Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Classical Justification of the Wave-Like Behavior of Electron Beams

Hamid V. Ansari

Published Aug 1, 2009• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Relying on this fact that not only role of the medium (intermediate gas) cannot be ignored in the electric discharge between cathode and anode, but also it is very important, the diffraction and interference phenomena which an electron beam can reveal are justified. This act is done after analyzing the manner in which stroke propagates via the gas valence electrons. In this respect an experiment is proposed as a test. We conclude that the cathodic ray does not carry charge, ie is not a ray of electrons being shot but is a longitudinal wave arising from the vibration of the valence electrons of the molecules of the carrying-wave medium. In this way the mechanism of production of and the difference between the longitudinal and transverse waves and that our longitudinal wave is only due to compression (not expansion) impacts are explained. Our ability for complete deflecting and making away the electron beam (behind the anode), existence of sharp shadow of anode in the electric discharge tube, existence of dark-bright striated columns in this tube (similar to Kundt tube in acoustics), and the action mechanism of image intensifying in the image intensifier tubes are all described as witnesses to confirm the wave-like motion for electron beam proposed in this paper and reject the shooting motion for it. Deflection of the trajectory of electron beams in electric and magnetic fields is justified in wave-like motion of going and backing for evaluation of which an experiment has been proposed. It is shown that how for transferring of momentum there is no necessity to suppose shooting motion for electron in the cathodic ray. Two separate parallel cathodic rays repel each other. This will be contrary to what the electromagnetism predicts if a cathodic ray is to carry charge. This phenomenon is justified by the model presented here.

Related papers

A Preliminary Study on the Genesis of De Broglie Wave

Yicheng Chen

As for DE Broglie's hypothesis of matter waves, many experimental physicists have experimentally verified it by using cathode ray tube and proved that matter waves do exist, so there is a mysterious hypothesis of wave-particle duality.In this paper, according to the electric field force of electrons in the cathode ray tube and the continuity equation of electrons, Under assumptions such as inelastic approximation, it is proved that the wave-particle duality is actually the macroscopic motion of real particles in the form of waves.In this paper, it is proved theoretically that the component of electron velocity in the tube satisfies the wave equation, and the wave velocity varies with the change of electric potential in the tube.From the discussion in this paper, it can be seen that there are still some problems to be studied about the motion of electrons in the cathode ray tube, so that the special motion law of electrons in the cathode ray tube can be further explored from both theoretical and experimental aspects.At the same time, it is expected that the theory in this paper can provide theoretical guidance for the manufacture and debugging of electron microscopes and the design of large-scale integrated circuits, and thus influence other related fields...This will involve a vast area of science and technology!This paper is devoted to the in-depth analysis of the objective truth of the wave-particle duality presented by microscopic particles.

OALib•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Re-understanding of Wave-particle Duality

Chun Wang

The author has worked with high-resolution transmission electron microscope for many years, which provides the most direct evidence of wave-particle duality. This relates to Crookes and J. J. Thomson's cathode rays tubes to determine that electron beams are of particle nature. This also relates to Röntgen's discovery that when an electron beam in the cathode rays tube strikes the glass wall, it produces X-rays with extremely high penetrating power. This behavior is consistent with Maxwell-Lorentz’s electrodynamics that electromagnetic waves must be produced whenever electricity carriers alter their velocity. The wave-particle duality proposed by de Broglie refers to accelerated electron beam, rather than single electron. De Broglie emphasized that the crystallographic diffraction pattern produced by his electron beam was completely consistent with the crystallographic diffraction pattern of von Laue by X-rays, therefore, he proposed that electrons possess wave-particle duality. This is actually the selected area electron diffraction pattern in transmission microscope. It is X-rays, not the waves of the electrons themselves to produce diffraction pattern. He extended this to the wave-particle duality of all matter and light. Schrödinger directly introduced de Broglie's electron beam behavior into electron wave in atoms. It was just at this stage that illogical reasoning occurred, making the quantum theory increasingly difficult to understand.

