Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.13589

Decoder- and Noise-Aware Optimization Framework for Clifford-Deformed Quantum Error-Correcting Codes

Julius Rye Bønnelykke, Benjamin Joecker, Peter Krogstrup, Vincent Philippe Michal, Mark Kamper Svendsen

quant-phSubmitted Oct 9, 2026• Announced Oct 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Practical fault-tolerant quantum computing requires qubit-efficient quantum error correction (QEC). Clifford deformations (CDs) modify the stabilizers of a QEC code to lower its logical error rate at no additional resource cost. However, the number of possible CDs grows exponentially with the number of qubits, making exhaustive search infeasible beyond small codes. In this work, we further show that under circuit level noise the optimal CD depends strongly on both the noise model and decoder. To make systematic CD optimization possible, we introduce Evolution-Based Best-arm Identification (EBBI), a shot-efficient search algorithm that treats the circuit, noise model and decoder as a black box. We benchmark EBBI's performance on the rotated surface code, under two strongly $Z$-biased circuit-level noise models with the PyMatching decoder. At distance 3, EBBI finds the optimal CD using up to $\sim 1100\times$ fewer shots than random search. At distance 5, when run at the target error rate, the median EBBI run converges to the CDs we believe to be optimal, while random search never converges. Under a $Z$-biased SI1000-like noise model, EBBI discovers a new CD, the B-XZZX code, which we generalized to larger distances. It differs from XZZX on only a fraction $\mathcal{O}(d^{-1})$ of the qubits at code distance $d$, yet its relative advantage grows from $\approx 5\%$ at $d = 3$ to $\approx 12\%$ at $d = 11$. We thus show that the B-XZZX pattern found by EBBI can be systematically scaled to larger code distances. Our work represents a first step towards scalable CD optimization for general QEC codes.

Related papers

Computationally Efficient Optimization of Per-Qubit Clifford Deformation for Non-uniform Biased Noise

Won Joon Yun, Andrew Nemec, Jonathan M. Baker

In fault-tolerant quantum computing systems with biased noise, Clifford deformation can substantially reduce the logical error rate (LER) without additional physical hardware overhead, such as extra qubits, syndrome extraction rounds, or code distance. Although Google Willow calibration data shows that $43\%$ of qubits exhibit strong $X/Z$ bias, existing calibration-aware deformation techniques remain impractical: (1) global searches over the $6^n$ deformation choices rely on computing-intensive simulations, and (2) local heuristics often underperform undeformed baselines. We present Chameleon, a fast, high-performance, and code-agnostic Clifford deformation compiler. We utilize our approximation to tackle a deformation problem based on an analytical bound on the LER. By minimizing this surrogate, Chameleon finds an optimized deformation that empirically reduces the LER with substantially lower computational overhead. In our evaluation, using calibration models derived from real superconducting devices, Chameleon demonstrates that improvements in our surrogate are strongly correlated with actual LER reductions, with an average rank correlation of $ρ=0.8$ and $ρ=0.89$-$0.94$ on the most strongly biased system. It also reduces classical computational time from $1.2$ days to $3.1$ minutes for the BB72 code. Chameleon achieves maximum LER reductions of $19\%$ ($13\%$ on average) for surface codes, $16\%$ ($7\%$) for color codes, and $10\%$ ($4\%$) for bivariate bicycle codes relative to competing baselines. The maximum gains for all code families are observed on the most strongly biased system.

quant-pharXiv:2608.17870•Aug 19, 2026•0 citations

Clifford-Deformed Compass Codes

Julie Campos, Kenneth R. Brown

We can design efficient quantum error-correcting (QEC) codes by tailoring them to our choice of quantum architecture. Useful tools for constructing such codes include Clifford deformations and appropriate gauge fixings of compass codes. In this work, we find Clifford deformations that can be applied to elongated compass codes resulting in QEC codes with improved performance under noise models with errors biased towards dephasing commonly seen in quantum computing architectures. These Clifford deformations enhance decoder performance by introducing symmetries, while the stabilizers of compass codes can be selected to obtain more information on high-rate errors. As a result, the codes exhibit thresholds that increase with bias and lower logical error rates under both code capacity and phenomenological noise models. One of the Clifford deformations we explore yields QEC codes with better thresholds and logical error rates than those of the XZZX surface code at moderate biases under code capacity noise.

