Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annals of the Japan Association for Philosophy of Science

On Experimenting on the Emergence of Life : Appraisal of Demonstrative Pronoun

Koichiro Matsuno

Published Jan 1, 2008• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Experimental endeavor addressing the emergence of life faces two different frameworks of space and time. While the space-time framework applicable to the experimentalist who is designing the setup is classical in accepting both space and time being homogeneous with infinite extension, the framework intrinsic to atoms and molecules moving around inside the setup is quantum-mechanical and accordingly nonlocal though limited in its extension. A descriptive access to those atoms and molecules carrying quantum nonlocality with limited extension can be made with use of the corresponding demonstrative pronouns. One advantage of referring to demonstrative pronouns instead of ordinary nouns rests upon the ease with which one can avoid an unnecessary theoretical burden of sticking to the classical space-time framework with infinite extension all the time. Once the empirical fact of quantum non-locality with limited extension is duly focused upon, atoms and molecules as quanta can become cohesive between themselves if they happen to interact with each other. Quantum non-locality makes material interactions cohesive in precipitating synchronization between the mutually interacting bodies. Assimilation as a material capacity grounded upon the cohesiveness latent in the act of coming into synchronization, which is totally absent in the classical framework, can underlie the synthetic chemical reactions which may have been relevant to the emergence of life.

DOI
10.4288/jafpos.16.1-2_113

Related papers

When an Atom Becomes a Message—Practicing Experiments on the Origins of Life

Koichiro Matsuno

Practicing experiments on the origins of life within the framework of quantum mechanics comes to face a task of distinguishing the descriptive spaces of the object between a space of physical states and a space of probability distributions. One candidate for accommodating both the physical and the probabilistic description in a mutually tolerable manner is to apply first-second person descriptions to the space of physical states while letting the space of probability distributions addressable in third person descriptions be accessible via first-second person descriptions. The mediator or messenger for accommodating these two types of description is the process of probability flow equilibration. The relative state formulation of quantum mechanics opens a possibility for the likelihood that a simple atom such as a carbon atom may carry a message for holding the process of probability flow equilibration. An experimental example demonstrating a carbon atom serving as a messenger is found in the running of the citric acid cycle in the absence of biological enzymes.

Information•Aug 13, 2012•1 citation

Temporality Naturalized

Koichiro Matsuno

The Schrödinger equation for quantum mechanics, which is approachable in third-person description, takes for granted tenseless time that does not distinguish between different tenses such as past, present, and future. The time-reversal symmetry grounded upon tenseless time globally may, however, be broken once measurement in the form of exchanging indivisible quantum particles between the measured and the measuring intervenes. Measurement breaks tenseless time locally and distinguishes different tenses. Since measurement is about the material process of feeding and acting upon the quantum resources already available from any material bodies to be measured internally, the agency of measurement is sought within the environment in the broadest sense. Most indicative of internal measurement of the environmental origin are chemical reactions in the reaction environment. Temporality naturalized in chemical reactions proceeding as being subjected to frequent interventions of internal measurement is approachable in second-person description because of the participation of multiple agents of measurement there. The use of second-person description is found in the appraisal of the material capacity of generating, distinguishing, and integrating different tenses. An essence of the temporality to be naturalized is within the genesis of different tenses. A most conspicuous exemplar of naturalized temporality is sought in the origins of life conceivable exclusively on the material ground.

Philosophies•Dec 17, 2018•8 citations

Informational Perspective on QBism and the Origins of Life

Koichiro Matsuno

One interpretation of quantum mechanics dubbed Quantum Bayesianism or QBism in short can be considered as a useful tool for approaching the origins of life as the genuine source matrix of complexity and information on the empirical ground. Any user of quantum mechanics that can assign a probability to whatever event other than itself within the framework of QBism is to occur with the conditional probability of duration approaching unity. Such a user occurring with the probability unity can be equated with the occurrence of the internal observer that can make itself durable. A physical means of making the internal user durable is through the preservation of its own class identity that can remain invariable while being subject to the constant exchange of component atomic elements. The emergence of a durable material organization upon exchanging individual component elements with another ones of the similar kinds can be taken to be an instance related to the origins of life. A concrete empirical case of a durable material organization is a reaction cycle in which each atomic component such as the carbon atom comes to experience the organizational whole from within through the constant replacement of the components. The source of complexity and information is found within the richness of counterfactual conditionals prepared and perceived by the user of quantum mechanics. Biological complexity is unique in appreciating the chemical affinity operating as crossing and integrating different tenses in a sharp contrast to the physical counterpart upon the physical affinity operating in tenseless time.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 24, 2016•0 citations

