Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.10040

Can we make sense out of negative kinetic energy?

Alessio Maiezza, Fabrizio Nesti

quant-phhep-thSubmitted Oct 7, 2026• Announced Oct 8, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many Quantum Field Theory models, either designed to improve the ultraviolet behavior via higher derivative terms or aimed at providing unified descriptions of Gravity, inevitably introduce negative-energy 'ghosts' states. These states raise fundamental questions regarding the stability of the theory. In this study, we investigate the time evolution of simplified quantum mechanical models consisting of two coupled normal and ghost subsystems. Although the full spectrum of these models is unbounded from below and, therefore, lacks a true ground state, we focus the time evolution of a 'would-be ground state': a zero-energy eigenstate of the decoupled system. By analyzing its metastability under interactions, we gain insights into the dynamics of ghost-like states. Contrary to the standard paradigm, our results demonstrate that, across a broad range of couplings, the would-be ground state does not decay and remains dynamically stable over long times. This provides evidence towards resolving the stability problems of Hamiltonians that are unbounded from below. We also discuss the connections with the corresponding classical and semiclassical dynamics.

AI Summary

Does coupling positive- and negative-energy degrees of freedom necessarily destabilize a quantum state? This paper studies $H=H_1-H_2+V$ for two harmonic oscillators with $\omega_1=1$, $\omega_2=\sqrt{2}$, starting from the product oscillator vacuum. The interactions are $V=(\lambda/2)x^2y^2e^{-(x^2+y^2)}$ and $V=(\lambda/2)x^2y^2$. The observable is the survival probability $P(t)=|\langle0,0|e^{-iHt}|0,0\rangle|^2$, supplemented by subsystem energies and probability currents. Formal perturbation expansions and cutoff-dependent numerical diagonalization are used, with spatial discretization and, for the quartic interaction, truncation in the oscillator basis. At weak coupling, the initial state predominantly overlaps one interacting eigenstate, and the computed survival probability exhibits persistent oscillations rather than complete decay within numerically reliable times. For the quartic interaction, an empirical envelope is $P(t)\gtrsim10^{-0.085\lambda^2-0.9\lambda^3}$ for $\lambda<0.15$. For the bounded interaction, survival remains approximately above $50\%$ for $\lambda\leq30$. Subsystem energies likewise oscillate without observed runaway in the weak-coupling regime. Excited initial states show stronger depletion; increasing the ghost frequency suppresses it. Classical simulations identify bounded-motion regions and runaway trajectories with qualitative parallels to the quantum results. The conclusions concern finite-time metastability, not proven asymptotic stability. Reliable simulation times shorten substantially at stronger coupling, and spectral counting does not rigorously establish the interacting spectral type. The two numerical regulators yield different survival curves despite apparent convergence within each scheme; this is interpreted as UV sensitivity, with predictive implications left unresolved. Extension to field-theoretic vacuum stability remains open.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The abstract's broad nondecay claim and the conclusion's survival at any later time exceed numerical evidence that establishes only finite-time persistence, most reliably at weak coupling. The two numerical regulators yield different survival probabilities beyond their estimated cutoff errors, leaving the claimed regulator-independent physical dynamics unresolved. Growing eigenvalue density in finite truncations does not establish the claimed dense point spectrum of the interacting infinite-dimensional Hamiltonian. For the specified quartic interaction and initial oscillator vacuum, the exact short-time survival coefficient is lambda^2/16, whereas the paper reports approximately 14 lambda^2. The printed finite-difference stencil already approximates minus one-half of the second derivative, so applying the subsequent kinetic prefactor yields the wrong kinetic operator as written, although the implemented operator is unknown.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
33 pages, 22 figure

Related papers

Unitary Time Evolution and Vacuum for a Quantum Stable Ghost

Cédric Deffayet, Atabak Fathe Jalali, Aaron Held +2 more

We quantize a classically stable system of a harmonic oscillator polynomially coupled to a ghost with negative kinetic energy. We prove that due to an integral of motion with a positive discrete spectrum: i) the Hamiltonian has a pure point spectrum unbounded in both directions, ii) the evolution is manifestly unitary, iii) the vacuum is well-defined, iv) expectation values for squares of canonical variables are bounded. Numerical solutions of the Schrödinger equation confirm these results. We argue that the discrete spectrum of the integral of motion enforces stability for extended interactions.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2604.21823•Apr 24, 2026

