA1U−1aQ2, Q2 being the range projector of ρ2). A number of coincidence experiments have confirmed this claim, and have disproved all attempts (on the quantum and on the subquantum levels) to view this decomposition of ρ2 as being present also before the measurement of A1. Hence, this decomposition into subensembles comes about in the very measurement of A1, and Ua determines them in a simple way. It is demonstrated that Ua is essential for twin observables and twin symmetry operators. A detailed study of these operators is presented from a unified point of view. Puzzling features of quantum correlations described by Ua show up in composite states when the mentioned distant decompositions of ρ2 into subensembles can be incompatible with one another. A general definition of such φEPR12 states (called Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen states) is given in a few equivalent forms, and the nonuniqueness of the Schmidt canonical form of φEPR12 is investigated in order to encourage further theoretical and experimental exploration of distant quantum correlations.

DOI
10.1063/1.526418

Related papers

Mixed-state twin observables

F Herbut, M Damnjanovic

Twin observables are opposite subsystem observables A + and A - if they are indistinguishable in measurement in a given mixed or pure state ρ in the sense that the measurement of one amounts to the same as the measurement of the other (direct measurement and so-called distant measurement, respectively). It is pointed out that twin observables may reveal quantum correlations that give rise to the disappearance of interference in the two-slit experiment. Twin observables in general states are investigated in detail algebraically and geometrically. It is shown that there is a far-reaching correspondence between the detectable (in ρ) spectral entities of the two operators. Twin observables are state-dependently quantum-logically equivalent, and the direct subsystem measurement of one of them ipso facto gives rise to the indirect (i.e. distant) measurement of the other. Existence of nontrivial twins requires a singularity of ρ. Systems in thermodynamic equilibrium do not admit subsystem twins. These observables may enable one to simplify the matrix representing ρ.

arXiv:quant-ph/0004085•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 16, 2000•12 citations

On Schmidt Decomposition: Approach Based on Correlation Operator as Bipartite Entanglement Entity

Fedor Herbut

An elaborated review with proofs of Schmidt canonical decomposition of any bipartite state vector is approached through general subsystem basis expansion. The upgraded forms of Schmidt decomposition in terms of correlation operator and twin observables are presented in detail. The discussion is extended to distant measurement, Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen states and Schrödinger's steering. All claims and proofs are given in standard form unlike in the previous articles of the author where all results were obtained utilizing the very rarely used antilinear Hilbert–Schmidt maps of one subsystem state space into the other. For practical reasons the formalism of partial traces with their rules and reduced density operators together with correlation operator are used. Quanta 2018; 7: 19–39.

Quanta•Feb 20, 2018•2 citations

On state-dependent implication in quantum-mechanical distant correlations

Fedor Herbut

Let be an arbitrary given composite-system state (statistical operator). It is shown that same-subsystem events imply each other state-dependently according to if and only if they act equally in the range of the corresponding subsystem state (reduced statistical operator). Opposite-subsystem events imply each other in the same way if and only if they are twin events, i.e. . If is a pure state, it is shown that the anti-unitary correlation operator also plays a decisive role in the latter implication.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 21, 1996•4 citations

Mixed-state twin observables

F Herbut, Milan Damnjanović

Abstract. Twin observables, i.e. opposite subsystem observables A+ and A− that are indistinguishable in measurement in a given mixed or pure state ρ, are investigated in detail algebraicly and geometrically. It is shown that there is a farreaching correspondence between the detectable (in ρ) spectral entities of the two operators. Twin observables are state-dependently quantum-logically equivalent, and direct subsystem measurement of one of them ipso facto gives rise to the indirect (i.e. distant) measurement of the other. Existence of nontrivial twins requires singularity of ρ. Systems in thermodynamic equilibrium do not admit subsystem twins. These observables may enable one to simplify the matrix representing ρ.

•Jan 1, 2000•7 citations

Delayed Twin Observables Are They a Fundamental Concept in Quantum Mechanics?

Fedor Herbut

Opposite-subsystem twin events and twin observables, studied previously in the context of distant correlations, are first generalized to pure states of not-necessarily-composite systems, and afterwards they are further generalized to delayed twins that are due to unitary evolution of the quantum system. The versatile aspects of delayed twin observables are studied in terms of necessary and sufficient conditions to make possible various applications. Three of these are sketched: Preparation of some quantum experiments, easy solution of a puzzle in an important Scully et al. real experiment, and, finally, it is shown that exact measurement in quantum mechanics is an example of opposite-subsystem delayed twins in bipartite pure states.

