The Yb delafossites NaYbSe$_2$, KYbSe$_2$, CsYbSe$_2$ and NaYbO$_2$ are candidates for the U(1) Dirac spin liquid (DSL) of the triangular lattice. Strong spin-orbit coupling gives their exchange an XXZ anisotropy $Δ$ and bond-dependent couplings $J_{\pm\pm}$, $J_{z\pm}$ that lock the spin frame to the lattice. We show that, within a single layer of a stable Heisenberg DSL, these couplings generate no relevant Lorentz-scalar operator of their own. Inversion at the bond centers removes the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya channel that gaps the kagome DSL, so the locked symmetry forbids a mass, density or current at any order and, assuming continuity, any new monopole term through charge three. Every Lorentz-scalar four-fermion operator induced by spin-orbit coupling shares an SU(4) multiplet, and hence its scaling dimension, with a Heisenberg-allowed one, and the nine non-scalar quartics without such a partner arise only at second order and are irrelevant at large $N$. The Heisenberg DSL itself allows a Lorentz-vector quartic of large-$N$ dimension 2.92, which a stable phase must also render irrelevant. Beyond a single layer, spin-orbit coupling opens an interlayer monopole channel in rhombohedral stacking. If the Heisenberg DSL is instead multicritical, an anisotropy as small as that of KYbSe$_2$ matters only below tens of mK. At the transition to 120$^\circ$ order the anisotropy is relevant, and exact diagonalization indicates that easy-plane anisotropy selects the chiral-Ising class. Existing KYbSe$_2$ neutron data below $J$ do not yet fix the K-point exponent, and gapless out-of-plane spin fluctuations at the K point would test the chiral-Ising selection.
The Yb delafossites NaYbSe2, KYbSe2, CsYbSe2 and NaYbO2 are candidates for the U(1) Dirac spin liquid (DSL) of the triangular lattice. Strong spin-orbit coupling gives their exchange an XXZ anisotropy Δ and bond-dependent couplings J±±, Jz± that lock the spin frame to the lattice. We show that, within a single layer of a stable Heisenberg DSL, these couplings generate no relevant Lorentz-scalar operator of their own. Inversion at the bond centers removes the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya channel that gaps the kagome DSL, so the locked symmetry forbids a mass, density or current at any order and, assuming continuity, any new monopole term through charge three. Every Lorentz-scalar four-fermion operator induced by spin-orbit coupling shares an SU(4) multiplet, and hence its scaling dimension, with a Heisenberg-allowed one, and the nine non-scalar quartics without such a partner arise only at second order and are irrelevant at large N. The Heisenberg DSL itself allows a Lorentz-vector quartic of large-N dimension 2.92, which a stable phase must also render irrelevant. Beyond a single layer, spin-orbit coupling opens an interlayer monopole channel in rhombohedral stacking. If the Heisenberg DSL is instead multicritical, an anisotropy as small as that of KYbSe2 matters only below tens of mK. At the transition to 120∘ order the anisotropy is relevant, and exact diagonalization indicates that easy-plane anisotropy selects the chiral-Ising class. Existing KYbSe2 neutron data below J do not yet fix the K-point exponent, and gapless out-of-plane spin fluctuations at the K point would test the chiral-Ising selection.