Theory of Metastable States in Many-Body Quantum Systems

Chao Yin, Federica Maria Surace, Andrew Lucas

We present a mathematical theory of metastable pure states in closed many-body quantum systems with finite-dimensional Hilbert space. Given a Hamiltonian, a pure state is defined to be metastable when all sufficiently local operators either stabilize the state or raise its average energy. We prove that short-range-entangled metastable states are necessarily eigenstates (scars) of a perturbatively close Hamiltonian. Given any metastable eigenstate of a Hamiltonian, in the presence of perturbations, we prove the presence of prethermal behavior: Local correlation functions decay at a rate bounded by a timescale nonperturbatively long in the inverse metastability radius, rather than Fermi’s golden rule. Inspired by this general theory, we prove that the lifetime of the false vacuum in certain d -dimensional quantum models grows at least as fast as exp ( ε − d ) , where ε → 0 is the relative energy density of the false vacuum; this lower bound matches, for the first time, explicit calculations using quantum field theory. We identify metastable states at finite energy density in the PXP model, along with exponentially many metastable states in “helical” spin chains and the two-dimensional Ising model. Our inherently quantum formalism reveals precise connections between many problems, including prethermalization, robust quantum scars, and quantum nucleation theory, and applies to systems without known semiclassical and/or field-theoretic limits.

arXiv:2408.05261•Physical Review X•Mar 19, 2025•27 citations

Ghosts versus Unstable Particles in Quantum Field Theory

Luca Buoninfante

We elucidate the physical nature of ghosts above the multi-particle threshold by contrasting them with unstable particles in quantum field theory. We first consider the asymptotic formulation, where ordinary positive-norm one-particle states can be unstable and decay, whereas ghosts survive asymptotically without decaying, yet admit no particle interpretation due to interference with the multi-particle component which masks the negative-norm one-particle state. This distinction originates from two different analytic structures of the dressed propagator, whose complex conjugate poles lie on the first or second Riemann sheet in the ghost or ordinary case, respectively. Ghost resonances are, in principle, phenomenologically distinguishable from ordinary ones, being narrower and exhibiting weaker interference between positive- and negative-energy peaks. We then formulate the quantum field theory in a finite interval of time and, working within a suitable approximation for the dressed propagator, find that finite-time effects amplify differences in the resonant behavior and give rise to new features, such as higher peaks in ghost resonances. Distinct temporal regimes are also identified: for times shorter than the inverse width, an approximate free-particle description is valid; at later times interactions and interference dominate, leading to decay or multi-particle masking. This study supports the absence of freely propagating ghost particles in the asymptotic limit.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2606.18349•Jun 18, 2026

Antilinear symmetry and the ghost problem in quantum field theory

Philip D. Mannheim

Abstract The recognition that the eigenvalues of a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian could all be real if the Hamiltonian had an antilinear symmetry such as PT stimulated new insight into the underlying structure of quantum mechanics. Specifically, it led to the realization that Hilbert space could be richer than the established Dirac approach of constructing inner products out of ket vectors and their Hermitian conjugate bra vectors. With antilinear symmetry one must instead build inner products out of ket vectors and their antilinear conjugates, and it is these inner products that would be time independent in the non-Hermitian but antilinearly symmetric case even as the standard Dirac inner products would not be. Moreover, and in a sense quite remarkably, antilinear symmetry could address not only the temporal behavior of the inner product but also the issue of its overall sign, with antilinear symmetry being capable of yielding a positive inner product in situations such as fourth-order derivative quantum field theories where the standard Dirac inner product is found to have ghostlike negative signature. Antilinear symmetry thus solves the ghost problem in such theories by showing that they are being formulated in the wrong Hilbert space, with antilinear symmetry providing a Hilbert space that is ghost free. Antilinear symmetry does not actually get rid of the ghost states. Rather, it shows that the reasoning that led one to think that ghosts were present in the first place is faulty. Implications of our results for constructing unitary quantum theories of gravity are presented.

arXiv:2104.03708•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Oct 1, 2021•4 citations

