arXiv:2611.04512
Motional Decoherence of the internal state of an atom by vacuum and thermal fluctuations of a quantum field: Necessity of a fully relativistic treatment
Jen-Tsung Hsiang, Bei-Lok Hu
Abstract
We consider a massive object, such as a neutral atom or an Unruh-DeWitt detector, moving at constant speed in a quantum field and investigate how motion affects the quantum coherence of its internal degrees of freedom, manifesting as quantum dispersion in the absence of a quantum field, and decoherence in its presence. Our investigation aims to serve two purposes: One is to obtain the correct results for these effects, which are essential for the design of quantum information processing schemes where the quantum coherence of an atom's internal degrees of freedom is of major concern. The other is to expose the fallacies in commonplace approaches, which start with a non-relativistic calculation and then add on relativistic ``corrections". We first show a fully relativistic calculation of the internal dynamics based on covariance principles, and then one which ignores these principles, often justified by the atom's slow motion. By a direct comparison of results from these two approaches, we identify {significant discrepancies} in a non-relativistic treatment, even at low atomic speeds. The proper procedure, and a much safer one in terms of accuracy, is recommended here: first derive the dynamics and the necessary regularizations within a fully covariant relativistic framework. Only after the exact, internally consistent equations of motion are established should low-velocity limits be extracted from them. Only in this way can all the relativistic effects which matter: time dilation, aberration, non-inertial mass shifts, be systematically preserved, and accurate results obtained.
AI Summary
The paper asks how uniform motion through vacuum or a thermal quantum field affects an atom’s internal fluctuations, and whether treating internal dynamics nonrelativistically introduces spurious velocity dependence. It models the object as a harmonic-oscillator Unruh–DeWitt detector, linearly coupled to a massless scalar field along a prescribed inertial worldline. A proper-time Langevin equation is derived by integrating out the field and renormalizing the oscillator frequency. Its solutions and the exact thermal noise spectrum determine the internal displacement variance through frequency integrals. Equivalent laboratory-time and comoving-frame formulations are compared with a hybrid model that retains laboratory-time oscillator dynamics while evaluating field correlations along the moving trajectory. In vacuum, the proper-time noise spectrum is $\widehat G_H(\kappa)=|\kappa|/(4\pi)$, so the variance is velocity-independent at fixed proper time. Laboratory-time relaxation is slowed by the Lorentz factor. The hybrid model instead predicts increasing vacuum variance with velocity. At finite temperature, Doppler shifts and aberration produce temperature-dependent velocity effects: low-temperature corrections can increase weakly with speed, whereas the leading high-temperature noise scales as $T\eta/(2\pi\sinh\eta)$, where $v=\tanh\eta$, and decreases with speed. The stated limitations include the idealized scalar monopole coupling rather than electromagnetic atomic structure, prescribed motion without center-of-mass backreaction, and a factorized initial detector–field state. Displacement variance is used as a covariant diagnostic, not a complete coherence measure; its connection to purity requires additional weak-coupling, approximately thermal-state assumptions.
Central claim may not hold: The claimed significance at low atomic speeds is not established: the steady-state vacuum discrepancy between the compared models is exactly v^2/(1-v^2), which vanishes quadratically with speed. Showing that one inconsistent hybrid prescription fails does not establish that systematic relativistic corrections to a nonrelativistic description fail. Position variance does not generally determine decoherence or purity, and time dilation does not justify the required weak-coupling approximation because it leaves the damping-to-frequency ratio unchanged. The finite-time Fourier-transform formulas are incorrect, and even the corrected transform produces a logarithmically ultraviolet-divergent finite-time position variance for the stated abrupt, factorized preparation, leaving the plotted finite-time results unsupported without an additional prescription. The displayed high-temperature oscillator variance is too small by a factor of two.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- DOI
- 10.48550/arxiv.2611.04512
- Comments
- 33 pages, two figures