Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.13078

More physics at the entangling surface: boundary conditions and entanglement in 2d TQFT

Jackson R. Fliss, Alan Rios Fukelman, Stathis Vitouladitis

Published Nov 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a systematic treatment of entanglement in two-dimensional topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Our approach clarifies the sensitivity of entanglement measures to the cutting maps that implement Hilbert space factorization. Such maps embed the TQFT Hilbert space into a description with potentially more degrees of freedom, and for entanglement to be well defined they must be isometric, i.e., they must preserve the norms of all states. We show that the naïve cutting map based solely upon path integration subject to boundary conditions is not isometric for generic TQFTs. For any 2d TQFT, we give a prescription to construct isometric cutting maps by dressing path integration with suitable edge operators. This allows us to compute entanglement for any state, any bipartition, and any boundary condition. As a consequence, we find a non-integer "ground-state degeneracy" à la Affleck-Ludwig, despite all boundary conditions being gapped. We further show how to reconstruct the partition function of the TQFT at arbitrary genus from the multi-interval Rényi entropies of a single state. For theories with (possibly non-invertible) symmetries, we show that the entanglement entropy of the symmetric ground state can distinguish gapped phases with the same symmetry, without any further knowledge of their vacua, while the entanglement asymmetry of the vacua entropically detects symmetry breaking. We illustrate our formalism with a range of applications, from finite gauge theories to Haagerup gapped phases and infrared phases of adjoint QCD$_2$.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.13078

Related papers

Entanglement, topology, & renormalization

Jackson R. Fliss

In this thesis we will explore entanglement of various subsystems in quantum field theory, and its uses for describing underlying structure of states. We begin this journey by focusing on topological quantum field theory in chapters 1 and 2. These chapters are based heavily upon the papers [1] and [2, 3], respectively. In the introduction to chapter 1 we take the opportunity to recall the definition of bipartite entanglement entropy in quantum field theory and describe, briefly, how the entropy associated to connected spatial subregions provides a signature of topological order at the level of the wave-function. In particular, for a gapped phase with topological order, we recapitulate how the sub-leading correction to the “area-law” of the entanglement entropy contains coarse information about the topological phase while also being insensitive to the short-distance details of the underlying theory. We then present results that show that this sub-leading correction can also detect the class of interactions that glue a subregion to its complement. In principle, the subregion could be a different topological phase than its complement, and so we say that the entanglement entropy provides a signature of the interface between topological phases. In showing this, we discuss the classes of interactions between gapped topological phases and how they are represented as boundary conditions in the low-energy effective topological field theory, which in this case is an Abelian Chern-Simons theory. Using these boundary conditions, we perform path-integral calculations of the entanglement entropy using the replica trick and show that the universal contribution does indeed depend on the class of boundary conditions, and the gapped topological phases of the subsystem and its complement. To finish this chapter we reformulate this problem at the level of the Hilbert space and show how these universal contributions are related to resolving a generic ambiguity in defining subsystems of field theories with gauge invariance. We continue in the theme of topological field theories for chapter 2. Here we will shift focus from subregions of a connected spatial slice to disconnected spatial regions in an effort to explore, firstly, how long-range entanglement is encoded in topological field theory, and secondly, how that entanglement is encoded amongst multiple parties. We begin with a brief introduction of multi-party entanglement and recall the classification of three-party entanglement. Moving on to our specific setup, we describe the construction of states on multiple non-intersecting torus boundaries. Generically, these are states on link complements where the torus boundaries can be thought of as the edges of thickened closed strings entwined and knotted inside a compact manifold, which we will take to be the three-sphere. The wave-functions of these states are represented by various link invariants (such as the Gauss linking number for Abelian links, and Jones polynomial for SU(2)). We will exhibit several examples of multi-component links in both the Abelian and the SU(2) theories, and afterwards discuss generic features of the entanglement of link states in Chern-Simons theories with a compact group. In this discussion, we will conjecture a classification (albeit broad) of links via multi-partite entanglement of their corresponding states. We will end the chapter moving away from compact groups and discuss hyperbolic links in SL(2,C) Chern-Simons theory in the semi-classical limit. In particular, utilizing the generalized volume conjecture, we will show that the entanglement structure of hyperbolic links is greatly constrained in this semi-classical limit. Finally, in chapter 3 we switch gears and discuss renormalization of free bosonic field theory. The content of this chapter is drawn from the work of [4]. Motivated by work establishing duality between the singlet sector of O(N) vector models at large N and higher spin gauge theory on Anti de Sitter (AdS) space, we develop an exact renormalization group (ERG) framework for discussing the renormalization of a large class of O(N) singlet states. We will show that for the ground state and the excited states in this class the ERG is implemented by the action of unitary operators (that can be taken to be local). Consequently, the ERG framework can be regarded as a continuum tensor network. We contrast this tensor network with some well known tensor network renormalization schemes such as the muti-scale entanglement renormalization ansatz (MERA) and its proposed continuum version (cMERA). We also comment on the nature of this network with ordinary Wilsonian renormalization. One of the central features of the ERG network is how it acts on the momentum space entanglement of the field theory. In particular, we argue that for excited states, the ERG disentangles modes that lie just above and below the UV cutoff.

