Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Canadian Journal of Physics

Quantum-mechanical irreversible motion of an infinite chain

Mohsen Razavy

Published Oct 1, 1979• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The rate of the energy transfer between the particles in an infinite uniform chain provides an interesting example of a system exhibiting a nonexponential approach to equilibrium. For this system, the quasi-particle description is not convenient, hence, for the purpose of quantization, the total Hamiltonian is decomposed into a sum of single particle Hamiltonians, each containing a time-dependent effective potential energy. The resulting Schrödinger equation for a single particle has a wave-packet-like solution in which the center of the packet moves according to the classical law of motion. The quantal problem shows the same kind of oscillatory decay law as the classical one, and there is no characteristic relaxation time for the system. From the Schrödinger equation, expressions for the total energy, the momentum, and the probability of excitation for each subsystem are obtained. It is shown that the ground state wave function satisfies a Fokker–Planck type equation, and that the equation of motion of each particle remains invariant under the time-reversal transformation. However, the direction of the flow of energy is the same for the actual and the time-reversed motions.

DOI
10.1139/p79-238

Related papers

Irreversible Wave Packet Dynamics in a Magnetic Field

Dieter Schuch

It has been shown that the irreversible dynamics of a system in a dissipative environment can be described by an effective one-particle Hamiltonian (in the classical case) or an effective one-particle Schrödinger equation (in the quantum mechanical case) without taking into account the environmental degrees of freedom explicitly. In the quantum mechanical case, the description can be achieved either by a nonlinear modification of the Schrödinger equation or an explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonian operator — where both forms are connected via a non-unitary transformation, corresponding to a non-canonical transformation on the classical level. Taking into account an external magnetic field, in both formalisms, an additional unphysical gauge-dependent term occurs in the equations of motion. This shortcoming can be eliminated if the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian that provide Maxwell’s equations of electrodynamics undergo, in the dissipative case, the same kind of transformation as the mechanical degrees of freedom of the system. As a result, a consistent description in terms of exact analytical wave packet-solutions for the dissipative motion in a magnetic field can be obtained that will be discussed in detail.

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Dec 17, 2005•1 citation

Introduction To Quantum Relaxation Processes

Abraham Nitzan

The first question to ask about the phenomenon of relaxation is why it occurs at all. Both the Newton and the Schrödinger equations are symmetrical under time reversal: The Newton equation, dx/dt = v ; dv/dt = −∂V/∂x, implies that particles obeying this law of motion will retrace their trajectory back in time after changing the sign of both the time t and the particle velocities v. The Schrödinger equation, ∂ψ/∂t = −(i/.h) Ĥ ψ, implies that if (ψ (t) is a solution then ψ *(−t) is also one, so that observables which depend on |ψ|2 are symmetric in time. On the other hand, nature clearly evolves asymmetrically as asserted by the second law of thermodynamics. How does this asymmetry arise in a system that obeys temporal symmetry in its time evolution? Readers with background in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics have encountered the intuitive answer: Irreversibility in a system with many degrees of freedom is essentially a manifestation of the system “getting lost in phase space”:Asystem starts from a given state and evolves in time. If the number of accessible states is huge, the probability that the system will find its way back to the initial state in finite time is vanishingly small, so that an observer who monitors properties associated with the initial state will see an irreversible evolution. The question is how is this irreversible behavior manifested through the reversible equations of motion, and how does it show in the quantitative description of the time evolution. This chapter provides an introduction to this subject using the time-dependent Schrödinger equation as a starting point. Chapter 10 discusses more advanced aspects of this problem within the framework of the quantum Liouville equation and the density operator formalism.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 6, 2006•0 citations

Quantum Dynamics

Uri Peskin

Explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians are ubiquitous in applications of quantum theory. It is therefore necessary to solve the time-dependent Schrödinger equation directly. The system’s dynamics is associated with a unitary time-evolution operator (a propagator), formally given as an infinite Dyson series. Time-dependent observables are invariant under unitary time-dependent transformations, where it is sometimes useful to transform the time-evolution from the states into the corresponding operators. This is carried out in part (in full) by transforming to the interaction (Heisenberg) picture. The corresponding equations of motion for the time-dependent operators are introduced. For quadratic potential energy functions, the time evolution of quantum expectation values coincides with the corresponding classical dynamics. This is demonstrated and analyzed in detail for Gaussian wave packets and a coherent state. Finally, we derive exact and approximate expressions for time-dependent transition probabilities and transition rates between quantum states. The validity of time-dependent perturbation theory is analyzed by comparison to exact dynamics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations

