Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Canadian Journal of Physics

Projected evolution superoperators and the density operator: theory and applications to inelastic scattering

R. E. Turner, John S. Dahler, Robert F. Snider

Published Oct 1, 1982• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The projection operator method of Zwanzig and Feshbach is used to construct the time dependent density operator associated with a binary scattering event. The formula developed to describe this time dependence involves time-ordered cosine and sine projected evolution (memory) superoperators. Both Sehrödinger and interaction picture results are presented. The former is used to demonstrate the equivalence of the time dependent solution of the von Neumann equation and the more familiar, frequency dependent Laplaee transform solution. For two particular classes of projection superoperators projected density operators arc shown to be equivalent to projected wave functions. Except for these two special eases, no projected wave function analogs of projected density operators exist. Along with the decoupled-motions approximation, projected interaction picture density operators arc applied to inelastic scattering events. Simple illustrations arc provided of how this formalism is related to previously established results for two-state processes, namely, the theory of resonant transfer events, the first order Magnus approximation, and the Landau–Zener theory.

DOI
10.1139/p82-185

Related papers

Time-dependent projection-operator approach to master equations for coupled systems. II. Systems with correlations

Richard H. Picard, C. R. Willis

In a previous paper we showed how time-dependent projection operators may be employed to enable the Nakajima-Zwanzig projection-operator technique for deriving exact master equations to deal efficiently with two or more coupled classical or quantum systems, neither of which is reservoir like. We considered in detail the case where the relevant part of the classical-system probability-density function (PDF) or quantumsystem density operator (DO) is a product of the PDF's or DO's for the separate subsystems, and we applied the techniques developed to problems in quantum optics and in the kinetic theory of dilute nonideal gases. In this paper we make the time-dependent projection-operator approach useful for a greater variety of systems by allowing the relevant part of the PDF or DO to include correlations between two of the interacting subsystems. This extension allows us to describe well the dynamics of strongly interacting systems in a low degree of approximation while avoiding the use of infinite resummations. We derive exact generalized master equations in this manner for the same two cases as in our earlier work, namely a classical gas of $N$ molecules interacting via a two-body potential and a quantum-optical system of $N$ two-level atoms interacting with an electromagnetic field. In the former case, the relevant part of the PDF contains two-body correlations, and we obtain two exact coupled master equations for the singlet and doublet PDF's ${F}_{1}(t)$ and ${F}_{2}(t)$. In the latter case, the relevant part of the DO contains atom-field correlations, and the result is three exact coupled equations for the single-atom DO ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{1}(t)$, the field DO $R(t)$, and the DO for one atom plus the field $\ensuremath{\chi}(t)$. From the exact equations we derive approximate equations by making simplifying assumptions. In the case of the gas we carry out a straightforward density expansion of the ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{F}}_{2}$ master equation and obtain a set of kinetic equations for dense gases, which have been derived previously by Frieman, Goldman, and Dorfman and which describe well effects due to the finite mean free path. In the quantum-optical case we derive kinetic equations for a single-mode laser by treating the $\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\chi}}$ equation in the Born-Markoff approximation. The equations describe gain saturation and other effects on the field dynamics which are of infinite order in the atom-field coupling constant. It is shown that these equations reduce to previously derived laser master equations if atom-atom correlations can be neglected. Finally, we mention possible generalizations of the time-dependent projection-operator approach used in this paper and briefly discuss its application to other problems, including the kinetics of liquids, collisional line broadening, superradiance, and amplified spontaneous emission.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1977•28 citations

Mori-Zwanzig projection operator formalism for far-from-equilibrium systems with time-dependent Hamiltonians

Michael te Vrugt, Raphael Wittkowski

The Mori-Zwanzig projection operator formalism is a powerful method for the derivation of mesoscopic and macroscopic theories based on known microscopic equations of motion. It has applications in a large number of areas including fluid mechanics, solid-state theory, spin relaxation theory, and particle physics. In its present form, however, the formalism cannot be directly applied to systems with time-dependent Hamiltonians. Such systems are relevant in many scenarios such as driven soft matter or nuclear magnetic resonance. In this article we derive a generalization of the present Mori-Zwanzig formalism that is able to treat also time-dependent Hamiltonians. The extended formalism can be applied to classical and quantum systems, close to and far from thermodynamic equilibrium, and even in the case of explicitly-time-dependent observables. Moreover, we develop a variety of approximation techniques that enhance the practical applicability of our formalism. Generalizations and approximations are developed for both equations of motion and correlation functions. Our formalism is demonstrated for the important case of spin relaxation in a time-dependent external magnetic field. The Bloch equations are derived together with microscopic expressions for the relaxation times.