•Jun 5, 2019•0 citations

Symmetries & tensor networks in two-dimensional quantum physics

Henrik Dreyer

The most general description of a quantum many-body system is given by a wave- function that lives in a Hilbert space with dimension exponential in the number of particles. This makes it extremely hard to study strongly correlated phenomena like the fractional quantum Hall effect and high-temperature superconductivity. Whenever interactions are sufficiently local and temperature is low, the system does not explore the full Hilbert space, but its ground state resides in the small corner of Hilbert space described by the area law. Containing little entanglement, the states can then be expressed as tensor networks, a family of wavefunctions with a polynomial number of parameters. On the one hand, tensor networks can be used as a variational manifold in nu- merical computations. On the other hand, they allow building model wavefunctions much like locality allows writing down physically realistic Hamiltonians. Besides allowing for an analytical treatment, these models grant access both to the physical and the entanglement degrees of freedom. This is particularly useful in classifying phases of matter. A large number of phases can be explained in terms of Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. This framework, however, is not complete, as exemplified by the existence of phases with intrinsic topological order in two dimensions. It was a major conceptual advance when tensor networks could explain (non-chiral) topological phases as those where the symmetry resides in the entanglement degrees of freedom. The symmetries corresponding to those topological phases act as discrete, finite groups on the virtual degrees of freedom. The purpose of this Thesis is to generalize this program to include other symmetries. We investigate a class of tensor networks with continuous symmetries and find that they cannot describe gapped physics with a unique ground state. The abelian case is found to describe a non-Lorentz invariant phase transition point into a topologically ordered phase. The physics of the non- abelian case is that of a plaquette state that spontaneously breaks the translation symmetry of the lattice. The non-abelian PEPS arises as the ground state of a local parent Hamiltonian whose ground state manifold is completely characterized by the tensor network. In both cases, we find two types of corrections to the entanglement entropy: first there is a correction that is logarithmic in the size of the boundary and independent of the shape. A further correction depends only on the shape of the partition, imposing further restrictions on regions that are suffciently thin. Finally, we investigate symmetries that mix the virtual with the physical degrees of freedom and are furthermore anisotropic. Their physics is described by subsystem symmetry protected topological order. In particular, we focus on the entanglement entropy in the cluster phase and show that there is a universal constant correction to the entropy throughout the phase. This is important in the program of establishing the entanglement entropy as a detection mechanism for topologically ordered phases. We put forward a numerical algorithm to compute the correction and use it to discover a novel phase of matter in which the cluster phase is embedded.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

On the universality of entanglement entropy in quantum field theory

Orr Sela

The standard definition of entanglement entropy in quantum field theory requires regularizing the entangling surface and factorizing the Hilbert space, which in turn involves a choice of boundary conditions at the regularized surface. This raises two natural questions which are open at present. The first is under what conditions there is a choice of boundary conditions that leads to a unitary map between the original Hilbert space and the factorized one, which is a necessary condition for a well-defined entanglement entropy. The second concerns the situation where there are multiple such choices, in which case the question is whether they all yield the same entropy, or at least the same terms usually referred to as universal. Focusing on topological theories and using three-dimensional Chern-Simons theory as a concrete illustration, we show under specified assumptions that different such choices affect only the non-universal terms in the entropy, such that the remaining terms are universal in this sense as well, while we explicitly demonstrate that boundary conditions corresponding to non-unitary maps can change these terms. We then explain how a similar argument applies to two-dimensional conformal field theories and discuss a condition for universality in general theories.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2611.04238•Nov 4, 2026•1 citation