Schrodinger Equation from Fokker-Planck Equation and Contradiction Due To Interference? Part II

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Classical mechanics traces a particle’s movement through space and time through x(t). For example, one may consider the case of a particle moving at constant speed (momentum p) in one direction or a particle bouncing back and forth at constant speed in a box. These problems are described in time and have direction and position associated with time etc. It is possible to define a probability P(x,t) in the classical picture based on delta time, the amount of time a particle spends in a little region of space dx. P(x,t), by itself, loses much relevant information present in the x(t) scenario because a particle moving to the right, or to the left, or bouncing back and forth all have the same probability, 1/L, where L is length. Furthermore, this probability is the same for all p (momentum) values. Thus a probability description, without extra information, is a subset of the relevant information in the problem. As a result, to describe the classical picture fully, one might say that a particle has a probability of 1/L, but also a mass mo and velocity +v (i.e. momentum mov nonrelativistically). For the particle bouncing back and forth in a box with constant p, one needs to give the initial position at time=0 and then a subsequent time (as well as the initial velocity and mo) in order to fully describe the problem, even though probability = 1/L. In the literature (see (1)), there have been many attempts to derive the quantum Schrodinger equation from a classical Fockker-Planck equation or a continuity equation (which follows from the Fokker-Planck equation as shown in (1)). The continuity equation contains a probability P(x,t) and a velocity(x,t) and is generally argued to represent classical physics. It does, if one retains appropriate classical conditions such as the discontinuity of density for a particle in a box (i.e. density=0 outside the box, but 1/L inside) and the notion of differing directions within the box. In fact, one may write density=W*(x,t)W(x,t) where W(x,t) is an ad hoc complex function and still retain compatibility with classical physics. If one does not, however, retain the classical conditions completely, nonclassical physics is introduced, even if density(x,t)=1/L. For example, in quantum mechanics density(x) is considered to be continuous in all x. Thus for a particle moving in a box, density outside the box is 0 so at the box wall it must also be 0. In the classical case, the density is 1 inside the box and 0 outside. There is a discontinuity classically and this cannot be changed and this contradicts the quantum mechanical picture. Thus quantum mechanics does not follow form classical Fokker-Planck or continuity equations which retain classical conditions.. Furthermore, because time is completely removed in the FP-continuity approach as applied to quantum mechanics, one cannot distinguish between forwards and backwards motion. As seen by the velocity field given in (1), v is zero for a bound particle which completely removes the sense of time and violates the classical physics conditions. It is, however, not zero for a particle moving in one direction. Thus there seems to be no issue in describing a Fokker-Planck-continuity equation as describing classical physics. One may even introduce density(x,t)= W*(x,t)W(x,t) provided one retains classical conditions allowing for discontinuity in density and different W(x,t) values at different times i.e. a discontinuity in W(x,t) at a box wall. If these conditions, however, are not met, then one no longer describes classical physics, but a new kind of physics (quantum physics). Thus one cannot argue that quantum mechanics follows from classical statistical Fokker-Planck-continuity equations. It may follow from these if one adds a set of extra conditions. Given these extra conditions, however, one could derive quantum mechanics without starting with classical density.

