Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.16716

Reply to the Comment by Hradil and Řeháček

Jens Arnbak Holbøll Nielsen, Jonas S. Neergaard-Nielsen, Tobias Gehring, Ulrik L. Andersen

Published Nov 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Hradil and Řeháček argue that the quantum metrological advantage demonstrated in our squeezed-vacuum phase-sensing experiment disappears, when measurement repetitions and total photon resources are properly accounted for. We show that this conclusion is mathematically unfounded and that neither resource accounting nor finite-sample statistical considerations invalidate the demonstrated quantum-enhanced local phase sensitivity.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.16716

Related papers

Comment on J.Qin et al., Unconditional and Robust Quantum Metrological Advantage beyond N00N States, PRL 130, 070801 (2023) and J.A. H. Nielsen et.al., Deterministic Quantum Phase Estimation beyond N00N States. PRL 130, 123603 (2023)

Zdenek Hradil, Jaroslav Rehacek

The papers by Qin et al. [1] and Nielsen et al. [2] report an unconditional quantum metrological advantage based on squeezed-vacuum phase sensing. The principal evidence for this claim is the Quantum Fisher Information (QFI) evaluated per trial or per detected photon, which is subsequently interpreted as a measure of metrological performance. This interpretation is statistically unjustified because it does not account for the total experimental resources required to construct an estimator. Consequently, the reported protocols do not provide an unconditional metrological advantage over classical phase-sensing strategies when resource accounting is performed consistently.

quant-pharXiv:2609.15212•Sep 15, 2026•0 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Saturating quantum advantages in postselected metrology with the positive Kirkwood-Dirac distribution' ”

Sourav Das, Subhrajit Modak, Manabendra Nath Bera

In Das et al. [Phys. Rev. A 107, 042413 (2023)], we showed that Kirkwood-Dirac negativity is not necessary to achieve anomalous quantum Fisher information. Arvidsson-Shukur et al. [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A (to be published)] claim that one of our conclusions is wrong. Here, we argue that the claim is unfounded and incorrect and conclusions in Das et al. stand correct when the standard form of the Kirkwood-Dirac distribution is investigated. The confusion arises due to the choice of the distribution under consideration. We clarify this issue along with an interpretation of nonclassicality attached to the positivity of Kirkwood-Dirac distribution.

Physical Review A•Jun 21, 2024•0 citations

Fundamental and operational limitations of Fisher-information-based quantum metrology

Zdeněk Hradil, Jaroslav Řeháček

Quantum-enhanced sensing is commonly benchmarked using the quantum Fisher information (QFI), often interpreted as a direct indicator of achievable precision. However, such an interpreta- tion is only justified within a fully specified inference framework that consistently incorporates state preparation, measurement design, resource accounting, estimator construction, prior information, and finite data effects. Here we develop an operational, end-to-end framework for quantum sensing under finite resources and identify general principles required for meaningful performance assess- ment. A central conceptual point is that the relevant unit of estimation is not a single detection event, but the complete data set required to construct a consistent estimator. Rather than relying on abstract statistical formalism, we analyze a set of paradigmatic and experimentally relevant ex- amples that expose common pitfalls in widely discussed quantum sensing strategies. These include quantum interferometry, sensing with squeezed states, and criticality-inspired protocols. Our results clarify when large Fisher information or nonclassical resources translate into genuine metrological advantage, and when they do not. They further provide a practical methodology for designing and evaluating quantum sensing protocols under realistic experimental constraints.

quant-pharXiv:2603.08306•Mar 10, 2026•4 citations

Reply to ‘‘Comment on ‘Further investigations of the operationally defined quantum phase’ ’’

J. W. Noh, A. Fougères, L. Mandeļ

It is pointed out in response to Hradil and Bajer [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 48, 1717 (1993)] that C${\mathrm{^}}_{\mathit{M}}$ and S${\mathrm{^}}_{\mathit{M}}$ cannot both be measured together by scheme 1, whereas they can by scheme 2. There is no phase angle whose cosine and sine both vanish, and putting C+iS equal to zero for certain measurement outcomes breaks the connection with phase.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1993•6 citations

Reply to ‘‘Comment on ‘Operational approach to the phase of a quantum field’ ’’