Tunneling topological vacua via extended operators: (Spin-)TQFT spectra and boundary deconfinement in various dimensions

Juven Wang, Kantaro Ohmori, Pavel Putrov +6 more

Distinct quantum vacua of topologically ordered states can be tunneled into each other via extended operators. The possible applications include condensed matter and quantum cosmology. We present a straightforward approach to calculate the partition function on various manifolds and ground state degeneracy (GSD), mainly based on continuum/cochain topological quantum field theories (TQFTs), in any dimension. This information can be related to the counting of extended operators of bosonic/fermionic TQFTs. On the lattice scale, anyonic particles/strings live at the ends of line/surface operators. Certain systems in different dimensions are related to each other through dimensional reduction schemes, analogous to (de)categorification. Examples include spin TQFTs derived from gauging the interacting fermionic symmetry-protected topological states (with fermion parity |$\mathbb{Z}_2^f$|⁠) of symmetry groups |$\mathbb{Z}_4\times \mathbb{Z}_2$| and |$(\mathbb{Z}_4)^2$| in 3+1D, also |$\mathbb{Z}_2$| and |$(\mathbb{Z}_2)^2$| in 2+1D. Gauging the last three cases begets non-Abelian spin TQFTs (fermionic topological order). We consider situations where a TQFT lives on (1) a closed spacetime or (2) a spacetime with a boundary, such that the bulk and boundary are fully gapped and short- or long-range entangled (SRE/LRE). Anyonic excitations can be deconfined on the boundary. We introduce new exotic topological interfaces on which neither particle nor string excitations alone condense, but only fuzzy-composite objects of extended operators can end (e.g., a string-like composite object formed by a set of particles can end on a special 2+1D boundary of 3+1D bulk). We explore the relations between group extension constructions and partially breaking constructions (e.g., 0-form/higher-form/“composite” breaking) of topological boundaries, after gauging. We comment on the implications of entanglement entropy for some such LRE systems.

arXiv:1801.05416•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Apr 13, 2018•73 citations

Interface contributions to topological entanglement in abelian Chern-Simons theory

Jackson R. Fliss, Xueda Wen, Onkar Parrikar +4 more

We study the entanglement entropy between (possibly distinct) topological phases across an interface using an Abelian Chern-Simons description with topological boundary conditions (TBCs) at the interface. From a microscopic point of view, these TBCs correspond to turning on particular gapping interactions between the edge modes across the interface. However, in studying entanglement in the continuum Chern-Simons description, we must confront the problem of non-factorization of the Hilbert space, which is a standard property of gauge theories. We carefully define the entanglement entropy by using an extended Hilbert space construction directly in the continuum theory. We show how a given TBC isolates a corresponding gauge invariant state in the extended Hilbert space, and hence compute the resulting entanglement entropy. We find that the sub-leading correction to the area law remains universal, but depends on the choice of topological boundary conditions. This agrees with the microscopic calculation of [1]. Additionally, we provide a replica path integral calculation for the entropy. In the case when the topological phases across the interface are taken to be identical, our construction gives a novel explanation of the equivalence between the left-right entanglement of (1+1)d Ishibashi states and the spatial entanglement of (2+1)d topological phases.

