Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.10540

State-Dependent Visibility of Non-Commutative Ordering in Quantum Dynamics

Ji-Chong Yang, Gui-Qi Hu

quant-phhep-latSubmitted Aug 11, 2026• Announced Aug 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A nonzero commutator proves that two orderings differ as operators, but it does not ensure that a physical state can reveal the difference. We ask when non-Abelian ordering information becomes dynamically invisible. For Hermitian operators $B$ and $C$, we compare the evolutions generated by the opposite-order products $M=(B+iC)(B-iC)$ and $\widetilde M=(B-iC)(B+iC)$, and define their operational visibility from the minimum overlap of the output states over a normalized time window. This visibility bounds the difference produced by the two orderings in every observable on the chosen state. An exact one-qubit solution shows that the same fixed pair can be perfectly invisible in one state and visible in another. We then keep the ordered generators fixed and vary only the many-body ground state across a quantum phase transition. The same ordering difference is nearly invisible in one regime and clearly visible in the other. Moreover, states with identical leading quadratic decay can develop sharply different finite-time visibility because their first distinction appears at higher order. The effect persists across distinct operator pairs and coefficient perturbations. Thus dynamical Abelianization is a property of the state-dependent process, i.e., non-Abelian ordering information can become operationally inaccessible even though the underlying operators remain non-commuting.

Comments
24 pages. 8 figures

Related papers

Operator Noncommutativity and Irreversibility in Quantum Chaos

Ryusuke Hamazaki, Kazuya Fujimoto, Masahito Ueda

We argue that two distinct probes of quantum chaos, i.e., the growth of noncommutativity of two unequal-time operators and the degree of irreversibility in a time-reversal test, are equivalent for initially localized states. We confirm this for interacting nonintegrable many-body systems and a quantum kicked rotor. Our results show that three-point out-of-time-ordered correlators dominate the growth of the squared commutator for initially localized states, in stark contrast to four-point out-of-time-ordered correlators that have extensively been studied for thermal initial states.

arXiv:1807.02360•Jul 6, 2018•9 citations

A Thermodynamic Criterion for Structural Persistence in Open Quantum Systems

Roberto Valtancoli

Complete dynamics and entropy balances of all proper subsystems need not determine global irreversibility. A three-qubit construction keeps one initial product state and every one- and two-qubit reduced semigroup fixed while changing only the organisation of energy-preserving shared phase events. The global entropy production changes, and the thermodynamic ranking of the full system against its proper subsystems reverses. Both trajectories remain separable, every compared score is positive, and interval bounds certify the opposite rankings.The comparison uses the finite-window Thermodynamic Criterion Index, the entropy reduction per unit outward entropy transfer. An exact lift identity determines when relational-information change exceeds the component deficit and the signed nonadditivity of entropy transfer. With common lower-order marginals and equal global export, a larger increment of irreducible higher-order information means an exactly equal reduction of global entropy production. At a common temperature and for an additive Hamiltonian, that information has a precise nonequilibrium free-energy value.Within the parity-contact model, fixed lower-order dynamics leave an explicit physical fibre of higher-order generators. Selective control inside this fibre changes a chosen collective decay rate. Two controllers with equal amounts of parity correlation can produce opposite thermodynamic rankings. Finite adaptive protocols confined to any fixed proper subsystem with private memory cannot identify the change; outcomes jointly retained from all three sites can reveal it. A certified pair of compatible generators gives nonzero lower bounds on the minimax absolute errors for global entropy production and the full-versus-proper yield gap, even with exact lower-order data. Complete lower-order descriptions therefore leave a physically controllable coordinate of global irreversibility undetermined.