•Apr 24, 2023•0 citations

Classical and Quantum Brownian Motion

Roumen Tsekov

In the frames of classical mechanics the generalized Langevin equation is derived for an arbitrary mechanical subsystem coupled to the harmonic bath of a solid. A time-acting temperature operator is introduced for the quantum Klein-Kramers and Smoluchowski equations, accounting for the effect of the quantum thermal bath oscillators. The model of Brownian emitters is theoretically studied and the relevant evolutionary equations for the probability density are derived. The Schrodinger equation is explained via collisions of the target point particles with the quantum force carriers, transmitting the fundamental interactions between the point particles. Thus, electrons and other point particles are no waves and the wavy chapter of quantum mechanics originated for the force carriers. A stochastic Lorentz-Langevin equation is proposed to describe the underlaying Brownian-like motion of the point particles in quantum mechanics. Considering the Brownian dynamics in the frames of the Bohmian mechanics, the density functional Bohm-Langevin equation is proposed, and the relevant Smoluchowski-Bohm equation is derived. A nonlinear master equation is proposed by proper quantization of the classical Klein-Kramers equation. Its equilibrium solution in the exact canonical Gibbs density operator, while the well-known Caldeira-Leggett equation is simply a linearization at high temperature. In the case of a free quantum Brownian particles, a new law for the spreading of the wave packet it discovered, which represents the quantum generalization of the classical Einstein law of Brownian motion. A new projector operator is proposed for the collapse of the wave function of a quantum particle moving in a classical environment. Its application results in dissipative Schrodinger equations, as well as in a new form of dissipative Liouville equation in classical mechanics.

arXiv:2105.05646•Jan 1, 2021•3 citations

Towards a new approach of quantum dissipation in simple chemical systems

J. P. Badiali

We suggest a new approach for describing quantum dissipation in a small systems for which the system-plus-reservoir approach is not relevant. We first analyze the fact that equilibrium thermodynamics may reveal the existence of an underlying dynamics. This is true in the algebraic approach of quantum mechanics via the Tomita-Takesaki theorem. A similar result is obtained if we start from the path integral expression of the partition function, an equation of motion is introduced. In both cases a parameter has to be identified with the physical time. Several arguments are presented showing that it is so. By investigating the dynamics for short times we introduce an equilibrium condition from which a natural unit of time appears. The equation of motion is extended to non equilibrium situations for which a H-theorem can be derived. The equation of motion can be transformed into a quantum Smoluchovski equation, its solution is a probability having a clear physical meaning. The relaxation of this probability towards its equilibrium value requires a time during which a thermodynamic description is possible or not. A standard bistable model is investigated and the chemical rate $k(t)$ is calculated as a function of time, it appears to be a non monotonic function of time. In some conditions the stationary value of $k(t)$ can be identified with the Kramers result. Finally we compare our approach which is naturally irreversible with an analysis based on the Schrödinger equation which is reversible. From all these results it appears that our equation of motion or its Smoluchovski version appear as a realistic starting point for describing quantum dissipation in small systems.

