Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.04512

Motional Decoherence of the internal state of an atom by vacuum and thermal fluctuations of a quantum field: Necessity of a fully relativistic treatment

Jen-Tsung Hsiang, Bei-Lok Hu

quant-phgr-qchep-thSubmitted Nov 3, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a massive object, such as a neutral atom or an Unruh-DeWitt detector, moving at constant speed in a quantum field and investigate how motion affects the quantum coherence of its internal degrees of freedom, manifesting as quantum dispersion in the absence of a quantum field, and decoherence in its presence. Our investigation aims to serve two purposes: One is to obtain the correct results for these effects, which are essential for the design of quantum information processing schemes where the quantum coherence of an atom's internal degrees of freedom is of major concern. The other is to expose the fallacies in commonplace approaches, which start with a non-relativistic calculation and then add on relativistic ``corrections". We first show a fully relativistic calculation of the internal dynamics based on covariance principles, and then one which ignores these principles, often justified by the atom's slow motion. By a direct comparison of results from these two approaches, we identify {significant discrepancies} in a non-relativistic treatment, even at low atomic speeds. The proper procedure, and a much safer one in terms of accuracy, is recommended here: first derive the dynamics and the necessary regularizations within a fully covariant relativistic framework. Only after the exact, internally consistent equations of motion are established should low-velocity limits be extracted from them. Only in this way can all the relativistic effects which matter: time dilation, aberration, non-inertial mass shifts, be systematically preserved, and accurate results obtained.

AI Summary

The paper asks how uniform motion through vacuum or a thermal quantum field affects an atom’s internal fluctuations, and whether treating internal dynamics nonrelativistically introduces spurious velocity dependence. It models the object as a harmonic-oscillator Unruh–DeWitt detector, linearly coupled to a massless scalar field along a prescribed inertial worldline. A proper-time Langevin equation is derived by integrating out the field and renormalizing the oscillator frequency. Its solutions and the exact thermal noise spectrum determine the internal displacement variance through frequency integrals. Equivalent laboratory-time and comoving-frame formulations are compared with a hybrid model that retains laboratory-time oscillator dynamics while evaluating field correlations along the moving trajectory. In vacuum, the proper-time noise spectrum is $\widehat G_H(\kappa)=|\kappa|/(4\pi)$, so the variance is velocity-independent at fixed proper time. Laboratory-time relaxation is slowed by the Lorentz factor. The hybrid model instead predicts increasing vacuum variance with velocity. At finite temperature, Doppler shifts and aberration produce temperature-dependent velocity effects: low-temperature corrections can increase weakly with speed, whereas the leading high-temperature noise scales as $T\eta/(2\pi\sinh\eta)$, where $v=\tanh\eta$, and decreases with speed. The stated limitations include the idealized scalar monopole coupling rather than electromagnetic atomic structure, prescribed motion without center-of-mass backreaction, and a factorized initial detector–field state. Displacement variance is used as a covariant diagnostic, not a complete coherence measure; its connection to purity requires additional weak-coupling, approximately thermal-state assumptions.

Some signs of AI-generated textOverclaimsUnclear noveltyMissing comparisonPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The claimed significance at low atomic speeds is not established: the steady-state vacuum discrepancy between the compared models is exactly v^2/(1-v^2), which vanishes quadratically with speed. Showing that one inconsistent hybrid prescription fails does not establish that systematic relativistic corrections to a nonrelativistic description fail. Position variance does not generally determine decoherence or purity, and time dilation does not justify the required weak-coupling approximation because it leaves the damping-to-frequency ratio unchanged. The finite-time Fourier-transform formulas are incorrect, and even the corrected transform produces a logarithmically ultraviolet-divergent finite-time position variance for the stated abrupt, factorized preparation, leaving the plotted finite-time results unsupported without an additional prescription. The displayed high-temperature oscillator variance is too small by a factor of two.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.04512
Comments
33 pages, two figures

Related papers

Vacuum viscosity and relativistic inertia: Motion of a massive object with charged internal degrees of freedom interacting with a classical field