•Apr 1, 2026•0 citations

The Hidden Nature of Non-Markovianity

Jihong Cai, Advith Govindarajan, Marius Junge

The theory of open quantum systems served as a tool to prepare entanglement at the beginning stage of quantum technology and more recently provides an important tool for state preparation. Dynamics given by time dependent Lindbladians are Markovian and lead to decoherence, decay of correlation and convergence to equilibrium. In contrast Non-Markovian evolutions can outperform their Markovian counterparts by enhancing memory. In this letter we compare the trajectories of Markovian and Non-Markovian evolutions starting from a fixed initial value. It turns out that under mild assumptions every trajectory can be obtained from a family of time dependent Lindbladians. Hence Non-Markovianity is invisible if single trajectories are concerned.

quant-pharXiv:2602.17631•Feb 20, 2026•0 citations

On two-qubit states ordering with quantum discords

M. Okrasa, Zbigniew Walczak

The counterintuitive effect of non-unique ordering of two-qubit states with quantum entanglement measures was discovered over ten years ago. More precisely, it was shown by Monte Carlo simulations that there exist states for which the entanglement of formation and the negativity do not impose the same ordering of states, i.e. E F (ρ AB )⩽(⩾)E F (ρ' AB ) is not equivalent to N (ρ AB )⩽(⩾) N (ρ' AB ). Recently, it was discovered that quantum discord and the geometric quantum discord do not necessarily imply the same ordering of two-qubit X -states, which means that the lack of the unique ordering of states with quantum entanglement measures goes beyond entanglement. Inspired by this observation, we study the problem of the states ordering with quantum discords, considering two-qubit Bell-diagonal states for analytical simplicity. In particular, we identify some classes of states for which the states ordering with quantum discords is preserved as long as the states belong to the same class and give a few illustrative examples.

arXiv:1109.4132•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•May 1, 2012•27 citations

Path Dependence and Confluence in Quantum Coarse-Graining

Yoshiki Ueoka

Does a sequence of quantum coarse-grainings depend only on its initial and final resolutions, or can the intermediate route remain operationally observable? We study finite-dimensional closed systems whose coarse descriptions are partitions of a fixed orthogonal fine decomposition. Each partition defines a non-selective L\"uders channel, and a monotone coarse-graining path alternates unitary evolution with nested L\"uders maps. Although all projectors commute at equal time, we exhibit a four-state example in which two paths with identical endpoints give final coarse probabilities $3/8$ and $5/8$. We show that arbitrary saturated merge paths are connected by two rank-two local moves, so local channel equality is sufficient for global monotone confluence. For each local comparison we derive an all-time necessary-and-sufficient microscopic criterion: the path defect vanishes exactly when Hamiltonian evolution never generates a coherence sector selected by the difference of the intermediate L\"uders maps. Equivalently, no local source block can dynamically feed both ends of a selected coherence pair. The first nonzero order is determined by a two-arm Hamiltonian--Krylov distance. Finally, we distinguish hereditary confluence from fixed-source confluence, where a nonzero local defect can remain inaccessible from the chosen global source. These results characterize when the history of changing coarse resolutions may be removed from an endpoint-based operational description.

