Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks

A Unified Framework for Modeling and Solving Combinatorial Optimization Problems: A Tutorial

Gary A. Kochenberger, Fred Glover

Published Jun 16, 2006• 29 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In recent years the unconstrained quadratic binary program (UQP) has emerged as a unified framework for modeling and solving a wide variety of combinatorial optimization problems. This tutorial gives an introduction to this evolving area. The methodology is illustrated by several examples and substantial computational experience demonstrating the viability and robustness of the approach.

DOI
10.1007/0-387-29550-x_4

Related papers

A Tutorial on Formulating and Using QUBO Models

Fred Glover, Gary A. Kochenberger, Yu Du

The Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) model has gained prominence in recent years with the discovery that it unifies a rich variety of combinatorial optimization problems. By its association with the Ising problem in physics, the QUBO model has emerged as an underpinning of the quantum computing area known as quantum annealing and has become a subject of study in neuromorphic computing. Through these connections, QUBO models lie at the heart of experimentation carried out with quantum computers developed by D-Wave Systems and neuromorphic computers developed by IBM. Computational experience is being amassed by both the classical and the quantum computing communities that highlights not only the potential of the QUBO model but also its effectiveness as an alternative to traditional modeling and solution methodologies. This tutorial discloses the basic features of the QUBO model that give it the power and flexibility to encompass the range of applications that have thrust it onto center stage of the optimization field. We show how many different types of constraining relationships arising in practice can be embodied within the "unconstrained" QUBO formulation in a very natural manner using penalty functions, yielding exact model representations in contrast to the approximate representations produced by customary uses of penalty functions. Each step of generating such models is illustrated in detail by simple numerical examples, to highlight the convenience of using QUBO models in numerous settings. We also describe recent innovations for solving QUBO models that offer a fertile avenue for integrating classical and quantum computing and for applying these models in machine learning.

arXiv:1811.11538•Nov 13, 2018•504 citations

A Tutorial on Formulating QUBO Models.

Fred Glover, Gary A. Kochenberger

The field of Combinatorial Optimization (CO) is one of the most important areas in the general field of optimization, with important applications found in every industry, including both the private and public sectors. It is also one of the most active research areas pursued by the research communities of Operations Research, Computer Science, and Analytics as they work to design and test new methods for solving real world CO problems. In recent years, we have discovered that a mathematical formulation known as QUBO, an acronym for a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization problem, can embrace a large variety of important CO problems found in industry and government. Through special reformulation techniques that are easy to apply, the power of QUBO solvers can be used to efficiently solve many important problems once they are put into the QUBO framework. This two-step process of first re-casting an original model into the form of a QUBO model and then solving it with appropriate software enables the QUBO model to become a unifying framework for combinatorial optimization. The alternative path that results for effectively modeling and solving many important problems is a new development in the field of combinatorial optimization. The materials provided in subsequent sections illustrate the process of reformulating important optimization problems as QUBO models through a series of explicit examples. Collectively these examples highlight the application breadth of the QUBO model. We do not focus here on modeling a given problem in the form classically adopted in the optimization community. Rather, our examples disclose the methods that can be used to recast a given problem, perhaps existing in a classical mathematical form, into an equivalent QUBO model.

•Nov 13, 2018•24 citations

Quadratic Optimization and Quantum Computing

Mark W. Lewis

Recent advances in quantum computing along with increased interest in solving difficult optimization problems is shining a light on a research area that has been quietly growing for the past twenty plus years. This area involves modeling difficult decision problems as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problems and then solving them on a new type

Science Trends•Nov 7, 2017•0 citations

Constraint Programming to Discover One-Flip Local Optima of Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization Problems

Amit Verma, Mark W. Lewis

The broad applicability of Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) constitutes a general-purpose modeling framework for combinatorial optimization problems and are a required format for gate array and quantum annealing computers. QUBO annealers as well as other solution approaches benefit from starting with a diverse set of solutions with local optimality an additional benefit. This paper presents a new method for generating a set of one-flip local optima leveraging constraint programming. Further, as demonstrated in experimental testing, analysis of the solution set allows the generation of soft constraints to help guide the optimization process.