arXiv:1705.09611•Journal of High Energy Physics•Sep 1, 2017•53 citations

Entanglement branes and factorization in conformal field theory

Ling-Yan Hung, Gabriel Wong

In this work, we consider the question of local Hilbert space factorization in 2D conformal field theory. Generalizing previous work on entanglement and open-closed TQFT, we interpret the factorization of CFT states in terms of path integral processes that split and join the Hilbert spaces of circles and intervals. More abstractly, these processes are cobordisms of an extended CFT which are defined purely in terms of the OPE data. In addition to the usual sewing axioms, we impose an entanglement boundary condition that is satisfied by the vacuum Ishibashi state. This choice of entanglement boundary state leads to reduced density matrices that sum over super-selection sectors, which we identify as the CFT edge modes. Finally, we relate our factorization map to the coproduct formula for the CFT symmetry algebra, which we show is equivalent to a Boguliubov transformation in the case of a free boson.

arXiv:1912.11201•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 27, 2021•45 citations
We present a systematic treatment of entanglement in two-dimensional topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Our approach clarifies the sensitivity of entanglement measures to the cutting maps that implement Hilbert space factorization. Such maps embed the TQFT Hilbert space into a description with potentially more degrees of freedom, and for entanglement to be well defined they must be isometric, i.e., they must preserve the norms of all states. We show that the naïve cutting map based solely upon path integration subject to boundary conditions is not isometric for generic TQFTs. For any 2d TQFT, we give a prescription to construct isometric cutting maps by dressing path integration with suitable edge operators. This allows us to compute entanglement for any state, any bipartition, and any boundary condition. As a consequence, we find a non-integer "ground-state degeneracy" à la Affleck-Ludwig, despite all boundary conditions being gapped. We further show how to reconstruct the partition function of the TQFT at arbitrary genus from the multi-interval Rényi entropies of a single state. For theories with (possibly non-invertible) symmetries, we show that the entanglement entropy of the symmetric ground state can distinguish gapped phases with the same symmetry, without any further knowledge of their vacua, while the entanglement asymmetry of the vacua entropically detects symmetry breaking. We illustrate our formalism with a range of applications, from finite gauge theories to Haagerup gapped phases and infrared phases of adjoint QCD2_22​.
In this thesis we will explore entanglement of various subsystems in quantum field theory, and its uses for describing underlying structure of states. We begin this journey by focusing on topological quantum field theory in chapters 1 and 2. These chapters are based heavily upon the papers [1] and [2, 3], respectively. In the introduction to chapter 1 we take the opportunity to recall the definition of bipartite entanglement entropy in quantum field theory and describe, briefly, how the entropy associated to connected spatial subregions provides a signature of topological order at the level of the wave-function. In particular, for a gapped phase with topological order, we recapitulate how the sub-leading correction to the “area-law” of the entanglement entropy contains coarse information about the topological phase while also being insensitive to the short-distance details of the underlying theory. We then present results that show that this sub-leading correction can also detect the class of interactions that glue a subregion to its complement. In principle, the subregion could be a different topological phase than its complement, and so we say that the entanglement entropy provides a signature of the interface between topological phases. In showing this, we discuss the classes of interactions between gapped topological phases and how they are represented as boundary conditions in the low-energy effective topological field theory, which in this case is an Abelian Chern-Simons theory. Using these boundary conditions, we perform path-integral calculations of the entanglement entropy using the replica trick and show that the universal contribution does indeed depend on the class of boundary conditions, and the gapped topological phases of the subsystem and its complement. To finish this chapter we reformulate this problem at the level of the Hilbert space and show how these universal contributions are related to resolving a generic ambiguity in defining subsystems of field theories with gauge invariance. We continue in the theme of topological field theories for chapter 2. Here we will shift focus from subregions of a connected spatial slice to disconnected spatial regions in an effort to explore, firstly, how long-range entanglement is encoded in topological field theory, and secondly, how that entanglement is encoded amongst multiple parties. We begin with a brief introduction of multi-party entanglement and recall the classification of three-party entanglement. Moving on to our specific setup, we describe the construction of states on multiple non-intersecting torus boundaries. Generically, these are states on link complements where the torus boundaries can be thought of as the edges of thickened closed strings