Engineering Open Access•Jan 6, 2026•0 citations

Some Recent Experiments on Cathode Rays

George Paget Thomson

To members of the British Institute of Radiology the cathode ray is probably most familiar as the necessary antecedent of X rays. You are interested in them chiefly as a means to an end, but the cathode rays had a very real intrinsic interest in the nineties of last century. It was the study of the beam of light in a low-pressure discharge tube which led to the recognition of the existence of a universal constituent of matter—the electron—and I hope to show that the importance of cathode rays for the study of fundamental problems in physics is not yet exhausted. The cathode rays still form in many respects the most convenient way of studying the properties if electrons. Of recent years our views on the nature of these electrons have undergone a striking change, as a result of the brilliant inspiration of Prince Louis de Broglie, who has been rewarded with a Nobel Prize. He founded the theory which is now dominant in physics under the name of wave mechanics, and which is a general theory of the behaviour of any form of particle. According to this view all particles are associated with some form of wave, the properties of which determine much of the behaviour of the particle. This theory was originally devised by de Broglie from considerations based upon relativity.

British Journal of Radiology•Feb 1, 1931•1 citation

Electron Waves

E. Taylor Jones

Among the secondary effects produced in an X-ray, or cathode ray tube, there is one which is of special interest to physicists because it seems to throw some light on the question as to the nature of an electron. It appears that when a pencil of cathode rays falls upon the surface of a metal crystal, some of the rays are reflected, or “scattered,” and that the intensity of the scattered rays is greatest in certain directions, so that on a photographic plate placed to receive them, a diffraction pattern is produced as with X rays. The experiment proves that electrons, which were till recently supposed to be merely “particles,” really consist (like X rays), of waves, or at any rate have waves associated with them. It is to these waves associated with electrons, or “electron waves” as they are called, that I propose to devote my remarks this evening. The effect was first observed experimentally in 1927, by Davisson and Germer, who reflected cathode rays from a nickel crystal and, using an electrical method of detection, found maxima of intensity in certain directions. From the positions of the maxima and the known spacing constants of nickel they were able to deduce the wave-length of the electron waves. Later in the same year Professor G. P. Thomson obtained similar effects by transmitting cathode rays through thin metal films and receiving them on a photographic plate.

British Journal of Radiology•Jul 1, 1933•0 citations

The Discovery of a New Type of Wave Form:?A Study on the Genesis of de Broglie Waves

Yicheng Chen

This article aims to reveal the truth behind the formation of de Broglie waves and clarify the mysterious assumptions such as wave-particle duality and probability waves, which people are familiar with but do not understand the reasons behind.On the towering tree of physics, the branch concerning the interpretation of de Broglie waves has grown crooked!This article intends to sprout new buds at this node to promote the progress and prosperity of physics!Based on the electric field force that electrons experience in a cathode ray tube and the continuity equation of electrons, under assumptions such as the non-elastic approximation, this article proves that wave-particle duality is actually the macroscopic movement of microscopic particles in the form of waves.Theoretically, it is demonstrated that the transverse component of the electron's velocity in the tube satisfies a nonlinear inhomogeneous wave equation.The equations of this type should describe a complex system: under certain parameters, the system may be extremely sensitive to initial conditions, showing chaotic characteristics, and its output is extremely complex and difficult to predict over the long term.This is the uncertainty in quantum mechanics!The conclusion of this article indicates that this is a new form of wave, that is, the form of waves not only includes the propagation of vibrations but also the macroscopic movement of microscopic particles in the form of waves.Therefore, this wave can transport material particles from one end to the other in the form of waves!Moreover, this article discusses a single electron, so even if the electrons are emitted one by one, their wave characteristics can still be observed on the screen!From the discussion in this article, it can be seen that there are still some problems with the movement of electrons in the cathode ray tube that need to be solved in order to further explore the special movement laws of electrons in the cathode ray tube from both theoretical and experimental aspects.At the same time, it is hoped that the theory in this article can provide theoretical guidance for the manufacture and debugging of electron microscopes and the design of large-scale integrated circuits, thereby influencing other related How to cite this paper: Chen, Y.C.

OALib•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

An Experimental Investigation of de Broglie's Equation

J. G. Tappert

The validity of de Broglie's equation is checked experimentally for electrons of 24 to 64 electron-kilovolts energy. The experiment consists essentially of deflecting a beam of cathode rays by an electrostatic field and, keeping the deflection constant, determining the relation between the intensity of the deflecting field, $V$, and the de Broglie wave-length, $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, of the deflected electrons. On the assumption that the motion of the electrons is in accordance with the laws of relativistic mechanics, and that the de Broglie wave-length is inversely proportional to the momentum, it is shown theoretically that the expression ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}V{(1+\frac{{h}^{2}}{{{m}_{0}}^{2}{c}^{2}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}})}^{\frac{1}{2}}$ should be independent of $\ensuremath{\lambda}$. Within the limits of experimental error this expression is found to be independent of $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, thereby demonstrating that the de Broglie equation, $\ensuremath{\lambda}=\frac{h}{\mathrm{mv}}$, combined with the relativity expression for $m$, is adequate to describe the facts.

