Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.03521

Quantum tomography on Schwartz space

Tobias Thrien, Gabriele Carcassi, David Carfì, Christine A. Aidala

quant-phmath-phSubmitted Nov 2, 2026• Announced Nov 3, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this work we show that standard results in quantum tomography, which are typically proven in the context of Hilbert spaces, can analogously be established in the theory of Schwartz spaces. In particular, we will see that quantum states are equivalently characterized by their Wigner function, the characteristic of their Wigner function, and the probability distributions for a family of linear combinations of position and momentum. Physically, the latter can be understood as the evolution of its probability distribution in position over time under, for example, free or harmonic evolution. The result is obtained with techniques that are more accessible to a physicist audience, and shows that, at least for tomography results, the full structure of Hilbert spaces is not necessary.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether standard continuous-variable quantum tomography can be formulated entirely on Schwartz space $\mathcal S(\mathbb R)$, without invoking the Hilbert-space completion $L^2$. It considers pure states represented by normalized smooth, rapidly decaying wavefunctions and establishes their characterization, up to global phase, by Wigner functions, Weyl–Heisenberg characteristic functions, and complete families of quadrature probability distributions. The reconstruction proceeds through explicit transformations. Fourier inversion recovers the rank-one kernel $K_\psi(x,y)=\psi(x)\overline{\psi(y)}$ from the Wigner function; fixing the phase at any point where the wavefunction is nonzero then recovers $\psi$. The characteristic function $\chi_\psi(a,b)=\langle\psi|e^{i(aX+bP)/\hbar}|\psi\rangle$ is the two-dimensional Fourier transform of the Wigner function. For quadratures $X\cos\alpha+P\sin\alpha$, the Fourier transform of the measured probability density gives $\chi_\psi(s\cos\alpha,s\sin\alpha)$. Consequently, distributions for all $\alpha\in[0,\pi)$ determine the state. The argument uses Fourier-transform closure and regularity properties of Schwartz functions. The quadrature family is interpreted through position measurements during harmonic evolution, covering the required angles in finite time, or free evolution, whose full angular coverage requires unbounded times. The paper explicitly presents these as Schwartz-space versions of existing tomography results rather than new informational-completeness claims. Its scope is pure Schwartz wavefunctions, not arbitrary mixed or $L^2$ states, and it gives no finite-sample or noise-stability guarantees. It also acknowledges that positional degrees of freedom alone do not provide a general foundation for quantum theory.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalUnclear noveltyPossible error

Error found: The paper incorrectly claims that operator-exponential power series are justified on arbitrary Schwartz functions merely because all operator powers preserve Schwartz space; its translation example and exponential-conjugation justification therefore lack a valid general foundation. For the paper's definition U_alpha = exp(-i alpha A/hbar), the displayed identity U_alpha X U_alpha† = cos(alpha)X + sin(alpha)P has the wrong sign; the plus-sign formula belongs to U_alpha† X U_alpha.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
14 pages

Related papers

Probability Representation of Quantum States

Olga V. Man’ko, Vladimir I. Man’ko

The review of new formulation of conventional quantum mechanics where the quantum states are identified with probability distributions is presented. The invertible map of density operators and wave functions onto the probability distributions describing the quantum states in quantum mechanics is constructed both for systems with continuous variables and systems with discrete variables by using the Born's rule and recently suggested method of dequantizer-quantizer operators. Examples of discussed probability representations of qubits (spin-1/2, two-level atoms), harmonic oscillator and free particle are studied in detail. Schrödinger and von Neumann equations, as well as equations for the evolution of open systems, are written in the form of linear classical-like equations for the probability distributions determining the quantum system states. Relations to phase-space representation of quantum states (Wigner functions) with quantum tomography and classical mechanics are elucidated.

Entropy•Apr 29, 2021•43 citations

Quantum Tomography

S. Rajasekar, R. Velusamy

This chapter provides the relevant theory and techniques of quantum tomography. Quantum tomography aims to determine the state of the system by determining its density matrix by means of a series of measurements done on fairly a large number of identically prepared copies of the same system. Wolfgang Ernst Pauli problem asks the question whether measurements of probability densities of position and momentum of a particle determine its quantum state wave function. The chapter outlines the optical homodyne tomography technique of reconstruction of Wigner function. Polarized light wave is described by the commonly used Stokes parameters introduced by George Gabriel Stokes in 1852. Quantum process tomography (QPT) aims to give full information on the dynamics of a quantum state. QPT can be used to improve the design and control of quantum hardware. Direct characterization of quantum dynamics differs in many ways from standard quantum process tomography and ancilla-assisted process tomography.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 5, 2022•0 citations