Jen-Tsung Hsiang, Bei-Lok Hu

Our present investigation into a rather rudimentary problem is motivated by two classes of problems studied since the 70's, cosmological particle creation and its more accessible analog, the dynamical Casimir effect on the one hand, and quantum friction a neutral atom moving along a dielectric surface would experience, on the other. The backreaction effects of produced particles being able to isotropize the expansion of the universe, or to slow down the moving mirror can be understood via the concept of vacuum viscosity arising from fluctuations of the quantum field. We want to track down the origin of this effect by asking the question whether a moving massive $M$ object with a charged internal degrees of freedom $χ$ interacting with a free unbounded classical field $φ$ at zero temperature would experience a viscous force, similar to the said precedents. Adopting a microphysics model for optomechanics which can treat the unequal tripartite $χ$-$φ$-$M$ interactions, we first perform a nonrelativistic calculation, which seems perfectly legitimate considering the needs of atomic physics, and found the answer to be yes, but a relativistic covariant calculation says no. We identify where the nonrelativistic framework is defective. The resolution of this latent yet real conflict is technically nontrivial but physically quite inspirational. It results in added enriched contents to Newton's first and second laws when the principles of special relativity are enforced, and rules to follow to get the correct nonrelativistic answer

quant-pharXiv:2608.20140•Aug 21, 2026

Decoherence of spatial superpositions along stationary worldlines

Clemens Jakubec, Aaron Bartleson, Peter W. Milonni +1 more

We analyze the decoherence of a particle's spatial superposition moving along a stationary worldline through the Minkowski vacuum. The particle is modeled via an internal degree of freedom that couples to a scalar field, and an external degree of freedom, i.e., its quantized center-of-mass motion around the stationary worldline. Assuming a separation of time scales between the particle's internal and external dynamics, we first obtain an effective red-shifted polarizability of the particle, characterizing the trajectory-dependent linear response of the internal oscillator to the field. We then derive a quantum Brownian motion master equation for the particle's center of mass, under the Born-Markov approximation, which describes its decoherence in the position basis, as well as, Hamiltonian modifications corresponding to a dispersive potential. The resulting decoherence has two components: (1) arising from a modified field spectrum observed by the particle; and (2) due to a differential time-dilation over the particle's extended spatial wavefunction. For stationary trajectories, both contributions take an effectively thermal form. We evaluate the decoherence rates for two specific cases of hyperbolic and uniform circular motion.

quant-pharXiv:2605.13677•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 14, 2026•1 citation

Dynamics of Unruh-DeWitt detectors in a relativistic quantum field

Shih-Yuin Lin

Based on our results for the detector-field system in Gaussian states, I am addressing the following issues about the quantum dynamics of atoms or detectors moving in a relativistic quantum field: First, the dynamics of the detectors as an open quantum quantum system, hence the entanglement creation and sudden death processes between the detectors, are non-Markovian in general. Second, the excitations of the accelerated detectors in the Unruh effect depend only on the kinematics of the detectors. The event horizon for the detector is not essential in this effect, and the particle notion of the quantum field is not needed here. Third, entanglement dynamics of the detectors are independent of time-slicing scheme. Local projective measurements on point-like detectors are also consistent in different time-slicing schemes even in the presence of relativistic quantum fields.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 8, 2011•2 citations

Internal dynamics and guided motion in general relativistic quantum interferometry

Thomas B. Mieling

The coupling between internal degrees of freedom of quantum systems and their overall motion in an external gravitational field plays a central role in multiple extensions of Einstein's equivalence principle to quantum physics. While previous models of such effects were predominantly restricted to linearized gravity and often required quantum particles to follow prescribed world-lines, this letter shows how such phenomena can be understood using generally covariant semi-classical approximations in the framework of quantum field theory in curved space-times. This method provides a unification and generalization of previously established results, but also predicts new effects such as an influence of internal energies on field amplitudes, as well as correction terms to the internal Schrödinger equation that give rise to Berry phases.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2602.21001•Feb 25, 2026

Thermal corrections to quantum friction and decoherence: A closed-time-path approach to atom-surface interaction

Ludmila Viotti, M. Belén Farías, Paula I. Villar +1 more

In this paper we study the dissipative effects and decoherence induced on a particle moving at constant speed in front of a dielectric plate in quantum vacuum, developing a closed-time-path (CTP) integral formulation in order to account for the corrections to these phenomena generated by finite temperatures. We compute the frictional force of the moving particle and find that it contains two different contributions: a pure quantum term due to quantum fluctuations (even present at vanishing temperatures) and a temperature-dependent component generated by thermal fluctuations (the bigger the contribution, the higher the temperature). We further estimate the decoherence timescale for the internal degree of freedom of the quantum particle. As expected, decoherence time is reduced by temperature; however, this feature is stronger for large velocities and for resonant situations. When the particle approaches relativistic speed, decoherence time becomes independent of temperature. The finite temperature corrections to the force or even in the decoherence timescale could be used to track traces of quantum friction through the study of the velocity dependence since the sole evidence of this dependence provides an indirect testimony of the existence of a quantum frictional force.

arXiv:1901.04556•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 13, 2019•16 citations

