Two-dimensional (2D) line shapes derived from four types of coherent third-order nonlinear spectroscopies as a function of two independent time or frequency variables are compared. The signals scattered into two wave-vector-matching directions in the limits of high-time or high-frequency resolution are calculated for an inhomogeneously broadened ensemble of two-level systems with phenomenological dephasing and population relaxation times. While one-dimensional (1D) line shape analysis for this model is ambiguous, the contours of these 2D line shapes are shown to be characteristic of the relative time scales of the three relevant line-broadening parameters. These broadening mechanisms are also apparent by comparing 2D spectral profiles along the diagonal and antidiagonal frequency axes. For time domain experiments, in analogy with NMR correlation spectroscopy, the radiated signal is observed as a function of the two coherence periods and is 2D Fourier transformed to obtain a line shape. For experiments based on the photon echo, the ellipticity of the absolute value 2D line shape is related to the ratio of the inhomogeneous width to the dephasing rate, whereas experiments based on the transient grating method are shown to be functionally 1D. For frequency domain experiments, the contours of the 2D line shape can yield information on static and both dynamic broadening mechanisms. While the addition of spectral diffusion to such calculations will modify these results for frequency domain experiments, characterizing these dynamics in the time domain naturally leads to a 3D experiment analogous to the spin diffusion experiment in NMR.
Two-dimensional (2D) line shapes derived from four types of coherent third-order nonlinear spectroscopies as a function of two independent time or frequency variables are compared. The signals scattered into two wave-vector-matching directions in the limits of high-time or high-frequency resolution are calculated for an inhomogeneously broadened ensemble of two-level systems with phenomenological dephasing and population relaxation times. While one-dimensional (1D) line shape analysis for this model is ambiguous, the contours of these 2D line shapes are shown to be characteristic of the relative time scales of the three relevant line-broadening parameters. These broadening mechanisms are also apparent by comparing 2D spectral profiles along the diagonal and antidiagonal frequency axes. For time domain experiments, in analogy with NMR correlation spectroscopy, the radiated signal is observed as a function of the two coherence periods and is 2D Fourier transformed to obtain a line shape. For experiments based on the photon echo, the ellipticity of the absolute value 2D line shape is related to the ratio of the inhomogeneous width to the dephasing rate, whereas experiments based on the transient grating method are shown to be functionally 1D. For frequency domain experiments, the contours of the 2D line shape can yield information on static and both dynamic broadening mechanisms. While the addition of spectral diffusion to such calculations will modify these results for frequency domain experiments, characterizing these dynamics in the time domain naturally leads to a 3D experiment analogous to the spin diffusion experiment in NMR.
The two-dimensional (2D) temporal shape of the (degenerate) three-pulse photon-echo (3-PPE) polarization P(3)(t′,τ12,τ23=0) has been theoretically analyzed for a weakly interacting two-site system (TSS) in the presence of site inhomogeneous broadening. The TSS has been modeled in terms of two identical, energy-degenerate, excitonically coupled pairs of electronic states in the site-representation (i.e., two S0 and S1 states forming a 4-level system). The 2D time-domain signal S(t′,τ12,τ23=0) has been derived in a closed-form solution which allowed to formulate the analytical Fourier transform analog under sequential δ-pulse excitation. The resulting 2D PE signal in frequency–frequency space S(ωt′,ωτ12) is formed in the region of the resonant, optical carrier frequency by, generally, four peaks, arranged at the edges of a square with distances determined by the excitonic coupling. The two diagonal peaks are of one-exciton origin, while the two off-diagonal (cross) peaks involve two-exciton effects, too. The relative heights of the four peaks are in distinct relation with the mutual orientation of the site-localized transition dipoles, thus these 2D line shapes serving as a structural probe for resonantly interacting molecules. The shapes of the peaks reflect the ratio between homogeneous and inhomogeneous dephasings and can be used for structural studies of statically disordered systems of TSS. The semiclassical two-site model is intended to provide a preparatory platform for mimicking electronically coupled segmental pairs dispersed in energy and space along the strongly disordered main chain contour. The results of the model calculation are taken to discuss the potential and the limitations of 2D line shape echo-spectroscopy in the study of short-range coherences and electronic coupling in π-conjugated polymers.
