arXiv:2611.04568
Time-invariant negativity and persistent bound entanglement in a cyclic two-qutrit family
Wenlin Zhang, Mazhar Ali, Haobo Ma
Abstract
We study the entanglement dynamics of two qutrits under collective dephasing for a family of states obtained by mixing a maximally entangled state that lives in the decoherence-free subspace with three nonstationary two-term states sharing a common amplitude ratio $r$. We obtain exact PPT and separability regions along the whole trajectory, a specialization of known results on cyclic sign invariant states, and we supply explicit certificates: a finite product decomposition, three fixed positive-map witnesses, and a closed realignment formula that detects every PPT-entangled state, so that no state is left undecided. The negativity is computed in closed form. It shows that the entanglement is time-invariant, positive and constant from the initial time although the state changes, exactly when the weight of the maximally entangled state exceeds the threshold $U_r=r/(1+r+r^2)$. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of time-invariant entanglement for qutrit--qutrit systems under collective dephasing. For smaller weights the entanglement decays and vanishes at a finite time: the state either becomes separable (entanglement sudden death) or, for $r\neq1$ in an intermediate range, loses distillability suddenly and remains bound entangled at all later times. Every state with negative partial transpose is one-copy distillable by a fixed local projection. The same trajectories arise from the global dephasing map and from a correlated local random-unitary semigroup, although the two channels differ on product inputs. Exact rational benchmarks and embeddings of the Horodecki and Ha--Kye--Park families are provided.
AI Summary
The paper studies when two-qutrit dephasing trajectories exhibit constant negativity or evolve from distillable to persistent bound entanglement. Its family mixes a decoherence-free maximally entangled state of weight $p$ with three two-term states sharing an amplitude ratio $r>0$; their coherences decay as $\gamma=e^{-\Gamma t/2}$. The exact classification is PPT iff $L_r(\gamma)\le p\le U_r$ and separable iff $L_r(\gamma)\le p\le S_r$, where $L_r(\gamma)=r\gamma/(1+r^2+r\gamma)$, $U_r=r/(1+r+r^2)$, and $S_r=\min\{1,r^2\}/(1+r^2+\min\{1,r^2\})$. Positive negativity is constant throughout evolution exactly when $p>U_r$; the trajectory is nonstationary for $p<1$. For $S_r<p<U_r$, initially one-copy-distillable states become PPT entangled at $t_{\mathrm P}=(2/\Gamma)\log[r(1-p)/(p(1+r^2))]$ and remain bound entangled thereafter. For $0<p\le S_r$, reaching PPT instead means becoming separable. The symmetric case $r=1$ has no PPT-entangled region. These statements follow from explicit partial-transpose blocks, a finite product decomposition, three fixed witnesses, and a realignment formula detecting every PPT-entangled member. A fixed two-level local projection establishes distillability throughout the NPT region. The static classification specializes established cyclic-state results, with known Horodecki and Ha–Kye–Park families embedded explicitly. The printed global dephasing channel can entangle product inputs, but a correlated local random-unitary semigroup reproduces these particular trajectories. Constant negativity does not establish constancy of other entanglement measures. Independent amplitude ratios and more general maximally correlated blocks remain outside the analysis.
[author] and [author] used AI tools, namely ChatGPT Pro (GPT-6 Pro), Codex (gpt-6.1-sol) and Claude Opus 5.5 (via Claude Code), for literature search, computation and double-checking.
Error found: The abstract's nonstationary time-invariance claim needs U_r < p < 1, because the included endpoint p = 1 is a stationary maximally entangled state. The abstract's finite-time disappearance claim excludes the allowed endpoint p = 0, whose negativity remains positive at every finite time and vanishes only asymptotically. In the persistent bound-entangled regime, negativity vanishes at the transition but entanglement does not, contrary to the abstract's wording.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- DOI
- 10.48550/arxiv.2611.04568
- Comments
- 14 pages, comments welcome