Quantized mass-energy effects in an Unruh-DeWitt detector

Carolyn E. Wood, Magdalena Zych

A simple but powerful particle detector model consists of a two-level system coupled to a field, where the detected particles are the field excitations. This is known as the Unruh-DeWitt detector. Research using this model has often focused on either a completely classical description of the external degrees of freedom of the detector, or a full field-theoretic treatment, where the detector itself is described as a field. Recently there has been much interest in quantum aspects of the detector's center of mass---either described as moving in superposition along semiclassical trajectories, or dynamically evolving under a nonrelativistic Hamiltonian. However, the processes of interest---the absorption or emission of field particles---necessarily change the detector's rest mass by the amount of energy of the absorbed or emitted field quanta. Neither of the above models can capture such effects. Here we incorporate the quantization of the detector's mass-energy into the Unruh-DeWitt model. We show that internal energy changes due to emission or absorption are relevant even in the lowest energy limit. Specifically, corrections to transition rates due to the detector's mass changing cannot be ignored unless the entire center of mass dynamics is also ignored. Our results imply that one cannot have a consistent model of the Unruh-DeWitt detector as a massive particle without including the mass-energy equivalence.

arXiv:2205.02394•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 20, 2022•8 citations
We consider a massive object, such as a neutral atom or an Unruh-DeWitt detector, moving at constant speed in a quantum field and investigate how motion affects the quantum coherence of its internal degrees of freedom, manifesting as quantum dispersion in the absence of a quantum field, and decoherence in its presence. Our investigation aims to serve two purposes: One is to obtain the correct results for these effects, which are essential for the design of quantum information processing schemes where the quantum coherence of an atom's internal degrees of freedom is of major concern. The other is to expose the fallacies in commonplace approaches, which start with a non-relativistic calculation and then add on relativistic ``corrections". We first show a fully relativistic calculation of the internal dynamics based on covariance principles, and then one which ignores these principles, often justified by the atom's slow motion. By a direct comparison of results from these two approaches, we identify {significant discrepancies} in a non-relativistic treatment, even at low atomic speeds. The proper procedure, and a much safer one in terms of accuracy, is recommended here: first derive the dynamics and the necessary regularizations within a fully covariant relativistic framework. Only after the exact, internally consistent equations of motion are established should low-velocity limits be extracted from them. Only in this way can all the relativistic effects which matter: time dilation, aberration, non-inertial mass shifts, be systematically preserved, and accurate results obtained.
The paper asks how uniform motion through vacuum or a thermal quantum field affects an atom’s internal fluctuations, and whether treating internal dynamics nonrelativistically introduces spurious velocity dependence. It models the object as a harmonic-oscillator Unruh–DeWitt detector, linearly coupled to a massless scalar field along a prescribed inertial worldline.
A proper-time Langevin equation is derived by integrating out the field and renormalizing the oscillator frequency. Its solutions and the exact thermal noise spectrum determine the internal displacement variance through frequency integrals. Equivalent laboratory-time and comoving-frame formulations are compared with a hybrid model that retains laboratory-time oscillator dynamics while evaluating field correlations along the moving trajectory.
In vacuum, the proper-time noise spectrum is G^H(κ)=∣κ∣/(4π)\widehat G_H(\kappa)=|\kappa|/(4\pi)GH​(κ)=∣κ∣/(4π), so the variance is velocity-independent at fixed proper time. Laboratory-time relaxation is slowed by the Lorentz factor. The hybrid model instead predicts increasing vacuum variance with velocity. At finite temperature, Doppler shifts and aberration produce temperature-dependent velocity effects: low-temperature corrections can increase weakly with speed, whereas the leading high-temperature noise scales as Tη/(2πsinh⁡η)T\eta/(2\pi\sinh\eta)Tη/(2πsinhη), where v=tanh⁡ηv=\tanh\etav=tanhη, and decreases with speed.
The stated limitations include the idealized scalar monopole coupling rather than electromagnetic atomic structure, prescribed motion without center-of-mass backreaction, and a factorized initial detector–field state. Displacement variance is used as a covariant diagnostic, not a complete coherence measure; its connection to purity requires additional weak-coupling, approximately thermal-state assumptions.
Our present investigation into a rather rudimentary problem is motivated by two classes of problems studied since the 70's, cosmological particle creation and its more accessible analog, the dynamical Casimir effect on the one hand, and quantum friction a neutral atom moving along a dielectric surface would experience, on the other. The backreaction effects of produced particles being able to isotropize the expansion of the universe, or to slow down the moving mirror can be understood via the concept of vacuum viscosity arising from fluctuations of the quantum field. We want to track down the origin of this effect by asking the question whether a moving massive MMM object with a charged internal degrees of freedom χχχ interacting with a free unbounded classical field φφφ at zero temperature would experience a viscous force, similar to the said precedents. Adopting a microphysics model for optomechanics which can treat the unequal tripartite χχχ-φφφ-MMM interactions, we first perform a nonrelativistic calculation, which seems perfectly legitimate considering the needs of atomic physics, and found the answer to be yes, but a relativistic covariant calculation says no. We identify where the nonrelativistic framework is defective. The resolution of this latent yet real conflict is technically nontrivial but physically quite inspirational. It results in added enriched contents to Newton's first and second laws when the principles of special relativity are enforced, and rules to follow to get the correct nonrelativistic answer
