Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.03760

Restricted triangular ice beyond the solvable manifolds: chiral ice and the critical region of dominant chiral vertices

Josep Amengual i Batle

Published Oct 17, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study two restrictions of Baxter's symmetric twenty-vertex model on the triangular lattice, in which the three classes of vertices allowed by the ice rule carry the weights $a$, $b$ and $c$: chiral ice, in which only the twelve chiral vertices are allowed, and the model that excludes only the two alternating vertices. We show that neither model belongs to any of the known exactly solvable families of the twenty-vertex model, and we characterise chiral ice as the ice model in which every vertex has exactly one through line, a property that imposes a parity constraint along every closed lattice line. We compute the residual entropies of both models with transfer matrices on cylinders of up to twelve vertices in circumference, extrapolated with the finite-size correction predicted by conformal invariance, which we adapt to the triangular geometry and verify at two exactly solved points. The number of upward arrows crossing the cylinder is conserved, and the cost of changing it shows that both models are critical, with the long-distance behaviour of a free massless field. Chiral ice is the extreme point of a region of the phase diagram in which ordering had been suggested; along two paths through that region we find the same critical behaviour at every point, with no feature at the proposed boundary of the region. Along Baxter's exactly solved curve we obtain the corresponding exponents in closed form.

DOI
10.13140/rg.2.2.10529.98408

Related papers

Full nonuniversality of the symmetric 16-vertex model on the square lattice

Eva Pospíšilová, Roman Krčmár, Andrej Gendiar +1 more

We consider the symmetric two-state 16-vertex model on the square lattice whose vertex weights are invariant under any permutation of adjacent edge states. The vertex-weight parameters are restricted to a critical manifold which is self-dual under the gauge transformation. The critical properties of the model are studied numerically with the Corner Transfer Matrix Renormalization Group method. Accuracy of the method is tested on two exactly solvable cases: the Ising model and a specific version of the Baxter eight-vertex model in a zero field that belong to different universality classes. Numerical results show that the two exactly solvable cases are connected by a line of critical points with the polarization as the order parameter. There are numerical indications that critical exponents vary continuously along this line in such a way that the weak universality hypothesis is violated.

arXiv:2002.02757•Physical review. E•Jul 13, 2020•0 citations

Exactly solvable interacting spin-ice vertex model

Anderson A. Ferreira, Francisco Castilho Alcaraz

A special family of solvable five-vertex model is introduced on a square lattice. In addition to the usual nearest-neighbor interactions, the vertices defining the model also interact along one of the diagonals of the lattice. This family of models includes in a special limit the standard six-vertex model. The exact solution of these models is an application of the matrix product ansatz introduced recently and applied successfully in the solution of quantum chains. The phase diagram and the free energy of the models are calculated in the thermodynamic limit. The models exhibit massless phases, and our analytical and numerical analyses indicate that such phases are governed by a conformal field theory with central charge c=1 and continuously varying critical exponents.

arXiv:cond-mat/0608504•Physical Review E•Jul 24, 2006•3 citations

The ice and Potts models in statistical mechanics

Stewart Beaton Kelland

This thesis deals with two two-dimensional lattice models in statistical mechanics. The first of these is the zero-field 20-vertex model on a triangular lattice. This model is the analogue to the ice-type, zero-field six-vertex model on a square lattice. We solve this problem exactly for a restricted set of vertex weights. The other model is the q-component Potts model on a square lattice. This model is equivalent to a staggered ice-type model on a square lattice. Using a variational method we estimate the critical exponent ß for several values of q. In part I we outline the fundamental statistical mechanical ideas needed, including the definition of the partition function and its relation to the thermodynamic quantities. Mention is also made of the existence and uniqueness of the thermodynamic limit for these models. The 20-vertex model is discussed in part II. The transfer matrix approach is adopted and a Bethe ansatz is used for the eigenvector. Unlike the square lattice ice-type model, the triangular lattice 20-vertex model is only soluble by this method for a restricted set of vertex weights. In particular, the ten parameters determining the vertex weights must be expressed in terms of four independent parameters. This results in only one type of non-trivial temperature independent solution. This solution exhibits critical behaviour similar to the square lattice KDP model. The general solution has three states: disordered, antiferroelectric and ferroelectric. Which state the model is in is determined by one of the above four parameters. The transition from the disordered to the antiferroelectric state is of infinite-order (i.e the free energy has an essential singularity), and from the disordered to the ferroelectric state is of finite-order. We also compare our results to the free-fermion solution of the same model and note where the two methods overlap. In part III the Potts model is considered. The model is defined and shown to be equivalent to a staggered ice-type model. A variational principle for the eigenvalues of the transfer matrix of the staggered ice model is determined. Using the zero-temperature solution as a ^uide a simple form for a sequence of approximations to the eigenvector, below T , is developed. By using the variational principle we arrive at a set of matrix equations determining the eigenvector at a given level of approximation. By noting some of the symmetries of the transfer matrix we are able to separate some of the dependences of the matrix elements and consequently simplify the original set of equations. We are also able to express the percolation probability ( the analogue of the spontaneous magnetization for general values of q ) of the Potts model as a simple function of these matrix elements. At each level of approximation there is a set of algebraic equations to solve. We have used an electronic computer to solve these equations for the first five levels of approximation, and for several values of q between zero and four. With our results we estimate the critical exponent 3 for the Potts model. These estimates agree reasonably well with previous work and indicate 3=0.145 ±.017 for q=l.