The One, the Many, and the Quantum

Ulrich Mohrhoff

The problem of understanding quantum mechanics is in large measure the problem of finding appropriate ways of thinking about the spatial and temporal aspects of the physical world. The standard, substantival, set-theoretic conception of space is inconsistent with quantum mechanics, and so is the doctrine of local realism, the principle of local causality, and the mathematical physicist's golden calf, determinism. The said problem is made intractable by our obtruding onto the physical world a theoretical framework that is more detailed than the physical world. This framework portraits space and time as infinitely and intrinsically differentiated, whereas the physical world is only finitely differentiated spacewise and timewise, namely to the extent that spatiotemporal relations and distinctions are warranted by facts. This has the following consequences: (i) The contingent properties of the physical world, including the times at which they are possessed, are indefinite and extrinsic. (ii) We cannot think of reality as being built "from the bottom up", out of locally instantiated physical properties. Instead we must conceive of the physical world as being built "from the top down": By entering into a multitude of spatial relations with itself, "existence itself" takes on both the aspect of a spatially differentiated world and the aspect of a multiplicity of formless relata, the fundamental particles. At the root of our interpretational difficulties is the "cookie cutter paradigm", according to which the world's synchronic multiplicity is founded on the introduction of surfaces that carve up space in the manner of three-dimensional cookie cutters. The neurophysiological underpinnings of this insidious notion are discussed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0005110•May 26, 2000•3 citations

What Is Life?

Stuart Alan Kauffman

Abstract Some standard ideas about the origin of life based on classical physics and chemistry are described. The subject of the quantum world and growing evidence for quantum biology is broached, and the apparently real Poised Realm, hovering reversibly between quantum and “classical” worlds, is discussed.

Israel Journal of Chemistry•Apr 8, 2015•4 citations

A Non-Spatial Reality

Massimiliano Sassoli de Bianchi

Abstract It is generally assumed, and usually taken for granted, that reality is fully contained in space. However, when taking a closer look at the strange behavior of the entities of the micro-world, we are forced to abandon such a prejudice and recognize that space is just a temporary crystallization of a small theatre for reality, where the material entities can take a place and meet with each other. More precisely, phenomena like quantum entanglement, quantum interference effects and quantum indistinguishability, when analyzed attentively, tell us that there is much more in our physical reality than what meets our three-dimensional human eyes. But if the building blocks of our physical reality are non-spatial, what does it mean? Can we understand what the nature of a non-spatial entity is? And if so, what are the consequences for our view of the world in which we live and evolve as a species? This article was written having in mind one of the objectives of the Center Leo Apostel for Interdisciplinary Studies, that of a broad dissemination of scientific knowledge. Hence, it addresses a transversal audience of readers, both academic and nonacademic, hoping to stimulate in this way the interdisciplinary dialogue about foundational issues in science.

