Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Information and Computation

Most robust and fragile two-qubit entangled states under deploarizing channels

Chao-Qian Pang, Fulin Zhang, Yue Jiang, Mai-Lin Liang, Jing‐Ling Chen

Published May 1, 2013• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

For a two-qubit system under local depolarizing channels, the most robust and most fragile states are derived for a given concurrence or negativity. For the one-sided channel, the pure states are proved to be the most robust ones, with the aid of the evolution equation for entanglement given by Konrad \emph{et al.} [Nat. Phys. 4, 99 (2008)]. Based on a generalization of the evolution equation for entanglement, we classify the ansatz states in our investigation by the amount of robustness, and consequently derive the most fragile states. For the two-sided channel, the pure states are the most robust for a fixed concurrence. Under the uniform channel, the most fragile states have the minimal negativity when the concurrence is given in the region $[1/2,1]$. For a given negativity, the most robust states are the ones with the maximal concurrence, and the most fragile ones are the pure states with minimum of concurrence. When the entanglement approaches zero, the most fragile states under general nonuniform channels tend to the ones in the uniform channel. Influences on robustness by entanglement, degree of mixture, and asymmetry between the two qubits are discussed through numerical calculations. It turns out that the concurrence and negativity are major factors for the robustness. When they are fixed, the impact of the mixedness becomes obvious. In the nonuniform channels, the most fragile states are closely correlated with the asymmetry, while the most robust ones with the degree of mixture.

DOI
10.26421/qic13.7-8-6

Related papers

Most robust and fragile two-qubit entangled states under depolarizing channels

Chao-Qian Pang, Fulin Zhang, Yue Jiang +2 more

For a two-qubit system under local depolarizing channels, the most robust and most fragile states are derived for a given concurrence or negativity. For the one-sided channel, the pure states are proved to be the most robust ones, with the aid of the evolution equation for entanglement given by Konrad et al. [Nat. Phys. 4, 99 (2008)]. Based on a generalization of the evolution equation for entanglement, we classify the ansatz states in our investigation by the amount of robustness, and consequently derive the most fragile states. For the two-sided channel, the pure states are the most robust for a fixed concurrence. Under the uniform channel, the most fragile states have the minimal negativity when the concurrence is given in the region [1/2,1]. For a given negativity, the most robust states are the ones with the maximal concurrence, and the most fragile ones are the pure states with minimum of concurrence. When the entanglement approaches zero, the most fragile states under general nonuniform channels tend to the ones in the uniform channel. Influences on robustness by entanglement, degree of mixture, and asymmetry between the two qubits are discussed through numerical calculations. It turns out that the concurrence and negativity are major factors for the robustness. When they are fixed, the impact of the mixedness becomes obvious. In the nonuniform channels, the most fragile states are closely correlated with the asymmetry, while the most robust ones with the degree of mixture.

arXiv:1202.2798•Feb 13, 2012•3 citations

Robustness of two-qubit and three-qubit states in correlated quantum channels

Zhan-Yun Wang, Feng-Lin Wu, Zhen-Yu Peng +1 more

We investigate how the correlated actions of quantum channels affect the robustness of entangled states. We consider the Bell-like state and random two-qubit pure states in the correlated depolarizing, bit flip, bit-phase flip, and phase flip channels. It is found that the robustness of two-qubit pure states can be noticeably enhanced due to the correlations between consecutive actions of these noisy channels, and the Bell-like state is always the most robust one. We also consider the robustness of three-qubit pure states in correlated noisy channels. For the correlated bit flip and phase flip channels, the result shows that although the most robust and most fragile states are locally unitary equivalent, they exhibit different robustness in different correlated channels, and the effect of channel correlations on them is also significantly different. However, for the correlated depolarizing and bit-phase flip channels, the robustness of two special three-qubit pure states is exactly the same. Moreover, compared with the random three-qubit pure states, they are neither the most robust states nor the most fragile states.

