Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.28985 · Physical Review A

Measure of set imaginarity

Yu Guo, Jiabo Pan, Yuqin Wang, Shuanping Du

quant-phSubmitted Aug 29, 2026• Announced Sep 1, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recent studies have shown that Bargmann invariants provide effective detectors of set imaginarity. In this paper, we investigate set imaginarity as a quantum resource in qubit systems. By exploiting the structure of Bargmann invariants, we show that the free operations for qubit set imaginarity consist precisely of common unital operations and common planarized operations. Based on this characterization, we introduce an axiomatic framework for set-imaginarity measures (SIMs). In particular, we propose two refined notions, namely unified SIMs and complete SIMs, which allow a more fine-grained quantification of set imaginarity. To make these notions concrete, we construct two qubit SIMs from the Bargmann invariants of three-state subsets. We prove that one of them is a unified SIM, while the other satisfies the stronger requirements of a complete SIM. Furthermore, we revisit the robustness of set imaginarity previously introduced in the literature. We show that, although this robustness is a valid SIM for qubit systems, it is neither a unified SIM nor a complete SIM. To overcome this limitation, we propose an improved robustness-type measure and rigorously prove that it defines a complete qubit SIM.

Journal reference
Physical Review A 114, 022453 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/1yc6-lzfk
Comments
13 pages, comments are welcome

Related papers

Multistate imaginarity and coherence in qubit systems

Mao-Sheng Li, Rafael Wagner, Lin Zhang

Traditionally, the characterization of quantum resources has focused on individual quantum states. Recent literature, however, has increasingly explored the characterization of resources in states—ordered collections of states indexed by a varying parameter. In this work, we provide a unitary-invariant framework to pinpoint imaginarity and coherence in sets of qubit states: We prove that Bloch vectors must be coplanar to be imaginarity free and collinear to be incoherent, yielding exact rank-based tests of coherence and imaginarity and closed-form bounds for existing robustness quantifiers, all based on two-state overlaps only. We also show that the set of imaginarity-free multistates is not convex, and that third-order invariants completely characterize multistate imaginarity of single-qubits but not of higher-dimensional systems. As our main technical result, we show that Bargmann invariant of single-qubit states is determined (up to conjugation) by two-state overlaps. Beyond qubits, we give purity and system-agnostic coherence witnesses from equality constraints on higher-order invariants and connect our results to practical protocols—characterization of partial distinguishability, spin-chirality detection, and subchannel discrimination.

arXiv:2507.14878•Physical Review A•Jan 5, 2026•3 citations

Bargmann invariants for quantum imaginarity

Mao-Sheng Li, Yi-Xi Tan

The imaginary in quantum theory plays a crucial role in describing quantum coherence and is widely applied in quantum information tasks such as state discrimination, pseudorandomness generation, and quantum metrology. A recent paper by Fernandes et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 190201 (2024)] showed how to use the Bargmann invariant to witness the imaginarity of a set of quantum states. In this work, we delve into the structure of Bargmann invariants and their quantum realization in qubit systems. First, we present a characterization of special sets of Bargmann invariants (also studied by Fernandes et al. for a set of four states) for a general set of $n$ quantum states. Then, we study the properties of the relevant Bargmann invariant set ${\mathcal{B}}_{n}$ and its quantum realization in qubit systems. Our results provide new insights into the structure of Bargmann invariants, contributing to the advancement of quantum information techniques, particularly within qubit systems.

Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2025•12 citations

Coherence and imaginarity of qubit states under vanishing Bargmann invariants

Hao-Fan Wang, Lin Chen

Set coherence and set imaginarity are two important quantum resources defined by sets of states. We investigate tuples of qubit states under vanishing higher-order Bargmann invariants and show that their set coherence and set imaginarity are each related to whether they contain a pair of orthogonal states. Specifically, when the relevant higher-order Bargmann invariants vanish, the tuple contains a pair of orthogonal states if and only if removing some state makes the remaining tuple incoherent. Moreover, when maximally mixed states are excluded, the same vanishing conditions imply that the tuple is imaginarity-free if and only if it contains a pair of orthogonal states. As a consequence, under these conditions, a tuple of single-qubit states has imaginarity precisely when every tuple obtained by deleting one of its states is coherent.

quant-pharXiv:2610.30618•Oct 23, 2026•0 citations

On the Bargmann invariants for quantum imaginarity

Mao-Sheng Li, Yi-Xi Tan

The imaginary in quantum theory plays a crucial role in describing quantum coherence and is widely applied in quantum information tasks such as state discrimination, pseudorandomness generation, and quantum metrology. A recent paper by Fernandes et al. [C. Fernandes, R. Wagner, L. Novo, and E. F. Galvão, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 190201 (2024) ] showed how to use the Bargmann invariant to witness the imaginarity of a set of quantum states. In this work, we delve into the structure of Bargmann invariants and their quantum realization in qubit systems. First, we present a characterization of special sets of Bargmann invariants (also studied by Fernandes et al. for a set of four states) for a general set of $n$ quantum states. Then, we study the properties of the relevant Bargmann invariant set $\mathcal{B}_n$ and its quantum realization in qubit systems. Our results provide new insights into the structure of Bargmann invariants, contributing to the advancement of quantum information techniques, particularly within qubit systems.

