We develop the kinematical and operator-algebraic foundations of a groupoid-based relational quantum field theory (RQFT) on curved spacetimes. Indeed, the usual group-based quantum reference frame (QRF) formalism is not directly suited to generic curved Lorentzian backgrounds as global symmetry groups are typically absent or too small. We formulate a notion of QRF for a continuous groupoid. This yields a groupoid relativization map and relational observables. We show that a localization limit recovers the ordinary non-relational description. We construct canonical sharp groupoid QRFs, which form the groupoidal counterpart of the ideal group QRFs based on $L^2(G)$. We further prove that the groupoid QRF construction reduces to the standard operational QRF formalism for locally compact groups. The action groupoid QRFs are torsor QRFs only for specific classes of fields of positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), and the torsor relativization map only applies to constant operator fields of system observables.
We review the foundations of RQFT in Minkowski spacetime. We prove new results that further link RQFT to Wightman QFT. We show that covariant POVMs are $μ$-continuous with respect to quasi-invariant $σ$-finite positive Borel measures $μ$. Thus, relational quantum fields can be understood as the smearing of pointwise-defined kernels with respect to the QRF's statistics. We develop RQFT in curved spacetime, where we argue that the correct replacement for the Poincaré group is the Poincaré groupoid of the spacetime. We also indicate how the framework extends further to internal gauge symmetry and relational gauge-covariant quantum field theory via Atiyah groupoids, providing a first step towards formulating a relational quantum Yang-Mills field theory.
Comments
78 pages, 7 figures. The paper is composed of two parts: the construction of groupoid quantum reference frames, and the development of relational quantum field theory. The arXiv abstract is abridged
We develop the kinematical and operator-algebraic foundations of a groupoid-based relational quantum field theory (RQFT) on curved spacetimes. Indeed, the usual group-based quantum reference frame (QRF) formalism is not directly suited to generic curved Lorentzian backgrounds as global symmetry groups are typically absent or too small. We formulate a notion of QRF for a continuous groupoid. This yields a groupoid relativization map and relational observables. We show that a localization limit recovers the ordinary non-relational description. We construct canonical sharp groupoid QRFs, which form the groupoidal counterpart of the ideal group QRFs based on L2(G). We further prove that the groupoid QRF construction reduces to the standard operational QRF formalism for locally compact groups. The action groupoid QRFs are torsor QRFs only for specific classes of fields of positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), and the torsor relativization map only applies to constant operator fields of system observables.
We review the foundations of RQFT in Minkowski spacetime. We prove new results that further link RQFT to Wightman QFT. We show that covariant POVMs are μ-continuous with respect to quasi-invariant σ-finite positive Borel measures μ. Thus, relational quantum fields can be understood as the smearing of pointwise-defined kernels with respect to the QRF's statistics. We develop RQFT in curved spacetime, where we argue that the correct replacement for the Poincaré group is the Poincaré groupoid of the spacetime. We also indicate how the framework extends further to internal gauge symmetry and relational gauge-covariant quantum field theory via Atiyah groupoids, providing a first step towards formulating a relational quantum Yang-Mills field theory.
Abstract We construct relational observables in group field theory (GFT) in terms of covariant positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), using techniques developed in the context of quantum reference frames (QRFs). We focus on matter QRFs; this can be generalized to other types of frames within the same POVM-based framework. The resulting family of relational observables provides a covariant framework to extract localized observables from GFT, which is typically defined in a perspective-neutral way. Then, we compare this formalism with previous proposals for relational observables in GFT. We find that our QRF-based relational observables overcome the intrinsic limitations of previous proposals while reproducing the same continuum limit results concerning expectation values of the number and volume operators on coherent states. Nonetheless, there can be important differences for more complex operators, as well as for other types of GFT states. Finally, we also use a specific class of POVMs to show how to project states and operators from the more general perspective-neutral GFT Fock space to a perspective-dependent one where a scalar matter field plays the role of a relational clock.
We develop an operational framework, combining relativistic quantum measurement theory with quantum reference frames (QRFs), in which local measurements of a quantum field on a background with symmetries are performed relative to a QRF. This yields a joint algebra of quantum-field and reference-frame observables that is invariant under the natural action of the group of spacetime isometries. For the appropriate class of quantum reference frames, this algebra is parameterised in terms of crossed products. Provided that the quantum field has good thermal properties (expressed by the existence of a KMS state at some nonzero temperature), one can use modular theory to show that the invariant algebra admits a semifinite trace. If furthermore the quantum reference frame has good thermal behaviour (expressed by the existence of a KMS weight) at the same temperature, this trace is finite. We give precise conditions for the invariant algebra of physical observables to be a type II1 factor. Our results build upon recent work of Chandrasekaran, Longo, Penington and Witten [JHEP 2023, 82 (2023)], providing both a significant mathematical generalisation of these findings and a refined operational understanding of their model.