arXiv:1903.00583•Physical review. E•Jun 17, 2019•53 citations

Q. M. Pictures; Heisenberg Equation; Linear Response; Superoperators and Non-Markovian Equations

Norman J. M. Horing

Abstract Three fundamental and equivalent mathematical frameworks (“pictures”) in which quantum theory can be lodged are exhibited and their relations and relative advantages/disadvantages are discussed: (1) The Schrödinger picture considers the dynamical development of the overall system state vector as a function of time relative to a fixed complete set of time-independent basis eigenstates; (2) The Heisenberg picture (convenient for the use of Green’s functions) embeds the dynamical development of the system in a time-dependent counter-rotation of the complete set of basis eigenstates relative to the fixed, time-independent overall system state, so that the relation of the latter fixed system state to the counter-rotating basis eigenstates is identically the same in the Heisenberg picture as it is in the Schrödinger picture; (3) the Interaction Picture addresses the situation in which a Hamiltonian, H=H0+H1, involves a part H0 whose equations are relatively easy to solve and a more complicated part, H1, treated perturbatively. The Heisenberg equation of motion for operators is discussed, and is applied to annihilation and creation operators. The S-matrix, density matrix and von Neumann equation, along with superoperators and non-Markovian kinetic equations are also addressed (e.g. the intracollisional field effect).

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 27, 2017•0 citations

Feshbach Projection Formalism for Open Quantum Systems

Dariusz Chruściński, Andrzej Kossakowski

We provide a new approach to open quantum systems which is based on the Feshbach projection method. Instead of looking for a master equation for the dynamical map acting in the space of density operators we provide the corresponding equation for the evolution in the Hilbert space of the amplitude operators. Its solution enables one to construct a legitimate quantum evolution (completely positive and trace preserving). Our approach, contrary to the standard Nakajima-Zwanzig method, allows for a series of consistent approximations resulting in a legitimate quantum evolution. The new scheme is illustrated by the well-known spin-boson model beyond the rotating wave approximation. It is shown that the presence of counterrotating terms dramatically changes the asymptotic evolution of the system.

arXiv:1302.6218•Physical Review Letters•Jul 30, 2013•36 citations

Projection Operator Technique

Biman Bagchi

Overview Projection operator technique is simple in purpose. It allows us to separate the dynamical evolution of a quantity into two parts: known and unknown, the latter to be evaluated. However, this technique serves multiple purposes in TDSM. It is used to derive a reduced equation of motion for the relaxation of a dynamical variable. It is also used to derive expression for an experimentally observed TCF in terms of theoretically known TCFs. This technique was developed by Zwanzig, who was inspired by Kubo’s approach of “reduction in degrees of freedom” in an interacting many-body system. In the projection operator method, we divide the time evolution of a dynamical variable A ( t ) into two parts: (i) one through a relevant subspace that is closely related to A and varies on a similar time scale, and (ii) an orthogonal subspace, which could be fast and therefore can be averaged out to obtain a time-dependent friction kernel. The idea then is that the first contribution is known while the second may be described accurately by projecting it onto the relevant subspace [that is, (i)]. In the derivation of the reduced equation of motion, one starts with the Liouville equation and projects out irrelevant degrees of freedom to obtain, after specific algebraic manipulations, an equation of motion of the dynamical variable. The final relaxation equation has the form of the Langevin equation with microscopic expressions for the terms involved (frequency term, the friction, and the random force term). This final equation of motion is often termed relaxation equation or memory function equation. It finds wide use in the study of time-dependent statistical mechanics. In the present chapter we derive the memory function equation and discuss a few applications.