entwined and knotted inside a compact manifold, which we will take to be the three-sphere. The wave-functions of these states are represented by various link invariants (such as the Gauss linking number for Abelian links, and Jones polynomial for SU(2)). We will exhibit several examples of multi-component links in both the Abelian and the SU(2) theories, and afterwards discuss generic features of the entanglement of link states in Chern-Simons theories with a compact group. In this discussion, we will conjecture a classification (albeit broad) of links via multi-partite entanglement of their corresponding states. We will end the chapter moving away from compact groups and discuss hyperbolic links in SL(2,C) Chern-Simons theory in the semi-classical limit. In particular, utilizing the generalized volume conjecture, we will show that the entanglement structure of hyperbolic links is greatly constrained in this semi-classical limit. Finally, in chapter 3 we switch gears and discuss renormalization of free bosonic field theory. The content of this chapter is drawn from the work of [4]. Motivated by work establishing duality between the singlet sector of O(N) vector models at large N and higher spin gauge theory on Anti de Sitter (AdS) space, we develop an exact renormalization group (ERG) framework for discussing the renormalization of a large class of O(N) singlet states. We will show that for the ground state and the excited states in this class the ERG is implemented by the action of unitary operators (that can be taken to be local). Consequently, the ERG framework can be regarded as a continuum tensor network. We contrast this tensor network with some well known tensor network renormalization schemes such as the muti-scale entanglement renormalization ansatz (MERA) and its proposed continuum version (cMERA). We also comment on the nature of this network with ordinary Wilsonian renormalization. One of the central features of the ERG network is how it acts on the momentum space entanglement of the field theory. In particular, we argue that for excited states, the ERG disentangles modes that lie just above and below the UV cutoff.
The most general description of a quantum many-body system is given by a wave- function that lives in a Hilbert space with dimension exponential in the number of particles. This makes it extremely hard to study strongly correlated phenomena like the fractional quantum Hall effect and high-temperature superconductivity. Whenever interactions are sufficiently local and temperature is low, the system does not explore the full Hilbert space, but its ground state resides in the small corner of Hilbert space described by the area law. Containing little entanglement, the states can then be expressed as tensor networks, a family of wavefunctions with a polynomial number of parameters. On the one hand, tensor networks can be used as a variational manifold in nu- merical computations. On the other hand, they allow building model wavefunctions much like locality allows writing down physically realistic Hamiltonians. Besides allowing for an analytical treatment, these models grant access both to the physical and the entanglement degrees of freedom. This is particularly useful in classifying phases of matter. A large number of phases can be explained in terms of Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. This framework, however, is not complete, as exemplified by the existence of phases with intrinsic topological order in two dimensions. It was a major conceptual advance when tensor networks could explain (non-chiral) topological phases as those where the symmetry resides in the entanglement degrees of freedom. The symmetries corresponding to those topological phases act as discrete, finite groups on the virtual degrees of freedom. The purpose of this Thesis is to generalize this program to include other symmetries. We investigate a class of tensor networks with continuous symmetries and find that they cannot describe gapped physics with a unique ground state. The abelian case is found to describe a non-Lorentz invariant phase transition point into a topologically ordered phase. The physics of the non- abelian case is that of a plaquette state that spontaneously breaks the translation symmetry of the lattice. The non-abelian PEPS arises as the ground state of a local parent Hamiltonian whose ground state manifold is completely characterized by the tensor network. In both cases, we find two types of corrections to the entanglement entropy: first there is a correction that is logarithmic in the size of the boundary and independent of the shape. A further correction depends only on the shape of the partition, imposing further restrictions on regions that are suffciently thin. Finally, we investigate symmetries that mix the virtual with the physical degrees of freedom and are furthermore anisotropic. Their physics is described by subsystem symmetry protected topological order. In particular, we focus on the entanglement entropy in the cluster phase and show that there is a universal constant correction to the entropy throughout the phase. This is important in the program of establishing the entanglement entropy as a detection mechanism for topologically ordered phases. We put forward a numerical algorithm to compute the correction and use it to discover a novel phase of matter in which the cluster phase is embedded.