arXiv:1301.7053•Jan 29, 2013•1 citation

Entanglement: non-separability

Gennaro Auletta, Mauro Fortunato, Giorgio Parisi A

In classical mechanics, two (or more) systems that do not interact – that do not exert any kind of force on each other – are completely separated (see Sec. 1.1), i.e. experiments performed locally on one of them cannot in any way influence experiments performed locally on the other. Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, admits that there can be a form of interdependence even in absence of physical interaction. This type of correlation goes under the name of entanglement (see Def. 5.1: p. 183). We already know that entanglement means non-factorizability of the state vector describing a system with at least two different degrees of freedom. In this chapter, we shall see that this may be the case also for systems that are very far away (space-like distant) from each other and we shall learn many interesting consequences of this state of affairs. Recent developments show that one may entangle even particles that have never interacted with each other. The starting point of the following analysis is necessarily represented by the pioneering paper of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, who inaugurated an incredible series of theoretical and experimental investigations right up to the present day that have confirmed the predictions of quantum mechanics. The “irony” of this history is that Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, EPR for short, aimed to present a definitive proof of the inconsistency of quantum mechanics relative to classical physical theory. In fact, they initiated one of the most prolific fields of modern science.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 16, 2009•0 citations
A composite quantum system consisting of two distant subsystems and described by a correlated state vector φ12 is considered. It was shown in a previous work by the authors [Ann. Phys. 96, 382 (1976)] that such a system can be equivalently described in terms of the reduced statistical operators ρ1 and ρ2 of φ12 applying to the subsystems and a correlation operator Ua between them. It is argued that this description has a firm physical foundation for the system considered in view of the fact that, on account of the subsystems being distant, one can only measure pairs of subsystem observables A1, B2 in coincidence. The direct measurement of A1 such that [A1,ρ1]=0 on the ensemble of first subsystems performs distantly (without interaction) an orthogonal decomposition of the ensemble of second subsystems ρ2, that amounts to the measurement of the twin observable A2 (A2≡UaA1U−1aQ2, Q2 being the range projector of ρ2). A number of coincidence experiments have confirmed this claim, and have disproved all attempts (on the quantum and on the subquantum levels) to view this decomposition of ρ2 as being present also before the measurement of A1. Hence, this decomposition into subensembles comes about in the very measurement of A1, and Ua determines them in a simple way. It is demonstrated that Ua is essential for twin observables and twin symmetry operators. A detailed study of these operators is presented from a unified point of view. Puzzling features of quantum correlations described by Ua show up in composite states when the mentioned distant decompositions of ρ2 into subensembles can be incompatible with one another. A general definition of such φEPR12 states (called Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen states) is given in a few equivalent forms, and the nonuniqueness of the Schmidt canonical form of φEPR12 is investigated in order to encourage further theoretical and experimental exploration of distant quantum correlations.
Twin observables are opposite subsystem observables A + and A - if they are indistinguishable in measurement in a given mixed or pure state ρ in the sense that the measurement of one amounts to the same as the measurement of the other (direct measurement and so-called distant measurement, respectively). It is pointed out that twin observables may reveal quantum correlations that give rise to the disappearance of interference in the two-slit experiment. Twin observables in general states are investigated in detail algebraically and geometrically. It is shown that there is a far-reaching correspondence between the detectable (in ρ) spectral entities of the two operators. Twin observables are state-dependently quantum-logically equivalent, and the direct subsystem measurement of one of them ipso facto gives rise to the indirect (i.e. distant) measurement of the other. Existence of nontrivial twins requires a singularity of ρ. Systems in thermodynamic equilibrium do not admit subsystem twins. These observables may enable one to simplify the matrix representing ρ.
An elaborated review with proofs of Schmidt canonical decomposition of any bipartite state vector is approached through general subsystem basis expansion. The upgraded forms of Schmidt decomposition in terms of correlation operator and twin observables are presented in detail. The discussion is extended to distant measurement, Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen states and Schrödinger's steering. All claims and proofs are given in standard form unlike in the previous articles of the author where all results were obtained utilizing the very rarely used antilinear Hilbert–Schmidt maps of one subsystem state space into the other. For practical reasons the formalism of partial traces with their rules and reduced density operators together with correlation operator are used. Quanta 2018; 7: 19–39.
Let be an arbitrary given composite-system state (statistical operator). It is shown that same-subsystem events imply each other state-dependently according to if and only if they act equally in the range of the corresponding subsystem state (reduced statistical operator). Opposite-subsystem events imply each other in the same way if and only if they are twin events, i.e. . If is a pure state, it is shown that the anti-unitary correlation operator also plays a decisive role in the latter implication.
Abstract. Twin observables, i.e. opposite subsystem observables A+ and A− that are indistinguishable in measurement in a given mixed or pure state ρ, are investigated in detail algebraicly and geometrically. It is shown that there is a farreaching correspondence between the detectable (in ρ) spectral entities of the two operators. Twin observables are state-dependently quantum-logically equivalent, and direct subsystem measurement of one of them ipso facto gives rise to the indirect (i.e. distant) measurement of the other. Existence of nontrivial twins requires singularity of ρ. Systems in thermodynamic equilibrium do not admit subsystem twins. These observables may enable one to simplify the matrix representing ρ.
Opposite-subsystem twin events and twin observables, studied previously in the context of distant correlations, are first generalized to pure states of not-necessarily-composite systems, and afterwards they are further generalized to delayed twins that are due to unitary evolution of the quantum system. The versatile aspects of delayed twin observables are studied in terms of necessary and sufficient conditions to make possible various applications. Three of these are sketched: Preparation of some quantum experiments, easy solution of a puzzle in an important Scully et al. real experiment, and, finally, it is shown that exact measurement in quantum mechanics is an example of opposite-subsystem delayed twins in bipartite pure states.
In classical mechanics, two (or more) systems that do not interact – that do not exert any kind of force on each other – are completely separated (see Sec. 1.1), i.e. experiments performed locally on one of them cannot in any way influence experiments performed locally on the other. Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, admits that there can be a form of interdependence even in absence of physical interaction. This type of correlation goes under the name of entanglement (see Def. 5.1: p. 183). We already know that entanglement means non-factorizability of the state vector describing a system with at least two different degrees of freedom. In this chapter, we shall see that this may be the case also for systems that are very far away (space-like distant) from each other and we shall learn many interesting consequences of this state of affairs. Recent developments show that one may entangle even particles that have never interacted with each other. The starting point of the following analysis is necessarily represented by the pioneering paper of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, who inaugurated an incredible series of theoretical and experimental investigations right up to the present day that have confirmed the predictions of quantum mechanics. The “irony” of this history is that Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, EPR for short, aimed to present a definitive proof of the inconsistency of quantum mechanics relative to classical physical theory. In fact, they initiated one of the most prolific fields of modern science.