Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.04568

Time-invariant negativity and persistent bound entanglement in a cyclic two-qutrit family

Wenlin Zhang, Mazhar Ali, Haobo Ma

quant-phSubmitted Nov 3, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the entanglement dynamics of two qutrits under collective dephasing for a family of states obtained by mixing a maximally entangled state that lives in the decoherence-free subspace with three nonstationary two-term states sharing a common amplitude ratio $r$. We obtain exact PPT and separability regions along the whole trajectory, a specialization of known results on cyclic sign invariant states, and we supply explicit certificates: a finite product decomposition, three fixed positive-map witnesses, and a closed realignment formula that detects every PPT-entangled state, so that no state is left undecided. The negativity is computed in closed form. It shows that the entanglement is time-invariant, positive and constant from the initial time although the state changes, exactly when the weight of the maximally entangled state exceeds the threshold $U_r=r/(1+r+r^2)$. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of time-invariant entanglement for qutrit--qutrit systems under collective dephasing. For smaller weights the entanglement decays and vanishes at a finite time: the state either becomes separable (entanglement sudden death) or, for $r\neq1$ in an intermediate range, loses distillability suddenly and remains bound entangled at all later times. Every state with negative partial transpose is one-copy distillable by a fixed local projection. The same trajectories arise from the global dephasing map and from a correlated local random-unitary semigroup, although the two channels differ on product inputs. Exact rational benchmarks and embeddings of the Horodecki and Ha--Kye--Park families are provided.

AI Summary

The paper studies when two-qutrit dephasing trajectories exhibit constant negativity or evolve from distillable to persistent bound entanglement. Its family mixes a decoherence-free maximally entangled state of weight $p$ with three two-term states sharing an amplitude ratio $r>0$; their coherences decay as $\gamma=e^{-\Gamma t/2}$. The exact classification is PPT iff $L_r(\gamma)\le p\le U_r$ and separable iff $L_r(\gamma)\le p\le S_r$, where $L_r(\gamma)=r\gamma/(1+r^2+r\gamma)$, $U_r=r/(1+r+r^2)$, and $S_r=\min\{1,r^2\}/(1+r^2+\min\{1,r^2\})$. Positive negativity is constant throughout evolution exactly when $p>U_r$; the trajectory is nonstationary for $p<1$. For $S_r<p<U_r$, initially one-copy-distillable states become PPT entangled at $t_{\mathrm P}=(2/\Gamma)\log[r(1-p)/(p(1+r^2))]$ and remain bound entangled thereafter. For $0<p\le S_r$, reaching PPT instead means becoming separable. The symmetric case $r=1$ has no PPT-entangled region. These statements follow from explicit partial-transpose blocks, a finite product decomposition, three fixed witnesses, and a realignment formula detecting every PPT-entangled member. A fixed two-level local projection establishes distillability throughout the NPT region. The static classification specializes established cyclic-state results, with known Horodecki and Ha–Kye–Park families embedded explicitly. The printed global dephasing channel can entangle product inputs, but a correlated local random-unitary semigroup reproduces these particular trajectories. Constant negativity does not establish constancy of other entanglement measures. Independent amplitude ratios and more general maximally correlated blocks remain outside the analysis.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedIncremental
[author] and [author] used AI tools, namely ChatGPT Pro (GPT-6 Pro), Codex (gpt-6.1-sol) and Claude Opus 5.5 (via Claude Code), for literature search, computation and double-checking.

