Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Quantum Noise. XI. Multitime Correspondence between Quantum and Classical Stochastic Processes

M. Lax

Published Aug 10, 1968• 443 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A correspondence ${a}_{j}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{j}$ between operators $\mathrm{a}=[{a}_{1}, {a}_{2}, \ensuremath{\cdots}{a}_{f}]$ and $c$ numbers $\ensuremath{\alpha}=[{\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{1}, {\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{2}, \ensuremath{\cdots}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{f}]$ together with an arbitrary ordering rule $\mathcal{C}$ (e.g., in sequence from 1 to $f$) permit an association $M(\mathrm{a})=\mathcal{C}{M}^{(c)}(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ between a general operator $M(\mathrm{a})$ and an associated $c$ number function ${M}^{(c)}(\ensuremath{\alpha})$. A quasiprobability $P(\ensuremath{\alpha}, t)$ is then defined so that a general ensemble average can be written as an ordinary integration: $〈M(\mathrm{a}(t))〉=\ensuremath{\int}{M}^{(c)}(\ensuremath{\alpha})d\ensuremath{\alpha}P(\ensuremath{\alpha}, t)$. The equation for $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}P(\ensuremath{\alpha}, t)}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$ suggests that the $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ obeys a classical Markoff process. If this classical Markoff process is taken literally, multitime classical averages can be computed. Do these correspond to appropriate quantum averages? For the case of field operators such that $[b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}]=1$, important in discussing laser statistics, we show that with ${a}_{1}={b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$ and ${a}_{f}=b$, the classical multitime average is equivalent to the average of the corresponding quantum operators written in time-ordered, normal-ordered sequence. For the atomic operators in a laser problem, we obtain the desired correspondence, but find that the more complicated commutation rules necessarily lead to derivative correction terms when multitime averages are taken. Our derivation of multitime averages is based on the quantum regression theorem. We show that this theorem is equivalent to assuming the quantum system to be Markoffian, by showing that it leads to an appropriate factorization of a multitime density matrix and to a Chapman-Kolmogoroff-like condition on the conditional density matrix.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.172.350

Related papers

Quantum Noise. X. Density-Matrix Treatment of Field and Population-Difference Fluctuations

M. Lax

Starting with the quantum-noise-source model of a maser developed in the fourth paper in this series and specializing to the case in which all atomic parameters except the population difference vary rapidly compared with the field, an equation is developed for the density operator $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, D, t)$ that depends on the electromagnetic field variables $b$, ${b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$ and the population difference $D$. The corresponding equation obeyed by the density matrix ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{mn}}(D, t)$ in the "$n$ representation" is obtained. The antinormal ordering correspondence $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, D, t)=\mathcal{a}{\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}(\ensuremath{\beta}, {\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}, D, t)$ [in which $\ensuremath{\beta}$ is replaced by $b$ and ${\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}$ by ${b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$ with all ${b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}'\mathrm{s}$ to the right of all $b'\mathrm{s}$] defines an associated classical function ${\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}$. The equation for $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\rho}}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$ corresponds to a Fokker-Planck equation for $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}{\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$. Under the Markoffian assumption, an associated classical random process is uniquely defined. The quantum-mechanical average of normal-ordered time-ordered operators is given by simple integrals over the corresponding classical distribution functions. For one-time operators this result is well known. For two-time operators, a proof is given using the quantum-regression theorem of the second paper in this series. Amplitude and phase fluctuations are discussed by rewriting the Fokker-Planck equation in the variables $I$, $\ensuremath{\varphi}$, $D$, where $\ensuremath{\beta}={I}^{\frac{1}{2}}\mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}i\ensuremath{\varphi})$. The Langevin description of the classical random process associated with ${\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}(\ensuremath{\beta}, {\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}, D, t)$ is used to make a classical adiabatic elimination of $D$. The resulting equations for ${\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}(\ensuremath{\beta}, {\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}, t)$ and $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, t)$ are shown to agree with the corresponding results of the ninth paper in this series, obtained by a more difficult quantum adiabatic elimination of $D$. The equation for $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, t)$, rewritten in the $n$ representation agrees with corresponding results of Scully and Lamb.