J. W. Noh, A. Fougères, L. Mandeļ

In response to Hradil's Comment [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 47, 4532 (1993)], we point out that his prescription for putting both the cosine and sine equal to zero when the data yield ${\mathit{n}}_{3}$=${\mathit{n}}_{4}$ and ${\mathit{n}}_{5}$=${\mathit{n}}_{6}$ can lead to meaningless results. Moreover, Hradil's Eq. (5) for obtaining ${\mathit{D}}^{2}$ from the measured variance leads to disagreement with experiment. Finally, it is possible to obtain a continuous spectrum of phases with our technique.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1993•16 citations

Correspondence: Reply to ‘Enhancing a phase measurement by sequentially probing a solid-state system’

Gang‐Qin Liu, Zhang Yu-Ran, Yanchun Chang +3 more

Knott et al . 1 argue in their comment on our recently published study 2 that the enhancement of phase sensitivity is obtained by applying a phase shift twice, and thus not from the entanglement. We clarify that the entanglement between the two non-identical qubits is the crucial and decisive factor in the achieved enhancement, and the experimental technique used to encode the phases to qubits does not affect this conclusion.

Nature Communications•May 9, 2016•1 citation
Hradil and Řeháček argue that the quantum metrological advantage demonstrated in our squeezed-vacuum phase-sensing experiment disappears, when measurement repetitions and total photon resources are properly accounted for. We show that this conclusion is mathematically unfounded and that neither resource accounting nor finite-sample statistical considerations invalidate the demonstrated quantum-enhanced local phase sensitivity.
The papers by Qin et al. [1] and Nielsen et al. [2] report an unconditional quantum metrological advantage based on squeezed-vacuum phase sensing. The principal evidence for this claim is the Quantum Fisher Information (QFI) evaluated per trial or per detected photon, which is subsequently interpreted as a measure of metrological performance. This interpretation is statistically unjustified because it does not account for the total experimental resources required to construct an estimator. Consequently, the reported protocols do not provide an unconditional metrological advantage over classical phase-sensing strategies when resource accounting is performed consistently.
In Das et al. [Phys. Rev. A 107, 042413 (2023)], we showed that Kirkwood-Dirac negativity is not necessary to achieve anomalous quantum Fisher information. Arvidsson-Shukur et al. [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A (to be published)] claim that one of our conclusions is wrong. Here, we argue that the claim is unfounded and incorrect and conclusions in Das et al. stand correct when the standard form of the Kirkwood-Dirac distribution is investigated. The confusion arises due to the choice of the distribution under consideration. We clarify this issue along with an interpretation of nonclassicality attached to the positivity of Kirkwood-Dirac distribution.
Quantum-enhanced sensing is commonly benchmarked using the quantum Fisher information (QFI), often interpreted as a direct indicator of achievable precision. However, such an interpreta- tion is only justified within a fully specified inference framework that consistently incorporates state preparation, measurement design, resource accounting, estimator construction, prior information, and finite data effects. Here we develop an operational, end-to-end framework for quantum sensing under finite resources and identify general principles required for meaningful performance assess- ment. A central conceptual point is that the relevant unit of estimation is not a single detection event, but the complete data set required to construct a consistent estimator. Rather than relying on abstract statistical formalism, we analyze a set of paradigmatic and experimentally relevant ex- amples that expose common pitfalls in widely discussed quantum sensing strategies. These include quantum interferometry, sensing with squeezed states, and criticality-inspired protocols. Our results clarify when large Fisher information or nonclassical resources translate into genuine metrological advantage, and when they do not. They further provide a practical methodology for designing and evaluating quantum sensing protocols under realistic experimental constraints.
In response to Hradil's Comment [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 47, 4532 (1993)], we point out that his prescription for putting both the cosine and sine equal to zero when the data yield n3{\mathit{n}}_{3}n3​=n4{\mathit{n}}_{4}n4​ and n5{\mathit{n}}_{5}n5​=n6{\mathit{n}}_{6}n6​ can lead to meaningless results. Moreover, Hradil's Eq. (5) for obtaining D2{\mathit{D}}^{2}D2 from the measured variance leads to disagreement with experiment. Finally, it is possible to obtain a continuous spectrum of phases with our technique.