Error found: The abstract's nonstationary time-invariance claim needs U_r < p < 1, because the included endpoint p = 1 is a stationary maximally entangled state. The abstract's finite-time disappearance claim excludes the allowed endpoint p = 0, whose negativity remains positive at every finite time and vanishes only asymptotically. In the persistent bound-entangled regime, negativity vanishes at the transition but entanglement does not, contrary to the abstract's wording.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.04568
Comments
14 pages, comments welcome

Related papers

Distillability sudden death in qutrit–qutrit systems under amplitude damping

Mazhar Ali

Recently it has been discovered that certain two-qutrit entangled states interacting with global and/or multi-local decoherence undergo distillability sudden death (DSD). We investigate this phenomenon for qutrit–qutrit systems interacting with statistically independent zero-temperature reservoirs. We show that certain initially prepared free-entangled states become bound-entangled in a finite time due to the action of a Markovian dissipative environment. As there is no definitive criterion for separability/entanglement of density matrices with dimension greater than 6, therefore we believe that the results obtained in this paper are restricted to a specific family of states considered here. Moreover, in contrast to local dephasing, simple local unitary transformations can completely avoid distillability sudden death under amplitude damping.

arXiv:0912.2868•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Jan 28, 2010•41 citations

Dynamics of Entanglement of Qutrit-Qutrit States with Stochastic Dephasing

Xiao-San Ma, Ming-Fan Ren, Guang-Xing Zhao +1 more

The effect of stochastic dephasing on the dynamics of entanglement of qutrit-qutrit states is investigated by using negativity and bound entanglement defined with realignment criterion. From the analysis, we find that the time evolution of quantum free entanglement and bound entanglement depends on the fluctuations of the stochastic variables and the parameters of the particular initial states of concern. Our results imply that some qutrits states display both distillability sudden death and entanglement sudden death, while some states do not display distillability sudden death but only entanglement sudden death.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Aug 1, 2011•4 citations

Distillability of Sudden Death in Qutrit-Qutrit Systems under Global Mixed Noise*

Bing-Bing Chai, Jin‐Liang Guo

Considering the influences of collective dephasing, multilocal qutrit-flip, local qutrit-flip, and the combination of global mixed noise, we study the dynamics of entanglement and the phenomenon of distillability of sudden death (DSD) in a qutrit-qutrit system under various decoherent noises. It is shown that the system always undergoes DSD when it interacts with multilocal and local qutrit-flip noise, and the time-determined bound entangled state is more dependent on different noises. Comparing with the cases of global mixed and collective dephasing noise, we conclude that the qutrit-flip noise is responsible for the DSD.

Chinese Physics Letters•May 1, 2019•1 citation

Geometric Characterization and Feasible Region Analysis of Bipartite Qutrit Bound Entanglement

Mazhar Ali

We characterize bound entanglement in bipartite qutrit systems by combining the Positive Partial Transpose (PPT) criterion with a structural, non-completely positive map. Focusing on a comprehensive three-parameter bipartite qutrit family $ρ_{a,b,c}$, we present an exact analytical and geometric partitioning of the physical state space simplex. We derive the closed-form quadratic boundary governing the leaf-like PPT region $(a^2+ab+b^2-b \leq 0)$ over the domain $0 < a \leq \frac{1}{3}$, and identify the exact linear threshold $(a > c)$ that characterizes the PPT bound entangled sub-region. This family strictly generalizes the well-known Horodecki bound entangled states, which appear as a single slice of the three-dimensional leaf. Applying the structural map to this decomposition, we show that it certifies bound entanglement throughout the entire threshold region, accounting for $14.76\%$ of the total PPT leaf area.

quant-pharXiv:2609.39141•Oct 1, 2026•1 citation

Distillability sudden death and sudden birth in a two-qutrit system under decoherence of finite temperature

You-neng Guo, Mao-Fa Fang, Guoyou Wang +2 more

Distillability sudden death and sudden birth in a two-qutrit system under decoherence of finite temperature is studied in detail. By using of the negativity and realignment criterion, it is shown that certain initial prepared free entangled states may become bound entangled or separable states in a finite time. Moreover, initial prepared bound entangled or separable states also may become distillabile entangled states in a finite time.

arXiv:1506.02743•Jun 9, 2015•0 citations

Sparse positive maps on qutrits with exact nondecomposability thresholds and PPT-entanglement transitions