A solution to Maxwell's equations in the three-dimensional frequency domain is used to calculate rephasing two-dimensional Fourier transform (2DFT) spectra of the D2 line of atomic rubidium vapor in argon buffer gas. Experimental distortions from the spatial propagation of pulses through the sample are simulated in 2DFT spectra calculated for the homogeneous Bloch line shape model. Spectral features that appear at optical densities of up to 3 are investigated. As optical density increases, absorptive and dispersive distortions start with peak shape broadening, progress to peak splitting, and ultimately result in a previously unexplored coherent transient twisting of the split peaks. In contrast to the low optical density limit, where the 2D peak shape for the Bloch model depends only on the total dephasing time, these distortions of the 2D peak shape at finite optical density vary with the waiting time and the excited state lifetime through coherent transient effects. Experiment-specific conditions are explored, demonstrating the effects of varying beam overlap within the sample and of pseudo-time domain filtering. For beam overlap starting at the sample entrance, decreasing the length of beam overlap reduces the line width along the ωτ axis but also reduces signal intensity. A pseudo-time domain filter, where signal prior to the center of the last excitation pulse is excluded from the FID-referenced 2D signal, reduces propagation distortions along the ωt axis. It is demonstrated that 2DFT rephasing spectra cannot take advantage of an excitation-detection transformation that can eliminate propagation distortions in 2DFT relaxation spectra. Finally, the high optical density experimental 2DFT spectrum of rubidium vapor in argon buffer gas [J. Phys. Chem. A 2013, 117, 6279-6287] is quantitatively compared, in line width, in depth of peak splitting, and in coherent transient peak twisting, to a simulation with optical density higher than that reported.
A theoretical analysis is carried out for the recently developed three-pulse photon echo spectroscopy employing dual frequency combs (DFC) as the light sources. In this method, the molecular sample interacts with three pulse trains derived from the DFC, and the generated third-order signal is displayed as a two-dimensional (2D) spectrum that depends on the waiting time introduced by employing the asynchronous optical sampling method. Through the analysis of the heterodyne-detected signal interferogram using a local oscillator derived from one of the optical frequency combs, we show that the 2D spectrum closely matches the spectrum expected from a conventional approach with four pulses derived from a single femtosecond laser pulse, and the waiting time between the second and third field-matter interactions is given by the down-converted detection time of the interferogram. The theoretical result is applied to a two-level model system with solvation effect described by solvatochromic spectral density. The model 2D spectrum reproduces spectral features such as the loss of frequency correlation, dephasing, and spectral shift as a function of the population time. We anticipate that the present theory will be the general framework for quantitative descriptions of DFC-based nonlinear optical spectroscopy.
The connection between dephasing of optical coherence and the measured spectral density of the pure solvent is made through measurements and calculations of photon echo signals. 2-pulse photon echo measurements of a cyanine dye in polar solvents are presented. Signals are recorded for both phase matched directions enabling accurate determination of the echo signal time shift. Echo signals are calculated by two approaches that employ the response function description of nonlinear spectroscopy; (i) a single Brownian oscillator line shape model, and (ii) the line shape obtained using the solvent spectral density. The strongly overdamped Brownian oscillator model incorporates only a single adjustable parameter while the experimental data present two fitting constraints. The second model incorporates the measured solvent spectral density. Both give very good agreement with the experimental results. The significance of the second method lies in this being a new approach to calculate nonlinear spectroscopic signals, for comparison with experimental data, that uses directly the measured spectrum of equilibrium fluctuations of the solvent. This approach also provides a better conceptual perspective for deriving insight into the nature of the solute–solvent coupling mechanism. Comparing the parameters for the strength of interaction in a variety of polar solvents it is found that the coupling involves the solvent polarizability and not the solvent polarity. The interaction mechanism cannot be deduced from the Brownian oscillator calculations.