arXiv:2104.01709•Apr 4, 2021•3 citations

Polynomial unconstrained binary optimisation â part 2

Fred Glover, Jin‐Kao Hao, Gary A. Kochenberger

The class of problems known as quadratic zero-one (binary) unconstrained optimization has provided access to a vast array of combinatorial optimization problems, allowing them to be expressed within the setting of a single unifying model. A gap exists, however, in addressing polynomial problems of degree greater than 2. to bridge this gap, we provide methods for efficiently executing core search processes for the general polynomial unconstrained binary (PUB) optimization problem. A variety of search algorithms for quadratic optimization can take advantage of our methods to be transformed directly into algorithms for problems where the objective functions involve arbitrary polynomials. Part 1 of this paper (Glover, Hao and Kochenberger, 2010) provided fundamental results for carrying out the transformations and described coding and decoding procedures relevant for efficiently handling sparse problems, where many coefficients are 0, as typically arise in practical applications. In the present Part 2 paper, we provide special algorithms and data structures for taking advantage of the basic results of Part 1. We also disclose how our designs can be used to enhance existing quadratic optimization algorithms.

International Journal of Metaheuristics•Jan 1, 2011•12 citations

A Method for Large Scale Unconstrained Binary Quadratic Programming Problem Based on Graph Neural Network

Jia-jia Huang, Shenshen Gu

In recent years, the advantages of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) in solving complex combinatorial optimization problems have become more and more obvious. Under this background, this paper demonstrates a method based on GNNs to solve large-scale Unconstrained 0–1 Quadratic Programming (UBQP) problems. Firstly, the UBQP problem models of different combinatorial optimization problems are converted into a unified graph model. This approach makes up for the shortcoming that GNNs cannot be effectively applied to combinatorial optimization problems not based on graph. Secondly, based on Graph Attention Network (GAT) algorithm, this study designs a general GNN model capable of solving UBQP problems. In addition, a random sampling scheme for the complete graph structure is devised, which greatly alleviates the pronounced over-smoothing phenomenon when the model is applied to complete graphs and speeds up the convergence rate. In this paper, a supervised learning approach is adopted to train and test a unified structured model (without changing network parameters) on UBQP problems of varying sizes, and to evaluate the model's generalization ability on high-dimensional UBQP problems. Furthermore, an unsupervised learning mechanism is utilized to train and solve individual sample problems of different dimensions. These experimental results consistently demonstrate that the model and strategy presented in this paper exhibit strong solving ability and generalization ability for combinatorial optimization problems.

