Operational Identity under Boosts - Classical Transparency and a Reduced-Spin Accessibility Tax
Paul Cooney
This paper investigates whether relativistic motion imposes an intrinsic cost on certifying a system’s identity. Identity refers here to internal physical parameters, such as a spectroscopic splitting, composition marker, or spin orientation, rather than to Poincaré-invariant labels such as mass and total spin. The central result is that a fixed Lorentz boost does not destroy identity information. A fixed, parameter-independent boost acts unitarily on the complete physical state, so the global quantum Fisher information associated with an internal parameter is exactly preserved. Any apparent loss of identity information must therefore arise from restricted measurements, finite detector resources, discarded degrees of freedom, incomplete knowledge of the boost, or averaging over transformations that are not recorded. The paper develops this conclusion through classical spectroscopy, relativistic flyby estimation, photon frequency encoding, and massive spin-momentum systems. Classical spectral identity A Doppler transformation uniformly rescales the line center, line width, and internal splitting of a spectrum. For a spectral doublet, the dimensionless ratio between the splitting and the line center remains unchanged. The per-photon Fisher information about the rest-frame splitting is therefore invariant under an ideal Doppler dilation. Relativistic motion can still change the total information collected because photon number, detector resolution, observing duration, and spectral bandwidth depend on the measurement protocol. The paper compares three detector classes: An ideal spectrometer with unlimited bandwidth A spectrometer with fixed observer-frame resolution A resolution-limited detector with a finite observing band These detectors produce different information-versus-velocity laws. Relativity therefore does not impose a universal identity-collapse exponent independently of the detector and resource convention. Relativistic flyby self-calibration The paper considers a source undergoing a relativistic flyby with unknown velocity, impact parameter, time of closest approach, source amplitude, rest transition frequency, and spectral splitting. The changing line-of-sight velocity generates a Doppler chirp. The same photons can therefore constrain both the trajectory and the source’s internal identity. For a symmetric doublet observed over a window that samples both sides of the encounter, the variance penalty from marginalizing over the unknown trajectory has the form variance inflation = 1 + O[(Δ/ν₀)²], where Δ is the rest-frame splitting and ν₀ is the central rest frequency. The trajectory is determined primarily through the much larger frequency scale ν₀, while the identity parameter is encoded in the smaller separation Δ. For the numerical examples studied, this produces a Fisher-information hierarchy of approximately one million and a trajectory-marginalization penalty below approximately 0.1 percent. The result remains valid when the rest transition frequency is treated as unknown. Two mechanisms make self-calibration possible. First, the ratio of the early and late Doppler asymptotes constrains the source velocity without requiring an external frequency reference. Second, changing the central frequency translates both spectral lines together, while changing the splitting moves them symmetrically apart. For a symmetric doublet, these score directions are approximately orthogonal. The self-calibration result is conditional on adequate signal strength, a resolved spectral structure, a sufficiently long observing window, and a nonsingular nuisance-parameter Fisher matrix. Retarded-time flyby calculation The paper explicitly includes the retarded relation between emission time and observation time. This confirms the small trajectory-marginalization penalty but changes the interpretation of total information accumulation. The blueshifted approach phase is compressed into a short interval of observer time. As a result, an ideal detector can collect less total information at higher velocity, while a resolution-limited detector can benefit when blueshift moves the doublet above its instrumental resolution floor. Whether relativistic motion helps or hinders estimation is therefore protocol-dependent. Quantum frequency encoding For a single photon whose identity parameter is encoded in its frequency wavefunction, a collinear Lorentz boost acts as a unitary frequency dilation. The global quantum Fisher information about the encoded parameter is exactly invariant. This result applies to the complete frequency state. It does not imply that every reduced photonic measurement remains invariant, particularly when momentum and polarization are coupled or when the detector accesses only a restricted measurement algebra. Massive carriers and reduced-spin accessibility For a massive spin-1/2 carrier, a Lorentz boost generates