Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.30335

Holographic Representations of Topological Quantum Criticality: Emergent Symmetry Approach around the Bott Clock

Fan Yang, Fei Zhou

Published Aug 31, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this article, we apply the idea of emergent symmetries to construct holographic representations of a broad class of topological quantum critical points (tQCPs) that appear in fermionic classes in the Bott clock. We show explicitly that around the Bott clock, an emergent symmetry $U_{EM}$ exists at a tQCP between different symmetry protected gapped phases with protecting symmetry $G_p$ in $d$ spatial dimensions. This emergent symmetry can be used to construct a $(d+1)$ spatial dimensional lattice model with a properly upgraded symmetry such as $U_{EM}\times G_p$ or $U_{EM} \rtimes G_p$, etc. By doubling the degrees of freedom of the adjacent topological class in $d$-dimensions, we successfully show that the $(d+1)$-dimensional lattice models constructed in this way have the desired enlarged symmetry groups that precisely belong to the adjacent topological classes, counterclockwise around the Bott clock. Furthermore, $d$-dimensional boundaries of these $(d+1)$ dimensional lattice models of gapped topological classes are shown to exhibit identical infrared dynamics as the corresponding tQCPs in the $d$-dimensional adjacent topological phases in the Bott clock, with lower symmetries.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2608.30335

Related papers

Emergent symmetries and interactions in high dimensions: An isolated fixed point versus a manifold of strongly interacting fixed points

Fei Zhou

In this article, we explore conditions of continuous emergent symmetries in gapless states, either as topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) or a stable phase with protecting symmetries and connections to smooth deformations of the gapped states around. For a wide class of gapless states that can be associated with fully isolated scale-invariant fixed points, we illustrate that there shall be emergent continuous symmetries that are directly related to smooth deformations of gapped states with symmetries lower than the protecting ones ${G}_{p}$. A short-distance invariance of gapped states under deformations can descend to be an emergent continuous symmetry when approaching the gapless limit. Around one TQCP with ${G}_{p}={Z}_{2}^{T}$ symmetry, we construct these deformations explicitly and show emergence of symmetries via fully gapped quaternion superconducting states that break the protecting symmetry ${G}_{p}={Z}_{2}^{T}$. For a 3D TQCP in DIII classes with ${G}_{p}={Z}_{2}^{T}, {U}_{EM}=U(1)$, and ${N}_{f}=\frac{1}{2}$ fermions but without charge $U(1)$ symmetry, we further explicitly construct a corresponding boundary representation based on a $4\text{D}$ topological state with lattice symmetry $H={Z}_{2}^{T}\ensuremath{\ltimes}U(1)$ and ${N}_{f}=1$ fermions. The lattice model is shown to be dual to a conventional $4\text{D}$ topological insulator. Although emergent continuous symmetries appear to be robust at weakly interacting TQCPs, we further show the breakdown of such one-to-one correspondence between deformations of gapped states and emergent continuous symmetries when gapless states become strongly interacting. In a strongly interacting limit, gapless states can be represented by a smooth manifold of conformal-field-theory fixed points rather than a fully isolated one. A smooth manifold of strong coupling fixed points hinders emergence of a continuous emergent symmetry in the strongly interacting gapless limit, as deformations no longer leave a gapless state or a TQCP invariant, unlike in the more conventional weakly interacting case. This typically reduces continuous emergent symmetries to a discrete symmetry originating from duality transformations under the protection symmetry ${G}_{p}$.

Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 2, 2024•4 citations

Emergent symmetries and Interactions: An isolated fixed point Vs a manifold of strongly interacting fixed points