Bulletin of the Australian Mathematical Society•Oct 1, 1976•1 citation

Chiral Color Ice: Exact Local Handedness Constraints and Möbius Zero Modes in Frustrated Magnets

Péter Kránitz, Yasir Iqbal, Karlo Penc

Local constraints govern the low-energy physics of frustrated matter, but familiar ice-type rules constrain flux-like quantities and are insensitive to handedness. Here we show that handedness itself can be imposed as an exact local quantum constraint without selecting an axis in spin space. We construct positive-semidefinite, SU(2)-invariant parent Hamiltonians whose complete zero-energy space on a tetrahedron has a prescribed chirality sign, rather than selecting a particular chiral wave function. For spin-1/2 the local term is a rank-one projector onto a chiral tetrahedral singlet, while for arbitrary spin it factorizes as $B^\dagger B$ through a singlet-annihilation operator, with a completely characterized kernel given by the span of the globally rotated chiral color-ice states. For coherent states, the same zero-energy condition becomes an $S$-independent nonlinear constraint in which three spin directions determine the fourth through a Möbius transformation; compositions of these maps define constraint holonomies on extended lattices. Connecting the same local constraint in different ways produces qualitatively different collective regimes: corner-sharing lattices retain exponentially large quantum ground-state kernels, with rigorous lower bounds exceeding conventional ice benchmarks; edge-sharing lattices support subdimensional plane or line zero modes; while triangular constructions suppress nonuniform coherent deformations and contain the complete Anderson tower of tetrahedral magnetic order at exactly zero energy. Two inequivalent triangular coverings further show that harmonic zero-mode counting does not determine the size of the quantum kernel. These results establish a tractable setting in which local handedness, nonlinear constraint geometry, and quantum degeneracy can be disentangled and related directly to the connectivity of the constraint network.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2608.30802•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations

Critical properties of the eight-vertex model in a field

Roman Krčmár, Ladislav Šamaj

The general eight-vertex model on a square lattice is studied numerically by using the Corner Transfer Matrix Renormalization Group method. The method is tested on the symmetric (zero-field) version of the model, the obtained dependence of critical exponents on model's parameters is in agreement with Baxter's exact solution and weak universality is verified with a high accuracy. It was suggested long time ago that the symmetric eight-vertex model is a special exceptional case and in the presence of external fields the eight-vertex model falls into the Ising universality class. We confirm numerically this conjecture in a subspace of vertex weights, except for two specific combinations of vertical and horizontal fields for which the system still exhibits weak universality.

arXiv:1610.08657•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Sep 1, 2016•6 citations