•Sep 12, 2026•0 citations

Generative Response Geometry and First-Residue Accessibility

Katsuya Tagawa

We develop a finite operational response theory for controlled quantum systems in which observer closure, hidden microscopic structure, and higher-order response are treated within a single algebraic framework. The central distinction is between generic higher-order observability and Closure–Residue (CR)-constrained generative response. Standard finite-dimensional quantum theory does not, by itself, impose the specific CR accessibility condition introduced here; physically realizable controls are ordinarily determined by the microscopic Hamiltonian, hardware connectivity, conservation laws, and environmental couplings of the system under study. We therefore formulate First-Residue Accessibility as an additional finite selection principle for the coherent-control sector studied here: the infinitesimal deformation of the observer closure algebra generated by any admissible tangent in the declared target control manifold must lie in the first-residue derivation space inherited from an underlying microscopic CR sector. The algebraic consequences are rigid. Within this coherent-control sector, the maximal abelianness of the population algebra implies that the infinitesimal action of a control on the closure algebra determines its anti-Hermitian generator uniquely modulo a diagonal population gauge. First-Residue Accessibility therefore forces the declared coherent control class, up to this gauge, to lie in a canonical graph-internal subtype extracted from the microscopic CR sector. For diagonal prepared states, the visible first-order population response is silent, while the second variation factorizes through a graph-divergence map of a microscopic bilinear edge flow. A three-site single-excitation benchmark realizes the factorization exactly and yields an even response law of the form Sigma(epsilon X) = epsilon^2 Q_CR(X,X) + O(epsilon^4). We also separate exact discrete support transport from continuous-time quasilocality. A hard one-step support cone has a singular continuous-time limit whenever the limiting generator genuinely spreads local observables; finite propagation in the continuous limit must therefore be formulated by soft tails rather than exact support. We introduce a normalized-trace visible-leakage profile and derive a soft causal readout bound. In the coherent single-excitation sector this profile is uniformly equivalent, up to fixed observer-volume constants, to intrinsic operator-norm quasilocality. For finite-range exchange with simultaneous site dephasing we prove an N-uniform normalized-trace quasilocality estimate without using rank preservation. This genuinely nonunitary extension establishes a common finite-time exponential locality class with standard open-system quasilocality, while the stronger two-sided intrinsic equivalence is claimed only for the coherent unitary subclass. We further show that divergence-image membership is non-discriminating for connected full-population readout, construct an explicit standard CPTP control family that is first-order silent but violates the CR component constraint on a disconnected graph, and isolate experimentally measurable null tests. We distinguish a declared target-control manifold from the larger independently calibrated manifold of physically available coherent controls, thereby separating a conditional declared-manifold accessibility hypothesis from the stronger Physical First-Residue Accessibility statement. Under star-compatible oriented provenance we also derive an observable cross-prediction bound that links independently fixed static CR data to a measurable quadratic response coefficient. A framework-discriminating test requires both that the CR structure be fixed without using the target Hessian data and that the resulting constraint be stronger than what follows from the same calibrated microscopic information in a standard quantum model. We further exhibit a connected three-site collective-mode candidate in which CR Accessibility predicts an exact left–right quadratic null, while a same-support standard comparator constrained only by independently fixed aggregate tangent norms permits a nonzero response envelope. This yields a strict prediction-set separation under an explicit Dataset-A information condition, while also making clear that the separation disappears if standard microscopic calibration independently fixes the same collective tangent relation. We map this strict comparator onto a single-electron linear triple quantum dot, construct a four-point mixed-Hessian estimator, and propagate swap-odd instrumental asymmetry, finite-difference bias, and shot noise into a preregistered experimental envelope. The deeper derivation of the accessibility principle from the full Generative Map is left to the subsequent axiomatic stage of the program.