Fei Zhou

In this article, we study conditions of continuous emergent symmetries in gapless states, either as topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) or a stable phase with protecting symmetries and connections to smooth deformations of the gapped states around. We illustrate that for a wide class of gapless states that can be associated with fully-isolated scale invariant fixed points, there shall always be emergent continuous symmetries that are directly related to smooth deformations of gapped states with symmetries lower than the protecting ones $G_p$. For a 3D TQCP in DIII classes with $G_p=Z^T_2$, $U_{EM}=U(1)$ and $N_f=\frac{1}{2}$ fermions but without charge $U(1)$ symmetry, we explicitly construct a corresponding boundary representation based on a $4D$ topological state with lattice symmetry $H=Z^T_2 \ltimes U(1)$ and $N_f={1}$ fermions. Although emergent continuous symmetries appear to be robust at weakly interacting TQCPs, we further show the breakdown of such one-to-one correspondence between deformations of gapped states and emergent continuous symmetries when gapless states become strongly interacting. In a strongly interacting limit, gapless states can be represented by a smooth manifold of conformal-field-theory fixed points rather than a fully isolated one. A smooth manifold of strong coupling fixed points hinders emergence of a continuous emergent symmetry in the strongly interacting gapless limit, as deformations no longer leave a gapless state or a TQCP invariant, unlike in the more conventional weakly interacting case. This typically reduces continuous emergent symmetries to a discrete symmetry originating from duality transformations under the protection symmetry $G_p$.

arXiv:2310.12252•Oct 18, 2023•0 citations

Dynamic critical exponents as an emergent property at interacting topological quantum critical points

Fan Yang, Zheng‐Cheng Gu, Fei Zhou

In standard studies of quantum critical points (QCPs), the dynamic critical exponent $z$ is introduced as a fundamental parameter along with global symmetries to identify universality classes. Often, the dynamic critical exponent $z$ is set to be one as the most natural choice for quantum field theory representations, which further implies emergence of higher space-time symmetries near QCPs in many condensed matter systems. In this article, we study a family of topological quantum critical points (tQCPs) where the $z=1$ quantum field theory is prohibited in a fundamental representation by a protecting symmetry, resulting in tQCPs with $z=2$. We further illustrate that when strong interactions are properly taken into account, the stable weakly interacting gapless tQCPs with $z=2$ can further make a transition to another family of gapless tQCPs with dynamic critical exponent $z=1$, without breaking the protecting symmetry. Our studies suggest that dynamic critical exponents, as well as the degrees of freedom in fermion fields, can crucially depend on interactions in topological quantum phase transitions; in tQCPs, to a large extent, they are better thought of as emergent properties.

arXiv:2503.01512•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 26, 2025•1 citation

Topological holography, quantum criticality, and boundary states

Sheng-Jie Huang, Meng Cheng

Topological holography is a holographic principle that describes the generalized global symmetry of a local quantum system in terms of a topological order in one higher dimension. This framework separates the topological data from the local dynamics of a theory and provides a unified description of the symmetry and duality in gapped and gapless phases of matter. In this work, we develop the topological holographic picture for (1+1) d d quantum phases, including both gapped phases as well as a wide range of quantum critical points, including phase transitions between symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases, symmetry enriched quantum critical points, deconfined quantum critical points, and intrinsically gapless SPT phases. Topological holography puts a strong constraint on the emergent symmetry and the anomaly for these critical theories. We show how the partition functions of these critical points can be obtained from dualizing (orbifolding) more familiar critical theories. The topological responses of the defect operators are also discussed in this framework. We further develop a topological holographic picture for conformal boundary states of (1+1) d d rational conformal field theories. This framework provides a simple physical picture to understand conformal boundary states and also uncovers the nature of the gapped phases corresponding to the boundary states.

arXiv:2310.16878•SciPost Physics•Jun 30, 2025•46 citations

Topological quantum critical points in strong coupling limits: Global symmetries and strongly interacting Majorana fermions