International Conference on Intelligent Control and Information Processing•Mar 8, 2024•1 citation
In recent years the unconstrained quadratic binary program (UQP) has emerged as a unified framework for modeling and solving a wide variety of combinatorial optimization problems. This tutorial gives an introduction to this evolving area. The methodology is illustrated by several examples and substantial computational experience demonstrating the viability and robustness of the approach.
The Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) model has gained prominence in recent years with the discovery that it unifies a rich variety of combinatorial optimization problems. By its association with the Ising problem in physics, the QUBO model has emerged as an underpinning of the quantum computing area known as quantum annealing and has become a subject of study in neuromorphic computing. Through these connections, QUBO models lie at the heart of experimentation carried out with quantum computers developed by D-Wave Systems and neuromorphic computers developed by IBM. Computational experience is being amassed by both the classical and the quantum computing communities that highlights not only the potential of the QUBO model but also its effectiveness as an alternative to traditional modeling and solution methodologies. This tutorial discloses the basic features of the QUBO model that give it the power and flexibility to encompass the range of applications that have thrust it onto center stage of the optimization field. We show how many different types of constraining relationships arising in practice can be embodied within the "unconstrained" QUBO formulation in a very natural manner using penalty functions, yielding exact model representations in contrast to the approximate representations produced by customary uses of penalty functions. Each step of generating such models is illustrated in detail by simple numerical examples, to highlight the convenience of using QUBO models in numerous settings. We also describe recent innovations for solving QUBO models that offer a fertile avenue for integrating classical and quantum computing and for applying these models in machine learning.
The field of Combinatorial Optimization (CO) is one of the most important areas in the general field of optimization, with important applications found in every industry, including both the private and public sectors. It is also one of the most active research areas pursued by the research communities of Operations Research, Computer Science, and Analytics as they work to design and test new methods for solving real world CO problems. In recent years, we have discovered that a mathematical formulation known as QUBO, an acronym for a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization problem, can embrace a large variety of important CO problems found in industry and government. Through special reformulation techniques that are easy to apply, the power of QUBO solvers can be used to efficiently solve many important problems once they are put into the QUBO framework. This two-step process of first re-casting an original model into the form of a QUBO model and then solving it with appropriate software enables the QUBO model to become a unifying framework for combinatorial optimization. The alternative path that results for effectively modeling and solving many important problems is a new development in the field of combinatorial optimization. The materials provided in subsequent sections illustrate the process of reformulating important optimization problems as QUBO models through a series of explicit examples. Collectively these examples highlight the application breadth of the QUBO model. We do not focus here on modeling a given problem in the form classically adopted in the optimization community. Rather, our examples disclose the methods that can be used to recast a given problem, perhaps existing in a classical mathematical form, into an equivalent QUBO model.
The broad applicability of Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) constitutes a general-purpose modeling framework for combinatorial optimization problems and are a required format for gate array and quantum annealing computers. QUBO annealers as well as other solution approaches benefit from starting with a diverse set of solutions with local optimality an additional benefit. This paper presents a new method for generating a set of one-flip local optima leveraging constraint programming. Further, as demonstrated in experimental testing, analysis of the solution set allows the generation of soft constraints to help guide the optimization process.
The class of problems known as quadratic zero-one (binary) unconstrained optimization has provided access to a vast array of combinatorial optimization problems, allowing them to be expressed within the setting of a single unifying model. A gap exists, however, in addressing polynomial problems of degree greater than 2. to bridge this gap, we provide methods for efficiently executing core search processes for the general polynomial unconstrained binary (PUB) optimization problem. A variety of search algorithms for quadratic optimization can take advantage of our methods to be transformed directly into algorithms for problems where the objective functions involve arbitrary polynomials. Part 1 of this paper (Glover, Hao and Kochenberger, 2010) provided fundamental results for carrying out the transformations and described coding and decoding procedures relevant for efficiently handling sparse problems, where many coefficients are 0, as typically arise in practical applications. In the present Part 2 paper, we provide special algorithms and data structures for taking advantage of the basic results of Part 1. We also disclose how our designs can be used to enhance existing quadratic optimization algorithms.
In recent years, the advantages of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) in solving complex combinatorial optimization problems have become more and more obvious. Under this background, this paper demonstrates a method based on GNNs to solve large-scale Unconstrained 0–1 Quadratic Programming (UBQP) problems. Firstly, the UBQP problem models of different combinatorial optimization problems are converted into a unified graph model. This approach makes up for the shortcoming that GNNs cannot be effectively applied to combinatorial optimization problems not based on graph. Secondly, based on Graph Attention Network (GAT) algorithm, this study designs a general GNN model capable of solving UBQP problems. In addition, a random sampling scheme for the complete graph structure is devised, which greatly alleviates the pronounced over-smoothing phenomenon when the model is applied to complete graphs and speeds up the convergence rate. In this paper, a supervised learning approach is adopted to train and test a unified structured model (without changing network parameters) on UBQP problems of varying sizes, and to evaluate the model's generalization ability on high-dimensional UBQP problems. Furthermore, an unsupervised learning mechanism is utilized to train and solve individual sample problems of different dimensions. These experimental results consistently demonstrate that the model and strategy presented in this paper exhibit strong solving ability and generalization ability for combinatorial optimization problems.