Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.27344

Limits for molecular spectroscopy from quantum channel discrimination

Anirban Dey, Akib Karim, Pieter Kok, Mark M. Wilde, Zixin Huang

quant-phSubmitted Sep 23, 2026• Announced Sep 24, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Absorption spectroscopy identifies molecules by detecting frequency-dependent optical loss, and its fundamental limit is a quantum channel-discrimination problem. In this work, we develop a general framework for characterizing the ultimate quantum limit of molecular absorption spectroscopy without collective measurements: we formulate it as an asymmetric quantum hypothesis testing task between different absorption channels. Using a semidefinite-programming formulation, we construct optimal probe states and compare them with coherent-state photon counting, Fock states, and two-mode squeezed vacuum probes. We introduce a random-loss channel model for imperfectly known background transmission, reflecting the fact that a blank experiment need not return all incident photons due to scattering, solvent absorption, or collection losses. Our results show that optimized non-classical probes can substantially outperform conventional laser spectroscopy, and that the advantage is robust to realistic baseline random loss. % In multi-frequency spectroscopy, the optimization also determines how photons should be allocated across absorption lines, revealing an additional resource-allocation advantage beyond single-mode state engineering. We illustrate our framework using infrared detection of 4-nitrophenol against chemically relevant comparison molecules, showing how quantum channel-discrimination methods provide constructive performance limits for molecular spectroscopy under realistic photon constraints.

AI Summary

The paper asks how probe-state and measurement optimization affect photon-constrained molecular absorption detection when collective measurements across interrogations are excluded. It formulates detection as asymmetric discrimination of bosonic loss channels, using channel measured relative entropy $D^M$ as the asymptotic missed-detection error exponent at fixed false-positive tolerance. Baseline attenuation is modelled by an independently redrawn random transmissivity, with additional molecular loss under the alternative hypothesis and weak dephasing under both hypotheses. An existing SDP approximation for $D^M$ is applied to single-frequency sensing and extended to frequency-product probes under a global photon budget. Numerical examples use three infrared features of 4-nitrophenol, with paracetamol and 4-aminophenol as competing hypotheses. Optimized probes outperform the coherent-state photon-counting benchmark; Fock and TMSV probes approach the single-frequency optimum. With baseline transmissivity uniform on $[0.95,1]$, this hierarchy persists. In the three-frequency example with mean photon budget $E=3$ and Fock cutoff $n_{ max}=6$, optimization assigns all photons to the $7.407\,\mu\mathrm m$ line; comparison probes receive equal allocations. For composite testing, a shared probe-and-measurement lower bound numerically coincides with the pairwise-optimized upper bound. Photon counting achieves over $90\%$ of the optimized exponent in the tested regime. Limitations include finite Fock truncation, independent baseline fluctuations, and exclusion of frequency-entangled probes. The multifrequency gain combines state optimization with unequal photon allocation. Second-order asymptotics suggest optimized probes become advantageous over Fock/TMSV probes around $n\gtrsim100$ interrogations in one example, but finite-sample optimization remains open.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalMissing comparisonStrong assumptionsOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The claimed ultimate photon-constrained optimum is established only in a finite Fock-space truncation, with substantial population at its upper cutoff and no demonstrated convergence or bound on omitted states. The multifrequency results optimize only frequency-product probes and measurements, rather than all strategies allowed by the absence of collective measurements across interrogations. The enlarged multifrequency advantage uses an allocation-optimized quantum strategy against equally populated benchmark modes, leaving the advantage over allocation-optimized laser spectroscopy unquantified.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
9 pages, 7 figures, 13 pages of appendices. Comments are welcome

Related papers

Entanglement-Assisted Absorption Spectroscopy

Haowei Shi, Zheshen Zhang, Stefano Pirandola +1 more

Spectroscopy is an important tool for probing the properties of materials, chemicals, and biological samples. We design a practical transmitter-receiver system that exploits entanglement to achieve a provable quantum advantage over all spectroscopic schemes based on classical sources. To probe the absorption spectra, modeled as a pattern of transmissivities among different frequency modes, we employ broadband signal-idler pairs in two-mode squeezed vacuum states. At the receiver side, we apply photodetection after optical parametric amplification. Finally, we perform a maximum likelihood decision test on the measurement results, achieving an error probability orders of magnitude lower than the optimum classical systems in various examples, including "wine tasting" and "drug testing" where real molecules are considered. In detecting the presence of an absorption line, our quantum scheme achieves the optimum performance allowed by quantum mechanics. The quantum advantage in our system is robust against noise and loss, which makes near-term experimental demonstration possible.