Foundations of Science•Nov 1, 2020•11 citations
Experimental endeavor addressing the emergence of life faces two different frameworks of space and time. While the space-time framework applicable to the experimentalist who is designing the setup is classical in accepting both space and time being homogeneous with infinite extension, the framework intrinsic to atoms and molecules moving around inside the setup is quantum-mechanical and accordingly nonlocal though limited in its extension. A descriptive access to those atoms and molecules carrying quantum nonlocality with limited extension can be made with use of the corresponding demonstrative pronouns. One advantage of referring to demonstrative pronouns instead of ordinary nouns rests upon the ease with which one can avoid an unnecessary theoretical burden of sticking to the classical space-time framework with infinite extension all the time. Once the empirical fact of quantum non-locality with limited extension is duly focused upon, atoms and molecules as quanta can become cohesive between themselves if they happen to interact with each other. Quantum non-locality makes material interactions cohesive in precipitating synchronization between the mutually interacting bodies. Assimilation as a material capacity grounded upon the cohesiveness latent in the act of coming into synchronization, which is totally absent in the classical framework, can underlie the synthetic chemical reactions which may have been relevant to the emergence of life.
Practicing experiments on the origins of life within the framework of quantum mechanics comes to face a task of distinguishing the descriptive spaces of the object between a space of physical states and a space of probability distributions. One candidate for accommodating both the physical and the probabilistic description in a mutually tolerable manner is to apply first-second person descriptions to the space of physical states while letting the space of probability distributions addressable in third person descriptions be accessible via first-second person descriptions. The mediator or messenger for accommodating these two types of description is the process of probability flow equilibration. The relative state formulation of quantum mechanics opens a possibility for the likelihood that a simple atom such as a carbon atom may carry a message for holding the process of probability flow equilibration. An experimental example demonstrating a carbon atom serving as a messenger is found in the running of the citric acid cycle in the absence of biological enzymes.
The Schrödinger equation for quantum mechanics, which is approachable in third-person description, takes for granted tenseless time that does not distinguish between different tenses such as past, present, and future. The time-reversal symmetry grounded upon tenseless time globally may, however, be broken once measurement in the form of exchanging indivisible quantum particles between the measured and the measuring intervenes. Measurement breaks tenseless time locally and distinguishes different tenses. Since measurement is about the material process of feeding and acting upon the quantum resources already available from any material bodies to be measured internally, the agency of measurement is sought within the environment in the broadest sense. Most indicative of internal measurement of the environmental origin are chemical reactions in the reaction environment. Temporality naturalized in chemical reactions proceeding as being subjected to frequent interventions of internal measurement is approachable in second-person description because of the participation of multiple agents of measurement there. The use of second-person description is found in the appraisal of the material capacity of generating, distinguishing, and integrating different tenses. An essence of the temporality to be naturalized is within the genesis of different tenses. A most conspicuous exemplar of naturalized temporality is sought in the origins of life conceivable exclusively on the material ground.
One interpretation of quantum mechanics dubbed Quantum Bayesianism or QBism in short can be considered as a useful tool for approaching the origins of life as the genuine source matrix of complexity and information on the empirical ground. Any user of quantum mechanics that can assign a probability to whatever event other than itself within the framework of QBism is to occur with the conditional probability of duration approaching unity. Such a user occurring with the probability unity can be equated with the occurrence of the internal observer that can make itself durable. A physical means of making the internal user durable is through the preservation of its own class identity that can remain invariable while being subject to the constant exchange of component atomic elements. The emergence of a durable material organization upon exchanging individual component elements with another ones of the similar kinds can be taken to be an instance related to the origins of life. A concrete empirical case of a durable material organization is a reaction cycle in which each atomic component such as the carbon atom comes to experience the organizational whole from within through the constant replacement of the components. The source of complexity and information is found within the richness of counterfactual conditionals prepared and perceived by the user of quantum mechanics. Biological complexity is unique in appreciating the chemical affinity operating as crossing and integrating different tenses in a sharp contrast to the physical counterpart upon the physical affinity operating in tenseless time.
The problem of understanding quantum mechanics is in large measure the problem of finding appropriate ways of thinking about the spatial and temporal aspects of the physical world. The standard, substantival, set-theoretic conception of space is inconsistent with quantum mechanics, and so is the doctrine of local realism, the principle of local causality, and the mathematical physicist's golden calf, determinism. The said problem is made intractable by our obtruding onto the physical world a theoretical framework that is more detailed than the physical world. This framework portraits space and time as infinitely and intrinsically differentiated, whereas the physical world is only finitely differentiated spacewise and timewise, namely to the extent that spatiotemporal relations and distinctions are warranted by facts. This has the following consequences: (i) The contingent properties of the physical world, including the times at which they are possessed, are indefinite and extrinsic. (ii) We cannot think of reality as being built "from the bottom up", out of locally instantiated physical properties. Instead we must conceive of the physical world as being built "from the top down": By entering into a multitude of spatial relations with itself, "existence itself" takes on both the aspect of a spatially differentiated world and the aspect of a multiplicity of formless relata, the fundamental particles. At the root of our interpretational difficulties is the "cookie cutter paradigm", according to which the world's synchronic multiplicity is founded on the introduction of surfaces that carve up space in the manner of three-dimensional cookie cutters. The neurophysiological underpinnings of this insidious notion are discussed.
Abstract It is generally assumed, and usually taken for granted, that reality is fully contained in space. However, when taking a closer look at the strange behavior of the entities of the micro-world, we are forced to abandon such a prejudice and recognize that space is just a temporary crystallization of a small theatre for reality, where the material entities can take a place and meet with each other. More precisely, phenomena like quantum entanglement, quantum interference effects and quantum indistinguishability, when analyzed attentively, tell us that there is much more in our physical reality than what meets our three-dimensional human eyes. But if the building blocks of our physical reality are non-spatial, what does it mean? Can we understand what the nature of a non-spatial entity is? And if so, what are the consequences for our view of the world in which we live and evolve as a species? This article was written having in mind one of the objectives of the Center Leo Apostel for Interdisciplinary Studies, that of a broad dissemination of scientific knowledge. Hence, it addresses a transversal audience of readers, both academic and nonacademic, hoping to stimulate in this way the interdisciplinary dialogue about foundational issues in science.