arXiv:2412.03808•Quantum•Apr 16, 2026•0 citations

Optimizing bias-tailored quantum error correction beyond code-capacity noise

César Benito, I. Jesán Velázquez-Reséndiz, Alejandro Bermudez

We find that the substantial advantages predicted for bias-tailored quantum error correction (QEC) under code-capacity noise are strongly reduced once realistic syndrome extraction and circuit-level noise models are considered. We start by comparing XZZX codes to rectangular surface codes with a bias-dependent optimised anisotropy. Although code-capacity simulations predict an advantage of rectangular surface codes in the limit of high noise bias, this actually disappears under circuit-level noise, making the XZZX codes the preferred and simplest choice even for platforms that allow for a flexible variation of the code layout adapted to changes in noise calibration. Our results identify bias degradation during syndrome extraction under circuit-level noise as the central limitation of biased-tailored QEC. To partially mitigate this effect, we introduce a bias-filtering CNOT gadget that temporarily encodes the ancillary target qubit during syndrome extraction in a repetition code and, upon measurement and feed forward, manages to reduce the bias degradation. In a regime of high-bias and low-idle errors, this bias-filtering gadget yields a few-percent relative improvement of the XZZX code error threshold, demonstrating that lightweight bias-filtering strategies can recover part of the lost bias-tailoring advantage for realistic circuit-level noise.

quant-pharXiv:2606.17709•Jun 17, 2026•0 citations

Error Mitigation of Fault-Tolerant Quantum Circuits with Soft Information

Zeyuan Zhou, Shaun Pexton, Aleksander Kubica +1 more

Quantum error mitigation (QEM) is typically viewed as a suite of practical techniques for today's noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, with limited relevance once fault-tolerant quantum computers become available. In this work, we challenge this conventional wisdom by showing that QEM can continue to provide substantial benefits in the era of quantum error correction (QEC), and in an even more efficient manner than it does on current devices. We introduce a framework for logical-level QEM that leverages soft information naturally produced by QEC decoders, requiring no additional data, hardware modifications, or runtime overhead beyond what QEC protocols already provide. Within this framework, we develop and analyze three logical-level QEM techniques: post-selection and runtime abort policies, probabilistic error cancellation, and zero-noise extrapolation. Our techniques reduce logical error rates by more than 100x while discarding fewer than 0.1% of shots; they also provide in situ characterization of logical channels for QEM protocols. As a proof of principle, we benchmark our approach using a surface-code architecture and two state-of-the-art decoders based on tensor-network contraction and minimum-weight perfect matching. We evaluate logical-level QEM on random Clifford circuits and molecular simulation algorithms and find that, compared to previous approaches relying on QEC only or QEC combined with QEM, we can achieve up to 87.4% spacetime overhead savings. Our results demonstrate that logical-level QEM with QEC decoder soft information can reliably improve logical performance, underscoring the efficiency and usefulness of QEM techniques for fault-tolerant quantum computers.

quant-pharXiv:2512.09863•Dec 11, 2025•0 citations

Clifford-deformed zero-rate LDPC codes with 50% biased noise thresholds

Jagannath Das, Sayandip Dhara, Pedro Medina +2 more

Applying single-qubit Clifford unitaries to a Pauli stabilizer code produces a Clifford-deformed variant whose stabilizers remain Pauli operators, but with locally rotated Pauli axes. Such deformations provide a simple way to tailor a fixed code to anisotropic noise, and have enabled unusually high thresholds under strongly biased dephasing. In this work, we discuss zero-rate quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, for which there exist Clifford-deformed variants where the number of biased logical operators scales slower than the distance, or there exists a basis of logical operators whose overlap satisfies certain scaling conditions; in this case, the code-capacity threshold for the Clifford-deformed variant under i.i.d. pure dephasing noise approaches 50%. This property provably explains previously known code examples with 50% biased noise thresholds, such as XY surface code, XZZX surface code, color code, as well as some 3D Clifford-deformed codes. As a concrete new example, we study Clifford deformations of the tile codes of Ref. [1]. Similar to the phase diagram of 50% thresholds for random Clifford deformations of the surface code in Ref. [2], we find a similar phase diagram for the tile codes. We also construct several translationally invariant deformations of the tile code with 50% thresholds, and present numerical evidence for improved performance at finite bias and under circuit-level noise. In the circuit-level setting, performance is governed by the residual bias after a full syndrome-extraction cycle, linking our simulations to phenomenological models commonly used to study Clifford-deformed codes. We estimate this residual bias for different qubit platforms by modeling microscopic implementations of tile-code syndrome extraction.

