Under stated assumptions, a static surface-code patch that adds no fold or \mbox{self-dual} structure cannot perform the magic-axis check that magic-state cultivation relies on while still accepting often. This is a conditional no-go. Fault-tolerant machines spend much of their cost making magic states, and cultivation makes them in place by measuring the magic axis, which every known construction does through a fold or \mbox{self-dual} patch that it is folklore to call necessary. We test the folklore. The no-go says that a useful check must pay for the magic axis somewhere. It can add a charge-converting resource, it can leave the dilute regime of its accepted history, or it can accept only exponentially rarely. For a single stabilizer-measurement transcript this is proved outright, from a topological reading of the accepted outcome. For adaptive, post-selected protocols in a bounded-depth (polynomial spacetime-volume) model, it holds under two structural assumptions plus a subcriticality assumption. We isolate the one open assumption, show that protection alone does not force it, and give the threshold any resolution must address. What remains is a single conjecture.
Under stated assumptions, a static surface-code patch that adds no fold or \mbox{self-dual} structure cannot perform the magic-axis check that magic-state cultivation relies on while still accepting often. This is a conditional no-go. Fault-tolerant machines spend much of their cost making magic states, and cultivation makes them in place by measuring the magic axis, which every known construction does through a fold or \mbox{self-dual} patch that it is folklore to call necessary. We test the folklore. The no-go says that a useful check must pay for the magic axis somewhere. It can add a charge-converting resource, it can leave the dilute regime of its accepted history, or it can accept only exponentially rarely. For a single stabilizer-measurement transcript this is proved outright, from a topological reading of the accepted outcome. For adaptive, post-selected protocols in a bounded-depth (polynomial spacetime-volume) model, it holds under two structural assumptions plus a subcriticality assumption. We isolate the one open assumption, show that protection alone does not force it, and give the threshold any resolution must address. What remains is a single conjecture.
We bound the magic of a post-selected logical measurement by the resource that produced it. The setting is one code block with one logical qubit and an adaptive protocol that measures, feeds forward and accepts. The witness reads the accepted effect against the free set of the resource theory of magic, outcome by outcome and not on the averaged channel, since a channel can be free while one of its outcomes measures the magic axis. Our first bound is unconditional. The accepted magic is at most a constant times the summed distance of the cells from the free set. The second is the main result. When the resource cells sit inside a bounded-spread exact-recovery skeleton, the recovery puts every insertion history below a threshold onto a single free branch, transcript by transcript, so only connected clusters reaching the threshold contribute and an exact-component expansion controls their weight. With a threshold linear in the code distance, polynomially many cells of bounded insertion degree and per-cell dilation amplitude O(1/d), the accepted magic times the acceptance probability is at most exp[−Ω(dlogd)]. Post-selection is disposed of before accepted transcripts are summed, so a branch of vanishing probability cannot be amplified into a magic effect. The threshold is certified from a circuit, and we run it on one exact round of stabilizer measurement followed by a split readout, which measures logical X on the accepted fibre and logical Z on the rejected ones. That certifies a threshold equal to the code distance for every single-layer pattern of weak Z-rotations, one per data qubit, so the hypotheses are met by a family and not one design. A member carries magic only if its support contains a logical Z string. One member attains the exponent, again at the level of the accepted effect. Suppression is set by the threshold and not by the topology of the block.
Fault-tolerant quantum computing requires a universal gate set, but the necessary non-Clifford gates represent a significant resource cost for most quantum error correction architectures. Magic state cultivation offers an efficient alternative to resource-intensive distillation protocols; however, testing the proposal's assumptions represents a challenging departure from quantum memory experiments. We present an experimental study of magic state cultivation on a superconducting quantum processor. We implement cultivation, including code-switching into a surface code, and develop a fault-tolerant measurement protocol to bound the magic state fidelity. Cultivation reduces the error by a factor of 40, with a state fidelity of 0.9999(1) (retaining 8% of attempts). Our results experimentally establish magic state cultivation as a viable solution to one of quantum computing's most significant challenges.