Quantum wall states for noise mitigation and eternal purity bounds

Miguel Casanova, Francesco Ticozzi

Abstract The present work analyzes state-stabilization techniques for decoupling a subsystem from environmental interactions. The proposed framework uses analytical and numerical tools to find an approximate decoherence-free subspace with improved passive noise isolation. Active state-stabilizing control on a subsystem mediating dominant environmental interactions, which we call the wall subsystem, creates an effective quantum wall state. The proposed method controls only the wall subsystem, leaving the logical subsystem untouched. This simplifies logic operations in the protected subsystem, and makes it suitable for integration with other quantum information protection techniques, such as dynamical decoupling (DD). We demonstrated its effectiveness in improving the performance of selective or complete DD. Under suitable conditions, our method maintains the purity of the system above a threshold for all times, achieving eternal purity preservation. Theoretical analysis links this behavior to the asymptotic spectrum of the Hamiltonian when the control gain grows unbounded.

arXiv:2507.07944•Quantum Science and Technology•Oct 28, 2025•0 citations

Completely quantized collapse and consequences

Philip Pearle

Promotion of quantum theory from a theory of measurement to a theory of reality requires an unambiguous specification of the ensemble of realizable states (and each state's probability of realization). Although not yet achieved within the framework of standard quantum theory, it has been achieved within the framework of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) wave-function collapse model. In CSL, a classical random field $w(\mathbf{x},t)$ interacts with quantum particles. The state vector corresponding to each $w(\mathbf{x},t)$ is a realizable state. In this paper, I consider a previously presented model, which is predictively equivalent to CSL. In this completely quantized collapse (CQC) model, the classical random field is quantized. It is represented by the operator $W(\mathbf{x},t)$ which satisfies $[W(\mathbf{x},t),W({\mathbf{x}}^{\ensuremath{'}},{t}^{\ensuremath{'}})]=0$. The ensemble of realizable states is described by a single state vector, the ``ensemble vector.'' Each superposed state which comprises the ensemble vector at time $t$ is the direct product of an eigenstate of $W(\mathbf{x},{t}^{\ensuremath{'}})$, for all $\mathbf{x}$ and for $0\ensuremath{\leqslant}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{\leqslant}t$, and the CSL state corresponding to that eigenvalue. These states never interfere (they satisfy a superselection rule at any time), they only branch, so the ensemble vector may be considered to be, as Schr\"odinger put it, a ``catalog'' of the realizable states. In this context, many different interpretations (e.g., many worlds, environmental decoherence, consistent histories, modal interpretation) may be satisfactorily applied. Using this description, a long-standing problem is resolved, where the energy comes from the particles gain due to the narrowing of their wave packets by the collapse mechanism. It is shown how to define the energy of the random field and its energy of interaction with particles so that total energy is conserved for the ensemble of realizable states. As a by-product, since the random-field energy spectrum is unbounded, its canonical conjugate, a self-adjoint time operator, can be discussed. Finally, CSL is a phenomenological description, whose connection to, or derivation from, more conventional physics has not yet appeared. We suggest that, because CQC is fully quantized, it is a natural framework for replacement of the classical field $w(\mathbf{x},t)$ of CSL by a quantized physical entity. Two illustrative examples are given.