Physical Review•Dec 15, 1938•0 citations
Relying on this fact that not only role of the medium (intermediate gas) cannot be ignored in the electric discharge between cathode and anode, but also it is very important, the diffraction and interference phenomena which an electron beam can reveal are justified. This act is done after analyzing the manner in which stroke propagates via the gas valence electrons. In this respect an experiment is proposed as a test. We conclude that the cathodic ray does not carry charge, ie is not a ray of electrons being shot but is a longitudinal wave arising from the vibration of the valence electrons of the molecules of the carrying-wave medium. In this way the mechanism of production of and the difference between the longitudinal and transverse waves and that our longitudinal wave is only due to compression (not expansion) impacts are explained.
Our ability for complete deflecting and making away the electron beam (behind the anode), existence of sharp shadow of anode in the electric discharge tube, existence of dark-bright striated columns in this tube (similar to Kundt tube in acoustics), and the action mechanism of image intensifying in the image intensifier tubes are all described as witnesses to confirm the wave-like motion for electron beam proposed in this paper and reject the shooting motion for it.
Deflection of the trajectory of electron beams in electric and magnetic fields is justified in wave-like motion of going and backing for evaluation of which an experiment has been proposed. It is shown that how for transferring of momentum there is no necessity to suppose shooting motion for electron in the cathodic ray.
Two separate parallel cathodic rays repel each other. This will be contrary to what the electromagnetism predicts if a cathodic ray is to carry charge. This phenomenon is justified by the model presented here.
As for DE Broglie's hypothesis of matter waves, many experimental physicists have experimentally verified it by using cathode ray tube and proved that matter waves do exist, so there is a mysterious hypothesis of wave-particle duality.In this paper, according to the electric field force of electrons in the cathode ray tube and the continuity equation of electrons, Under assumptions such as inelastic approximation, it is proved that the wave-particle duality is actually the macroscopic motion of real particles in the form of waves.In this paper, it is proved theoretically that the component of electron velocity in the tube satisfies the wave equation, and the wave velocity varies with the change of electric potential in the tube.From the discussion in this paper, it can be seen that there are still some problems to be studied about the motion of electrons in the cathode ray tube, so that the special motion law of electrons in the cathode ray tube can be further explored from both theoretical and experimental aspects.At the same time, it is expected that the theory in this paper can provide theoretical guidance for the manufacture and debugging of electron microscopes and the design of large-scale integrated circuits, and thus influence other related fields...This will involve a vast area of science and technology!This paper is devoted to the in-depth analysis of the objective truth of the wave-particle duality presented by microscopic particles.
The author has worked with high-resolution transmission electron microscope for many years, which provides the most direct evidence of wave-particle duality. This relates to Crookes and J. J. Thomson's cathode rays tubes to determine that electron beams are of particle nature. This also relates to Röntgen's discovery that when an electron beam in the cathode rays tube strikes the glass wall, it produces X-rays with extremely high penetrating power. This behavior is consistent with Maxwell-Lorentz’s electrodynamics that electromagnetic waves must be produced whenever electricity carriers alter their velocity. The wave-particle duality proposed by de Broglie refers to accelerated electron beam, rather than single electron. De Broglie emphasized that the crystallographic diffraction pattern produced by his electron beam was completely consistent with the crystallographic diffraction pattern of von Laue by X-rays, therefore, he proposed that electrons possess wave-particle duality. This is actually the selected area electron diffraction pattern in transmission microscope. It is X-rays, not the waves of the electrons themselves to produce diffraction pattern. He extended this to the wave-particle duality of all matter and light. Schrödinger directly introduced de Broglie's electron beam behavior into electron wave in atoms. It was just at this stage that illogical reasoning occurred, making the quantum theory increasingly difficult to understand.
To members of the British Institute of Radiology the cathode ray is probably most familiar as the necessary antecedent of X rays. You are interested in them chiefly as a means to an end, but the cathode rays had a very real intrinsic interest in the nineties of last century. It was the study of the beam of light in a low-pressure discharge tube which led to the recognition of the existence of a universal constituent of matter—the electron—and I hope to show that the importance of cathode rays for the study of fundamental problems in physics is not yet exhausted. The cathode rays still form in many respects the most convenient way of studying the properties if electrons. Of recent years our views on the nature of these electrons have undergone a striking change, as a result of the brilliant inspiration of Prince Louis de Broglie, who has been rewarded with a Nobel Prize. He founded the theory which is now dominant in physics under the name of wave mechanics, and which is a general theory of the behaviour of any form of particle. According to this view all particles are associated with some form of wave, the properties of which determine much of the behaviour of the particle. This theory was originally devised by de Broglie from considerations based upon relativity.