•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations
A nonzero commutator proves that two orderings differ as operators, but it does not ensure that a physical state can reveal the difference. We ask when non-Abelian ordering information becomes dynamically invisible. For Hermitian operators BBB and CCC, we compare the evolutions generated by the opposite-order products M=(B+iC)(B−iC)M=(B+iC)(B-iC)M=(B+iC)(B−iC) and M~=(B−iC)(B+iC)\widetilde M=(B-iC)(B+iC)M=(B−iC)(B+iC), and define their operational visibility from the minimum overlap of the output states over a normalized time window. This visibility bounds the difference produced by the two orderings in every observable on the chosen state. An exact one-qubit solution shows that the same fixed pair can be perfectly invisible in one state and visible in another. We then keep the ordered generators fixed and vary only the many-body ground state across a quantum phase transition. The same ordering difference is nearly invisible in one regime and clearly visible in the other. Moreover, states with identical leading quadratic decay can develop sharply different finite-time visibility because their first distinction appears at higher order. The effect persists across distinct operator pairs and coefficient perturbations. Thus dynamical Abelianization is a property of the state-dependent process, i.e., non-Abelian ordering information can become operationally inaccessible even though the underlying operators remain non-commuting.
We argue that two distinct probes of quantum chaos, i.e., the growth of noncommutativity of two unequal-time operators and the degree of irreversibility in a time-reversal test, are equivalent for initially localized states. We confirm this for interacting nonintegrable many-body systems and a quantum kicked rotor. Our results show that three-point out-of-time-ordered correlators dominate the growth of the squared commutator for initially localized states, in stark contrast to four-point out-of-time-ordered correlators that have extensively been studied for thermal initial states.
Complete dynamics and entropy balances of all proper subsystems need not determine global irreversibility. A three-qubit construction keeps one initial product state and every one- and two-qubit reduced semigroup fixed while changing only the organisation of energy-preserving shared phase events. The global entropy production changes, and the thermodynamic ranking of the full system against its proper subsystems reverses. Both trajectories remain separable, every compared score is positive, and interval bounds certify the opposite rankings.The comparison uses the finite-window Thermodynamic Criterion Index, the entropy reduction per unit outward entropy transfer. An exact lift identity determines when relational-information change exceeds the component deficit and the signed nonadditivity of entropy transfer. With common lower-order marginals and equal global export, a larger increment of irreducible higher-order information means an exactly equal reduction of global entropy production. At a common temperature and for an additive Hamiltonian, that information has a precise nonequilibrium free-energy value.Within the parity-contact model, fixed lower-order dynamics leave an explicit physical fibre of higher-order generators. Selective control inside this fibre changes a chosen collective decay rate. Two controllers with equal amounts of parity correlation can produce opposite thermodynamic rankings. Finite adaptive protocols confined to any fixed proper subsystem with private memory cannot identify the change; outcomes jointly retained from all three sites can reveal it. A certified pair of compatible generators gives nonzero lower bounds on the minimax absolute errors for global entropy production and the full-versus-proper yield gap, even with exact lower-order data. Complete lower-order descriptions therefore leave a physically controllable coordinate of global irreversibility undetermined.
The theory of open quantum systems served as a tool to prepare entanglement at the beginning stage of quantum technology and more recently provides an important tool for state preparation. Dynamics given by time dependent Lindbladians are Markovian and lead to decoherence, decay of correlation and convergence to equilibrium. In contrast Non-Markovian evolutions can outperform their Markovian counterparts by enhancing memory. In this letter we compare the trajectories of Markovian and Non-Markovian evolutions starting from a fixed initial value. It turns out that under mild assumptions every trajectory can be obtained from a family of time dependent Lindbladians. Hence Non-Markovianity is invisible if single trajectories are concerned.
The counterintuitive effect of non-unique ordering of two-qubit states with quantum entanglement measures was discovered over ten years ago. More precisely, it was shown by Monte Carlo simulations that there exist states for which the entanglement of formation and the negativity do not impose the same ordering of states, i.e. E F (ρ AB )⩽(⩾)E F (ρ' AB ) is not equivalent to N (ρ AB )⩽(⩾) N (ρ' AB ). Recently, it was discovered that quantum discord and the geometric quantum discord do not necessarily imply the same ordering of two-qubit X -states, which means that the lack of the unique ordering of states with quantum entanglement measures goes beyond entanglement. Inspired by this observation, we study the problem of the states ordering with quantum discords, considering two-qubit Bell-diagonal states for analytical simplicity. In particular, we identify some classes of states for which the states ordering with quantum discords is preserved as long as the states belong to the same class and give a few illustrative examples.