arXiv:0910.1948•Oct 12, 2009•0 citations
The rate of the energy transfer between the particles in an infinite uniform chain provides an interesting example of a system exhibiting a nonexponential approach to equilibrium. For this system, the quasi-particle description is not convenient, hence, for the purpose of quantization, the total Hamiltonian is decomposed into a sum of single particle Hamiltonians, each containing a time-dependent effective potential energy. The resulting Schrödinger equation for a single particle has a wave-packet-like solution in which the center of the packet moves according to the classical law of motion. The quantal problem shows the same kind of oscillatory decay law as the classical one, and there is no characteristic relaxation time for the system. From the Schrödinger equation, expressions for the total energy, the momentum, and the probability of excitation for each subsystem are obtained. It is shown that the ground state wave function satisfies a Fokker–Planck type equation, and that the equation of motion of each particle remains invariant under the time-reversal transformation. However, the direction of the flow of energy is the same for the actual and the time-reversed motions.
It has been shown that the irreversible dynamics of a system in a dissipative environment can be described by an effective one-particle Hamiltonian (in the classical case) or an effective one-particle Schrödinger equation (in the quantum mechanical case) without taking into account the environmental degrees of freedom explicitly. In the quantum mechanical case, the description can be achieved either by a nonlinear modification of the Schrödinger equation or an explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonian operator — where both forms are connected via a non-unitary transformation, corresponding to a non-canonical transformation on the classical level. Taking into account an external magnetic field, in both formalisms, an additional unphysical gauge-dependent term occurs in the equations of motion. This shortcoming can be eliminated if the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian that provide Maxwell’s equations of electrodynamics undergo, in the dissipative case, the same kind of transformation as the mechanical degrees of freedom of the system. As a result, a consistent description in terms of exact analytical wave packet-solutions for the dissipative motion in a magnetic field can be obtained that will be discussed in detail.
The first question to ask about the phenomenon of relaxation is why it occurs at all. Both the Newton and the Schrödinger equations are symmetrical under time reversal: The Newton equation, dx/dt = v ; dv/dt = −∂V/∂x, implies that particles obeying this law of motion will retrace their trajectory back in time after changing the sign of both the time t and the particle velocities v. The Schrödinger equation, ∂ψ/∂t = −(i/.h) Ĥ ψ, implies that if (ψ (t) is a solution then ψ *(−t) is also one, so that observables which depend on |ψ|2 are symmetric in time. On the other hand, nature clearly evolves asymmetrically as asserted by the second law of thermodynamics. How does this asymmetry arise in a system that obeys temporal symmetry in its time evolution? Readers with background in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics have encountered the intuitive answer: Irreversibility in a system with many degrees of freedom is essentially a manifestation of the system “getting lost in phase space”:Asystem starts from a given state and evolves in time. If the number of accessible states is huge, the probability that the system will find its way back to the initial state in finite time is vanishingly small, so that an observer who monitors properties associated with the initial state will see an irreversible evolution. The question is how is this irreversible behavior manifested through the reversible equations of motion, and how does it show in the quantitative description of the time evolution. This chapter provides an introduction to this subject using the time-dependent Schrödinger equation as a starting point. Chapter 10 discusses more advanced aspects of this problem within the framework of the quantum Liouville equation and the density operator formalism.
Explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians are ubiquitous in applications of quantum theory. It is therefore necessary to solve the time-dependent Schrödinger equation directly. The system’s dynamics is associated with a unitary time-evolution operator (a propagator), formally given as an infinite Dyson series. Time-dependent observables are invariant under unitary time-dependent transformations, where it is sometimes useful to transform the time-evolution from the states into the corresponding operators. This is carried out in part (in full) by transforming to the interaction (Heisenberg) picture. The corresponding equations of motion for the time-dependent operators are introduced. For quadratic potential energy functions, the time evolution of quantum expectation values coincides with the corresponding classical dynamics. This is demonstrated and analyzed in detail for Gaussian wave packets and a coherent state. Finally, we derive exact and approximate expressions for time-dependent transition probabilities and transition rates between quantum states. The validity of time-dependent perturbation theory is analyzed by comparison to exact dynamics.
Classical mechanics traces a particle’s movement through space and time through x(t). For example, one may consider the case of a particle moving at constant speed (momentum p) in one direction or a particle bouncing back and forth at constant speed in a box. These problems are described in time and have direction and position associated with time etc. It is possible to define a probability P(x,t) in the classical picture based on delta time, the amount of time a particle spends in a little region of space dx. P(x,t), by itself, loses much relevant information present in the x(t) scenario because a particle moving to the right, or to the left, or bouncing back and forth all have the same probability, 1/L, where L is length. Furthermore, this probability is the same for all p (momentum) values. Thus a probability description, without extra information, is a subset of the relevant information in the problem. As a result, to describe the classical picture fully, one might say that a