The standard definition of entanglement entropy in quantum field theory requires regularizing the entangling surface and factorizing the Hilbert space, which in turn involves a choice of boundary conditions at the regularized surface. This raises two natural questions which are open at present. The first is under what conditions there is a choice of boundary conditions that leads to a unitary map between the original Hilbert space and the factorized one, which is a necessary condition for a well-defined entanglement entropy. The second concerns the situation where there are multiple such choices, in which case the question is whether they all yield the same entropy, or at least the same terms usually referred to as universal. Focusing on topological theories and using three-dimensional Chern-Simons theory as a concrete illustration, we show under specified assumptions that different such choices affect only the non-universal terms in the entropy, such that the remaining terms are universal in this sense as well, while we explicitly demonstrate that boundary conditions corresponding to non-unitary maps can change these terms. We then explain how a similar argument applies to two-dimensional conformal field theories and discuss a condition for universality in general theories.
Distinct quantum vacua of topologically ordered states can be tunneled into each other via extended operators. The possible applications include condensed matter and quantum cosmology. We present a straightforward approach to calculate the partition function on various manifolds and ground state degeneracy (GSD), mainly based on continuum/cochain topological quantum field theories (TQFTs), in any dimension. This information can be related to the counting of extended operators of bosonic/fermionic TQFTs. On the lattice scale, anyonic particles/strings live at the ends of line/surface operators. Certain systems in different dimensions are related to each other through dimensional reduction schemes, analogous to (de)categorification. Examples include spin TQFTs derived from gauging the interacting fermionic symmetry-protected topological states (with fermion parity |Z2f\mathbb{Z}_2^fZ2f​|⁠) of symmetry groups |Z4×Z2\mathbb{Z}_4\times \mathbb{Z}_2Z4​×Z2​| and |(Z4)2(\mathbb{Z}_4)^2(Z4​)2| in 3+1D, also |Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​| and |(Z2)2(\mathbb{Z}_2)^2(Z2​)2| in 2+1D. Gauging the last three cases begets non-Abelian spin TQFTs (fermionic topological order). We consider situations where a TQFT lives on (1) a closed spacetime or (2) a spacetime with a boundary, such that the bulk and boundary are fully gapped and short- or long-range entangled (SRE/LRE). Anyonic excitations can be deconfined on the boundary. We introduce new exotic topological interfaces on which neither particle nor string excitations alone condense, but only fuzzy-composite objects of extended operators can end (e.g., a string-like composite object formed by a set of particles can end on a special 2+1D boundary of 3+1D bulk). We explore the relations between group extension constructions and partially breaking constructions (e.g., 0-form/higher-form/“composite” breaking) of topological boundaries, after gauging. We comment on the implications of entanglement entropy for some such LRE systems.
We study the entanglement entropy between (possibly distinct) topological phases across an interface using an Abelian Chern-Simons description with topological boundary conditions (TBCs) at the interface. From a microscopic point of view, these TBCs correspond to turning on particular gapping interactions between the edge modes across the interface. However, in studying entanglement in the continuum Chern-Simons description, we must confront the problem of non-factorization of the Hilbert space, which is a standard property of gauge theories. We carefully define the entanglement entropy by using an extended Hilbert space construction directly in the continuum theory. We show how a given TBC isolates a corresponding gauge invariant state in the extended Hilbert space, and hence compute the resulting entanglement entropy. We find that the sub-leading correction to the area law remains universal, but depends on the choice of topological boundary conditions. This agrees with the microscopic calculation of [1]. Additionally, we provide a replica path integral calculation for the entropy. In the case when the topological phases across the interface are taken to be identical, our construction gives a novel explanation of the equivalence between the left-right entanglement of (1+1)d Ishibashi states and the spatial entanglement of (2+1)d topological phases.
In this work, we consider the question of local Hilbert space factorization in 2D conformal field theory. Generalizing previous work on entanglement and open-closed TQFT, we interpret the factorization of CFT states in terms of path integral processes that split and join the Hilbert spaces of circles and intervals. More abstractly, these processes are cobordisms of an extended CFT which are defined purely in terms of the OPE data. In addition to the usual sewing axioms, we impose an entanglement boundary condition that is satisfied by the vacuum Ishibashi state. This choice of entanglement boundary state leads to reduced density matrices that sum over super-selection sectors, which we identify as the CFT edge modes. Finally, we relate our factorization map to the coproduct formula for the CFT symmetry algebra, which we show is equivalent to a Boguliubov transformation in the case of a free boson.