Fei Zhou

In this paper, we discuss strong coupling limits of topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) where quantum phase transitions between two topological distinct superconducting states take place. We illustrate that while superconducting phases on both sides of TQCPs spontaneously break the same symmetries, universality classes of critical states can be identified only when global symmetries in topological states are further specified. In dimensions $d=2\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{and}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}3$, we find that continuous $(d+1)\mathrm{th}$-order transitions at weakly interacting TQCPs that were pointed out previously in the presence of the emergent Lorentz symmetry can be terminated by strongly interacting fixed points of Majorana fields. For $2d$ time reversal symmetry breaking TQCPs, termination points are supersymmetric with $\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=1$ (where ${N}_{f}$ is the number of four-component Dirac fermions and $\mathcal{N}$ is the number of two-component real fermions) beyond which transitions are discontinuous first-order ones. For $2d$ time reversal symmetric TQCPs without other global symmetries, termination points of $(d+1)\mathrm{th}$-order continuous transition lines are generically conformal invariant without supersymmetry. Beyond these strong coupling fixed points, there are first-order discontinuous transitions as far as the protecting symmetry is not spontaneously broken but no direct transitions if the protecting symmetry is spontaneously broken in the presence of strong interactions. In this case, termination points can become supersymmetric with $\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=2$ only when interacting Majorana fermions further display an emergent global $\text{U}(1)$ symmetry. In $3d$, strong coupling termination points can be further effectively represented by new emergent gapless real bosons weakly coupled with free gapless Majorana fermions. However, in $1d$, time reversal symmetric $(d+1)\mathrm{th}$ continuous transition lines of TQCPs are terminated by simple free Majorana fermion fixed points.

arXiv:2110.08332•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 3, 2022•9 citations

Classification of 1+1D gapless symmetry protected phases via topological holography

Wen, Rui, Andrew C. Potter

Symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) gives a holographic correspondence between systems with a global symmetry and a higher-dimensional topological field theory. In this framework, classification of gapped phases of matter in spacetime dimension 1+1D correspond to classifications of mechanisms to confine the SymTFT by condensing anyons. In this work, we extend these results to characterize gapless symmetry-protected topological states: symmetry-enriched gapless phases or critical points that exhibit edge modes protected by symmetry and topology. We establish a one-to-one correspondence between 1+1D bosonic gSPTs, and partially-confined boundaries of 2+1D SymTFTs. From general physical considerations, we determine the set of data and consistency conditions required to define a 1+1D gSPT, and show that this data precisely matches that of symmetry-preserving partial confinement (or partially gapped boundaries) of 2+1D quantum double models. We illustrate this correspondence through a dimensional reduction (thin-slab) construction, which enables a physically-intuitive derivation of how properties of the gSPT such as edge modes, emergent anomalies, and stability to perturbations arise from the SymTFT perspective.ditions required to define a 1+1D gSPT and show that they fully determine the physics of the gSPT including edge modes and emergent anomaly.

