Comment on Unruh's Paper
Henry Pierce Stapp
Abstract
William Unruh has commented on my recent proof of the incompatibility of certain predictions of quantum theory with the idea that no influence of any kind can act backward in time in any Lorentz frame.He argues that my proof contains, contrary to my explicit claim, a tacit reality assumption that conflicts with the ideas quantum theory.I show here that Unruh's argument fails to draw a necessary distinction between statements that make an assertion about actual values and statements that make an assertion about correlations between possible values, and that consequently his argument fails demonstrate the occurrence in my proof of any reality assumption that is alien to the principles of quantum theory.