arXiv:2009.12026•Physical Review Letters•Oct 28, 2020•49 citations

Absorption spectroscopy at the ultimate quantum limit from single-photon states

Rebecca Whittaker, Chris Erven, Alex Neville +4 more

Absorption spectroscopy is routinely used to characterise chemical and biological samples. For the state-of-the-art in laser absorption spectroscopy, precision is theoretically limited by shot-noise due to the fundamental Poisson-distribution of photon number in laser radiation. In practice, the shot-noise limit can only be achieved when all other sources of noise are eliminated. Here, we use wavelength-correlated and tuneable photon pairs to demonstrate how absorption spectroscopy can be performed with precision beyond the shot-noise limit and near the ultimate quantum limit by using the optimal probe for absorption measurement—single photons. We present a practically realisable scheme, which we characterise both the precision and accuracy of by measuring the response of a control feature. We demonstrate that the technique can successfully probe liquid samples and using two spectrally similar types of haemoglobin we show that obtaining a given precision in resolution requires fewer heralded single probe photons compared to using an idealised laser.

arXiv:1508.00849•New Journal of Physics•Dec 21, 2016•93 citations

Ultimate Limits for Multiple Quantum Channel Discrimination

Quntao Zhuang, Stefano Pirandola

Quantum hypothesis testing is a central task in the entire field of quantum information theory. Understanding its ultimate limits will give insight into a wide range of quantum protocols and applications, from sensing to communication. Although the limits of hypothesis testing between quantum states have been completely clarified by the pioneering works of Helstrom in the 1970s, the more difficult problem of hypothesis testing with quantum channels, i.e., channel discrimination, is less understood. This is mainly due to the complications coming from the use of input entanglement and the possibility of employing adaptive strategies. In this Letter, we establish a lower limit for the ultimate error probability affecting the discrimination of an arbitrary number of quantum channels. We also show that this lower bound is achievable when the channels have certain symmetries. As an example, we apply our results to the problem of channel position finding, where the goal is to identify the location of a target channel among multiple background channels. In this general setting, we find that the use of entanglement offers a great advantage over strategies without entanglement, with nontrivial implications for data readout, target detection, and quantum spectroscopy.

arXiv:2007.14566•Physical Review Letters•Aug 21, 2020•52 citations

Quantum enhanced estimation of optical detector efficiencies

Marco Barbieri, Datta Animesh, Tim J. Bartley +3 more

Abstract Quantum mechanics establishes the ultimate limit to the scaling of the precision on any parameter, by identifying optimal probe states and measurements. While this paradigm is, at least in principle, adequate for the metrology of quantum channels involving the estimation of phase and loss parameters, we show that estimating the loss parameters associated with a quantum channel and a realistic quantum detector are fundamentally different. While Fock states are provably optimal for the former, we identify a crossover in the nature of the optimal probe state for estimating detector imperfections as a function of the loss parameter using Fisher information as a benchmark. We provide theoretical results for on-off and homodyne detectors, the most widely used detectors in quantum photonics technologies, when using Fock states and coherent states as probes.

arXiv:1502.00681•Quantum Measurements and Quantum Metrology•Jan 1, 2016•2 citations

Entanglement-Assisted Absorption Spectroscopy by Hong-Ou-Mandel Interference

Yuanyuan Chen, Qian Shen, Song Luo +3 more

Absorption spectroscopy has long been hailed as an absolute necessity for detecting the properties of complex chemical and biological samples. While conventional spectroscopy using classical light is severely limited by shot noise and lacks robustness against experimental imperfections, quantum light offers an avenue to perform absorption spectroscopy with provable advantages in the technical operations and the measurement precision. Here, we present an experimental approach to implement entanglement-based absorption spectroscopy with the assistance of Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. Since the temporal interference fringe is determined by the spectrum pattern, a maximum-likelihood decision is sufficient for revealing the relevant quantum information about the absorptive properties of the test samples. These experimental results may significantly facilitate the use of quantum interferometric spectroscopy to practical applications, which may be particularly relevant for photon-sensitive biological and chemical samples.