arXiv:2412.08022•Dec 11, 2024•1 citation

Measure of set coherence

Jiabo Panel, Yu Guo, Yuqin Wang

Set coherence is a quantum resource for a set of states that characterizes whether a collection of quantum states contains coherence, namely whether these states fail to be simultaneously incoherent in a common basis. In this work, we show that the free operations of set coherence are common commutativity-preserving quantum channels, from which we then establish an axiomatic framework for set-coherence measure (SCM). Within this framework, we investigate the robustness based measures deduced by taking, respectively, the average, maximum, and sum of the single-state robustnesses over a common reference basis, where the first two were previously introduced in the literature and we check here whether they satisfy our SCM axioms. Consequently, we show that the averaged robustness is an SCM but it is neither unified nor complete, the maximal robustness is a unified SCM but is neither complete nor strongly superadditive, whereas the sum robustness is a complete SCM. Furthermore, we propose several classes of SCMs based on pairwise commutators. We show that the Schatten $p$-norm based SCMs are complete and strongly superadditive. We also find that the universal fourth-order Bargmann gap measure proposed in the literature is a complete and strongly superadditive quantifier of set coherence. Finally, we discuss the operational meaning of the SCM in the context of optimal approximate quantum broadcasting, and show that the amount of set coherence can closely reflect the performance of this task.

quant-pharXiv:2610.34784•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations

A Survey of Bargmann Invariants: Geometric Foundations and Applications

Lin Zhang, Bing Xie

Bargmann invariants, a class of unitary-invariant quantities arising from the overlaps of quantum state vectors, provide a profound and unifying framework for understanding the relative geometry of the projective Hilbert space. This survey offers a comprehensive overview of their theoretical characterization and practical applications, with particular emphasis on recent progress in determining the full structure of their admissible set. The core of this review demonstrates how these invariants serve as a powerful tool for characterizing the intrinsic geometry of the space of quantum states, leading to applications in determining local unitary equivalence and constructing a complete set of polynomial invariants for mixed states. On the operational side, we review the cycle-test quantum circuit for the direct estimation of Bargmann invariants without full state tomography, and demonstrate their utility in witnessing quantum imaginary, discriminating local unitary equivalence, and detecting entanglement via partial-transpose moments---with explicit complete invariant sets provided for two-qubit systems. By connecting fundamental geometric classification with experimentally feasible estimation protocols,this survey establishes Bargmann invariants as indispensable probes of the relational, noncommutative, and geometric structure of quantum states, and identifies key open problems for multipartite high-dimensional systems and for quantum resource theories.