arXiv:2311.00050•Oct 31, 2023•7 citations
In this article, we apply the idea of emergent symmetries to construct holographic representations of a broad class of topological quantum critical points (tQCPs) that appear in fermionic classes in the Bott clock. We show explicitly that around the Bott clock, an emergent symmetry UEMU_{EM}UEM​ exists at a tQCP between different symmetry protected gapped phases with protecting symmetry GpG_pGp​ in ddd spatial dimensions. This emergent symmetry can be used to construct a (d+1)(d+1)(d+1) spatial dimensional lattice model with a properly upgraded symmetry such as UEM×GpU_{EM}\times G_pUEM​×Gp​ or UEM⋊GpU_{EM} \rtimes G_pUEM​⋊Gp​, etc. By doubling the degrees of freedom of the adjacent topological class in ddd-dimensions, we successfully show that the (d+1)(d+1)(d+1)-dimensional lattice models constructed in this way have the desired enlarged symmetry groups that precisely belong to the adjacent topological classes, counterclockwise around the Bott clock. Furthermore, ddd-dimensional boundaries of these (d+1)(d+1)(d+1) dimensional lattice models of gapped topological classes are shown to exhibit identical infrared dynamics as the corresponding tQCPs in the ddd-dimensional adjacent topological phases in the Bott clock, with lower symmetries.
In this article, we explore conditions of continuous emergent symmetries in gapless states, either as topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) or a stable phase with protecting symmetries and connections to smooth deformations of the gapped states around. For a wide class of gapless states that can be associated with fully isolated scale-invariant fixed points, we illustrate that there shall be emergent continuous symmetries that are directly related to smooth deformations of gapped states with symmetries lower than the protecting ones Gp{G}_{p}Gp​. A short-distance invariance of gapped states under deformations can descend to be an emergent continuous symmetry when approaching the gapless limit. Around one TQCP with Gp=Z2T{G}_{p}={Z}_{2}^{T}Gp​=Z2T​ symmetry, we construct these deformations explicitly and show emergence of symmetries via fully gapped quaternion superconducting states that break the protecting symmetry Gp=Z2T{G}_{p}={Z}_{2}^{T}Gp​=Z2T​. For a 3D TQCP in DIII classes with Gp=Z2T,UEM=U(1){G}_{p}={Z}_{2}^{T}, {U}_{EM}=U(1)Gp​=Z2T​,UEM​=U(1), and Nf=12{N}_{f}=\frac{1}{2}Nf​=21​ fermions but without charge U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetry, we further explicitly construct a corresponding boundary representation based on a 4D4\text{D}4D topological state with lattice symmetry $H={Z}_{2}^{T}\ensuremath{\ltimes}U(1)$ and Nf=1{N}_{f}=1Nf​=1 fermions. The lattice model is shown to be dual to a conventional 4D4\text{D}4D topological insulator. Although emergent continuous symmetries appear to be robust at weakly interacting TQCPs, we further show the breakdown of such one-to-one correspondence between deformations of gapped states and emergent continuous symmetries when gapless states become strongly interacting. In a strongly interacting limit, gapless states can be represented by a smooth manifold of conformal-field-theory fixed points rather than a fully isolated one. A smooth manifold of strong coupling fixed points hinders emergence of a continuous emergent symmetry in the strongly interacting gapless limit, as deformations no longer leave a gapless state or a TQCP invariant, unlike in the more conventional weakly interacting case. This typically reduces continuous emergent symmetries to a discrete symmetry originating from duality transformations under the protection symmetry Gp{G}_{p}Gp​.
In this article, we study conditions of continuous emergent symmetries in gapless states, either as topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) or a stable phase with protecting symmetries and connections to smooth deformations of the gapped states around. We illustrate that for a wide class of gapless states that can be associated with fully-isolated scale invariant fixed points, there shall always be emergent continuous symmetries that are directly related to smooth deformations of gapped states with symmetries lower than the protecting ones GpG_pGp​. For a 3D TQCP in DIII classes with Gp=Z2TG_p=Z^T_2Gp​=Z2T​, UEM=U(1)U_{EM}=U(1)UEM​=U(1) and Nf=12N_f=\frac{1}{2}Nf​=21​ fermions but without charge U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetry, we explicitly construct a corresponding boundary representation based on a 4D4D4D topological state with lattice symmetry H=Z2T⋉U(1)H=Z^T_2 \ltimes U(1)H=Z2T​⋉U(1) and Nf=1N_f={1}Nf​=1 fermions. Although emergent continuous symmetries appear to be robust at weakly interacting TQCPs, we further show the breakdown of such one-to-one correspondence between deformations of gapped states and emergent continuous symmetries when gapless states become strongly interacting. In a strongly interacting limit, gapless states can be represented by a smooth manifold of conformal-field-theory fixed points rather than a fully isolated one. A smooth manifold of strong coupling fixed points hinders emergence of a continuous emergent symmetry in the strongly interacting gapless limit, as deformations no longer leave a gapless state or a TQCP invariant, unlike in the more conventional weakly interacting case. This typically reduces continuous emergent symmetries to a discrete symmetry originating from duality transformations under the protection symmetry GpG_pGp​.
