Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on the Momentum-Translation Approximation

Claude N. Cohen-Tannoudji, J. Dupont-Roc, Claude Fabre, G. Grynberg

Published Nov 1, 1973• 38 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Some objections concerning the validity of a new nonperturbative treatment of multiphoton processes ("momentum-translation approximation") are presented and discussed. In the present state of the question, it seems that the multiphoton amplitudes given by this theory cannot be considered as reliable.
DOI
10.1103/physreva.8.2747

Related papers

A comment on the momentum translation approximation for the calculation of transition amplitude for high-order electromagnetic transitions

Bhaskar J. Choudhury

The author has compared multiphoton transition probability calculated by the momentum translation approximation with that of the perturbation theory calculation. By this comparison, it is shown that the momentum translation approximation gives a cross section which is always lower than the cross section calculated by the use of perturbation theory.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Mar 1, 1973•5 citations

Validity and meaning of the momentum-translation approximation for bound states in a radiation field

Alain Decoster

The conditions of validity for the momentum-translation approximation of Reiss are found much more stringent than was thought before: multiphotonic transitions induced by one strong field cannot be described by this method. First-order transitions between bound states dressed by a strong low-frequency field can be calculated, but the method gives nothing but a trivial result; only for the ionization of a dressed atom is the approximation found useful.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1974•17 citations

Comments on the short-time behaviour of multiphoton ionisation

S N Dixit, A. T. Georges, P. Lambropoulos +1 more

Some questions regarding the applicability of theoretical results (1977, 1978) for the short-time behaviour of the multiphoton ionisation to the experiments are discussed. It is argued that the relevant conditions could not have been satisfied in the experiments concerned.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Mar 14, 1980•3 citations

Momentum-Translation Approximation outside Its Domain of Applicability

John E. Rogerson, Robert N. De Witt, Howard R. Reiss

The momentum-translation approximation is valid for electromagnetic transitions in bound systems caused by external radiation of photon energy much less than the transition energy. Its utility is explored here for two types of problems that violate that restriction. One application is to resonant bound-bound multiphoton transitions of low multiphoton order, and results are compared to recent perturbative calculations. The other application is to both the transition rate and the spectrum of two-photon spontaneous emission from the metastable $2S$ state in hydrogen. Predicted transition rates are too low, but the spectrum agrees well with the known results. All momentum-translation results follow from simple closed-form analytical expressions.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1973•12 citations

Multiphoton-ionization transition amplitudes and the Keldysh approximation

Fabio Trombetta, S. Basile, G. Ferrante

The Keldysh approximation to treat the multiphoton ionization of atoms is reconsidered. It is shown that, if one consistently uses the hypothesis under which the approximation should be valid (essentially, that of a weak, short-range binding potential), a Keldysh-like term results as an approximation to the first term of a uniformly convergent series in powers of the binding potential. No cancellation occurs when higher-order terms are taken into account. This result allows one to consider the Keldysh approximation as a well-defined theoretical model, without implying, however, that it is adequate to describe multiphoton ionization of real atoms.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1989•11 citations

Comment on ‘‘Multiphoton-ionization transition amplitudes and the Keldysh approximation’’

H. S. Antunes Neto, L. Davidovich, Peter W. Milonni

We show that the approach of Trombetta, Basile, and Ferrante [Phys. Rev. A 40, 2774 (1989)] does not establish the Keldysh ansatz as a well-defined approximation. In particular, it in effect replaces a vanishing contribution to the ionization rate by a nonvanishing one.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1990•6 citations
The momentum-translation approximation is valid for electromagnetic transitions in bound systems caused by external radiation of photon energy much less than the transition energy. Its utility is explored here for two types of problems that violate that restriction. One application is to resonant bound-bound multiphoton transitions of low multiphoton order, and results are compared to recent perturbative calculations. The other application is to both the transition rate and the spectrum of two-photon spontaneous emission from the metastable 2S2S2S state in hydrogen. Predicted transition rates are too low, but the spectrum agrees well with the known results. All momentum-translation results follow from simple closed-form analytical expressions.
The Keldysh approximation to treat the multiphoton ionization of atoms is reconsidered. It is shown that, if one consistently uses the hypothesis under which the approximation should be valid (essentially, that of a weak, short-range binding potential), a Keldysh-like term results as an approximation to the first term of a uniformly convergent series in powers of the binding potential. No cancellation occurs when higher-order terms are taken into account. This result allows one to consider the Keldysh approximation as a well-defined theoretical model, without implying, however, that it is adequate to describe multiphoton ionization of real atoms.