Does a sequence of quantum coarse-grainings depend only on its initial and final resolutions, or can the intermediate route remain operationally observable? We study finite-dimensional closed systems whose coarse descriptions are partitions of a fixed orthogonal fine decomposition. Each partition defines a non-selective L\"uders channel, and a monotone coarse-graining path alternates unitary evolution with nested L\"uders maps. Although all projectors commute at equal time, we exhibit a four-state example in which two paths with identical endpoints give final coarse probabilities 3/83/83/8 and 5/85/85/8. We show that arbitrary saturated merge paths are connected by two rank-two local moves, so local channel equality is sufficient for global monotone confluence. For each local comparison we derive an all-time necessary-and-sufficient microscopic criterion: the path defect vanishes exactly when Hamiltonian evolution never generates a coherence sector selected by the difference of the intermediate L\"uders maps. Equivalently, no local source block can dynamically feed both ends of a selected coherence pair. The first nonzero order is determined by a two-arm Hamiltonian--Krylov distance. Finally, we distinguish hereditary confluence from fixed-source confluence, where a nonzero local defect can remain inaccessible from the chosen global source. These results characterize when the history of changing coarse resolutions may be removed from an endpoint-based operational description.
We develop a finite operational response theory for controlled quantum systems in which observer closure, hidden microscopic structure, and higher-order response are treated within a single algebraic framework. The central distinction is between generic higher-order observability and Closure–Residue (CR)-constrained generative response. Standard finite-dimensional quantum theory does not, by itself, impose the specific CR accessibility condition introduced here; physically realizable controls are ordinarily determined by the microscopic Hamiltonian, hardware connectivity, conservation laws, and environmental couplings of the system under study. We therefore formulate First-Residue Accessibility as an additional finite selection principle for the coherent-control sector studied here: the infinitesimal deformation of the observer closure algebra generated by any admissible tangent in the declared target control manifold must lie in the first-residue derivation space inherited from an underlying microscopic CR sector. The algebraic consequences are rigid. Within this coherent-control sector, the maximal abelianness of the population algebra implies that the infinitesimal action of a control on the closure algebra determines its anti-Hermitian generator uniquely modulo a diagonal population gauge. First-Residue Accessibility therefore forces the declared coherent control class, up to this gauge, to lie in a canonical graph-internal subtype extracted from the microscopic CR sector. For diagonal prepared states, the visible first-order population response is silent, while the second variation factorizes through a graph-divergence map of a microscopic bilinear edge flow. A three-site single-excitation benchmark realizes the factorization exactly and yields an even response law of the form Sigma(epsilon X) = epsilon^2 Q_CR(X,X) + O(epsilon^4). We also separate exact discrete support transport from continuous-time quasilocality. A hard one-step support cone has a singular continuous-time limit whenever the limiting generator genuinely spreads local observables; finite propagation in the continuous limit must therefore be formulated by soft tails rather than exact support. We introduce a normalized-trace visible-leakage profile and derive a soft causal readout bound. In the coherent single-excitation sector this profile is uniformly equivalent, up to fixed observer-volume constants, to intrinsic operator-norm quasilocality. For finite-range exchange with simultaneous site dephasing we prove an N-uniform normalized-trace quasilocality estimate without using rank preservation. This genuinely nonunitary extension establishes a common finite-time exponential locality class with standard open-system quasilocality, while the stronger two-sided intrinsic equivalence is claimed only for the coherent unitary subclass. We further show that divergence-image membership is non-discriminating for connected full-population readout, construct an explicit standard CPTP control family that is first-order silent but violates the CR component constraint on a disconnected graph, and isolate experimentally measurable null tests. We distinguish a declared target-control manifold from the larger independently calibrated manifold of physically available coherent controls, thereby separating a conditional declared-manifold accessibility hypothesis from the stronger Physical First-Residue Accessibility statement. Under star-compatible oriented provenance we also derive an observable cross-prediction bound that links independently fixed static CR data to a measurable quadratic response coefficient. A framework-discriminating test requires both that the CR structure be fixed without using the target Hessian data and that the resulting constraint be stronger than what follows from the same calibrated microscopic information in a standard quantum model. We further exhibit a connected three-site collective-mode candidate in which CR Accessibility predicts an exact left–right quadratic null, while a same-support standard comparator constrained only by independently fixed aggregate tangent norms permits a nonzero response envelope. This yields a strict prediction-set separation under an explicit Dataset-A information condition, while also making clear that the separation disappears if standard microscopic calibration independently fixes the same collective tangent relation. We map this strict comparator onto a single-electron linear triple quantum dot, construct a four-point mixed-Hessian estimator, and propagate swap-odd instrumental asymmetry, finite-difference bias, and shot noise into a preregistered experimental envelope. The deeper derivation of the accessibility principle from the full Generative Map is left to the subsequent axiomatic stage of the program.