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Oct 2, 2023•0 citations

Reduced equations of motion and reduced S matrix for scattering processes

Shaul Mukamel

Reduced equations of motion (REM) are derived for the reduced density matrix of some of the degrees of freedom taking part in a scattering process. The derivation is made making use of the Zwanzig–Mori projection operator technique and utilizing a partial time ordering prescription (POP) which results in simple REM which contain no convolution in time. The present formulation is convenient for the direct calculation of reduced information on scattering events since it avoids the necessity of calculating the complete S matrix. The entire dynamical information relevant for the present description is expressed in terms of a hierarchy of correlation functions which in turn depend on the potential surface only in the region of interest. We further develop an exponential approximation for the reduced tetradic scattering S matrix in Liouville space, which forms a convenient framework for systematic approximations.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 1, 1981•4 citations
The projection operator method of Zwanzig and Feshbach is used to construct the time dependent density operator associated with a binary scattering event. The formula developed to describe this time dependence involves time-ordered cosine and sine projected evolution (memory) superoperators. Both Sehrödinger and interaction picture results are presented. The former is used to demonstrate the equivalence of the time dependent solution of the von Neumann equation and the more familiar, frequency dependent Laplaee transform solution. For two particular classes of projection superoperators projected density operators arc shown to be equivalent to projected wave functions. Except for these two special eases, no projected wave function analogs of projected density operators exist. Along with the decoupled-motions approximation, projected interaction picture density operators arc applied to inelastic scattering events. Simple illustrations arc provided of how this formalism is related to previously established results for two-state processes, namely, the theory of resonant transfer events, the first order Magnus approximation, and the Landau–Zener theory.
In a previous paper we showed how time-dependent projection operators may be employed to enable the Nakajima-Zwanzig projection-operator technique for deriving exact master equations to deal efficiently with two or more coupled classical or quantum systems, neither of which is reservoir like. We considered in detail the case where the relevant part of the classical-system probability-density function (PDF) or quantumsystem density operator (DO) is a product of the PDF's or DO's for the separate subsystems, and we applied the techniques developed to problems in quantum optics and in the kinetic theory of dilute nonideal gases. In this paper we make the time-dependent projection-operator approach useful for a greater variety of systems by allowing the relevant part of the PDF or DO to include correlations between two of the interacting subsystems. This extension allows us to describe well the dynamics of strongly interacting systems in a low degree of approximation while avoiding the use of infinite resummations. We derive exact generalized master equations in this manner for the same two cases as in our earlier work, namely a classical gas of NNN molecules interacting via a two-body potential and a quantum-optical system of NNN two-level atoms interacting with an electromagnetic field. In the former case, the relevant part of the PDF contains two-body correlations, and we obtain two exact coupled master equations for the singlet and doublet PDF's F1(t){F}_{1}(t)F1​(t) and F2(t){F}_{2}(t)F2​(t). In the latter case, the relevant part of the DO contains atom-field correlations, and the result is three exact coupled equations for the single-atom DO ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{1}(t)$, the field DO R(t)R(t)R(t), and the DO for one atom plus the field $\ensuremath{\chi}(t)$. From the exact equations we derive approximate equations by making simplifying assumptions. In the case of the gas we carry out a straightforward density expansion of the ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{F}}_{2}$ master equation and obtain a set of kinetic equations for dense gases, which have been derived previously by Frieman, Goldman, and Dorfman and which describe well effects due to the finite mean free path. In the quantum-optical case we derive kinetic equations for a single-mode laser by treating the $\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\chi}}$ equation in the Born-Markoff approximation. The equations describe gain saturation and other effects on the field dynamics which are of infinite order in the atom-field coupling constant. It is shown that these equations reduce to previously derived laser master equations if atom-atom correlations can be neglected. Finally, we mention possible generalizations of the time-dependent projection-operator approach used in this paper and briefly discuss its application to other problems, including the kinetics of liquids, collisional line broadening, superradiance, and amplified spontaneous emission.