We classify the fermion bilinears of the SU(2) gauge theory of the Shastry-Sutherland Dirac spin liquids under the spin-orbit-locked space group and treat the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya (DM) interactions of SrCu2(BO3)2 at leading order in 1/N and at one loop. At linear order DM can neither gap the spinons nor destabilize the SO(5) point above a scale T∗. Symmetry forbids every local gauge-singlet fermion mass at any order. Among the singlet bilinears, the in-plane couplings induce only a conserved spin current of dimension exactly 2, which sets T∗=4λ≃0.03-0.17 K, and the out-of-plane coupling only a flavored spin-2 current, irrelevant at a unitary critical point. DM-induced Yukawa couplings start below 2% of the one that bounds the pseudocritical window. In zero field, measured samples order above 1 K, at or above T∗. Below T∗, in a two-dimensional sample at the critical pressure, the Dirac cones reconstruct into a chirally protected d-wave quadratic band touching whose only gauge-singlet gap channels are the two valence-bond components and the scalar chirality. A one-loop flow, with the gauge field screened by the band touching, ends at T∗∗∼(0.03-0.1)λ on a ray containing valence-bond order for the material's exchange and for most random couplings, and otherwise on a gapped chiral Z2 spin liquid. The DM bias between the two plaquette patterns is at most of order 10−4, with a direction not fixed at O(1/N), whereas non-magnetic quenched disorder couples a relevant random field to the plaquette doublet and none to the chirality. A field along [100] induces a (π,π) Néel moment linear in the field; a field along [001] does not. This selection rule also holds in the dimer phase and is testable by 11B NMR under pressure.
Theory of Dirac spin liquids on spin-S triangular lattice: possible application to α-CrOOH(D)
Triangular lattice quantum antiferromagnet has recently emerged to be a promising playground for realizing Dirac spin liquids (DSLs) -- a class of highly entangled quantum phases hosting emergent gauge fields and gapless Dirac fermions. While previous theories and experiments focused mainly on S=1/2 spin systems, more recently signals of a DSL were detected in an S=3/2 system α-CrOOH(D). In this work we develop a theory of DSLs on triangular lattice with spin-S moments. We argue that in the most natural scenario, a spin-S system realizes a U(2S) DSL, described at low energy by gapless Dirac fermions coupled with an emergent U(2S) gauge field (also known as U(2S) QCD3). An appealing feature of this scenario is that at sufficiently large S, the U(2S) QCD becomes intrinsically unstable toward spontaneous symmetry breaking and confinement. The confined phase is simply the 120∘ coplanar magnetic order, which agrees with semiclassical (large-S) results on simple Heisenberg-like models. Other scenarios are nevertheless possible, especially at small S when quantum fluctuations are strong. For S=3/2, we argue that a U(1) DSL is also theoretically possible and phenomenologically compatible with existing measurements. One way to distinguish the U(3) DSL from the U(1) DSL is to break time-reversal symmetry, for example by adding a spin chirality term Si⋅(Sj×Sk) in numerical simulations: the U(1) DSL becomes the standard Kalmeyer-Laughlin chiral spin liquid with semion/anti-semion excitation; the U(3) DSL, in contrast, becomes a non-abelian chiral spin liquid described by the SU(2)3 topological order, with Fibonacci-like anyons.
The U(1) Dirac spin liquid might realize an exotic phase of matter whose low-energy properties are described by quantum electrodynamics in 2+1 dimensions, where gapless modes exist but spinons and gauge fields are strongly coupled. Its existence was proposed in frustrated Heisenberg models in the presence of frustrating superexchange interactions by the (Abrikosov) fermionic representation of the spin operators [Wen, Phys. Rev. B 65, 165113 (2002)], supplemented by the Gutzwiller projection. Here, we construct charge-Q monopole excitations in the Heisenberg model on the triangular lattice with nearest-neighbor (J1) and next-nearest-neighbor (J2) couplings. In the highly frustrated regime, singlet and triplet monopoles with Q=1 become gapless in the thermodynamic limit; in addition, the energies for generic Q agree with field-theoretical predictions, obtained for a large number of gapless fermion modes. Finally, we consider localized gauge excitations, in which magnetic $\ensuremath{\pi}$ fluxes are concentrated in the triangular plaquettes (in analogy with Z2 visons), showing that these kinds of states do not play a relevant role at low energies. All our findings lend support to a stable U(1) Dirac spin liquid in the ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ Heisenberg model on the triangular lattice.