Davide Poderini, Angela Rosy Morgillo, Fabio Benatti +3 more

We study a family of sparse positive maps on qutrits for which positivity, decomposability, and PPT entanglement can all be analysed explicitly. The block structure of the associated Choi matrices reduces positivity to a Hermitian biquadratic form and leads to exact positivity boundaries for three representative parametric families. For the same families we determine the exact transition between decomposable and non-decomposable maps and construct associated PPT states of two classes. The first consists of witness-adapted deformations naturally tied to the non-decomposability analysis. The second consists of analytically tractable families whose full PPT-entangled branch is detected by fixed positive maps, yielding exact thresholds between separability and bound entanglement. For the trace-preserving subclass, we further compare positivity with a recent eigenvalue bound for 2-positive maps, thereby making the gap between positivity and higher-order positivity fully explicit within this family.

quant-pharXiv:2606.19765•Quantum Science and Technology•Jun 19, 2026•3 citations
We study the entanglement dynamics of two qutrits under collective dephasing for a family of states obtained by mixing a maximally entangled state that lives in the decoherence-free subspace with three nonstationary two-term states sharing a common amplitude ratio rrr. We obtain exact PPT and separability regions along the whole trajectory, a specialization of known results on cyclic sign invariant states, and we supply explicit certificates: a finite product decomposition, three fixed positive-map witnesses, and a closed realignment formula that detects every PPT-entangled state, so that no state is left undecided. The negativity is computed in closed form. It shows that the entanglement is time-invariant, positive and constant from the initial time although the state changes, exactly when the weight of the maximally entangled state exceeds the threshold Ur=r/(1+r+r2)U_r=r/(1+r+r^2)Ur​=r/(1+r+r2). To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of time-invariant entanglement for qutrit--qutrit systems under collective dephasing. For smaller weights the entanglement decays and vanishes at a finite time: the state either becomes separable (entanglement sudden death) or, for r≠1r\neq1r=1 in an intermediate range, loses distillability suddenly and remains bound entangled at all later times. Every state with negative partial transpose is one-copy distillable by a fixed local projection. The same trajectories arise from the global dephasing map and from a correlated local random-unitary semigroup, although the two channels differ on product inputs. Exact rational benchmarks and embeddings of the Horodecki and Ha--Kye--Park families are provided.
The paper studies when two-qutrit dephasing trajectories exhibit constant negativity or evolve from distillable to persistent bound entanglement. Its family mixes a decoherence-free maximally entangled state of weight ppp with three two-term states sharing an amplitude ratio r>0r>0r>0; their coherences decay as γ=e−Γt/2\gamma=e^{-\Gamma t/2}γ=e−Γt/2.
The exact classification is PPT iff Lr(γ)≤p≤UrL_r(\gamma)\le p\le U_rLr​(γ)≤p≤Ur​ and separable iff Lr(γ)≤p≤SrL_r(\gamma)\le p\le S_rLr​(γ)≤p≤Sr​, where Lr(γ)=rγ/(1+r2+rγ)L_r(\gamma)=r\gamma/(1+r^2+r\gamma)Lr​(γ)=rγ/(1+r2+rγ), Ur=r/(1+r+r2)U_r=r/(1+r+r^2)Ur​=r/(1+r+r2), and Sr=min⁡{1,r2}/(1+r2+min⁡{1,r2})S_r=\min\{1,r^2\}/(1+r^2+\min\{1,r^2\})Sr​=min{1,r2}/(1+r2+min{1,r2}). Positive negativity is constant throughout evolution exactly when p>Urp>U_rp>Ur​; the trajectory is nonstationary for p<1p<1p<1. For Sr<p<UrS_r<p<U_rSr​<p<Ur​, initially one-copy-distillable states become PPT entangled at tP=(2/Γ)log⁡[r(1−p)/(p(1+r2))]t_{\mathrm P}=(2/\Gamma)\log[r(1-p)/(p(1+r^2))]tP​=(2/Γ)log[r(1−p)/(p(1+r2))] and remain bound entangled thereafter. For 0<p≤Sr0<p\le S_r0<p≤Sr​, reaching PPT instead means becoming separable. The symmetric case r=1r=1r=1 has no PPT-entangled region.
These statements follow from explicit partial-transpose blocks, a finite product decomposition, three fixed witnesses, and a realignment formula detecting every PPT-entangled member. A fixed two-level local projection establishes distillability throughout the NPT region. The static classification specializes established cyclic-state results, with known Horodecki and Ha–Kye–Park families embedded explicitly.