Chinese Physics B•Jan 12, 2022•2 citations

Derivation of the robustness from the concurrence

Yuri Krynytskyi, Andrij Romanovych Kuzmak

Adding the maximally mixed state with some weight to the entanglement system leads to disentanglement of the latter. For each predefined entangled state there exists a minimal value of this weight for which the system loses its entanglement properties. These values were proposed to be used as a quantitative measure of entanglement called robustness [G. Vidal and R. Tarrach, Phys. Rev. A 59, 141 (1999)]. Using the concurrence, we propose the derivation of this measure for the system of two-qubit. Namely, for a two-qubit pure state, an exact expression of robustness is obtained. Finally, in the same way, the robustness of special cases of mixed two-qubit states is calculated.

arXiv:1811.03118•Modern Physics Letters A•Jul 28, 2021•3 citations

Phonon decoherence of quantum entanglement: Robust and fragile states

T. Yu, Joseph H. Eberly

We study the robustness and fragility of entanglement of open quantum systems in some exactly solvable models in which the decoherence is caused by a pure dephasing process. In particular, for the toy models presented in this paper, we identify two different time scales, one is responsible for local dephasing, while the other is for entanglement decay. For a class of fragile entangled states defined in this paper, we find that the entanglement of two qubits, as measured by concurrence, decays faster asymptotically than the quantum dephasing of an individual qubit.

arXiv:quant-ph/0209037•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Nov 13, 2002•187 citations

Concurrence versus purity: Influence of local channels on Bell states of two qubits

Mário Ziman, Vladimír Bužek

We analyze how a maximally entangled state of two qubits (e.g., the singlet ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{s}$) is affected by the action of local channels described by completely positive maps $\mathcal{E}$. We analyze the concurrence and the purity of states ${\ensuremath{\varrho}}_{\mathcal{E}}=\mathcal{E}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\mathcal{I}[{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{s}]$. Using the concurrence-versus-purity phase diagram we characterize local channels $\mathcal{E}$ by their action on the singlet state ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{s}$. We specify a region of the concurrence-versus-purity diagram that is achievable from the singlet state via the action of unital channels. We show that even the most general (including nonunital) local channels acting just on a single qubit of the original singlet state cannot generate the maximally entangled mixed states. We study in detail various time evolutions of the original singlet state induced by local Markovian semigroups. We show that the decoherence process is represented in the concurrence-versus-purity diagram by a line that forms the lower bound of the achievable region for unital maps. On the other hand, the depolarization process is represented by a line that forms the upper bound of the region of maps induced by unital maps.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508106•Physical Review A•Nov 22, 2005•57 citations

Concurrence versus purity: Influence of local channels on Bell states of two qubits

Liscie udolie Quniverse

We analyze how a maximally entangled state of two qubits (e.g., the singlet {psi}{sub s}) is affected by the action of local channels described by completely positive maps E. We analyze the concurrence and the purity of states {rho}{sub E}=ExI[{psi}{sub s}]. Using the concurrence-versus-purity phase diagram we characterize local channels E by their action on the singlet state {psi}{sub s}. We specify a region of the concurrence-versus-purity diagram that is achievable from the singlet state via the action of unital channels. We show that even the most general (including nonunital) local channels acting just on a single qubit of the original singlet state cannot generate the maximally entangled mixed states. We study in detail various time evolutions of the original singlet state induced by local Markovian semigroups. We show that the decoherence process is represented in the concurrence-versus-purity diagram by a line that forms the lower bound of the achievable region for unital maps. On the other hand, the depolarization process is represented by a line that forms the upper bound of the region of maps induced by unital maps.

