Band structure of two-dimensional graphene and of one-dimensional nanoribbons via variational quantum algorithms: from energies to wavefunction quality
Raúl Medrano Millán, Rodrigo Gil-Merino y Rubio, Juan Borge, Unai Aseguinolaza Aguirreche
cond-mat.mtrl-sciquant-phSubmitted Nov 3, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
Simulating quantum many-body systems classically encounters exponential bottlenecks, which quantum devices circumvent by natively encoding wavefunctions. In the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, however, hardware noise constrains simulation accuracy. As a stepping stone toward strongly correlated materials, we compute the band structure of 2D monolayer graphene and 1D nanoribbons (zigzag and armchair) using a single variational workflow in the $p_z$ tight-binding approximation. Non-interacting ground states also provide essential initial reference states for subspace and warm-started variational methods to solve interacting spectra. By mapping the Bloch Hamiltonian to Pauli operators, we extract the ground band via the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and excited subbands via Variational Quantum Deflation (VQD), validating our approach from ideal simulations to execution on physical IBM Quantum processors. In ideal simulations, the workflow reproduces exact diagonalization results with high precision, whereas hardware noise introduces energy deviations of a few hundredths of the hopping parameter. While qubit counts scale logarithmically with ribbon width, fixed-depth ansatz accuracy degrades with Hilbert space dimension. Crucially, deepening the ansatz improves ideal simulation accuracy by over three orders of magnitude but worsens energy estimates under noise, proving that practical circuit depth is bounded by hardware noise rather than expressivity. Finally, we complement energy evaluations with a wavefunction-level diagnostic measuring subspace containment. This diagnostic captures degenerate manifolds and exposes optimization failure modes disguised by energy agreement alone. Operating directly on NISQ hardware, this validated workflow establishes a controlled baseline for studying topological and strongly correlated phases in realistic materials.
AI Summary
Queued: an LLM will read the paper as soon as there is capacity.
Simulating quantum many-body systems classically encounters exponential bottlenecks, which quantum devices circumvent by natively encoding wavefunctions. In the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, however, hardware noise constrains simulation accuracy. As a stepping stone toward strongly correlated materials, we compute the band structure of 2D monolayer graphene and 1D nanoribbons (zigzag and armchair) using a single variational workflow in the pz tight-binding approximation. Non-interacting ground states also provide essential initial reference states for subspace and warm-started variational methods to solve interacting spectra. By mapping the Bloch Hamiltonian to Pauli operators, we extract the ground band via the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and excited subbands via Variational Quantum Deflation (VQD), validating our approach from ideal simulations to execution on physical IBM Quantum processors. In ideal simulations, the workflow reproduces exact diagonalization results with high precision, whereas hardware noise introduces energy deviations of a few hundredths of the hopping parameter. While qubit counts scale logarithmically with ribbon width, fixed-depth ansatz accuracy degrades with Hilbert space dimension. Crucially, deepening the ansatz improves ideal simulation accuracy by over three orders of magnitude but worsens energy estimates under noise, proving that practical circuit depth is bounded by hardware noise rather than expressivity. Finally, we complement energy evaluations with a wavefunction-level diagnostic measuring subspace containment. This diagnostic captures degenerate manifolds and exposes optimization failure modes disguised by energy agreement alone. Operating directly on NISQ hardware, this validated workflow establishes a controlled baseline for studying topological and strongly correlated phases in realistic materials.
Abstract Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and its extension, Variational Quantum Deflation (VQD), have emerged as promising algorithms for computing ground and excited state energy eigenvalues of Hamiltonians, particularly in quantum physics, chemistry, and materials science. Recently, the VQE and VQD algorithms were implemented to calculate the electronic band structure described by the tight-binding Hamiltonian. Despite their success for simple models, scalability remains a challenge due to the need for a large number of circuit executions, limited qubit coherence times, and low gate fidelities. In this work, we implemented the VQE and VQD algorithms for tight-binding models of diamond and zincblende crystal structures (Sn, C, Si, Ge, AlP, AlAs, AlSb, and GaP) using a quantum computer simulator. We investigate the scalability challenges, focusing on the significant overhead caused by a large number of quantum circuit executions required to find the energy eigenvalues. Our analysis highlights the substantial amount of both measurement and optimization overheads in VQD, particularly as the number of excited states increases. Based on our findings, we critically discuss the implications of implementing VQD on current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices.