The Mori-Zwanzig projection operator formalism is a powerful method for the derivation of mesoscopic and macroscopic theories based on known microscopic equations of motion. It has applications in a large number of areas including fluid mechanics, solid-state theory, spin relaxation theory, and particle physics. In its present form, however, the formalism cannot be directly applied to systems with time-dependent Hamiltonians. Such systems are relevant in many scenarios such as driven soft matter or nuclear magnetic resonance. In this article we derive a generalization of the present Mori-Zwanzig formalism that is able to treat also time-dependent Hamiltonians. The extended formalism can be applied to classical and quantum systems, close to and far from thermodynamic equilibrium, and even in the case of explicitly-time-dependent observables. Moreover, we develop a variety of approximation techniques that enhance the practical applicability of our formalism. Generalizations and approximations are developed for both equations of motion and correlation functions. Our formalism is demonstrated for the important case of spin relaxation in a time-dependent external magnetic field. The Bloch equations are derived together with microscopic expressions for the relaxation times.
Abstract Three fundamental and equivalent mathematical frameworks (“pictures”) in which quantum theory can be lodged are exhibited and their relations and relative advantages/disadvantages are discussed: (1) The Schrödinger picture considers the dynamical development of the overall system state vector as a function of time relative to a fixed complete set of time-independent basis eigenstates; (2) The Heisenberg picture (convenient for the use of Green’s functions) embeds the dynamical development of the system in a time-dependent counter-rotation of the complete set of basis eigenstates relative to the fixed, time-independent overall system state, so that the relation of the latter fixed system state to the counter-rotating basis eigenstates is identically the same in the Heisenberg picture as it is in the Schrödinger picture; (3) the Interaction Picture addresses the situation in which a Hamiltonian, H=H0+H1, involves a part H0 whose equations are relatively easy to solve and a more complicated part, H1, treated perturbatively. The Heisenberg equation of motion for operators is discussed, and is applied to annihilation and creation operators. The S-matrix, density matrix and von Neumann equation, along with superoperators and non-Markovian kinetic equations are also addressed (e.g. the intracollisional field effect).
We provide a new approach to open quantum systems which is based on the Feshbach projection method. Instead of looking for a master equation for the dynamical map acting in the space of density operators we provide the corresponding equation for the evolution in the Hilbert space of the amplitude operators. Its solution enables one to construct a legitimate quantum evolution (completely positive and trace preserving). Our approach, contrary to the standard Nakajima-Zwanzig method, allows for a series of consistent approximations resulting in a legitimate quantum evolution. The new scheme is illustrated by the well-known spin-boson model beyond the rotating wave approximation. It is shown that the presence of counterrotating terms dramatically changes the asymptotic evolution of the system.
Overview Projection operator technique is simple in purpose. It allows us to separate the dynamical evolution of a quantity into two parts: known and unknown, the latter to be evaluated. However, this technique serves multiple purposes in TDSM. It is used to derive a reduced equation of motion for the relaxation of a dynamical variable. It is also used to derive expression for an experimentally observed TCF in terms of theoretically known TCFs. This technique was developed by Zwanzig, who was inspired by Kubo’s approach of “reduction in degrees of freedom” in an interacting many-body system. In the projection operator method, we divide the time evolution of a dynamical variable A ( t ) into two parts: (i) one through a relevant subspace that is closely related to A and varies on a similar time scale, and (ii) an orthogonal subspace, which could be fast and therefore can be averaged out to obtain a time-dependent friction kernel. The idea then is that the first contribution is known while the second may be described accurately by projecting it onto the relevant subspace [that is, (i)]. In the derivation of the reduced equation of motion, one starts with the Liouville equation and projects out irrelevant degrees of freedom to obtain, after specific algebraic manipulations, an equation of motion of the dynamical variable. The final relaxation equation has the form of the Langevin equation with microscopic expressions for the terms involved (frequency term, the friction, and the random force term). This final equation of motion is often termed relaxation equation or memory function equation. It finds wide use in the study of time-dependent statistical mechanics. In the present chapter we derive the memory function equation and discuss a few applications.
Reduced equations of motion (REM) are derived for the reduced density matrix of some of the degrees of freedom taking part in a scattering process. The derivation is made making use of the Zwanzig–Mori projection operator technique and utilizing a partial time ordering prescription (POP) which results in simple REM which contain no convolution in time. The present formulation is convenient for the direct calculation of reduced information on scattering events since it avoids the necessity of calculating the complete S matrix. The entire dynamical information relevant for the present description is expressed in terms of a hierarchy of correlation functions which in turn depend on the potential surface only in the region of interest. We further develop an exponential approximation for the reduced tetradic scattering S matrix in Liouville space, which forms a convenient framework for systematic approximations.