quant-pharXiv:2601.01858•Jan 6, 2026•0 citations
Recent studies have shown that Bargmann invariants provide effective detectors of set imaginarity. In this paper, we investigate set imaginarity as a quantum resource in qubit systems. By exploiting the structure of Bargmann invariants, we show that the free operations for qubit set imaginarity consist precisely of common unital operations and common planarized operations. Based on this characterization, we introduce an axiomatic framework for set-imaginarity measures (SIMs). In particular, we propose two refined notions, namely unified SIMs and complete SIMs, which allow a more fine-grained quantification of set imaginarity. To make these notions concrete, we construct two qubit SIMs from the Bargmann invariants of three-state subsets. We prove that one of them is a unified SIM, while the other satisfies the stronger requirements of a complete SIM. Furthermore, we revisit the robustness of set imaginarity previously introduced in the literature. We show that, although this robustness is a valid SIM for qubit systems, it is neither a unified SIM nor a complete SIM. To overcome this limitation, we propose an improved robustness-type measure and rigorously prove that it defines a complete qubit SIM.
Traditionally, the characterization of quantum resources has focused on individual quantum states. Recent literature, however, has increasingly explored the characterization of resources in states—ordered collections of states indexed by a varying parameter. In this work, we provide a unitary-invariant framework to pinpoint imaginarity and coherence in sets of qubit states: We prove that Bloch vectors must be coplanar to be imaginarity free and collinear to be incoherent, yielding exact rank-based tests of coherence and imaginarity and closed-form bounds for existing robustness quantifiers, all based on two-state overlaps only. We also show that the set of imaginarity-free multistates is not convex, and that third-order invariants completely characterize multistate imaginarity of single-qubits but not of higher-dimensional systems. As our main technical result, we show that Bargmann invariant of single-qubit states is determined (up to conjugation) by two-state overlaps. Beyond qubits, we give purity and system-agnostic coherence witnesses from equality constraints on higher-order invariants and connect our results to practical protocols—characterization of partial distinguishability, spin-chirality detection, and subchannel discrimination.
The imaginary in quantum theory plays a crucial role in describing quantum coherence and is widely applied in quantum information tasks such as state discrimination, pseudorandomness generation, and quantum metrology. A recent paper by Fernandes et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 190201 (2024)] showed how to use the Bargmann invariant to witness the imaginarity of a set of quantum states. In this work, we delve into the structure of Bargmann invariants and their quantum realization in qubit systems. First, we present a characterization of special sets of Bargmann invariants (also studied by Fernandes et al. for a set of four states) for a general set of nnn quantum states. Then, we study the properties of the relevant Bargmann invariant set Bn{\mathcal{B}}_{n}Bn​ and its quantum realization in qubit systems. Our results provide new insights into the structure of Bargmann invariants, contributing to the advancement of quantum information techniques, particularly within qubit systems.
Set coherence and set imaginarity are two important quantum resources defined by sets of states. We investigate tuples of qubit states under vanishing higher-order Bargmann invariants and show that their set coherence and set imaginarity are each related to whether they contain a pair of orthogonal states. Specifically, when the relevant higher-order Bargmann invariants vanish, the tuple contains a pair of orthogonal states if and only if removing some state makes the remaining tuple incoherent. Moreover, when maximally mixed states are excluded, the same vanishing conditions imply that the tuple is imaginarity-free if and only if it contains a pair of orthogonal states. As a consequence, under these conditions, a tuple of single-qubit states has imaginarity precisely when every tuple obtained by deleting one of its states is coherent.
The imaginary in quantum theory plays a crucial role in describing quantum coherence and is widely applied in quantum information tasks such as state discrimination, pseudorandomness generation, and quantum metrology. A recent paper by Fernandes et al. [C. Fernandes, R. Wagner, L. Novo, and E. F. Galvão, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 190201 (2024) ] showed how to use the Bargmann invariant to witness the imaginarity of a set of quantum states. In this work, we delve into the structure of Bargmann invariants and their quantum realization in qubit systems. First, we present a characterization of special sets of Bargmann invariants (also studied by Fernandes et al. for a set of four states) for a general set of nnn quantum states. Then, we study the properties of the relevant Bargmann invariant set Bn\mathcal{B}_nBn​ and its quantum realization in qubit systems. Our results provide new insights into the structure of Bargmann invariants, contributing to the advancement of quantum information techniques, particularly within qubit systems.
Set coherence is a quantum resource for a set of states that characterizes whether a collection of quantum states contains coherence, namely whether these states fail to be simultaneously incoherent in a common basis. In this work, we show that the free operations of set coherence are common commutativity-preserving quantum channels, from which we then establish an axiomatic framework for set-coherence measure (SCM). Within this framework, we investigate the robustness based measures deduced by taking, respectively, the average, maximum, and sum of the single-state robustnesses over a common reference basis, where the first two were previously introduced in the literature and we check here whether they satisfy our SCM axioms. Consequently, we show that the averaged robustness is an SCM but it is neither unified nor complete, the maximal robustness is a unified SCM but is neither complete nor strongly superadditive, whereas the sum robustness is a complete SCM. Furthermore, we propose several classes of SCMs based on pairwise commutators. We show that the Schatten ppp-norm based SCMs are complete and strongly superadditive. We also find that the universal fourth-order Bargmann gap measure proposed in the literature is a complete and strongly superadditive quantifier of set coherence. Finally, we discuss the operational meaning of the SCM in the context of optimal approximate quantum broadcasting, and show that the amount of set coherence can closely reflect the performance of this task.
Bargmann invariants, a class of unitary-invariant quantities arising from the overlaps of quantum state vectors, provide a profound and unifying framework for understanding the relative geometry of the projective Hilbert space. This survey offers a comprehensive overview of their theoretical characterization and practical applications, with particular emphasis on recent progress in determining the full structure of their admissible set. The core of this review demonstrates how these invariants serve as a powerful tool for characterizing the intrinsic geometry of the space of quantum states, leading to applications in determining local unitary equivalence and constructing a complete set of polynomial invariants for mixed states. On the operational side, we review the cycle-test quantum circuit for the direct estimation of Bargmann invariants without full state tomography, and demonstrate their utility in witnessing quantum imaginary, discriminating local unitary equivalence, and detecting entanglement via partial-transpose moments---with explicit complete invariant sets provided for two-qubit systems. By connecting fundamental geometric classification with experimentally feasible estimation protocols,this survey establishes Bargmann invariants as indispensable probes of the relational, noncommutative, and geometric structure of quantum states, and identifies key open problems for multipartite high-dimensional systems and for quantum resource theories.