The square-hexagon-dodecagon (SHD) lattice hosts an exactly solvable Kitaev spin liquid, while further-neighbor couplings frustrate its Heisenberg magnet into classically degenerate lines where quantum fluctuations can melt the Néel order. To place this state among the lattice's spin liquids, we classify fermionic parton mean-field states with singlet and spin-orbit-coupled triplet amplitudes by their projective symmetry groups (PSGs). As SHD sites lack site symmetry, its Z2 PSGs are the projective classes of p6mm with time reversal, from which those of every single-orbit p6mm lattice follow. In the idealized Kitaev model, where lattice operations do not rotate spins, these liquids carry a single Z2 PSG descending from the SU(2) Lieb-flux state, and their projections are exact eigenstates. The PSG's sixfold-rotation sign, fixed by the dodecagon flux, doubles all Majorana bands, and the mirrors exclude a chiral phase in any uniform field, so only a sublattice-staggered three-spin term drives the non-Abelian Ising phase. Beyond the Kitaev state, we find a critical semi-Dirac spin liquid, with mean-field correlations ∝r−3 along three directions and r−6 otherwise, and extended Dirac phases with up to 48 fermion flavors, among them an Nf=12 state whose PSG forbids every singlet mass. Out-of-plane Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya couplings gap the Dirac states of its U(1) class into a mean-field spinon counterpart of the Kane-Mele quantum spin Hall insulator, with spin Chern number 1 or 3 and spin-carrying monopoles. Chiral states imply Kalmeyer-Laughlin, semion×semion, and three-fermion orders, rotation-breaking ones show q→−q asymmetric neutron spectra, and sign-alternating fluxes break time reversal alone. Masses and monopoles in these many-flavor phases and the energetics of frustrated SHD Heisenberg models are natural next steps.
Abstract We analyze a Higgs transition from a U(1) Dirac spin liquid to a gapless ℤ2 spin liquid. This ℤ2 spin liquid is of relevance to the spin S = 1/2 square lattice antiferromagnet, where recent numerical studies have given evidence for such a phase existing in the regime of high frustration between nearest neighbor and next-nearest neighbor antiferromagnetic interactions (the J1-J2 model), appearing in a parameter regime between the vanishing of Néel order and the onset of valence bond solid ordering. The proximate Dirac spin liquid is unstable to monopole proliferation on the square lattice, ultimately leading to Néel or valence bond solid ordering. As such, we conjecture that this Higgs transition describes the critical theory separating the gapless ℤ2 spin liquid of the J1-J2 model from one of the two proximate ordered phases. The transition into the other ordered phase can be described in a unified manner via a transition into an unstable SU(2) spin liquid, which we have analyzed in prior work. By studying the deconfined critical theory separating the U(1) Dirac spin liquid from the gapless ℤ2 spin liquid in a 1/Nf expansion, with Nf proportional to the number of fermions, we find a stable fixed point with an anisotropic spinon dispersion and a dynamical critical exponent z ≠ 1. We analyze the consequences of this anisotropic dispersion by calculating the angular profiles of the equal-time Néel and valence bond solid correlation functions, and we find them to be distinct. We also note the influence of the anisotropy on the scaling dimension of monopoles.
Dynamics and stability of U(1) spin liquids beyond mean-field theory: Triangular-lattice J1-J2 Heisenberg model
Quantum spin liquids (QSLs) are long-range entangled phases of frustrated magnets exhibiting fractionalised spin excitations. In two dimensions, there is limited analytical understanding of their excitation spectra beyond parton mean-field theories, which fail to capture many features of the finite frequency dynamical response. We use a self-consistent mean-field theory combined with the random phase approximation (RPA) for the J1-J2 Heisenberg model on the triangular lattice to describe the strong spinon-spinon interactions of the U(1) Dirac QSL. We obtain quantitative results for the dynamical spin structure factor and phase diagram compatible with comprehensive numerical efforts. We show the continuum response at the Brillouin zone corners is described by a spinon-exciton hybridised with monopole gauge excitations. We further show that the transition from the QSL to 120-degree coplanar order is in the QED3 O(3)-GN universality class. We extend the method to chiral QSLs and XXZ anisotropy, and discuss its broad range of applicability to other models and for describing inelastic neutron scattering experiments in KYbSe2.