arXiv:quant-ph/0506177•Physical Review A•Aug 29, 2005•61 citations
Many Quantum Field Theory models, either designed to improve the ultraviolet behavior via higher derivative terms or aimed at providing unified descriptions of Gravity, inevitably introduce negative-energy 'ghosts' states. These states raise fundamental questions regarding the stability of the theory. In this study, we investigate the time evolution of simplified quantum mechanical models consisting of two coupled normal and ghost subsystems. Although the full spectrum of these models is unbounded from below and, therefore, lacks a true ground state, we focus the time evolution of a 'would-be ground state': a zero-energy eigenstate of the decoupled system. By analyzing its metastability under interactions, we gain insights into the dynamics of ghost-like states. Contrary to the standard paradigm, our results demonstrate that, across a broad range of couplings, the would-be ground state does not decay and remains dynamically stable over long times. This provides evidence towards resolving the stability problems of Hamiltonians that are unbounded from below. We also discuss the connections with the corresponding classical and semiclassical dynamics.
Does coupling positive- and negative-energy degrees of freedom necessarily destabilize a quantum state? This paper studies H=H1−H2+VH=H_1-H_2+VH=H1​−H2​+V for two harmonic oscillators with ω1=1\omega_1=1ω1​=1, ω2=2\omega_2=\sqrt{2}ω2​=2​, starting from the product oscillator vacuum. The interactions are V=(λ/2)x2y2e−(x2+y2)V=(\lambda/2)x^2y^2e^{-(x^2+y^2)}V=(λ/2)x2y2e−(x2+y2) and V=(λ/2)x2y2V=(\lambda/2)x^2y^2V=(λ/2)x2y2. The observable is the survival probability P(t)=∣⟨0,0∣e−iHt∣0,0⟩∣2P(t)=|\langle0,0|e^{-iHt}|0,0\rangle|^2P(t)=∣⟨0,0∣e−iHt∣0,0⟩∣2, supplemented by subsystem energies and probability currents.
Formal perturbation expansions and cutoff-dependent numerical diagonalization are used, with spatial discretization and, for the quartic interaction, truncation in the oscillator basis. At weak coupling, the initial state predominantly overlaps one interacting eigenstate, and the computed survival probability exhibits persistent oscillations rather than complete decay within numerically reliable times. For the quartic interaction, an empirical envelope is P(t)≳10−0.085λ2−0.9λ3P(t)\gtrsim10^{-0.085\lambda^2-0.9\lambda^3}P(t)≳10−0.085λ2−0.9λ3 for λ<0.15\lambda<0.15λ<0.15. For the bounded interaction, survival remains approximately above 50%50\%50% for λ≤30\lambda\leq30λ≤30. Subsystem energies likewise oscillate without observed runaway in the weak-coupling regime. Excited initial states show stronger depletion; increasing the ghost frequency suppresses it. Classical simulations identify bounded-motion regions and runaway trajectories with qualitative parallels to the quantum results.
The conclusions concern finite-time metastability, not proven asymptotic stability. Reliable simulation times shorten substantially at stronger coupling, and spectral counting does not rigorously establish the interacting spectral type. The two numerical regulators yield different survival curves despite apparent convergence within each scheme; this is interpreted as UV sensitivity, with predictive implications left unresolved. Extension to field-theoretic vacuum stability remains open.
We quantize a classically stable system of a harmonic oscillator polynomially coupled to a ghost with negative kinetic energy. We prove that due to an integral of motion with a positive discrete spectrum: i) the Hamiltonian has a pure point spectrum unbounded in both directions, ii) the evolution is manifestly unitary, iii) the vacuum is well-defined, iv) expectation values for squares of canonical variables are bounded. Numerical solutions of the Schrödinger equation confirm these results. We argue that the discrete spectrum of the integral of motion enforces stability for extended interactions.
We present a mathematical theory of metastable pure states in closed many-body quantum systems with finite-dimensional Hilbert space. Given a Hamiltonian, a pure state is defined to be metastable when all sufficiently local operators either stabilize the state or raise its average energy. We prove that short-range-entangled metastable states are necessarily eigenstates (scars) of a perturbatively close Hamiltonian. Given any metastable eigenstate of a Hamiltonian, in the presence of perturbations, we prove the presence of prethermal behavior: Local correlation functions decay at a rate bounded by a timescale nonperturbatively long in the inverse metastability radius, rather than Fermi’s golden rule. Inspired by this general theory, we prove that the lifetime of the false vacuum in certain d -dimensional quantum models grows at least as fast as exp ( ε − d ) , where ε → 0 is the relative energy density of the false vacuum; this lower bound matches, for the first time, explicit calculations using quantum field theory. We identify metastable states at finite energy density in the PXP model, along with exponentially many metastable states in “helical” spin chains and the two-dimensional Ising model. Our inherently quantum formalism reveals precise connections between many problems, including prethermalization, robust quantum scars, and quantum nucleation theory, and applies to systems without known semiclassical and/or field-theoretic limits.