Magic state cultivation is a state-of-the-art protocol to prepare ultra-high fidelity non-Clifford resource states for universal quantum computation. It offers a significant reduction in spacetime overhead compared to traditional magic state distillation techniques. Cultivation protocols involve measuring a transversal logical Clifford operator on an initial small-distance code and then rapidly growing to a larger-distance code. In this work, we present a new cultivation scheme in which we measure the fold-transversal Hadamard of the unrotated surface code, and leverage unitary techniques to grow within the surface code family. Using both stabilizer and state vector simulations we find that this approach achieves the lowest known spacetime overhead for magic state cultivation. Practical implementation of our protocol is best suited to architectures with nonlocal connectivity, showing the strength of architectures where such connectivity is readily available.
Magic states are a scarce resource for two-dimensional qubit stabilizer codes. Magic state cultivation was recently proposed to reduce the cost of magic state preparation by measuring the transversal Clifford operator of the color code. Cultivation achieves ∼10−9 logical error rates for the d=5 color code, with substantially lower space-time overhead than magic state distillation. However, due to the O(d) depth of the Clifford measurement circuit, magic state cultivation becomes impractical for d>5. Here, we perform logical XS† measurements on the color code by gauging a transversal Clifford gate, resulting in a constant-depth logical measurement circuit. We employ repeated gauging measurements with post-selection rather than performing error correction on the Clifford stabilizer code that emerges during the gauging protocol, thus gaining simplicity at the cost of scalability. Our protocol requires a regular square grid connectivity and yields logical error rates comparable to magic state cultivation. The d=7 version of our protocol gives access to the 10−12 logical error rate regime at 0.05% physical error rate while retaining more than 1% of the shots after the equivalent of the cultivation stage.
Magic state cultivation is a promising method for preparing high-fidelity non-Clifford resource states - a central component of fault-tolerant quantum computing - with low spacetime overhead. In benchmarking cultivation, existing resource estimates assume access to noiseless transversal measurement of the output magic state to allow for postselection during the final escape stage of the cultivation process. However, such measurements would destroy the magic state and are therefore unavailable during computation. We develop an open-boundary postselection method, Caliper, that uses only nondestructive mid-circuit syndrome information and substantially outperforms existing methods operating under these constraints. In some regimes, our postselection method uniquely recovers the resource efficiency of prior estimates. However, in other cases, we observe a tradeoff. At spacetime costs reported in previous works, the achievable logical error rates can be orders of magnitude higher, and recovering the reported logical error rate requires substantially larger codes and longer escape stages. Our results highlight how practical considerations involving mid-circuit postselection can impact the design and performance of magic state cultivation protocols.
Preparation of high-fidelity logical magic states is crucial for fault-tolerant quantum computation. Among previous attempts to reduce the substantial cost of magic state preparation, magic state cultivation (MSC) [Gidney , Magic state cultivation: growing T states as cheap as CNOT gates, arXiv:2409.17595], a recently proposed protocol for logical T state preparation without magic state distillation, achieves state-of-the-art efficiency. Inspired by this work [Gidney , Magic state cultivation: growing T states as cheap as CNOT gates, arXiv:2409.17595], we propose a MSC procedure that can produce logical T states on the rotated surface code at a further reduced cost. To maintain high efficiency throughout our protocol, we design structured codes along with compact circuits bridging between them. More specifically, we construct a code family, the RP code, by putting the rotated surface code on R P 2 (a two-dimensional manifold), as well as two self-dual Calderbank-Shor-Steane codes, named SRP-3 and SRP-5, respectively. In our MSC protocol, we start with a cultivation process, in which a high-fidelity T state is prepared on a small RP code with distance 3 or 5. Then, to preserve the logical T state, we use an efficient and easy-to-decode expansion stage to grow a small RP code to a larger rotated surface code in one syndrome extraction (SE) round. The RP code serves as an efficient transfer station with efficient SE circuits and compact interfaces between the SRP-3 (or SRP-5) code—used in the cultivation process to efficiently verify the correctness of the logical T state—and larger rotated surface codes for preserving the prepared logical T state. Our MSC protocol utilizes nonlocal connectivity, available on both neutral atom array and ion trap platforms. According to our Monte Carlo sampling results, our MSC protocol requires about an order of magnitude smaller space-time volume to reach a target logical error rate of around 10 − 9 compared to the original MSC protocol.