Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Essays

Statistical Equivalence and Particle Indistinguishability

Bernard H. Lavenda

Published Jun 1, 1992• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.4006/1.3028972

Related papers

Indistinguishability of particles and complementarity in statistical thermodynamics

D. Neri

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B•Jun 1, 1987•0 citations

On the geometry of quantum indistinguishability

A F Reyes-Lega

An algebraic approach to the study of quantum mechanics on configuration spaces with a finite fundamental group is presented. It uses, in an essential way, the Gelfand–Naimark and Serre–Swan equivalences and thus allows one to represent geometric properties of such systems in algebraic terms. As an application, the problem of quantum indistinguishability is reformulated in the light of the proposed approach. Previous attempts aiming at a proof of the spin-statistics theorem in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are explicitly recast in the global language inherent to the presented techniques. This leads to a critical discussion of single-valuedness of wavefunctions for systems of indistinguishable particles. Potential applications of the methods presented in this paper to problems related to quantization, geometric phases and phase transitions in spin systems are proposed.

arXiv:1112.6300•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 21, 2011•0 citations

Indistinguishability of particles and exchangeable random variables

Istvan Vincze

De Gruyter eBooks•Dec 31, 1985•0 citations

The Principle of equal Probabilities of Quantum States

M. Psimopoulos, Emilie Dafflon

The statistical problem of the distribution of $s$ quanta of equal energy $ε_0$ and total energy $E$ among $N$ distinguishable particles is resolved using the conventional theory based on Boltzmann's principle of equal probabilities of configurations of particles distributed among energy levels and the concept of average state. In particular, the probability that a particle is in the \k{appa}-th energy level i.e. contains \k{appa} quanta, is given by $p(κ)=\displaystyle \frac{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-κ-2}{N-2}}{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-1}{N-1}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; κ= 0, 1, 2, \cdots, s$ In this context, the special case ($N=4$, $s=4$) presented indicates that the alternative concept of most probable state is not valid for finite values of $s$ and $N$. In the present article we derive alternatively $p(κ)$ by distributing $s$ quanta over $N$ particles and by introducing a new principle of equal probability of quantum states, where the quanta are indistinguishable in agreement with the Bose statistics. Therefore, the analysis of the two approaches presented in this paper highlights the equivalence of quantum theory with classical statistical mechanics for the present system. At the limit $ε_{o} \rightarrow 0 $; $s \rightarrow \infty $; $s ε_{o} = E \sim$ fixed, where the energy of the particles becomes continuous, $p(κ)$ transforms to the Boltzmann law $P(ε) = \displaystyle \frac{1}{\langle ε\rangle}e^{-\fracε{\langle ε\rangle}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; 0\leq ε< +\infty$ where $\langle ε\rangle = E/N$. Hence, the classical principle of equal a priori probabilities for the energy of the particles leading to the above law, is justified here by quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2111.09246•Nov 17, 2021•0 citations

Quantum Statistics from Indistinguishability

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Spatial Asymmetry For Particle Pairs And The Spin-Statistics Theorem

Michael J. York

We discuss the conditions under which identical particles may yet be distinguishable and the relationship between particle permutation and exchange. We show that we can always define permutation-symmetric state vectors. When the particles are completely indistinguishable, then exchange is equivalent to permutation and therefore the exchange eigenvalue for such permutation-symmetric state vectors is always +1. Exchange asymmetry arises when the particles are physically distinguishable, even though otherwise identical, and can be computed from the transformations that arise when the distinguishing features are reversed. There is a fundamental spatial asymmetry between the relative orientations of any two vectors in a common frame of reference that persists even in the limit that the vectors coincide. For a pair of particles this asymmetry between their spin quantization frames renders them distinguishable even when otherwise identical. In the conventional construction, this distinction is not properly accounted for. Particle exchange is then equivalent to reversing this relative orientation --- which requires a relative rotation by 2pi on the spin quantization frame of one particle with respect to the other, thus resulting in the conventional exchange phase.

arXiv:quant-ph/9809012•Sep 5, 1998•1 citation
An algebraic approach to the study of quantum mechanics on configuration spaces with a finite fundamental group is presented. It uses, in an essential way, the Gelfand–Naimark and Serre–Swan equivalences and thus allows one to represent geometric properties of such systems in algebraic terms. As an application, the problem of quantum indistinguishability is reformulated in the light of the proposed approach. Previous attempts aiming at a proof of the spin-statistics theorem in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are explicitly recast in the global language inherent to the presented techniques. This leads to a critical discussion of single-valuedness of wavefunctions for systems of indistinguishable particles. Potential applications of the methods presented in this paper to problems related to quantization, geometric phases and phase transitions in spin systems are proposed.
The statistical problem of the distribution of sss quanta of equal energy ε0ε_0ε0​ and total energy EEE among NNN distinguishable particles is resolved using the conventional theory based on Boltzmann's principle of equal probabilities of configurations of particles distributed among energy levels and the concept of average state. In particular, the probability that a particle is in the \k{appa}-th energy level i.e. contains \k{appa} quanta, is given by p(κ)=(N+s−κ−2N−2)(N+s−1N−1)      ;      κ=0,1,2,⋯ ,sp(κ)=\displaystyle \frac{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-κ-2}{N-2}}{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-1}{N-1}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; κ= 0, 1, 2, \cdots, sp(κ)=(N−1N+s−1​)(N−2N+s−κ−2​)​;κ=0,1,2,⋯,s In this context, the special case (N=4N=4N=4, s=4s=4s=4) presented indicates that the alternative concept of most probable state is not valid for finite values of sss and NNN. In the present article we derive alternatively p(κ)p(κ)p(κ) by distributing sss quanta over NNN particles and by introducing a new principle of equal probability of quantum states, where the quanta are indistinguishable in agreement with the Bose statistics. Therefore, the analysis of the two approaches presented in this paper highlights the equivalence of quantum theory with classical statistical mechanics for the present system. At the limit $ε_{o} \rightarrow 0 $; $s \rightarrow \infty $; sεo=E∼s ε_{o} = E \simsεo​=E∼ fixed, where the energy of the particles becomes continuous, p(κ)p(κ)p(κ) transforms to the Boltzmann law P(ε)=1⟨ε⟩e−ε⟨ε⟩      ;      0≤ε<+∞P(ε) = \displaystyle \frac{1}{\langle ε\rangle}e^{-\fracε{\langle ε\rangle}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; 0\leq ε< +\inftyP(ε)=⟨ε⟩1​e−⟨ε⟩ε​;0≤ε<+∞ where ⟨ε⟩=E/N\langle ε\rangle = E/N⟨ε⟩=E/N. Hence, the classical principle of equal a priori probabilities for the energy of the particles leading to the above law, is justified here by quantum mechanics.
We discuss the conditions under which identical particles may yet be distinguishable and the relationship between particle permutation and exchange. We show that we can always define permutation-symmetric state vectors. When the particles are completely indistinguishable, then exchange is equivalent to permutation and therefore the exchange eigenvalue for such permutation-symmetric state vectors is always +1. Exchange asymmetry arises when the particles are physically distinguishable, even though otherwise identical, and can be computed from the transformations that arise when the distinguishing features are reversed. There is a fundamental spatial asymmetry between the relative orientations of any two vectors in a common frame of reference that persists even in the limit that the vectors coincide. For a pair of particles this asymmetry between their spin quantization frames renders them distinguishable even when otherwise identical. In the conventional construction, this distinction is not properly accounted for. Particle exchange is then equivalent to reversing this relative orientation --- which requires a relative rotation by 2pi on the spin quantization frame of one particle with respect to the other, thus resulting in the conventional exchange phase.