In standard studies of quantum critical points (QCPs), the dynamic critical exponent zzz is introduced as a fundamental parameter along with global symmetries to identify universality classes. Often, the dynamic critical exponent zzz is set to be one as the most natural choice for quantum field theory representations, which further implies emergence of higher space-time symmetries near QCPs in many condensed matter systems. In this article, we study a family of topological quantum critical points (tQCPs) where the z=1z=1z=1 quantum field theory is prohibited in a fundamental representation by a protecting symmetry, resulting in tQCPs with z=2z=2z=2. We further illustrate that when strong interactions are properly taken into account, the stable weakly interacting gapless tQCPs with z=2z=2z=2 can further make a transition to another family of gapless tQCPs with dynamic critical exponent z=1z=1z=1, without breaking the protecting symmetry. Our studies suggest that dynamic critical exponents, as well as the degrees of freedom in fermion fields, can crucially depend on interactions in topological quantum phase transitions; in tQCPs, to a large extent, they are better thought of as emergent properties.
Topological holography is a holographic principle that describes the generalized global symmetry of a local quantum system in terms of a topological order in one higher dimension. This framework separates the topological data from the local dynamics of a theory and provides a unified description of the symmetry and duality in gapped and gapless phases of matter. In this work, we develop the topological holographic picture for (1+1) d d quantum phases, including both gapped phases as well as a wide range of quantum critical points, including phase transitions between symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases, symmetry enriched quantum critical points, deconfined quantum critical points, and intrinsically gapless SPT phases. Topological holography puts a strong constraint on the emergent symmetry and the anomaly for these critical theories. We show how the partition functions of these critical points can be obtained from dualizing (orbifolding) more familiar critical theories. The topological responses of the defect operators are also discussed in this framework. We further develop a topological holographic picture for conformal boundary states of (1+1) d d rational conformal field theories. This framework provides a simple physical picture to understand conformal boundary states and also uncovers the nature of the gapped phases corresponding to the boundary states.
In this paper, we discuss strong coupling limits of topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) where quantum phase transitions between two topological distinct superconducting states take place. We illustrate that while superconducting phases on both sides of TQCPs spontaneously break the same symmetries, universality classes of critical states can be identified only when global symmetries in topological states are further specified. In dimensions d=2and3d=2\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{and}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}3d=2and3, we find that continuous (d+1)th(d+1)\mathrm{th}(d+1)th-order transitions at weakly interacting TQCPs that were pointed out previously in the presence of the emergent Lorentz symmetry can be terminated by strongly interacting fixed points of Majorana fields. For 2d2d2d time reversal symmetry breaking TQCPs, termination points are supersymmetric with N=4Nf=1\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=1N=4Nf​=1 (where Nf{N}_{f}Nf​ is the number of four-component Dirac fermions and N\mathcal{N}N is the number of two-component real fermions) beyond which transitions are discontinuous first-order ones. For 2d2d2d time reversal symmetric TQCPs without other global symmetries, termination points of (d+1)th(d+1)\mathrm{th}(d+1)th-order continuous transition lines are generically conformal invariant without supersymmetry. Beyond these strong coupling fixed points, there are first-order discontinuous transitions as far as the protecting symmetry is not spontaneously broken but no direct transitions if the protecting symmetry is spontaneously broken in the presence of strong interactions. In this case, termination points can become supersymmetric with N=4Nf=2\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=2N=4Nf​=2 only when interacting Majorana fermions further display an emergent global U(1)\text{U}(1)U(1) symmetry. In 3d3d3d, strong coupling termination points can be further effectively represented by new emergent gapless real bosons weakly coupled with free gapless Majorana fermions. However, in 1d1d1d, time reversal symmetric (d+1)th(d+1)\mathrm{th}(d+1)th continuous transition lines of TQCPs are terminated by simple free Majorana fermion fixed points.
Symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) gives a holographic correspondence between systems with a global symmetry and a higher-dimensional topological field theory. In this framework, classification of gapped phases of matter in spacetime dimension 1+1D correspond to classifications of mechanisms to confine the SymTFT by condensing anyons. In this work, we extend these results to characterize gapless symmetry-protected topological states: symmetry-enriched gapless phases or critical points that exhibit edge modes protected by symmetry and topology. We establish a one-to-one correspondence between 1+1D bosonic gSPTs, and partially-confined boundaries of 2+1D SymTFTs. From general physical considerations, we determine the set of data and consistency conditions required to define a 1+1D gSPT, and show that this data precisely matches that of symmetry-preserving partial confinement (or partially gapped boundaries) of 2+1D quantum double models. We illustrate this correspondence through a dimensional reduction (thin-slab) construction, which enables a physically-intuitive derivation of how properties of the gSPT such as edge modes, emergent anomalies, and stability to perturbations arise from the SymTFT perspective.ditions required to define a 1+1D gSPT and show that they fully determine the physics of the gSPT including edge modes and emergent anomaly.