Physical Review Applied•Jan 7, 2022•22 citations

Optimal single-shot discrimination of optical modes

Ignatius William Primaatmaja, Asaph Ho, Valerio Scarani

Retrieving classical information encoded in optical modes is at the heart of many quantum information processing tasks, especially in the field of quantum communication and sensing. Yet, despite its importance, the fundamental limits of optical mode discrimination have been studied only in a few specific examples. Here we present a toolbox to find the optimal discrimination of any set of optical modes. The toolbox uses linear and semidefinite programming techniques, which provide rigorous (not heuristic) bounds, and which can be efficiently solved on standard computers. We study both probabilistic and unambiguous single-shot discrimination in two scenarios: the channel-discrimination scenario, typical of metrology, in which the verifier holds the light source and can set up a reference frame for the phase; and the source-discrimination scenario, more frequent in cryptography, in which the verifier only sees states that are diagonal in the photon-number basis. Our techniques are illustrated with several examples. Among the results, we find that, for many sets of modes, the optimal state for mode discrimination is a superposition or mixture of at most two number states; but this is not general, and we also exhibit counterexamples.

arXiv:2012.11104•Physical Review A•May 10, 2021•3 citations
Absorption spectroscopy identifies molecules by detecting frequency-dependent optical loss, and its fundamental limit is a quantum channel-discrimination problem. In this work, we develop a general framework for characterizing the ultimate quantum limit of molecular absorption spectroscopy without collective measurements: we formulate it as an asymmetric quantum hypothesis testing task between different absorption channels. Using a semidefinite-programming formulation, we construct optimal probe states and compare them with coherent-state photon counting, Fock states, and two-mode squeezed vacuum probes. We introduce a random-loss channel model for imperfectly known background transmission, reflecting the fact that a blank experiment need not return all incident photons due to scattering, solvent absorption, or collection losses. Our results show that optimized non-classical probes can substantially outperform conventional laser spectroscopy, and that the advantage is robust to realistic baseline random loss. % In multi-frequency spectroscopy, the optimization also determines how photons should be allocated across absorption lines, revealing an additional resource-allocation advantage beyond single-mode state engineering. We illustrate our framework using infrared detection of 4-nitrophenol against chemically relevant comparison molecules, showing how quantum channel-discrimination methods provide constructive performance limits for molecular spectroscopy under realistic photon constraints.
The paper asks how probe-state and measurement optimization affect photon-constrained molecular absorption detection when collective measurements across interrogations are excluded. It formulates detection as asymmetric discrimination of bosonic loss channels, using channel measured relative entropy DMD^MDM as the asymptotic missed-detection error exponent at fixed false-positive tolerance. Baseline attenuation is modelled by an independently redrawn random transmissivity, with additional molecular loss under the alternative hypothesis and weak dephasing under both hypotheses.
An existing SDP approximation for DMD^MDM is applied to single-frequency sensing and extended to frequency-product probes under a global photon budget. Numerical examples use three infrared features of 4-nitrophenol, with paracetamol and 4-aminophenol as competing hypotheses. Optimized probes outperform the coherent-state photon-counting benchmark; Fock and TMSV probes approach the single-frequency optimum. With baseline transmissivity uniform on [0.95,1][0.95,1][0.95,1], this hierarchy persists. In the three-frequency example with mean photon budget E=3E=3E=3 and Fock cutoff n_{ max}=6, optimization assigns all photons to the 7.407 μm7.407\,\mu\mathrm m7.407μm line; comparison probes receive equal allocations. For composite testing, a shared probe-and-measurement lower bound numerically coincides with the pairwise-optimized upper bound. Photon counting achieves over 90%90\%90% of the optimized exponent in the tested regime.
Limitations include finite Fock truncation, independent baseline fluctuations, and exclusion of frequency-entangled probes. The multifrequency gain combines state optimization with unequal photon allocation. Second-order asymptotics suggest optimized probes become advantageous over Fock/TMSV probes around n≳100n\gtrsim100n≳100 interrogations in one example, but finite-sample optimization remains open.
Spectroscopy is an important tool for probing the properties of materials, chemicals, and biological samples. We design a practical transmitter-receiver system that exploits entanglement to achieve a provable quantum advantage over all spectroscopic schemes based on classical sources. To probe the absorption spectra, modeled as a pattern of transmissivities among different frequency modes, we employ broadband signal-idler pairs in two-mode squeezed vacuum states. At the receiver side, we apply photodetection after optical parametric amplification. Finally, we perform a maximum likelihood decision test on the measurement results, achieving an error probability orders of magnitude lower than the optimum classical systems in various examples, including "wine tasting" and "drug testing" where real molecules are considered. In detecting the presence of an absorption line, our quantum scheme achieves the optimum performance allowed by quantum mechanics. The quantum advantage in our system is robust against noise and loss, which makes near-term experimental demonstration possible.