Among the secondary effects produced in an X-ray, or cathode ray tube, there is one which is of special interest to physicists because it seems to throw some light on the question as to the nature of an electron. It appears that when a pencil of cathode rays falls upon the surface of a metal crystal, some of the rays are reflected, or “scattered,” and that the intensity of the scattered rays is greatest in certain directions, so that on a photographic plate placed to receive them, a diffraction pattern is produced as with X rays. The experiment proves that electrons, which were till recently supposed to be merely “particles,” really consist (like X rays), of waves, or at any rate have waves associated with them. It is to these waves associated with electrons, or “electron waves” as they are called, that I propose to devote my remarks this evening. The effect was first observed experimentally in 1927, by Davisson and Germer, who reflected cathode rays from a nickel crystal and, using an electrical method of detection, found maxima of intensity in certain directions. From the positions of the maxima and the known spacing constants of nickel they were able to deduce the wave-length of the electron waves. Later in the same year Professor G. P. Thomson obtained similar effects by transmitting cathode rays through thin metal films and receiving them on a photographic plate.
This article aims to reveal the truth behind the formation of de Broglie waves and clarify the mysterious assumptions such as wave-particle duality and probability waves, which people are familiar with but do not understand the reasons behind.On the towering tree of physics, the branch concerning the interpretation of de Broglie waves has grown crooked!This article intends to sprout new buds at this node to promote the progress and prosperity of physics!Based on the electric field force that electrons experience in a cathode ray tube and the continuity equation of electrons, under assumptions such as the non-elastic approximation, this article proves that wave-particle duality is actually the macroscopic movement of microscopic particles in the form of waves.Theoretically, it is demonstrated that the transverse component of the electron's velocity in the tube satisfies a nonlinear inhomogeneous wave equation.The equations of this type should describe a complex system: under certain parameters, the system may be extremely sensitive to initial conditions, showing chaotic characteristics, and its output is extremely complex and difficult to predict over the long term.This is the uncertainty in quantum mechanics!The conclusion of this article indicates that this is a new form of wave, that is, the form of waves not only includes the propagation of vibrations but also the macroscopic movement of microscopic particles in the form of waves.Therefore, this wave can transport material particles from one end to the other in the form of waves!Moreover, this article discusses a single electron, so even if the electrons are emitted one by one, their wave characteristics can still be observed on the screen!From the discussion in this article, it can be seen that there are still some problems with the movement of electrons in the cathode ray tube that need to be solved in order to further explore the special movement laws of electrons in the cathode ray tube from both theoretical and experimental aspects.At the same time, it is hoped that the theory in this article can provide theoretical guidance for the manufacture and debugging of electron microscopes and the design of large-scale integrated circuits, thereby influencing other related How to cite this paper: Chen, Y.C.
The validity of de Broglie's equation is checked experimentally for electrons of 24 to 64 electron-kilovolts energy. The experiment consists essentially of deflecting a beam of cathode rays by an electrostatic field and, keeping the deflection constant, determining the relation between the intensity of the deflecting field, VVV, and the de Broglie wave-length, $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, of the deflected electrons. On the assumption that the motion of the electrons is in accordance with the laws of relativistic mechanics, and that the de Broglie wave-length is inversely proportional to the momentum, it is shown theoretically that the expression ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}V{(1+\frac{{h}^{2}}{{{m}_{0}}^{2}{c}^{2}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}})}^{\frac{1}{2}}$ should be independent of $\ensuremath{\lambda}$. Within the limits of experimental error this expression is found to be independent of $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, thereby demonstrating that the de Broglie equation, $\ensuremath{\lambda}=\frac{h}{\mathrm{mv}}$, combined with the relativity expression for mmm, is adequate to describe the facts.