We have recently shown that homogeneous and heterogeneous kinetics can be distinguished by experiments that compare the evolution of the population of a state over two time intervals [E. van Veldhoven et al., ChemPhysChem 8, 1761 (2007)]. This paper elaborates on the analogy between these multiple population-period transient spectroscopy (MUPPETS) experiments and more familiar spectroscopies based on the evolution of coherences. Using a modified inverse-Laplace transform, a standard kinetics decay is re-expressed as a "rate spectrum." A nonexponential decay creates a linewidth in this spectrum. Mechanisms for line broadening in rate spectra are compared to those for line broadening in frequency-domain spectra. Homogeneous and heterogeneous kinetics are defined precisely and are shown to be the counterparts of homogeneous and inhomogeneous line broadenings in frequency-domain spectra. Homogeneous line broadening mechanisms are further divided into equilibrium and nonequilibrium mechanisms, with equilibrium mechanisms more prevalent in frequency spectra and nonequilibrium mechanisms more prevalent in rate spectra. Spectral representations of two-dimensional MUPPETS experiments are developed that are equivalent to two-dimensional coherence spectroscopies. In particular, spectra equivalent to hole-burning and to correlation spectra are defined. Frequency-domain spectra are often modeled as an inhomogeneous distribution of identical homogeneous line shapes. A parallel homogeneous-heterogeneous model for kinetics is defined. Within this model, MUPPETS has sufficient information to completely separate the homogeneous and heterogeneous contributions to a nonexponential decay, even when the homogeneous contribution is nonexponential.
Over the past 15 years, researchers have extended the multidimensional techniques which originated with NMR in the 1970s to infrared and visible coherent spectroscopy. These advances have dramatically enhanced the temporal resolution from the microsecond to the femtosecond regime. NMR spectroscopists have developed principles for the design of pulse sequences that enhance selected spectral features and reveal desired dynamical events. Extending these principles to the optical regime offers numerous opportunities for narrowing the line shapes in specific directions, unraveling weak cross-peaks from otherwise congested spectra, and controlling the interferences between quantum pathways. We can achieve these enhancements by shaping the spectral and temporal profiles of the pulses. Pulse polarization shaping may lead to unique probes of time-dependent chirality. In this Account, we compare two types of signals. The first, the photon echo, is generated in the direction -k(1) + k(2) + k(3), and the second, double quantum coherence, is detected at +k(1) + k(2) - k(3). Here k(1), k(2), and k(3) are the wave vectors of the three incoming pulses in chronological order. We illustrate the novel information extracted from these signals by simulations of three physical systems. In the first system, spectra of GaAs semiconductor quantum wells provide a direct look at many-body electron correlation effects. We directly observe specific projections of the many-electron wave function, which we can use to test the quality of various levels of computational techniques for electronic structure. Secondly, the spectra of photosynthetic aggregates reveal couplings between chromophores, quantum coherence signatures of chromophore entanglement, and energy-transfer pathways. Using some fundamental symmetries of pulse polarization configurations of nonlinear signals, we can construct superpositions of signals designed to better distinguish among various coherent and incoherent exciton transport pathways and amplify subtle variations among different species of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) antenna complex. Both of the first two applications require femtosecond pulses of light in the visible range. The third application demonstrates how resonant core spectroscopy may be used to generate core excitations that are highly localized at selected atoms. Such signals can monitor the motions of valence electron wavepackets in real space with atomic spatial resolution. These future X-ray applications will require attosecond bright X-ray sources, which are currently being developed in several labs. Common principles underlie these techniques in coherent spectroscopy for spins, valence electrons, and core electronic excitations, spanning frequencies from radiowaves to hard X-rays.