Abstract Variational quantum algorithms such as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and variational quantum deflation (VQD) have emerged as leading candidates for computing electronic structure on near-term quantum hardware. For periodic solids, however, their reach has been limited not by the quantum algorithm itself but by the cost of constructing a faithful second-quantized Hamiltonian for each material, typically via density-functional theory (DFT) followed by Wannierization or by hand-fitted empirical tight-binding parameters. SlaKoNet, a recently developed method, significantly reduces the computational cost of electronic Hamiltonian construction with a small accuracy tradeoff. It integrates modern deep-learning methods and the Slater-Koster tight-binding formalism to fit thousands of onsite and distance-dependent hopping and overlap tight-binding parameters across 65 elements of the periodic table. After fitting, these parameters can be used to deterministically construct an electronic Hamiltonian for any crystal made up of any of the 65 elements in the training set, and the crystal's band structure can subsequently be computed. In this work, we combine a SlaKoNet model trained on the JARVIS-TBmBJ dataset with a Qiskit-based variational quantum deflation algorithm, replacing the traditional and costly Hamiltonian construction step with a universal neural Hamiltonian generator. Within the 65-element set, the resulting SlaKoNet-VQD workflow is structure-agnostic, fully differentiable, fast, and suited to high-throughput screening of band structures. We benchmark the workflow on silicon, recovering the full eight-band band structure along the standard high-symmetry k-path with a mean absolute deviation of 1.78 meV from exact diagonalization on a 3-qubit statevector simulator. We further compute the full band structure for five additional conventional superconductors, Al, Ta, Nb, V, and ZrN, achieving a mean absolute deviation within approximately 1.8 meV, and demonstrate full execution of SlaKoNet-VQD on IBM Quantum hardware for a representative k-point ground-state calculation on aluminum with a mean absolute error of roughly 0.37 eV. Beyond the single-particle level, we promote the same SlaKoNet Hamiltonian to a correlated Hubbard model and solve it with dynamical mean-field theory, recovering the weakening of correlations across the group-5 metals and strong quasiparticle renormalization in the cuprate La₂CuO₄, and we identify the resulting impurity problem as the natural target for a quantum solver. The pipeline opens a path to high-throughput benchmarking of variational quantum algorithms across the periodic table and to gradient-based co-optimization of ansatz and Hamiltonian for materials discovery. An interactive web app is available at https://atomgpt.org/quantum.
Over the last decade, researchers have been working to improve a crucial aspect of quantum computing to predict Hamiltonian energy of solids. Quantum algorithms such as Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and Variational Quantum Deflation (VQD) have been used to study the molecular systems. However, there is growing interest in adapting and applying these methods to periodic solid-state materials. In this work, we have integrated first-principles density functional theory with VQE and VQD algorithms and utilizing the Wannier Tight-Binding Hamiltonian (WTBH) method to predict the electronic characteristics of solids. We demonstrate that VQE and VQD algorithms can be used to accurately predict electronic characteristics in a variety of multi-component prototype solid-state materials such as - Silicon (semiconductor), Gold (metallic), Boron Nitrile (insulator), Graphene (semi-metal). Efficient SU2 performs well among all the predefined ansatz used in the study. COBYLA is the fastest optimizer among the classical optimizers with minimum number of iterations for convergence. Results of noise models help to understand the band structure when calculated on real quantum hardware. As quantum hardware advances, our method might be a starting point for using quantum computers to study materials and could help make material discovery more automatic in the future.
Variational quantum algorithms are among the most promising approaches for simulating interacting quantum many-body systems on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. However, the practical success of variational quantum eigensolvers (VQE) critically depends on the structure of the chosen variational ansatz. In this work, we investigate the ground-state properties of the one-dimensional antiferromagnetic Heisenberg spin-1/2 chain using both generic hardware-efficient ansatz and physics-informed, symmetry-preserving variational circuits. We benchmark variational results against exact diagonalization and noiseless simulations, and subsequently validate the approach on real IQM Garnet quantum hardware. Our results demonstrate that incorporating physical symmetries into the circuit design leads to significantly improved energy estimates, enhanced robustness against hardware noise, and clearer convergence behavior when compared to hardware-efficient ansatz under identical resource constraints. These findings highlight the importance of problem specific ansatz construction for reliable quantum simulations in the NISQ era.
Graphene, a material of extraordinary interest in condensed matter physics due to its unique electronic properties, presents a fundamental challenge: the precise calculation of its band structure. This Master’s Thesis addresses this problem by proposing the use of one of the most widely used algorithms in quantum computing. To achieve this, a tight-binding model is used that describes the electron hopping between the atoms of the single-layer hexagonal lattice that defines graphene. This model is extended to include not only the interactions of each atom in the lattice with adjacent atoms (first neighbors), but also with the next closest atoms (second neighbors), allowing for the capture of more subtle physical effects. The resulting hamiltonian is then prepared for execution in the quantum simulators of IBM’s Qiskit platform. The results under ideal conditions demonstrate that the algorithm reproduces analytical solutions with high fidelity, capturing essential features such as Dirac points, where valence and conduction bands intersect, causing electrons to behave as massless particles, and electron-hole symmetry breaking, which reflects the difference in the energetic behavior of electrons and their absences (holes). However, when introducing a noise model that emulates current quantum processors (inherently noisy, intermediate-scale devices, the socalled NISQ era), a systematic deviation is observed that underscores the limiting impact of the hardware. The study concludes that VQE is a conceptually viable and powerful tool for materials simulation, but its practical application to achieve quantum advantage will critically depend on the development of advanced error mitigation techniques.
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm designed for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware to estimate eigenvalues of many-body Hamiltonians. Unlike fully quantum approaches such as quantum phase estimation (QPE), VQE trades deep coherent circuits for repeated state preparation, measurement, and classical optimization, making it more compatible with limited qubit counts and finite coherence times. Recent developments have focused on reducing quantum resource requirements while retaining chemically meaningful wavefunction structure. In this paper, we examine recent progress in VQE methods for molecular electronic structure with an emphasis on three themes: (i) strategies for circuit and ansatz complexity reduction, including adaptive and selectively screened approaches, (ii) chemically motivated workflows that combine VQE with orbital optimization, fragmentation, and localized active-space ideas to better address strong correlation, and (iii) extensions of VQE to excited-state calculations. Throughout, we emphasize the tradeoffs among parameter count, gate depth, symmetry preservation, measurement overhead, and classical preprocessing, and discuss where these approaches may become most useful for chemically challenging active spaces. We also highlight benchmarking considerations for assessing both accuracy and resource requirements, and conclude with a perspective on regimes in which VQE may offer the greatest long-term value, particularly multireference active spaces and low-lying excited-state manifolds.