Riemann–Hilbert approach to the six-vertex model

Pavel Bleher, Karl Liechty

The six-vertex model, or the square ice model, with domain wall boundary conditions (DWBC) has been introduced and solved for finite n by Korepin and Izergin. The solution is based on the Yang–Baxter equations and it represents the free energy in terms of an n × n Hankel determinant. Paul Zinn-Justin observed that the Izergin–Korepin formula can be expressed in terms of the partition function of a random matrix model with a nonpolynomial interaction. We use this observation to obtain the large n asymptotics of the six-vertex model with DWBC. The solution is based on the Riemann–Hilbert approach. In this paper we review asymptotic results obtained in different regions of the phase diagram. 1. Six-vertex model The six-vertex model , or the model of two-dimensional ice , is stated on a square lattice with arrows on edges. The arrows obey the rule that at every vertex there are two arrows pointing in and two arrows pointing out. This rule is sometimes called the ice-rule. There are only six possible configurations of arrows at each vertex, hence the name of the model; see Figure 1. We will consider the domain wall boundary conditions (DWBC), in which the arrows on the upper and lower boundaries point into the square, and the ones on the left and right boundaries point out. One possible configuration with DWBC on the 4 × 4 lattice is shown on Figure 2. The name of the square ice comes from the two-dimensional arrangement of water molecules, H2O, with oxygen atoms at the vertices of the lattice and one hydrogen atom between each pair of adjacent oxygen atoms. We place an arrow in the direction from a hydrogen atom toward an oxygen atom if there is a bond between them. Thus, as we already noticed before, there are two in-bound and two out-bound arrows at each vertex. Figure 1. The six arrow configurations allowed at a vertex. Figure 2. An example of a 4 x 4 configuration (left) and the corresponding ice crystal (right). For each possible vertex state we assign a weight w i , i =1, ...., 6, and define, as usual, the partition function , as a sum over all possible arrow configurations of the product of the vertex weights, where V n is the n × n set of vertices,σ (x)∈{1,...,6} is the vertex configuration of σ at vertex x according to Figure 1, and N i (σ) is the number of vertices of type i in the configuration σ.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 15, 2014•0 citations
We study two restrictions of Baxter's symmetric twenty-vertex model on the triangular lattice, in which the three classes of vertices allowed by the ice rule carry the weights aaa, bbb and ccc: chiral ice, in which only the twelve chiral vertices are allowed, and the model that excludes only the two alternating vertices. We show that neither model belongs to any of the known exactly solvable families of the twenty-vertex model, and we characterise chiral ice as the ice model in which every vertex has exactly one through line, a property that imposes a parity constraint along every closed lattice line. We compute the residual entropies of both models with transfer matrices on cylinders of up to twelve vertices in circumference, extrapolated with the finite-size correction predicted by conformal invariance, which we adapt to the triangular geometry and verify at two exactly solved points. The number of upward arrows crossing the cylinder is conserved, and the cost of changing it shows that both models are critical, with the long-distance behaviour of a free massless field. Chiral ice is the extreme point of a region of the phase diagram in which ordering had been suggested; along two paths through that region we find the same critical behaviour at every point, with no feature at the proposed boundary of the region. Along Baxter's exactly solved curve we obtain the corresponding exponents in closed form.
We consider the symmetric two-state 16-vertex model on the square lattice whose vertex weights are invariant under any permutation of adjacent edge states. The vertex-weight parameters are restricted to a critical manifold which is self-dual under the gauge transformation. The critical properties of the model are studied numerically with the Corner Transfer Matrix Renormalization Group method. Accuracy of the method is tested on two exactly solvable cases: the Ising model and a specific version of the Baxter eight-vertex model in a zero field that belong to different universality classes. Numerical results show that the two exactly solvable cases are connected by a line of critical points with the polarization as the order parameter. There are numerical indications that critical exponents vary continuously along this line in such a way that the weak universality hypothesis is violated.
A special family of solvable five-vertex model is introduced on a square lattice. In addition to the usual nearest-neighbor interactions, the vertices defining the model also interact along one of the diagonals of the lattice. This family of models includes in a special limit the standard six-vertex model. The exact solution of these models is an application of the matrix product ansatz introduced recently and applied successfully in the solution of quantum chains. The phase diagram and the free energy of the models are calculated in the thermodynamic limit. The models exhibit massless phases, and our analytical and numerical analyses indicate that such phases are governed by a conformal field theory with central charge c=1 and continuously varying critical exponents.
This thesis deals with two two-dimensional lattice models in statistical mechanics. The first of these is the zero-field 20-vertex model on a triangular lattice. This model is the analogue to the ice-type, zero-field six-vertex model on a square lattice. We solve this problem exactly for a restricted set of vertex weights. The other model is the q-component Potts model on a square lattice. This model is equivalent to a staggered ice-type model on a square lattice. Using a variational method we estimate the critical exponent ß for several values of q. In part I we outline the fundamental statistical mechanical ideas needed, including the definition of the partition function and its relation to the thermodynamic quantities. Mention is also made of the existence and uniqueness of the thermodynamic limit for these models. The 20-vertex model is discussed in part II. The transfer matrix approach is adopted and a Bethe ansatz is used for the eigenvector. Unlike the square lattice ice-type model, the triangular lattice 20-vertex model is only soluble by this method for a restricted set of vertex weights. In particular, the ten parameters determining the vertex weights must be expressed in terms of four independent parameters. This results in only one type of non-trivial temperature independent