Physical Review•May 10, 1967•214 citations

Quantum Noise. IV. Quantum Theory of Noise Sources

M. Lax

For a quantum system describable in a Markoffian way, via a set of variables $\mathrm{a}={{a}_{1}, {a}_{2}, \ensuremath{\cdots}}$, we show that the Langevin noise sources ${F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ in the operator equations of motion $\frac{d{a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}{\mathrm{dt}}={A}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}(\mathrm{a})+{F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ possess second moments $〈{F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}(t){F}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}(u)〉=2〈{D}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}(\mathrm{a}, t)〉\ensuremath{\delta}(t\ensuremath{-}u)$. The diffusion coefficients ${D}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}$ can be determined from a knowledge of the mean equations of motion via the (exact) time-dependent Einstein relation $2〈{D}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}〉=\ensuremath{-}〈{A}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{a}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}〉\ensuremath{-}〈{a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{A}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}〉+\frac{d〈{a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}(t){a}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}(t)〉}{\mathrm{dt}}$, where $〈 〉$ represents a reservoir average. The sources ${F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$, ${F}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ do not commute with one another, and as a result the commutation rules of the ${a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ are shown to be preserved in time. The mean motion and diffusion coefficients are calculated for a harmonic oscillator, and for a set of atomic levels. We prove that two dynamically coupled systems (e.g., field and atoms) have uncorrelated Langevin forces if they are coupled to independent reservoirs. Radiation-field-atom coupling adds no new noise sources. We thus obtain simply the maser model including noise sources used in Quantum Noise V. Direct calculations of the mean motion and fluctuations in a system coupled to a reservoir yield relationships in agreement with the Einstein relation. For reservoirs violating time reversal, anomalous frequency shifts are found possible that violate the Ritz combination principle since $\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{12}+\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{23}+\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{31}$ need not vanish.

Physical Review•May 6, 1966•451 citations

On Open Quantum Systems and Mathematical Modeling of Quantum Noise

Andrzej Jamiokowski

In modeling of physical systems for which time behaviour can be represented by stochastic processes one assumes that a system in question is described by certain mathematical model, for example, by random variables in classical case or by sets of non-commuting observables in quantum case, acting on an abstract probability space. In most cases our assumptions are not believed to be a fully realistic model of the physical reality, but nevertheless very often it turns out to be extremely useful.

InTech eBooks•Jul 24, 2013•1 citation

Phase-Space Analysis of Time-Correlation Functions

G. S. Agarwal

Using the recently developed phase-space techniques for the treatment of quantum-mechanical problems, we set up a procedure for calculating multitime-correlation functions in terms of the joint distribution functions. The correlation functions are then expressed simply as integrals over the associated phase space. Explicit expressions are given for these joint distribution functions, in terms of Green's functions of the $c$-number equations of motion for the phase-space equivalent of the density operator. Using these joint distribution functions, an exact regression theorem is rederived, and the connection with the multitime correspondence between classical and quantum stochastic processes is discussed.

Physical Review•Jan 5, 1969•16 citations

Real-time path-integral approach to quantum coherence and dephasing in nonadiabatic transitions and nonlinear optical response

Yoshitaka Tanimura, Shaul Mukamel

Quantum coherence and its destruction (dephasing) by coupling to a dissipative environment plays an important role in time-resolved nonlinear optical response as well as nonadiabatic transitions and tunneling processes in condensed phases. Generating functions of density-matrix elements and multitime coordinate and momentum correlation functions related to these phenomena are calculated using a pathintegral approach by performing functional integration. The dissipative environment is assumed to be an ensemble of harmonic oscillators and is taken into account by using Feynman-Vernon influence functional. Closed-form expressions for generating functions in terms of the bath spectral density are derived. The present theory generalizes earlier calculations of these quantities to arbitrary temperatures, any dependence of the transition coupling on coordinates (non-Condon effects), and arbitrary order in the interstate coupling. Conditions for factorizing the Liouville-space generating functions that allow a reduced description based on the classical Langevin equation are established. Possible applications to four-wave-mixing spectroscopy and nonadiabatic rate processes are discussed.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Jan 1, 1993•132 citations

Quantum Black Noise and Generalized Quantum Stochastic Equations

Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen, Igor Vasil'evich Volovich