quant-pharXiv:2605.15348•May 18, 2026•0 citations

Tailored XZZX codes for biased noise

Qian Xu, Nam Mannucci, Alireza Seif +3 more

Quantum error correction (QEC) for generic errors is challenging due to the demanding threshold and resource requirements. Interestingly, when physical noise is biased, we can tailor our QEC schemes to the noise to improve performance. Here we study a family of codes having XZZX-type stabilizer generators, including a set of cyclic codes generalized from the five-qubit code and a set of topological codes that we call generalized toric codes (GTCs). We show that these XZZX codes are highly qubit efficient if tailored to biased noise. To characterize the code performance, we use the notion of effective distance, which generalizes code distance to the case of biased noise and constitutes a proxy for the logical failure rate. We find that the XZZX codes can achieve a favorable resource scaling by this metric under biased noise. We also show that the XZZX codes have remarkably high thresholds that reach what is achievable by random codes, and furthermore they can be efficiently decoded using matching decoders. Finally, by adding only one flag qubit, the XZZX codes can realize fault-tolerant QEC while preserving their large effective distance. In combination, our results show that tailored XZZX codes give a resource-efficient scheme for fault-tolerant QEC against biased noise.

arXiv:2203.16486•Physical Review Research•Jan 23, 2023•38 citations
Practical fault-tolerant quantum computing requires qubit-efficient quantum error correction (QEC). Clifford deformations (CDs) modify the stabilizers of a QEC code to lower its logical error rate at no additional resource cost. However, the number of possible CDs grows exponentially with the number of qubits, making exhaustive search infeasible beyond small codes. In this work, we further show that under circuit level noise the optimal CD depends strongly on both the noise model and decoder. To make systematic CD optimization possible, we introduce Evolution-Based Best-arm Identification (EBBI), a shot-efficient search algorithm that treats the circuit, noise model and decoder as a black box. We benchmark EBBI's performance on the rotated surface code, under two strongly ZZZ-biased circuit-level noise models with the PyMatching decoder. At distance 3, EBBI finds the optimal CD using up to ∼1100×\sim 1100\times∼1100× fewer shots than random search. At distance 5, when run at the target error rate, the median EBBI run converges to the CDs we believe to be optimal, while random search never converges. Under a ZZZ-biased SI1000-like noise model, EBBI discovers a new CD, the B-XZZX code, which we generalized to larger distances. It differs from XZZX on only a fraction O(d−1)\mathcal{O}(d^{-1})O(d−1) of the qubits at code distance ddd, yet its relative advantage grows from ≈5%\approx 5\%≈5% at d=3d = 3d=3 to ≈12%\approx 12\%≈12% at d=11d = 11d=11. We thus show that the B-XZZX pattern found by EBBI can be systematically scaled to larger code distances. Our work represents a first step towards scalable CD optimization for general QEC codes.
In fault-tolerant quantum computing systems with biased noise, Clifford deformation can substantially reduce the logical error rate (LER) without additional physical hardware overhead, such as extra qubits, syndrome extraction rounds, or code distance. Although Google Willow calibration data shows that 43%43\%43% of qubits exhibit strong X/ZX/ZX/Z bias, existing calibration-aware deformation techniques remain impractical: (1) global searches over the 6n6^n6n deformation choices rely on computing-intensive simulations, and (2) local heuristics often underperform undeformed baselines. We present Chameleon, a fast, high-performance, and code-agnostic Clifford deformation compiler. We utilize our approximation to tackle a deformation problem based on an analytical bound on the LER. By minimizing this surrogate, Chameleon finds an optimized deformation that empirically reduces the LER with substantially lower computational overhead. In our evaluation, using calibration models derived from real superconducting devices, Chameleon demonstrates that improvements in our surrogate are strongly correlated with actual LER reductions, with an average rank correlation of ρ=0.8ρ=0.8ρ=0.8 and ρ=0.89ρ=0.89ρ=0.89-0.940.940.94 on the most strongly biased system. It also reduces classical computational time from 1.21.21.2 days to 3.13.13.1 minutes for the BB72 code. Chameleon achieves maximum LER reductions of 19%19\%19% (13%13\%13% on average) for surface codes, 16%16\%16% (7%7\%7%) for color codes, and 10%10\%10% (4%4\%4%) for bivariate bicycle codes relative to competing baselines. The maximum gains for all code families are observed on the most strongly biased system.
We can design efficient quantum error-correcting (QEC) codes by tailoring them to our choice of quantum architecture. Useful tools for constructing such codes include Clifford deformations and appropriate gauge fixings of compass codes. In this work, we find Clifford deformations that can be applied to elongated compass codes resulting in QEC codes with improved performance under noise models with errors biased towards dephasing commonly seen in quantum computing architectures. These Clifford deformations enhance decoder performance by introducing symmetries, while the stabilizers of compass codes can be selected to obtain more information on high-rate errors. As a result, the codes exhibit thresholds that increase with bias and lower logical error rates under both code capacity and phenomenological noise models. One of the Clifford deformations we explore yields QEC codes with better thresholds and logical error rates than those of the XZZX surface code at moderate biases under code capacity noise.