solution. This solution exhibits critical behaviour similar to the square lattice KDP model. The general solution has three states: disordered, antiferroelectric and ferroelectric. Which state the model is in is determined by one of the above four parameters. The transition from the disordered to the antiferroelectric state is of infinite-order (i.e the free energy has an essential singularity), and from the disordered to the ferroelectric state is of finite-order. We also compare our results to the free-fermion solution of the same model and note where the two methods overlap. In part III the Potts model is considered. The model is defined and shown to be equivalent to a staggered ice-type model. A variational principle for the eigenvalues of the transfer matrix of the staggered ice model is determined. Using the zero-temperature solution as a ^uide a simple form for a sequence of approximations to the eigenvector, below T , is developed. By using the variational principle we arrive at a set of matrix equations determining the eigenvector at a given level of approximation. By noting some of the symmetries of the transfer matrix we are able to separate some of the dependences of the matrix elements and consequently simplify the original set of equations. We are also able to express the percolation probability ( the analogue of the spontaneous magnetization for general values of q ) of the Potts model as a simple function of these matrix elements. At each level of approximation there is a set of algebraic equations to solve. We have used an electronic computer to solve these equations for the first five levels of approximation, and for several values of q between zero and four. With our results we estimate the critical exponent 3 for the Potts model. These estimates agree reasonably well with previous work and indicate 3=0.145 ±.017 for q=l.
Local constraints govern the low-energy physics of frustrated matter, but familiar ice-type rules constrain flux-like quantities and are insensitive to handedness. Here we show that handedness itself can be imposed as an exact local quantum constraint without selecting an axis in spin space. We construct positive-semidefinite, SU(2)-invariant parent Hamiltonians whose complete zero-energy space on a tetrahedron has a prescribed chirality sign, rather than selecting a particular chiral wave function. For spin-1/2 the local term is a rank-one projector onto a chiral tetrahedral singlet, while for arbitrary spin it factorizes as B†BB^\dagger BB†B through a singlet-annihilation operator, with a completely characterized kernel given by the span of the globally rotated chiral color-ice states. For coherent states, the same zero-energy condition becomes an SSS-independent nonlinear constraint in which three spin directions determine the fourth through a Möbius transformation; compositions of these maps define constraint holonomies on extended lattices. Connecting the same local constraint in different ways produces qualitatively different collective regimes: corner-sharing lattices retain exponentially large quantum ground-state kernels, with rigorous lower bounds exceeding conventional ice benchmarks; edge-sharing lattices support subdimensional plane or line zero modes; while triangular constructions suppress nonuniform coherent deformations and contain the complete Anderson tower of tetrahedral magnetic order at exactly zero energy. Two inequivalent triangular coverings further show that harmonic zero-mode counting does not determine the size of the quantum kernel. These results establish a tractable setting in which local handedness, nonlinear constraint geometry, and quantum degeneracy can be disentangled and related directly to the connectivity of the constraint network.
The general eight-vertex model on a square lattice is studied numerically by using the Corner Transfer Matrix Renormalization Group method. The method is tested on the symmetric (zero-field) version of the model, the obtained dependence of critical exponents on model's parameters is in agreement with Baxter's exact solution and weak universality is verified with a high accuracy. It was suggested long time ago that the symmetric eight-vertex model is a special exceptional case and in the presence of external fields the eight-vertex model falls into the Ising universality class. We confirm numerically this conjecture in a subspace of vertex weights, except for two specific combinations of vertical and horizontal fields for which the system still exhibits weak universality.
The six-vertex model, or the square ice model, with domain wall boundary conditions (DWBC) has been introduced and solved for finite n by Korepin and Izergin. The solution is based on the Yang–Baxter equations and it represents the free energy in terms of an n × n Hankel determinant. Paul Zinn-Justin observed that the Izergin–Korepin formula can be expressed in terms of the partition function of a random matrix model with a nonpolynomial interaction. We use this observation to obtain the large n asymptotics of the six-vertex model with DWBC. The solution is based on the Riemann–Hilbert approach. In this paper we review asymptotic results obtained in different regions of the phase diagram. 1. Six-vertex model The six-vertex model , or the model of two-dimensional ice , is stated on a square lattice with arrows on edges. The arrows obey the rule that at every vertex there are two arrows pointing in and two arrows pointing out. This rule is sometimes called the ice-rule. There are only six possible configurations of arrows at each vertex, hence the name of the model; see Figure 1. We will consider the domain wall boundary conditions (DWBC), in which the arrows on the upper and lower boundaries point into the square, and the ones on the left and right boundaries point out. One possible configuration with DWBC on the 4 × 4 lattice is shown on Figure 2. The name of the square ice comes from the two-dimensional arrangement of water molecules, H2O, with oxygen atoms at the vertices of the lattice and one hydrogen atom between each pair of adjacent oxygen atoms. We place an arrow in the direction from a hydrogen atom toward an oxygen atom if there is a bond between them. Thus, as we already noticed before, there are two in-bound and two out-bound arrows at each vertex. Figure 1. The six arrow configurations allowed at a vertex. Figure 2. An example of a 4 x 4 configuration (left) and the corresponding ice crystal (right). For each possible vertex state we assign a weight w i , i =1, ...., 6, and define, as usual, the partition function , as a sum over all possible arrow configurations of the product of the vertex weights, where V n is the n × n set of vertices,σ (x)∈{1,...,6} is the vertex configuration of σ at vertex x according to Figure 1, and N i (σ) is the number of vertices of type i in the configuration σ.