This paper is the thirty-first in a sequence developing an interpretive framework that redescribes physical reality as a causally consistent history of information updates rather than as a collection of independently existing objects. It is the third panel — the capstone — of the eighth grouping, a foundational-physics trilogy. Its subject is spacetime localization: where and when a record or system is — its position, orientation, relative phase, and time. The claim is that localization is real but not authoritatively global. There is no Global Frame: no physically privileged reference system that fixes absolute location and orientation, a privileged global simultaneity, a classical frame standing outside quantum theory, and one physically privileged, globally valid perspectival gauge-fixing. Localization is relational: positions and times are defined relative to a declared quantum reference frame (QRF), itself a quantum system that may be superposed and entangled with what it localizes (Giacomini, Castro-Ruiz, & Brukner, 2019; Loveridge, Miyadera, & Busch, 2018). What keeps this objective rather than subjective is a strict typing of cross-frame comparison: a single gauge-invariant relational (Dirac) observable has one invariant prediction, its perspectival representations intertwined by a frame-change map (case A); distinct relational observables form a relationally consistent web (case B); and where two frames share no common refinement their claims are declared incomparable (case C). "Objective" means invariance of the physical predictions under the declared symmetry group and the frame-change groupoid over the admissible frame family, to a declared tolerance — never frame-independence in an absolute sense. The flagship R-A is a dynamics-independent kinematic existence witness: a finite-dimensional discrete-ring model exhibits one physical state and two admissible ideal QRFs under which the localization profile and the entanglement structure differ — a sharp product relative to one particle; an entangled state with a delocalized, mixed marginal relative to another — while the distribution of the same relational observable is preserved. R-B splits into a domain covariance on shared refinements (ideal QRFs compose and agree on shared Dirac predictions) and a model-dependent global-perspective obstruction: where a globally valid relational gauge-fixing fails, as in known Gribov-type models (Vanrietvelde, Höhn, & Giacomini, 2023), no single perspective covers the whole physical state space — which is neither the same as, nor a consequence of, the absence of a privileged frame, and does not preclude a perspective-neutral description. R-C places Paper 8's relational time as the time-translation special case, with its finite-resolution-clock, conditional-covariance, and record–clock qualifications, separating the retired claim (no global clock) from the deferred one (relativistic foliation with dynamical geometry). R-D identifies and transports the frame-representable localization sector of certain Paper-30 grains, partially discharging that paper's grain-coherence deferral while leaving interaction, fragmentation, redundancy, and history-family structure grain-relative. This completes the trilogy's dismantling of the Global Bookkeeper while keeping geometry fixed: the quantum-mechanics–gravity interface is prepared, not entered. Localization is frame-relative but objective: no absolute frame, no globally gauge-fixed perspective claimed beyond what models establish, and no anarchy. ALAC Paper 31. Third panel (capstone) of the eighth grouping — a foundational-physics trilogy (29 Public Quantum Records -> 30 Classicality Without a Global Classicalizer -> 31 Spacetime Localization Without a Global Frame). Part of the Consistency-Constrained Information History (Akashic Ledger Architecture Cosmology) series. Presents no new quantum mechanics; results are interpretive (L2) on imported physics (L1).
Abstract We develop an operational framework, combining relativistic quantum measurement theory with quantum reference frames (QRFs), in which local measurements of a quantum field on a background with symmetries are performed relative to a QRF. This yields a joint algebra of quantum-field and reference-frame observables that is invariant under the natural action of the group of spacetime isometries. For the appropriate class of quantum reference frames, this algebra is parameterised in terms of crossed products. Provided that the quantum field has good thermal properties (expressed by the existence of a KMS state at some nonzero temperature), one can use modular theory to show that the invariant algebra admits a semifinite trace. If furthermore the quantum reference frame has good thermal behaviour (expressed in terms of the properties of a KMS weight) at the same temperature, this trace is finite. We give precise conditions for the invariant algebra of physical observables to be a type II1 II 1 factor. Our results build upon recent work of Chandrasekaran et al. (J High Energy Phys 2023(2): 1–56, 2023. arXiv:2206.10780 ), providing both a significant mathematical generalisation of these findings and a refined operational understanding of their model.
We propose a relational bundle-geometric formulation of the gravitational path integral by invoking the new tool of quantum reference frames (QRFs), which in gravity are gauge-covariant coordinate systems constructed from the available field content. Formulated in terms of relational (frame-dressed) observables, this yields a manifestly gauge-invariant path integral without ghosts and anomalies, and in which observables and their correlators are local to a frame. While eliminating the need for gauge fixing, it is equivalent to Faddeev-Popov versions in which the QRF is gauge-fixed, recovering certain previous proposals. A key feature is its covariance under QRF changes: it is a perspective-neutral path integral which encodes all internal QRF perspectives and the transformations between them. This leads to several qualitative predictions: local correlators and time evolution of relational observables in one QRF perspective become fuzzy in another, and a new spectrum of relational vacua arises. Comprised of frame-dependent no-boundary and asymptotic ground states, a vacuum from one perspective appears generally excited in another. Finally, we construct gauge-invariant, yet frame-dependent effective actions by coupling sources exclusively to relational observables, setting the stage for a relational definition of renormalization.