A new view of Bell’s inequalities

E. C. G. Sudarshan, Tony Rothman

Paweł Horodecki, Marcin Pawłowski, Ryszard Horodecki

It is known that the local bound of a Bell inequality is sensitive to the knowledge of the external observer about the settings statistics. Here we ask how that sensitivity depends on the structure of that knowledge. It turns out that in some cases it may happen that the local bound is much more sensitive to adversary's knowledge about settings of one party than the other. Remarkably, there are Bell inequalities which are highly asymmetric with respect to the adversary's knowledge about local settings. This property may be viewed as a hidden intrinsic asymmetry of Bell inequalities. Potential implications of the revealed asymmetry effect are also discussed.

Willem M. de Muynck, Omar Abu-Zeid

Soazig Le Bihan

Since he proved his theorem in 1982, Fine has been challenging the traditional interpretation of the experimental violation of the Bell Inequalities (BI). A natural interpretation of Fine's theorem is that it provides us with an alternative set of assumptions on which to place blame for the failure of the BI, and opens to a new interpretation of the violation of the BI. Fine has a stronger interpretation for his theorem. He claims that his result undermines the traditional interpretation in terms of local realism. The aim of this paper is to understand and to assess Fine's claim. We distinguish three different strategies that Fine uses in order to support his view. We show that none of these strategies is successful. Fine fails to prove that local realism is not at stake in the violation of the BI by quantum phenomena.

Rik van Heerden

Quantum networks play an important role in the fields of quantum information and quantum computation. One of the current problems for these networks concerns nonlocality. Characterizing and detecting nonlocality is relevant to the implementation of quantum networks and quantum repeaters, where Bell inequalities can be used to test if configurations are prepared correctly. This report contains an overview of an iterative method to find Bell inequalities for networks. Starting from a given network, this method constructs a new Bell inequality for a network containing one additional source and one additional party. We use this procedure to find new Bell inequalities for specific network structures and analyse how these can be used to detect nonlocality within a network. In the first part the Bell inequalities are considered from a more theoretical point of view. We focus on star-shaped networks and discuss violations predicted by quantum mechanics. We look for quantitative bounds describing a set of states that lead to violation, giving an indication of the required quality of the sources. Finally this method is applied to a setup similar to the one described by Bernien et al. We consider a network consisting of three parties and two sources. The effect of errors during preparation of an entangled pair of photons on the ability to detect nonlocality is evaluated. The same is done for the effect of measurement errors. Using numerical computations we show that violation of the Bell inequality can be improved by choosing different measurement angles.

Gábor Hofer‐Szabó