A pedagogical presentation of aC⋆-algebraic approach to quantum tomography

Alberto Ibort, Vladimir I. Man’ko, Giuseppe Marmo +2 more

It is now well established that quantum tomography provides an alternative picture of quantum mechanics. It is common to introduce tomographic concepts starting with the Schrödinger–Dirac picture of quantum mechanics on Hilbert spaces. In this picture, states are a primary concept and observables are derived from them. On the other hand, the Heisenberg picture, which has evolved in the C ⋆ -algebraic approach to quantum mechanics, starts with the algebra of observables and introduces states as a derived concept. The equivalence between these two pictures amounts, essentially, to the Gelfand–Naimark–Segal construction. In this construction, the abstract C ⋆ -algebra is realized as an algebra of operators acting on a constructed Hilbert space. The representation that is defined may be reducible or irreducible, but in either case it allows us to identify a unitary group associated with the C ⋆ -algebra by means of its invertible elements. In this picture both states and observables are appropriate functions on the group; it also follows that quantum tomograms are strictly related with appropriate functions (positive-type) on the group. In this paper we present, using very simple examples, a tomographic description emerging from the set of ideas connected with the C ⋆ -algebra picture of quantum mechanics. In particular, we introduce the tomographic probability distributions for finite and compact groups, and formulate an autonomous criterion to recognize a given probability distribution as a tomogram of quantum state.

arXiv:1204.5231•Physica Scripta•Nov 22, 2011•22 citations

Longitudinal quantum beam tomography

David A. Kokorowski, David E. Pritchard

We propose an experiment to determine the density operator for the longitudinal quantum state of an atomic beam. The method is based on tomographic reconstruction of the Wigner function via a set of measured probability distributions for the phase-space rotated position operator. The time evolution of the Wigner function in free space effectively performs the required phase-space rotation. We propose a state-selective time-dependent technique for measuring longitudinal probability distributions.

Journal of Modern Optics•Nov 1, 1997•12 citations

Quantum computers in phase space

César Miquel, Juan Pablo Paz, Marcos Saraceno

We represent both the states and the evolution of a quantum computer in phase space using the discrete Wigner function. We study properties of the phase space representation of quantum algorithms: apart from analyzing important examples, such as the Fourier transform and Grover's search, we examine the conditions for the existence of a direct correspondence between quantum and classical evolutions in phase space. Finally, we describe how to measure directly the Wigner function in a given phase-space point by means of a tomographic method that, itself, can be interpreted as a simple quantum algorithm.

arXiv:quant-ph/0204149•Physical Review A•Jun 5, 2002•146 citations

Quantum phase space functions and relations of entropic localisation measures

Kedar S. Ranade

The concept of quantum phase space offers a view on quantum mechanics, which is different from the standard Hilbert space approach, but which more closely resembles the classical phase space. Due to the properties of quantum mechanics there are several equivalent quantum phase space descriptions, and one cannot always prefer one or another as they all have certain merits and drawbacks. For example, the Husimi-Kano Q function is a probability distribution and thus gives rise to entropic quantities, namely the Renyi-Wehrl entropies, of which several properties are known. The Wigner function, on the other hand, has an easier physical explanation, but may take negative values. In this article, we investigate entropic measures of localisation for a state in quantum phase space by using the Beckner-Brascamp-Lieb inequality to relate different phase-space functions.