•Feb 28, 2002•0 citations
A correspondence aj\ensuremath↔\ensuremathαj{a}_{j}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{j}aj​\ensuremath↔\ensuremathαj​ between operators a=[a1,a2,\ensuremath⋯af]\mathrm{a}=[{a}_{1}, {a}_{2}, \ensuremath{\cdots}{a}_{f}]a=[a1​,a2​,\ensuremath⋯af​] and ccc numbers \ensuremathα=[\ensuremathα1,\ensuremathα2,\ensuremath⋯\ensuremathαf]\ensuremath{\alpha}=[{\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{1}, {\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{2}, \ensuremath{\cdots}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{f}]\ensuremathα=[\ensuremathα1​,\ensuremathα2​,\ensuremath⋯\ensuremathαf​] together with an arbitrary ordering rule C\mathcal{C}C (e.g., in sequence from 1 to fff) permit an association M(a)=CM(c)(\ensuremathα)M(\mathrm{a})=\mathcal{C}{M}^{(c)}(\ensuremath{\alpha})M(a)=CM(c)(\ensuremathα) between a general operator M(a)M(\mathrm{a})M(a) and an associated ccc number function M(c)(\ensuremathα){M}^{(c)}(\ensuremath{\alpha})M(c)(\ensuremathα). A quasiprobability P(\ensuremathα,t)P(\ensuremath{\alpha}, t)P(\ensuremathα,t) is then defined so that a general ensemble average can be written as an ordinary integration: 〈M(a(t))〉=\ensuremath∫M(c)(\ensuremathα)d\ensuremathαP(\ensuremathα,t)〈M(\mathrm{a}(t))〉=\ensuremath{\int}{M}^{(c)}(\ensuremath{\alpha})d\ensuremath{\alpha}P(\ensuremath{\alpha}, t)〈M(a(t))〉=\ensuremath∫M(c)(\ensuremathα)d\ensuremathαP(\ensuremathα,t). The equation for \ensuremath∂P(\ensuremathα,t)\ensuremath∂t\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}P(\ensuremath{\alpha}, t)}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}\ensuremath∂t\ensuremath∂P(\ensuremathα,t)​ suggests that the \ensuremathα\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremathα obeys a classical Markoff process. If this classical Markoff process is taken literally, multitime classical averages can be computed. Do these correspond to appropriate quantum averages? For the case of field operators such that [b,b\ifmmode†\else\textdagger\fi]=1[b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}]=1[b,b\ifmmode†\else\textdagger\fi]=1, important in discussing laser statistics, we show that with a1=b\ifmmode†\else\textdagger\fi{a}_{1}={b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}a1​=b\ifmmode†\else\textdagger\fi and af=b{a}_{f}=baf​=b, the classical multitime average is equivalent to the average of the corresponding quantum operators written in time-ordered, normal-ordered sequence. For the atomic operators in a laser problem, we obtain the desired correspondence, but find that the more complicated commutation rules necessarily lead to derivative correction terms when multitime averages are taken. Our derivation of multitime averages is based on the quantum regression theorem. We show that this theorem is equivalent to assuming the quantum system to be Markoffian, by showing that it leads to an appropriate factorization of a multitime density matrix and to a Chapman-Kolmogoroff-like condition on the conditional density matrix.
Starting with the quantum-noise-source model of a maser developed in the fourth paper in this series and specializing to the case in which all atomic parameters except the population difference vary rapidly compared with the field, an equation is developed for the density operator $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, D, t)$ that depends on the electromagnetic field variables bbb, ${b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$ and the population difference DDD. The corresponding equation obeyed by the density matrix ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{mn}}(D, t)$ in the "nnn representation" is obtained. The antinormal ordering correspondence $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, D, t)=\mathcal{a}{\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}(\ensuremath{\beta}, {\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}, D, t)$ [in which $\ensuremath{\beta}$ is replaced by bbb and ${\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}$ by ${b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$ with all ${b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}'\mathrm{s}$ to the right of all b′sb'\mathrm{s}b′s] defines an associated classical function ${\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}$. The equation for $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\rho}}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$ corresponds to a Fokker-Planck equation for $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}{\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$. Under the Markoffian assumption, an associated classical random process is uniquely defined. The quantum-mechanical average of normal-ordered time-ordered operators is given by simple integrals over the corresponding classical distribution functions. For one-time operators this result is well known. For two-time operators, a proof is given using the quantum-regression theorem of the second paper in this series. Amplitude and phase fluctuations are discussed by rewriting the Fokker-Planck equation in the variables III, $\ensuremath{\varphi}$, DDD, where $\ensuremath{\beta}={I}^{\frac{1}{2}}\mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}i\ensuremath{\varphi})$. The Langevin description of the classical random process associated with ${\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}(\ensuremath{\beta}, {\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}, D, t)$ is used to make a classical adiabatic elimination of DDD. The resulting equations for ${\overline{\ensuremath{\rho}}}^{(a)}(\ensuremath{\beta}, {\ensuremath{\beta}}^{*}, t)$ and $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, t)$ are shown to agree with the corresponding results of the ninth paper in this series, obtained by a more difficult quantum adiabatic elimination of DDD. The equation for $\ensuremath{\rho}(b, {b}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}, t)$, rewritten in the nnn representation agrees with corresponding results of Scully and Lamb.