Absorption spectroscopy is routinely used to characterise chemical and biological samples. For the state-of-the-art in laser absorption spectroscopy, precision is theoretically limited by shot-noise due to the fundamental Poisson-distribution of photon number in laser radiation. In practice, the shot-noise limit can only be achieved when all other sources of noise are eliminated. Here, we use wavelength-correlated and tuneable photon pairs to demonstrate how absorption spectroscopy can be performed with precision beyond the shot-noise limit and near the ultimate quantum limit by using the optimal probe for absorption measurement—single photons. We present a practically realisable scheme, which we characterise both the precision and accuracy of by measuring the response of a control feature. We demonstrate that the technique can successfully probe liquid samples and using two spectrally similar types of haemoglobin we show that obtaining a given precision in resolution requires fewer heralded single probe photons compared to using an idealised laser.
Quantum hypothesis testing is a central task in the entire field of quantum information theory. Understanding its ultimate limits will give insight into a wide range of quantum protocols and applications, from sensing to communication. Although the limits of hypothesis testing between quantum states have been completely clarified by the pioneering works of Helstrom in the 1970s, the more difficult problem of hypothesis testing with quantum channels, i.e., channel discrimination, is less understood. This is mainly due to the complications coming from the use of input entanglement and the possibility of employing adaptive strategies. In this Letter, we establish a lower limit for the ultimate error probability affecting the discrimination of an arbitrary number of quantum channels. We also show that this lower bound is achievable when the channels have certain symmetries. As an example, we apply our results to the problem of channel position finding, where the goal is to identify the location of a target channel among multiple background channels. In this general setting, we find that the use of entanglement offers a great advantage over strategies without entanglement, with nontrivial implications for data readout, target detection, and quantum spectroscopy.
Abstract Quantum mechanics establishes the ultimate limit to the scaling of the precision on any parameter, by identifying optimal probe states and measurements. While this paradigm is, at least in principle, adequate for the metrology of quantum channels involving the estimation of phase and loss parameters, we show that estimating the loss parameters associated with a quantum channel and a realistic quantum detector are fundamentally different. While Fock states are provably optimal for the former, we identify a crossover in the nature of the optimal probe state for estimating detector imperfections as a function of the loss parameter using Fisher information as a benchmark. We provide theoretical results for on-off and homodyne detectors, the most widely used detectors in quantum photonics technologies, when using Fock states and coherent states as probes.
Absorption spectroscopy has long been hailed as an absolute necessity for detecting the properties of complex chemical and biological samples. While conventional spectroscopy using classical light is severely limited by shot noise and lacks robustness against experimental imperfections, quantum light offers an avenue to perform absorption spectroscopy with provable advantages in the technical operations and the measurement precision. Here, we present an experimental approach to implement entanglement-based absorption spectroscopy with the assistance of Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. Since the temporal interference fringe is determined by the spectrum pattern, a maximum-likelihood decision is sufficient for revealing the relevant quantum information about the absorptive properties of the test samples. These experimental results may significantly facilitate the use of quantum interferometric spectroscopy to practical applications, which may be particularly relevant for photon-sensitive biological and chemical samples.
Retrieving classical information encoded in optical modes is at the heart of many quantum information processing tasks, especially in the field of quantum communication and sensing. Yet, despite its importance, the fundamental limits of optical mode discrimination have been studied only in a few specific examples. Here we present a toolbox to find the optimal discrimination of any set of optical modes. The toolbox uses linear and semidefinite programming techniques, which provide rigorous (not heuristic) bounds, and which can be efficiently solved on standard computers. We study both probabilistic and unambiguous single-shot discrimination in two scenarios: the channel-discrimination scenario, typical of metrology, in which the verifier holds the light source and can set up a reference frame for the phase; and the source-discrimination scenario, more frequent in cryptography, in which the verifier only sees states that are diagonal in the photon-number basis. Our techniques are illustrated with several examples. Among the results, we find that, for many sets of modes, the optimal state for mode discrimination is a superposition or mixture of at most two number states; but this is not general, and we also exhibit counterexamples.