momentum-dependent Wigner rotations. The complete spin-momentum state preserves its global quantum Fisher information. However, a detector that measures spin while ignoring momentum accesses only the reduced spin state. Tracing over momentum can therefore reduce the spin-only quantum Fisher information. For canonical Wigner spin, a narrow isotropic Gaussian momentum packet, and the spin-angle encoding studied in the paper, the leading fractional accessibility loss is proportional to [2/(1 + cos²θ)] × (σₚ/mc)² × tanh²(ξ/2), where θ is the encoding angle, σₚ is the momentum spread, m is the carrier mass, and ξ is the boost rapidity. The accessibility tax has three important properties. It depends on the spin-encoding direction. It increases with momentum spread. It saturates at high rapidity because tanh²(ξ/2) approaches one. The reduced-spin information loss therefore does not grow without bound as the relative velocity approaches the speed of light. The missing information is recoverable in principle. It has been transferred into momentum dependence and spin-momentum correlations. A joint measurement of spin and momentum restores access to the invariant global information. The effect is therefore a subsystem-accessibility cost, not an irreversible destruction of identity. Localization and action-count scaling For a minimum-uncertainty wave packet, σₓσₚ = ℏ/2. The Compton wavelength is λ_C = ℏ/(mc). Using the localization scale R = σₓ, the rest-frame action-count is Ξ = ER/(ℏc) = mcσₓ/ℏ = σₓ/λ_C. At large rapidity, the reduced-spin accessibility tax scales as Ξ⁻², with an additional factor determined by the spin-encoding angle. A carrier localized over a distance much larger than its Compton wavelength therefore pays a negligible reduced-spin accessibility cost. For packets that do not saturate the uncertainty relation, the same argument gives a bound rather than an equality. Energy and identity information The paper asks whether the kinetic energy required to match the source frame can be interpreted as the price of recovering identity information. Three arguments reject a universal proportionality. First, frame-matching energy grows without bound with the Lorentz factor, while the reduced-spin accessibility loss saturates. Second, frame matching is not necessary. Classical Doppler self-calibration can recover a spectral identity parameter without accelerating the detector into the source frame. In the quantum case, expanding the measured algebra to include momentum can recover the lost spin-only information. Third, kinetic energy invested in frame matching can in principle be recovered by later deceleration, while the acquired measurement record remains. Energy constrains storage capacity, evolution speed, and thermodynamic reset costs, but the paper finds no universal energy price per unit of Fisher information acquired. Main conclusions The paper establishes that: Fixed, parameter-independent Lorentz boosts preserve global quantum Fisher information. Per-photon spectral identity information is invariant under ideal Doppler dilation. Total information remains detector- and protocol-dependent. Relativistic flyby chirps can self-calibrate unknown source kinematics. Trajectory marginalization produces only a small identity-estimation penalty for well-resolved symmetric doublets. Reduced-spin measurements can lose access to information through momentum-dependent Wigner rotations. The reduced-spin accessibility tax depends on encoding angle and saturates with rapidity. Joint spin-momentum measurements restore the invariant global information. For minimum-uncertainty packets, the reduced-spin tax scales as Ξ⁻². No universal proportionality exists between frame-matching energy and identity information. Scope The global invariance theorem applies to fixed Lorentz transformations that do not depend on the identity parameter. The paper does not analyze unknown boosts as joint quantum-estimation parameters or random boost distributions that are averaged without being recorded. The reduced-spin result is derived for a single massive spin-1/2 carrier, canonical Wigner spin, a narrow isotropic Gaussian momentum packet, and a momentum-insensitive spin measurement. Broad or anisotropic packets, composite carriers, alternative relativistic spin observables, generic reduced photonic channels, and sequential non-collinear boosts remain open extensions. The classical flyby conclusions apply to high-signal, sufficiently resolved, symmetric spectral doublets observed over an adequate time window. Relation to the companion paper The companion paper examines the accelerated rather than inertial case: Action-Count, Observer Integrity, and Horizon Saturation: A Unified Framework from Ξ = ER/(ℏc)https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19599288 Together, the two papers distinguish the operational effects of velocity and acceleration. Uniform velocity preserves global identity information but can redistribut
•Jul 13, 2026•0 citations