For a quantum system describable in a Markoffian way, via a set of variables $\mathrm{a}={{a}_{1}, {a}_{2}, \ensuremath{\cdots}}$, we show that the Langevin noise sources ${F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ in the operator equations of motion $\frac{d{a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}{\mathrm{dt}}={A}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}(\mathrm{a})+{F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ possess second moments $〈{F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}(t){F}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}(u)〉=2〈{D}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}(\mathrm{a}, t)〉\ensuremath{\delta}(t\ensuremath{-}u)$. The diffusion coefficients ${D}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}$ can be determined from a knowledge of the mean equations of motion via the (exact) time-dependent Einstein relation $2〈{D}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}〉=\ensuremath{-}〈{A}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{a}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}〉\ensuremath{-}〈{a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{A}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}〉+\frac{d〈{a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}(t){a}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}(t)〉}{\mathrm{dt}}$, where 〈〉〈 〉〈〉 represents a reservoir average. The sources ${F}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$, ${F}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ do not commute with one another, and as a result the commutation rules of the ${a}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ are shown to be preserved in time. The mean motion and diffusion coefficients are calculated for a harmonic oscillator, and for a set of atomic levels. We prove that two dynamically coupled systems (e.g., field and atoms) have uncorrelated Langevin forces if they are coupled to independent reservoirs. Radiation-field-atom coupling adds no new noise sources. We thus obtain simply the maser model including noise sources used in Quantum Noise V. Direct calculations of the mean motion and fluctuations in a system coupled to a reservoir yield relationships in agreement with the Einstein relation. For reservoirs violating time reversal, anomalous frequency shifts are found possible that violate the Ritz combination principle since $\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{12}+\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{23}+\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{31}$ need not vanish.
Using the recently developed phase-space techniques for the treatment of quantum-mechanical problems, we set up a procedure for calculating multitime-correlation functions in terms of the joint distribution functions. The correlation functions are then expressed simply as integrals over the associated phase space. Explicit expressions are given for these joint distribution functions, in terms of Green's functions of the ccc-number equations of motion for the phase-space equivalent of the density operator. Using these joint distribution functions, an exact regression theorem is rederived, and the connection with the multitime correspondence between classical and quantum stochastic processes is discussed.
Quantum coherence and its destruction (dephasing) by coupling to a dissipative environment plays an important role in time-resolved nonlinear optical response as well as nonadiabatic transitions and tunneling processes in condensed phases. Generating functions of density-matrix elements and multitime coordinate and momentum correlation functions related to these phenomena are calculated using a pathintegral approach by performing functional integration. The dissipative environment is assumed to be an ensemble of harmonic oscillators and is taken into account by using Feynman-Vernon influence functional. Closed-form expressions for generating functions in terms of the bath spectral density are derived. The present theory generalizes earlier calculations of these quantities to arbitrary temperatures, any dependence of the transition coupling on coordinates (non-Condon effects), and arbitrary order in the interstate coupling. Conditions for factorizing the Liouville-space generating functions that allow a reduced description based on the classical Langevin equation are established. Possible applications to four-wave-mixing spectroscopy and nonadiabatic rate processes are discussed.