Physical Review A•Nov 15, 2005•0 citations
For a two-qubit system under local depolarizing channels, the most robust and most fragile states are derived for a given concurrence or negativity. For the one-sided channel, the pure states are proved to be the most robust ones, with the aid of the evolution equation for entanglement given by Konrad \emph{et al.} [Nat. Phys. 4, 99 (2008)]. Based on a generalization of the evolution equation for entanglement, we classify the ansatz states in our investigation by the amount of robustness, and consequently derive the most fragile states. For the two-sided channel, the pure states are the most robust for a fixed concurrence. Under the uniform channel, the most fragile states have the minimal negativity when the concurrence is given in the region [1/2,1][1/2,1][1/2,1]. For a given negativity, the most robust states are the ones with the maximal concurrence, and the most fragile ones are the pure states with minimum of concurrence. When the entanglement approaches zero, the most fragile states under general nonuniform channels tend to the ones in the uniform channel. Influences on robustness by entanglement, degree of mixture, and asymmetry between the two qubits are discussed through numerical calculations. It turns out that the concurrence and negativity are major factors for the robustness. When they are fixed, the impact of the mixedness becomes obvious. In the nonuniform channels, the most fragile states are closely correlated with the asymmetry, while the most robust ones with the degree of mixture.
For a two-qubit system under local depolarizing channels, the most robust and most fragile states are derived for a given concurrence or negativity. For the one-sided channel, the pure states are proved to be the most robust ones, with the aid of the evolution equation for entanglement given by Konrad et al. [Nat. Phys. 4, 99 (2008)]. Based on a generalization of the evolution equation for entanglement, we classify the ansatz states in our investigation by the amount of robustness, and consequently derive the most fragile states. For the two-sided channel, the pure states are the most robust for a fixed concurrence. Under the uniform channel, the most fragile states have the minimal negativity when the concurrence is given in the region [1/2,1]. For a given negativity, the most robust states are the ones with the maximal concurrence, and the most fragile ones are the pure states with minimum of concurrence. When the entanglement approaches zero, the most fragile states under general nonuniform channels tend to the ones in the uniform channel. Influences on robustness by entanglement, degree of mixture, and asymmetry between the two qubits are discussed through numerical calculations. It turns out that the concurrence and negativity are major factors for the robustness. When they are fixed, the impact of the mixedness becomes obvious. In the nonuniform channels, the most fragile states are closely correlated with the asymmetry, while the most robust ones with the degree of mixture.
We investigate how the correlated actions of quantum channels affect the robustness of entangled states. We consider the Bell-like state and random two-qubit pure states in the correlated depolarizing, bit flip, bit-phase flip, and phase flip channels. It is found that the robustness of two-qubit pure states can be noticeably enhanced due to the correlations between consecutive actions of these noisy channels, and the Bell-like state is always the most robust one. We also consider the robustness of three-qubit pure states in correlated noisy channels. For the correlated bit flip and phase flip channels, the result shows that although the most robust and most fragile states are locally unitary equivalent, they exhibit different robustness in different correlated channels, and the effect of channel correlations on them is also significantly different. However, for the correlated depolarizing and bit-phase flip channels, the robustness of two special three-qubit pure states is exactly the same. Moreover, compared with the random three-qubit pure states, they are neither the most robust states nor the most fragile states.
Adding the maximally mixed state with some weight to the entanglement system leads to disentanglement of the latter. For each predefined entangled state there exists a minimal value of this weight for which the system loses its entanglement properties. These values were proposed to be used as a quantitative measure of entanglement called robustness [G. Vidal and R. Tarrach, Phys. Rev. A 59, 141 (1999)]. Using the concurrence, we propose the derivation of this measure for the system of two-qubit. Namely, for a two-qubit pure state, an exact expression of robustness is obtained. Finally, in the same way, the robustness of special cases of mixed two-qubit states is calculated.
We study the robustness and fragility of entanglement of open quantum systems in some exactly solvable models in which the decoherence is caused by a pure dephasing process. In particular, for the toy models presented in this paper, we identify two different time scales, one is responsible for local dephasing, while the other is for entanglement decay. For a class of fragile entangled states defined in this paper, we find that the entanglement of two qubits, as measured by concurrence, decays faster asymptotically than the quantum dephasing of an individual qubit.
We analyze how a maximally entangled state of two qubits (e.g., the singlet ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{s}$) is affected by the action of local channels described by completely positive maps E\mathcal{E}E. We analyze the concurrence and the purity of states ${\ensuremath{\varrho}}_{\mathcal{E}}=\mathcal{E}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\mathcal{I}[{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{s}]$. Using the concurrence-versus-purity phase diagram we characterize local channels E\mathcal{E}E by their action on the singlet state ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{s}$. We specify a region of the concurrence-versus-purity diagram that is achievable from the singlet state via the action of unital channels. We show that even the most general (including nonunital) local channels acting just on a single qubit of the original singlet state cannot generate the maximally entangled mixed states. We study in detail various time evolutions of the original singlet state induced by local Markovian semigroups. We show that the decoherence process is represented in the concurrence-versus-purity diagram by a line that forms the lower bound of the achievable region for unital maps. On the other hand, the depolarization process is represented by a line that forms the upper bound of the region of maps induced by unital maps.
We analyze how a maximally entangled state of two qubits (e.g., the singlet {psi}{sub s}) is affected by the action of local channels described by completely positive maps E. We analyze the concurrence and the purity of states {rho}{sub E}=ExI[{psi}{sub s}]. Using the concurrence-versus-purity phase diagram we characterize local channels E by their action on the singlet state {psi}{sub s}. We specify a region of the concurrence-versus-purity diagram that is achievable from the singlet state via the action of unital channels. We show that even the most general (including nonunital) local channels acting just on a single qubit of the original singlet state cannot generate the maximally entangled mixed states. We study in detail various time evolutions of the original singlet state induced by local Markovian semigroups. We show that the decoherence process is represented in the concurrence-versus-purity diagram by a line that forms the lower bound of the achievable region for unital maps. On the other hand, the depolarization process is represented by a line that forms the upper bound of the region of maps induced by unital maps.