Bell’s Theorem and Mermin’s Gedanken Experiment

William J. Mullin

Chapter 7 discusses the Bell theorem and its demonstration using Mermin’s machine. The Bell theorem proves that a theory based on local realism (one with hidden variables) must satisfy certain inequalities; quantum mechanics predicts these are violated. Mermin designed a gedanken experiment having a double-particle source and two detectors each having three settings, which can correspond to measurements along three spin orientations. A simple hidden-variable assumption is shown to violate quantum predictions. The CHSH inequality, a form of the general Bell inequality, is proved. This relation has been shown to be violated experimentally in quantum experiments, implying that quantum mechanics indeed has “spooky action at a distance.” Many experiments over the years had loopholes, ways used to explain away the data in order to preserve local reality, but recent experiments have been able to eliminate most of these.

P. K. Aravind

In the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-Mermin (GHZM) proof of Bell's theorem, a source periodically emits an entangled state of three particles whose properties are analyzed by three distant observers and used to prove Bell's nonlocality theorem. This paper analyzes a somewhat different gedanken experiment involving only two observers that nevertheless makes indirect use of the GHZ states to prove Bell's theorem. The relationship of the GHZM proof to the present one is discussed, and it is pointed out that the latter provides an interesting new view of the connection between the "two theorems of John Bell".

P. K. Aravind

This paper describes a device, consisting of a central source and two widely separated detectors with six switch settings each, that provides a simple gedanken demonstration of quantum nonlocality suitable for a general audience. A comparison is made with several earlier gedanken demonstrations of the same type given by Mermin, and the new features of the present scheme are highlighted.

Damian Canals‐Frau