We analyze the decoherence of a particle's spatial superposition moving along a stationary worldline through the Minkowski vacuum. The particle is modeled via an internal degree of freedom that couples to a scalar field, and an external degree of freedom, i.e., its quantized center-of-mass motion around the stationary worldline. Assuming a separation of time scales between the particle's internal and external dynamics, we first obtain an effective red-shifted polarizability of the particle, characterizing the trajectory-dependent linear response of the internal oscillator to the field. We then derive a quantum Brownian motion master equation for the particle's center of mass, under the Born-Markov approximation, which describes its decoherence in the position basis, as well as, Hamiltonian modifications corresponding to a dispersive potential. The resulting decoherence has two components: (1) arising from a modified field spectrum observed by the particle; and (2) due to a differential time-dilation over the particle's extended spatial wavefunction. For stationary trajectories, both contributions take an effectively thermal form. We evaluate the decoherence rates for two specific cases of hyperbolic and uniform circular motion.
Based on our results for the detector-field system in Gaussian states, I am addressing the following issues about the quantum dynamics of atoms or detectors moving in a relativistic quantum field: First, the dynamics of the detectors as an open quantum quantum system, hence the entanglement creation and sudden death processes between the detectors, are non-Markovian in general. Second, the excitations of the accelerated detectors in the Unruh effect depend only on the kinematics of the detectors. The event horizon for the detector is not essential in this effect, and the particle notion of the quantum field is not needed here. Third, entanglement dynamics of the detectors are independent of time-slicing scheme. Local projective measurements on point-like detectors are also consistent in different time-slicing schemes even in the presence of relativistic quantum fields.
The coupling between internal degrees of freedom of quantum systems and their overall motion in an external gravitational field plays a central role in multiple extensions of Einstein's equivalence principle to quantum physics. While previous models of such effects were predominantly restricted to linearized gravity and often required quantum particles to follow prescribed world-lines, this letter shows how such phenomena can be understood using generally covariant semi-classical approximations in the framework of quantum field theory in curved space-times. This method provides a unification and generalization of previously established results, but also predicts new effects such as an influence of internal energies on field amplitudes, as well as correction terms to the internal Schrödinger equation that give rise to Berry phases.
In this paper we study the dissipative effects and decoherence induced on a particle moving at constant speed in front of a dielectric plate in quantum vacuum, developing a closed-time-path (CTP) integral formulation in order to account for the corrections to these phenomena generated by finite temperatures. We compute the frictional force of the moving particle and find that it contains two different contributions: a pure quantum term due to quantum fluctuations (even present at vanishing temperatures) and a temperature-dependent component generated by thermal fluctuations (the bigger the contribution, the higher the temperature). We further estimate the decoherence timescale for the internal degree of freedom of the quantum particle. As expected, decoherence time is reduced by temperature; however, this feature is stronger for large velocities and for resonant situations. When the particle approaches relativistic speed, decoherence time becomes independent of temperature. The finite temperature corrections to the force or even in the decoherence timescale could be used to track traces of quantum friction through the study of the velocity dependence since the sole evidence of this dependence provides an indirect testimony of the existence of a quantum frictional force.
A simple but powerful particle detector model consists of a two-level system coupled to a field, where the detected particles are the field excitations. This is known as the Unruh-DeWitt detector. Research using this model has often focused on either a completely classical description of the external degrees of freedom of the detector, or a full field-theoretic treatment, where the detector itself is described as a field. Recently there has been much interest in quantum aspects of the detector's center of mass---either described as moving in superposition along semiclassical trajectories, or dynamically evolving under a nonrelativistic Hamiltonian. However, the processes of interest---the absorption or emission of field particles---necessarily change the detector's rest mass by the amount of energy of the absorbed or emitted field quanta. Neither of the above models can capture such effects. Here we incorporate the quantization of the detector's mass-energy into the Unruh-DeWitt model. We show that internal energy changes due to emission or absorption are relevant even in the lowest energy limit. Specifically, corrections to transition rates due to the detector's mass changing cannot be ignored unless the entire center of mass dynamics is also ignored. Our results imply that one cannot have a consistent model of the Unruh-DeWitt detector as a massive particle without including the mass-energy equivalence.