particle has a probability of 1/L, but also a mass mo and velocity +v (i.e. momentum mov nonrelativistically). For the particle bouncing back and forth in a box with constant p, one needs to give the initial position at time=0 and then a subsequent time (as well as the initial velocity and mo) in order to fully describe the problem, even though probability = 1/L. In the literature (see (1)), there have been many attempts to derive the quantum Schrodinger equation from a classical Fockker-Planck equation or a continuity equation (which follows from the Fokker-Planck equation as shown in (1)). The continuity equation contains a probability P(x,t) and a velocity(x,t) and is generally argued to represent classical physics. It does, if one retains appropriate classical conditions such as the discontinuity of density for a particle in a box (i.e. density=0 outside the box, but 1/L inside) and the notion of differing directions within the box. In fact, one may write density=W*(x,t)W(x,t) where W(x,t) is an ad hoc complex function and still retain compatibility with classical physics. If one does not, however, retain the classical conditions completely, nonclassical physics is introduced, even if density(x,t)=1/L. For example, in quantum mechanics density(x) is considered to be continuous in all x. Thus for a particle moving in a box, density outside the box is 0 so at the box wall it must also be 0. In the classical case, the density is 1 inside the box and 0 outside. There is a discontinuity classically and this cannot be changed and this contradicts the quantum mechanical picture. Thus quantum mechanics does not follow form classical Fokker-Planck or continuity equations which retain classical conditions.. Furthermore, because time is completely removed in the FP-continuity approach as applied to quantum mechanics, one cannot distinguish between forwards and backwards motion. As seen by the velocity field given in (1), v is zero for a bound particle which completely removes the sense of time and violates the classical physics conditions. It is, however, not zero for a particle moving in one direction. Thus there seems to be no issue in describing a Fokker-Planck-continuity equation as describing classical physics. One may even introduce density(x,t)= W*(x,t)W(x,t) provided one retains classical conditions allowing for discontinuity in density and different W(x,t) values at different times i.e. a discontinuity in W(x,t) at a box wall. If these conditions, however, are not met, then one no longer describes classical physics, but a new kind of physics (quantum physics). Thus one cannot argue that quantum mechanics follows from classical statistical Fokker-Planck-continuity equations. It may follow from these if one adds a set of extra conditions. Given these extra conditions, however, one could derive quantum mechanics without starting with classical density.
In the frames of classical mechanics the generalized Langevin equation is derived for an arbitrary mechanical subsystem coupled to the harmonic bath of a solid. A time-acting temperature operator is introduced for the quantum Klein-Kramers and Smoluchowski equations, accounting for the effect of the quantum thermal bath oscillators. The model of Brownian emitters is theoretically studied and the relevant evolutionary equations for the probability density are derived. The Schrodinger equation is explained via collisions of the target point particles with the quantum force carriers, transmitting the fundamental interactions between the point particles. Thus, electrons and other point particles are no waves and the wavy chapter of quantum mechanics originated for the force carriers. A stochastic Lorentz-Langevin equation is proposed to describe the underlaying Brownian-like motion of the point particles in quantum mechanics. Considering the Brownian dynamics in the frames of the Bohmian mechanics, the density functional Bohm-Langevin equation is proposed, and the relevant Smoluchowski-Bohm equation is derived. A nonlinear master equation is proposed by proper quantization of the classical Klein-Kramers equation. Its equilibrium solution in the exact canonical Gibbs density operator, while the well-known Caldeira-Leggett equation is simply a linearization at high temperature. In the case of a free quantum Brownian particles, a new law for the spreading of the wave packet it discovered, which represents the quantum generalization of the classical Einstein law of Brownian motion. A new projector operator is proposed for the collapse of the wave function of a quantum particle moving in a classical environment. Its application results in dissipative Schrodinger equations, as well as in a new form of dissipative Liouville equation in classical mechanics.
We suggest a new approach for describing quantum dissipation in a small systems for which the system-plus-reservoir approach is not relevant. We first analyze the fact that equilibrium thermodynamics may reveal the existence of an underlying dynamics. This is true in the algebraic approach of quantum mechanics via the Tomita-Takesaki theorem. A similar result is obtained if we start from the path integral expression of the partition function, an equation of motion is introduced. In both cases a parameter has to be identified with the physical time. Several arguments are presented showing that it is so. By investigating the dynamics for short times we introduce an equilibrium condition from which a natural unit of time appears. The equation of motion is extended to non equilibrium situations for which a H-theorem can be derived. The equation of motion can be transformed into a quantum Smoluchovski equation, its solution is a probability having a clear physical meaning. The relaxation of this probability towards its equilibrium value requires a time during which a thermodynamic description is possible or not. A standard bistable model is investigated and the chemical rate k(t)k(t)k(t) is calculated as a function of time, it appears to be a non monotonic function of time. In some conditions the stationary value of k(t)k(t)k(t) can be identified with the Kramers result. Finally we compare our approach which is naturally irreversible with an analysis based on the Schrödinger equation which is reversible. From all these results it appears that our equation of motion or its Smoluchovski version appear as a realistic starting point for describing quantum dissipation in small systems.