The interference pattern in electron double-slit diffraction is a hallmark of quantum mechanics. A long-standing question for stochastic electrodynamics (SED) is whether or not it is capable of reproducing such effects, as interference is a manifestation of quantum coherence. In this study, we used excited harmonic oscillators to directly test this quantum feature in SED. We used two counter-propagating dichromatic laser pulses to promote a ground-state harmonic oscillator to a squeezed Schrödinger cat state. Upon recombination of the two well-separated wavepackets, an interference pattern emerges in the quantum probability distribution but is absent in the SED probability distribution. We thus give a counterexample that rejects SED as a valid alternative to quantum mechanics.
A general comparison is presented between random electrodynamics and quantum electrodynamics for the two systems which can be solved exactly in both theories, free electromagnetic fields and point dipole oscillators. The
N-point correlation functions of the fields are computed in both theories and are found to differ in general because of the dependence upon the order of the quantum operators within products of operators. However, if all products of quantum operators are symmetrized by taking all permutations of the operator order, then the two theories give identical results for the correlation functions. Analogous results hold to all orders in the fine-structure constant for dipole oscllators in quantum and random electrodynamics. The theories agree only if the quantum operator products are symmetrized. In the limit that the oscillator couplings to the radiation fields vanish, th oscllators can be regarded as mechanical oscillators in quantum mechanics and in random mechanics. The theory of random mechanics is defined in terms of this limit which uncouples a mechanical oscillator from the radiation field. The average values of oscillator variables in random mechanics agree with those of symmetrized products in quantum mechanics. The question is then raised as to the physical significance of the many quantum operators which differ only in the order of their factors. It is pointed out that some operator products which are regarded as physically important, such as the square of the angular momentum, indeed involve unsymmetrized products of operators. On this account the average values of the angular momentum squared in the ground state of an isotropic three-dimensional harmonic oscillator differ between the random-mechanical and quantum-mechanical descriptions. However, there seems to be no case in which experiments have shown that the (unsymmetrized) quantum operator value is to be preferred to that provided by random mechanics. The presence of thermal radiation is next treated for free electromagnetic fields and for dipole-oscillator systems. Despite extraordinary differences in the points of view toward thermal radiation taken by the two theories, the conclusion is the same as that found for zero temperature; the two theories agree in their average values if all products of quantum operators are symmetrized. Finally, as a further example of the power of random electrodynamics to give an account of phenomena where Lorentz's classical electron theory failed, we investigate the diamagnetism of a charged three-dimensional isotropic oscillator. The mathematical descriptions at finite temperature are developed in full random electrodynamics and quantum electrodynamics and in second-order perturbation theory in quantum mechanics.