We elucidate the physical nature of ghosts above the multi-particle threshold by contrasting them with unstable particles in quantum field theory. We first consider the asymptotic formulation, where ordinary positive-norm one-particle states can be unstable and decay, whereas ghosts survive asymptotically without decaying, yet admit no particle interpretation due to interference with the multi-particle component which masks the negative-norm one-particle state. This distinction originates from two different analytic structures of the dressed propagator, whose complex conjugate poles lie on the first or second Riemann sheet in the ghost or ordinary case, respectively. Ghost resonances are, in principle, phenomenologically distinguishable from ordinary ones, being narrower and exhibiting weaker interference between positive- and negative-energy peaks. We then formulate the quantum field theory in a finite interval of time and, working within a suitable approximation for the dressed propagator, find that finite-time effects amplify differences in the resonant behavior and give rise to new features, such as higher peaks in ghost resonances. Distinct temporal regimes are also identified: for times shorter than the inverse width, an approximate free-particle description is valid; at later times interactions and interference dominate, leading to decay or multi-particle masking. This study supports the absence of freely propagating ghost particles in the asymptotic limit.
Abstract The recognition that the eigenvalues of a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian could all be real if the Hamiltonian had an antilinear symmetry such as PT stimulated new insight into the underlying structure of quantum mechanics. Specifically, it led to the realization that Hilbert space could be richer than the established Dirac approach of constructing inner products out of ket vectors and their Hermitian conjugate bra vectors. With antilinear symmetry one must instead build inner products out of ket vectors and their antilinear conjugates, and it is these inner products that would be time independent in the non-Hermitian but antilinearly symmetric case even as the standard Dirac inner products would not be. Moreover, and in a sense quite remarkably, antilinear symmetry could address not only the temporal behavior of the inner product but also the issue of its overall sign, with antilinear symmetry being capable of yielding a positive inner product in situations such as fourth-order derivative quantum field theories where the standard Dirac inner product is found to have ghostlike negative signature. Antilinear symmetry thus solves the ghost problem in such theories by showing that they are being formulated in the wrong Hilbert space, with antilinear symmetry providing a Hilbert space that is ghost free. Antilinear symmetry does not actually get rid of the ghost states. Rather, it shows that the reasoning that led one to think that ghosts were present in the first place is faulty. Implications of our results for constructing unitary quantum theories of gravity are presented.
Abstract The present work analyzes state-stabilization techniques for decoupling a subsystem from environmental interactions. The proposed framework uses analytical and numerical tools to find an approximate decoherence-free subspace with improved passive noise isolation. Active state-stabilizing control on a subsystem mediating dominant environmental interactions, which we call the wall subsystem, creates an effective quantum wall state. The proposed method controls only the wall subsystem, leaving the logical subsystem untouched. This simplifies logic operations in the protected subsystem, and makes it suitable for integration with other quantum information protection techniques, such as dynamical decoupling (DD). We demonstrated its effectiveness in improving the performance of selective or complete DD. Under suitable conditions, our method maintains the purity of the system above a threshold for all times, achieving eternal purity preservation. Theoretical analysis links this behavior to the asymptotic spectrum of the Hamiltonian when the control gain grows unbounded.
Promotion of quantum theory from a theory of measurement to a theory of reality requires an unambiguous specification of the ensemble of realizable states (and each state's probability of realization). Although not yet achieved within the framework of standard quantum theory, it has been achieved within the framework of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) wave-function collapse model. In CSL, a classical random field w(x,t)w(\mathbf{x},t)w(x,t) interacts with quantum particles. The state vector corresponding to each w(x,t)w(\mathbf{x},t)w(x,t) is a realizable state. In this paper, I consider a previously presented model, which is predictively equivalent to CSL. In this completely quantized collapse (CQC) model, the classical random field is quantized. It is represented by the operator W(x,t)W(\mathbf{x},t)W(x,t) which satisfies $[W(\mathbf{x},t),W({\mathbf{x}}^{\ensuremath{'}},{t}^{\ensuremath{'}})]=0$. The ensemble of realizable states is described by a single state vector, the ``ensemble vector.'' Each superposed state which comprises the ensemble vector at time ttt is the direct product of an eigenstate of $W(\mathbf{x},{t}^{\ensuremath{'}})$, for all x\mathbf{x}x and for $0\ensuremath{\leqslant}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{\leqslant}t$, and the CSL state corresponding to that eigenvalue. These states never interfere (they satisfy a superselection rule at any time), they only branch, so the ensemble vector may be considered to be, as Schr\"odinger put it, a ``catalog'' of the realizable states. In this context, many different interpretations (e.g., many worlds, environmental decoherence, consistent histories, modal interpretation) may be satisfactorily applied. Using this description, a long-standing problem is resolved, where the energy comes from the particles gain due to the narrowing of their wave packets by the collapse mechanism. It is shown how to define the energy of the random field and its energy of interaction with particles so that total energy is conserved for the ensemble of realizable states. As a by-product, since the random-field energy spectrum is unbounded, its canonical conjugate, a self-adjoint time operator, can be discussed. Finally, CSL is a phenomenological description, whose connection to, or derivation from, more conventional physics has not yet appeared. We suggest that, because CQC is fully quantized, it is a natural framework for replacement of the classical field w(x,t)w(\mathbf{x},t)w(x,t) of CSL by a quantized physical entity. Two illustrative examples are given.