We find that the substantial advantages predicted for bias-tailored quantum error correction (QEC) under code-capacity noise are strongly reduced once realistic syndrome extraction and circuit-level noise models are considered. We start by comparing XZZX codes to rectangular surface codes with a bias-dependent optimised anisotropy. Although code-capacity simulations predict an advantage of rectangular surface codes in the limit of high noise bias, this actually disappears under circuit-level noise, making the XZZX codes the preferred and simplest choice even for platforms that allow for a flexible variation of the code layout adapted to changes in noise calibration. Our results identify bias degradation during syndrome extraction under circuit-level noise as the central limitation of biased-tailored QEC. To partially mitigate this effect, we introduce a bias-filtering CNOT gadget that temporarily encodes the ancillary target qubit during syndrome extraction in a repetition code and, upon measurement and feed forward, manages to reduce the bias degradation. In a regime of high-bias and low-idle errors, this bias-filtering gadget yields a few-percent relative improvement of the XZZX code error threshold, demonstrating that lightweight bias-filtering strategies can recover part of the lost bias-tailoring advantage for realistic circuit-level noise.
Quantum error mitigation (QEM) is typically viewed as a suite of practical techniques for today's noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, with limited relevance once fault-tolerant quantum computers become available. In this work, we challenge this conventional wisdom by showing that QEM can continue to provide substantial benefits in the era of quantum error correction (QEC), and in an even more efficient manner than it does on current devices. We introduce a framework for logical-level QEM that leverages soft information naturally produced by QEC decoders, requiring no additional data, hardware modifications, or runtime overhead beyond what QEC protocols already provide. Within this framework, we develop and analyze three logical-level QEM techniques: post-selection and runtime abort policies, probabilistic error cancellation, and zero-noise extrapolation. Our techniques reduce logical error rates by more than 100x while discarding fewer than 0.1% of shots; they also provide in situ characterization of logical channels for QEM protocols. As a proof of principle, we benchmark our approach using a surface-code architecture and two state-of-the-art decoders based on tensor-network contraction and minimum-weight perfect matching. We evaluate logical-level QEM on random Clifford circuits and molecular simulation algorithms and find that, compared to previous approaches relying on QEC only or QEC combined with QEM, we can achieve up to 87.4% spacetime overhead savings. Our results demonstrate that logical-level QEM with QEC decoder soft information can reliably improve logical performance, underscoring the efficiency and usefulness of QEM techniques for fault-tolerant quantum computers.
Applying single-qubit Clifford unitaries to a Pauli stabilizer code produces a Clifford-deformed variant whose stabilizers remain Pauli operators, but with locally rotated Pauli axes. Such deformations provide a simple way to tailor a fixed code to anisotropic noise, and have enabled unusually high thresholds under strongly biased dephasing. In this work, we discuss zero-rate quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, for which there exist Clifford-deformed variants where the number of biased logical operators scales slower than the distance, or there exists a basis of logical operators whose overlap satisfies certain scaling conditions; in this case, the code-capacity threshold for the Clifford-deformed variant under i.i.d. pure dephasing noise approaches 50%. This property provably explains previously known code examples with 50% biased noise thresholds, such as XY surface code, XZZX surface code, color code, as well as some 3D Clifford-deformed codes. As a concrete new example, we study Clifford deformations of the tile codes of Ref. [1]. Similar to the phase diagram of 50% thresholds for random Clifford deformations of the surface code in Ref. [2], we find a similar phase diagram for the tile codes. We also construct several translationally invariant deformations of the tile code with 50% thresholds, and present numerical evidence for improved performance at finite bias and under circuit-level noise. In the circuit-level setting, performance is governed by the residual bias after a full syndrome-extraction cycle, linking our simulations to phenomenological models commonly used to study Clifford-deformed codes. We estimate this residual bias for different qubit platforms by modeling microscopic implementations of tile-code syndrome extraction.
Quantum error correction (QEC) for generic errors is challenging due to the demanding threshold and resource requirements. Interestingly, when physical noise is biased, we can tailor our QEC schemes to the noise to improve performance. Here we study a family of codes having XZZX-type stabilizer generators, including a set of cyclic codes generalized from the five-qubit code and a set of topological codes that we call generalized toric codes (GTCs). We show that these XZZX codes are highly qubit efficient if tailored to biased noise. To characterize the code performance, we use the notion of effective distance, which generalizes code distance to the case of biased noise and constitutes a proxy for the logical failure rate. We find that the XZZX codes can achieve a favorable resource scaling by this metric under biased noise. We also show that the XZZX codes have remarkably high thresholds that reach what is achievable by random codes, and furthermore they can be efficiently decoded using matching decoders. Finally, by adding only one flag qubit, the XZZX codes can realize fault-tolerant QEC while preserving their large effective distance. In combination, our results show that tailored XZZX codes give a resource-efficient scheme for fault-tolerant QEC against biased noise.