The printed global dephasing channel can entangle product inputs, but a correlated local random-unitary semigroup reproduces these particular trajectories. Constant negativity does not establish constancy of other entanglement measures. Independent amplitude ratios and more general maximally correlated blocks remain outside the analysis.
Recently it has been discovered that certain two-qutrit entangled states interacting with global and/or multi-local decoherence undergo distillability sudden death (DSD). We investigate this phenomenon for qutrit–qutrit systems interacting with statistically independent zero-temperature reservoirs. We show that certain initially prepared free-entangled states become bound-entangled in a finite time due to the action of a Markovian dissipative environment. As there is no definitive criterion for separability/entanglement of density matrices with dimension greater than 6, therefore we believe that the results obtained in this paper are restricted to a specific family of states considered here. Moreover, in contrast to local dephasing, simple local unitary transformations can completely avoid distillability sudden death under amplitude damping.
The effect of stochastic dephasing on the dynamics of entanglement of qutrit-qutrit states is investigated by using negativity and bound entanglement defined with realignment criterion. From the analysis, we find that the time evolution of quantum free entanglement and bound entanglement depends on the fluctuations of the stochastic variables and the parameters of the particular initial states of concern. Our results imply that some qutrits states display both distillability sudden death and entanglement sudden death, while some states do not display distillability sudden death but only entanglement sudden death.
Considering the influences of collective dephasing, multilocal qutrit-flip, local qutrit-flip, and the combination of global mixed noise, we study the dynamics of entanglement and the phenomenon of distillability of sudden death (DSD) in a qutrit-qutrit system under various decoherent noises. It is shown that the system always undergoes DSD when it interacts with multilocal and local qutrit-flip noise, and the time-determined bound entangled state is more dependent on different noises. Comparing with the cases of global mixed and collective dephasing noise, we conclude that the qutrit-flip noise is responsible for the DSD.
We characterize bound entanglement in bipartite qutrit systems by combining the Positive Partial Transpose (PPT) criterion with a structural, non-completely positive map. Focusing on a comprehensive three-parameter bipartite qutrit family ρa,b,cρ_{a,b,c}ρa,b,c​, we present an exact analytical and geometric partitioning of the physical state space simplex. We derive the closed-form quadratic boundary governing the leaf-like PPT region (a2+ab+b2−b≤0)(a^2+ab+b^2-b \leq 0)(a2+ab+b2−b≤0) over the domain 0<a≤130 < a \leq \frac{1}{3}0<a≤31​, and identify the exact linear threshold (a>c)(a > c)(a>c) that characterizes the PPT bound entangled sub-region. This family strictly generalizes the well-known Horodecki bound entangled states, which appear as a single slice of the three-dimensional leaf. Applying the structural map to this decomposition, we show that it certifies bound entanglement throughout the entire threshold region, accounting for 14.76%14.76\%14.76% of the total PPT leaf area.
We study a family of sparse positive maps on qutrits for which positivity, decomposability, and PPT entanglement can all be analysed explicitly. The block structure of the associated Choi matrices reduces positivity to a Hermitian biquadratic form and leads to exact positivity boundaries for three representative parametric families. For the same families we determine the exact transition between decomposable and non-decomposable maps and construct associated PPT states of two classes. The first consists of witness-adapted deformations naturally tied to the non-decomposability analysis. The second consists of analytically tractable families whose full PPT-entangled branch is detected by fixed positive maps, yielding exact thresholds between separability and bound entanglement. For the trace-preserving subclass, we further compare positivity with a recent eigenvalue bound for 2-positive maps, thereby making the gap between positivity and higher-order positivity fully explicit within this family.