arXiv:1305.7322•May 31, 2013•0 citations
In this work we show that standard results in quantum tomography, which are typically proven in the context of Hilbert spaces, can analogously be established in the theory of Schwartz spaces. In particular, we will see that quantum states are equivalently characterized by their Wigner function, the characteristic of their Wigner function, and the probability distributions for a family of linear combinations of position and momentum. Physically, the latter can be understood as the evolution of its probability distribution in position over time under, for example, free or harmonic evolution. The result is obtained with techniques that are more accessible to a physicist audience, and shows that, at least for tomography results, the full structure of Hilbert spaces is not necessary.
The paper asks whether standard continuous-variable quantum tomography can be formulated entirely on Schwartz space S(R)\mathcal S(\mathbb R)S(R), without invoking the Hilbert-space completion L2L^2L2. It considers pure states represented by normalized smooth, rapidly decaying wavefunctions and establishes their characterization, up to global phase, by Wigner functions, Weyl–Heisenberg characteristic functions, and complete families of quadrature probability distributions.
The reconstruction proceeds through explicit transformations. Fourier inversion recovers the rank-one kernel Kψ(x,y)=ψ(x)ψ(y)‾K_\psi(x,y)=\psi(x)\overline{\psi(y)}Kψ​(x,y)=ψ(x)ψ(y)​ from the Wigner function; fixing the phase at any point where the wavefunction is nonzero then recovers ψ\psiψ. The characteristic function χψ(a,b)=⟨ψ∣ei(aX+bP)/ℏ∣ψ⟩\chi_\psi(a,b)=\langle\psi|e^{i(aX+bP)/\hbar}|\psi\rangleχψ​(a,b)=⟨ψ∣ei(aX+bP)/ℏ∣ψ⟩ is the two-dimensional Fourier transform of the Wigner function. For quadratures Xcos⁡α+Psin⁡αX\cos\alpha+P\sin\alphaXcosα+Psinα, the Fourier transform of the measured probability density gives χψ(scos⁡α,ssin⁡α)\chi_\psi(s\cos\alpha,s\sin\alpha)χψ​(scosα,ssinα). Consequently, distributions for all α∈[0,π)\alpha\in[0,\pi)α∈[0,π) determine the state. The argument uses Fourier-transform closure and regularity properties of Schwartz functions.
The quadrature family is interpreted through position measurements during harmonic evolution, covering the required angles in finite time, or free evolution, whose full angular coverage requires unbounded times. The paper explicitly presents these as Schwartz-space versions of existing tomography results rather than new informational-completeness claims. Its scope is pure Schwartz wavefunctions, not arbitrary mixed or L2L^2L2 states, and it gives no finite-sample or noise-stability guarantees. It also acknowledges that positional degrees of freedom alone do not provide a general foundation for quantum theory.
The review of new formulation of conventional quantum mechanics where the quantum states are identified with probability distributions is presented. The invertible map of density operators and wave functions onto the probability distributions describing the quantum states in quantum mechanics is constructed both for systems with continuous variables and systems with discrete variables by using the Born's rule and recently suggested method of dequantizer-quantizer operators. Examples of discussed probability representations of qubits (spin-1/2, two-level atoms), harmonic oscillator and free particle are studied in detail. Schrödinger and von Neumann equations, as well as equations for the evolution of open systems, are written in the form of linear classical-like equations for the probability distributions determining the quantum system states. Relations to phase-space representation of quantum states (Wigner functions) with quantum tomography and classical mechanics are elucidated.
This chapter provides the relevant theory and techniques of quantum tomography. Quantum tomography aims to determine the state of the system by determining its density matrix by means of a series of measurements done on fairly a large number of identically prepared copies of the same system. Wolfgang Ernst Pauli problem asks the question whether measurements of probability densities of position and momentum of a particle determine its quantum state wave function. The chapter outlines the optical homodyne tomography technique of reconstruction of Wigner function. Polarized light wave is described by the commonly used Stokes parameters introduced by George Gabriel Stokes in 1852. Quantum process tomography (QPT) aims to give full information on the dynamics of a quantum state. QPT can be used to improve the design and control of quantum hardware. Direct characterization of quantum dynamics differs in many ways from standard quantum process tomography and ancilla-assisted process tomography.
It is now well established that quantum tomography provides an alternative picture of quantum mechanics. It is common to introduce tomographic concepts starting with the Schrödinger–Dirac picture of quantum mechanics on Hilbert spaces. In this picture, states are a primary concept and observables are derived from them. On the other hand, the Heisenberg picture, which has evolved in the C ⋆ -algebraic approach to quantum mechanics, starts with the algebra of observables and introduces states as a derived concept. The equivalence between these two pictures amounts, essentially, to the Gelfand–Naimark–Segal construction. In this construction, the abstract C ⋆ -algebra is realized as an algebra of operators acting on a constructed Hilbert space. The representation that is defined may be reducible or irreducible, but in either case it allows us to identify a unitary group associated with the C ⋆ -algebra by means of its invertible elements. In this picture both states and observables are appropriate functions on the group; it also follows that quantum tomograms are strictly related with appropriate functions (positive-type) on the group. In this paper we present, using very simple examples, a tomographic description emerging from the set of ideas connected with the C ⋆ -algebra picture of quantum mechanics. In particular, we introduce the tomographic probability distributions for finite and compact groups, and formulate an autonomous criterion to recognize a given probability distribution as a tomogram of quantum state.
We represent both the states and the evolution of a quantum computer in phase space using the discrete Wigner function. We study properties of the phase space representation of quantum algorithms: apart from analyzing important examples, such as the Fourier transform and Grover's search, we examine the conditions for the existence of a direct correspondence between quantum and classical evolutions in phase space. Finally, we describe how to measure directly the Wigner function in a given phase-space point by means of a tomographic method that, itself, can be interpreted as a simple quantum algorithm.
The concept of quantum phase space offers a view on quantum mechanics, which is different from the standard Hilbert space approach, but which more closely resembles the classical phase space. Due to the properties of quantum mechanics there are several equivalent quantum phase space descriptions, and one cannot always prefer one or another as they all have certain merits and drawbacks. For example, the Husimi-Kano Q function is a probability distribution and thus gives rise to entropic quantities, namely the Renyi-Wehrl entropies, of which several properties are known. The Wigner function, on the other hand, has an easier physical explanation, but may take negative values. In this article, we investigate entropic measures of localisation for a state in quantum phase space by using the Beckner-Brascamp-Lieb inequality to relate different phase-space functions.