The uncertainty relation for joint measurement of postion and momentum

Reinhard F. Werner

Published Dec 1, 2004• 77 citations

Abstract

We prove an uncertainty relation, which imposes a bound on any joint measurement of position and momentum. It is of the form (ΔP)(ΔQ) ≥ Ch, where the 'uncertainties' quantify the difference between the marginals of the joint measurement and the corresponding ideal observable. Applied to an approximate position measurement followed by a momentum measurement, the uncertainties become the precision ΔQ of the position measurement, and the perturbation ΔP of the conjugate variable introduced by such a measurement. We also determine the best constant C, which is attained for a unique phase space covariant measurement.

DOI: 10.5555/2011593.2011606

Related papers

The uncertainty relation for joint measurement of position and momentum

Reinhard F. Werner

We prove an uncertainty relation, which imposes a bound on any joint measurement of position and momentum. It is of the form (\Delta P)(\Delta Q)\geq C\hbar, where the `uncertainties' quantify the difference between the marginals of the joint measurement and the corresponding ideal observable. Applied to an approximate position measurement followed by a momentum measurement, the uncertainties become the precision \Delta Q of the position measurement, and the perturbation \Delta P of the conjugate variable introduced by such a measurement. We also determine the best constant C, which is attained for a unique phase space covariant measurement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0405184Quantum Information and ComputationDec 1, 200459 citations

Measurement Uncertainty Relations for Position and Momentum: Relative Entropy Formulation

Alberto Barchielli, Matteo Gregoratti, Alessandro Toigo

Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle has recently led to general measurement uncertainty relations for quantum systems: incompatible observables can be measured jointly or in sequence only with some unavoidable approximation, which can be quantified in various ways. The relative entropy is the natural theoretical quantifier of the information loss when a `true’ probability distribution is replaced by an approximating one. In this paper, we provide a lower bound for the amount of information that is lost by replacing the distributions of the sharp position and momentum observables, as they could be obtained with two separate experiments, by the marginals of any smeared joint measurement. The bound is obtained by introducing an entropic error function, and optimizing it over a suitable class of covariant approximate joint measurements. We fully exploit two cases of target observables: (1) n-dimensional position and momentum vectors; (2) two components of position and momentum along different directions. In (1), we connect the quantum bound to the dimension n; in (2), going from parallel to orthogonal directions, we show the transition from highly incompatible observables to compatible ones. For simplicity, we develop the theory only for Gaussian states and measurements.

arXiv:1705.09949EntropyJun 24, 201716 citations

Measurement uncertainty relations

Paul Busch, PEKKA J. LAHTI, Reinhard F. Werner

Measurement uncertainty relations are quantitative bounds on the errors in an approximate joint measurement of two observables. They can be seen as a generalization of the error/disturbance tradeoff first discussed heuristically by Heisenberg. Here we prove such relations for the case of two canonically conjugate observables like position and momentum, and establish a close connection with the more familiar preparation uncertainty relations constraining the sharpness of the distributions of the two observables in the same state. Both sets of relations are generalized to means of order α rather than the usual quadratic means, and we show that the optimal constants are the same for preparation and for measurement uncertainty. The constants are determined numerically and compared with some bounds in the literature. In both cases, the near-saturation of the inequalities entails that the state (resp. observable) is uniformly close to a minimizing one.

arXiv:1312.4392Journal of Mathematical PhysicsApr 1, 201488 citations

Uncertainty relations for quantum particles

Σπυρίδων Κεχριμπάρης

The focus of the present investigation is uncertainty relations for quantum particles, which quantify the fundamental limitations on some of their properties due to their incompatibility. In the first, longer part, we are concerned with preparational uncertainty \nrelations, while in the second we touch upon measurement inequalities through a generalisation of a model of joint measurement of position and momentum. \nSpecifically, starting from a triple of canonical operators, we prove product and sum inequalities for their variances with bounds larger than those following from combining the pairwise ones. We extend these results to N observables for a quantum particle and prove uncertainty relations for the sums and products of their variances \nin terms of the commutators. \nFurthermore, we present a general theory of preparational uncertainty relations for a quantum particle in one dimension and derive conditions for a smooth function of the second moments to assume a lower bound. The Robertson-Schroedinger inequality \nis found to be of special significance and we geometrically study the space of second moments. We prove new uncertainty relations for various functions of the variances and covariance of position and momentum of a quantum particle. Some of our findings are shown to extend to more than one spatial degree of freedom and we derive \nvarious types of inequalities. \nFinally, we propose a generalisation of the Arthurs-Kelly model of joint measurement of position and momentum to incorporate the case of more than two observables and derive joint-measurement inequalities for the statistics of the probes. For the case of \nthree canonical observables and suitable definitions of error and disturbance we obtain a number of error-error-error and error-error-disturbance inequalities and show that the lower bound is identical to the preparational one.

Dec 1, 20151 citation

Uncertainty relation and the measurement error–perturbation relation

Yurii I. Vorontsov

The origins and physical consequences of the traditionally used relation between the position measurement error and the momentum perturbation, Δm2xΔp2p ≥ 2/4, are discussed. It is demonstrated that the corresponding increase in the momentum variance for the aposteriori state occurs only in some special cases. The product of Δm2A and Δp2B is shown to essentially differ from the one given by the uncertainty relation if the commutator is an operator. The error quantum limits for the joint homodyne measurement of quadrature amplitudes for an optical mode are found. It is shown that similar results can be obtained if the quadratures of a harmonic oscillator are estimated by means of continuous position measurement.

Physics-UspekhiOct 31, 20057 citations

Error and unsharpness in approximate joint measurements of position and momentum

Paul Busch, David B. Pearson

In recent years, novel quantifications of measurement error in quantum mechanics have for the first time enabled precise formulations of Heisenberg's famous but often challenged measurement uncertainty relation. These relations take the form of a trade-off for the necessary errors in joint approximate measurements of position and momentum and other incompatible pairs of observables. Here we review some of these error measures, examine their properties and suitability, and compare their relative strengths as criteria for "good" approximations.

arXiv:1405.6956May 27, 20142 citations