Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.10632

Semiclassical asymptotics of multiphotonic scattering probabilities with partial indistinguishability

Alonso Botero, Hubert de Guise, Orlando Melo-Vargas

quant-phmath-phSubmitted Jul 12, 2026• Announced Jul 14, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose a framework for computing multiphotonic scattering probabilities in a lossless multiport interferometer for arbitrary photon numbers and degrees of indistinguishability. By exploiting a toroidal expansion of multiphotonic states in tensor powers of single-particle states, the framework defines a map from a torus of relative phases to the probability simplex that governs the asymptotic behavior of scattering probabilities in the large-photon limit. Specifically, the probabilities concentrate on the "classically allowed region" defined by the map, and the slowly-varying part of the multiphotonic distribution reproduces a classical measure induced by the map. As a result, we are able to establish a new asymptotic formula for the multiphotonic probabilities in a general scenario of partially indistinguishable photons, while also providing a single-particle picture to explain the asymptotics of known multiphotonic transition amplitudes in the fully indistinguishable case. More broadly, our framework yields new, directly testable consequences in relation to asymptotic photon bunching patterns: it translates features of the classical map -- such as caustics and voids -- into direct predictions about regions of large or exponentially suppressed photon-distribution probability.

AI Summary

The paper studies multiphoton scattering in a lossless $M$-port interferometer as $N\to\infty$ with $M$ and normalized input/output occupations fixed. It treats “correlated mode states”: photons entering each port share a pure internal state, while states associated with different ports have overlaps encoded by a Gram matrix $\Gamma$. A Fourier projection expands the input state into tensor powers of single-particle states parametrized by relative phases. This yields an exact double-torus integral for scattering probabilities and a classical map $\phi\mapsto\operatorname{Diag}(Ut_\phi\rho t_\phi^\dagger U^\dagger)$, where $\rho=[\bar n]^{1/2}\Gamma[\bar n]^{1/2}$. Its image $\mathcal R$ controls the large-$N$ distribution. In particular, $P(n'|U,n,\Gamma)\leq(N+1)^M e^{-N\min_{\nu\in\mathcal R}D(\bar n'\|\nu)}$, establishing exponential suppression outside the classically allowed region. At regular points, complex Laplace analysis shows that $N^{M-1}P_{\mathrm{slow}}$ converges to the pushforward of uniform phase measure, with density given by a sum of inverse absolute Jacobian determinants. For generic interferometers and full-rank $\rho$, off-diagonal interference contributions vanish asymptotically, so this density describes the full probability. Perfect indistinguishability instead recovers known semiclassical amplitude formulas with interference phases. Three-port examples at $N=24$ and $48$ illustrate suppressed-probability voids, enhanced-probability caustics, and interference fringes. The analysis excludes caustics from its pointwise asymptotic formulas. Stated open extensions include sharp forbidden-region exponential rates, uniform treatment of caustics and allowed–forbidden transitions, intermediate-rank Gram matrices, and higher-port geometry. The fixed-$M$ regime and restricted input family do not cover general partially distinguishable boson-sampling inputs.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Error found: The abstract omits that the framework covers correlated mode inputs, with a single pure internal state shared by all photons entering each port, rather than arbitrary partially distinguishishable multiphoton inputs. The asymptotic results require fixed port number, and the envelope and pointwise probability formulas exclude caustics and other nonregular points, qualifications absent from the abstract. Equation (action) mishandles square-root phase branches and, for a balanced two-port example at regular output points, predicts a nonzero leading probability where the exact probability is zero.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
35 pages, 6 figures

Related papers

Partial indistinguishability theory for multiphoton experiments in multiport devices

V. S. Shchesnovich

We generalize an approach for description of multiphoton experiments with multiport unitary linear optical devices, started in Phys. Rev. A 89, 022333 (2014) with single photons in mixed spectral states, to arbitrary (multiphoton) input and arbitrary photon detectors. We show that output probabilities are always given in terms of the matrix permanents of the Hadamard product of a matrix built from the network matrix and matrices built from the spectral state of photons and spectral sensitivities of detectors. Moreover, in the case of input with up to one photon per mode, the output probabilities are given by a sum (or integral) with each term being the absolute value squared of such a matrix permanent. We conjecture that, for an arbitrary multiphoton input, zero output probability of an output configuration is always the result of an exact cancellation of quantum transition amplitudes of completely indistinguishable photons (a subset of all input photons) and, moreover, is independent of coherence between only partially indistinguishable photons. The conjecture is supported by examples. Furthermore, we propose a measure of partial indistinguishability of photons which generalizes Mandel's observation, and find the law of degradation of quantum coherence in a realistic boson-sampling device with increase of the total number of photons and/or their ``classicality parameter.''

arXiv:1410.1506•Physical Review A•Jan 29, 2015•111 citations

The quantum beam splitter with many partially indistinguishable photons: multiphotonic interference and asymptotic classical correspondence

Miguel Villalobos, Alejandra Valencia, Alonso Botero

We present the asymptotic analysis of the quantum two-port interferometer in the $n \rightarrow \infty$ limit of $n$ partially indistinguishable photons. Using the unitary-unitary duality between port and inner-mode degrees of freedom, the probability distribution of output port counts can be decomposed as a sum of contributions from independent channels, each associated to a spin-$j$ representation of $SU(2)$ and, in this context, to $2 j$ effectively indistinguishable photons in the channel. Our main result is that the asymptotic output distribution is dominated by the $O(\sqrt{n})$ channels around a certain $j^*$ that depends on the degree of indistinguishability. The asymptotic form is essentially the doubly-humped semi-classical envelope of the distribution that would arise from $2 j^*$ indistinguishable photons, and which reproduces the corresponding classical intensity distribution.

arXiv:2312.16774•Dec 28, 2023•0 citations

A unified framework for anomalous boson bunching

Léo Pioge, Leonardo Novo, Nicolas J. Cerf

Anomalous bunching is a paradoxical quantum interferometric phenomenon in which partially distinguishable photons exhibit a higher probability of bunching into two or more modes than fully indistinguishable photons [Nat. Photonics 17, 702 (2023)]. While this effect is directly linked to violations of certain conjectures on matrix permanents, the mechanism underlying the anomaly is not yet fully understood. Here, we show that boson bunching is governed not by internal indistinguishability alone, but by the total indistinguishability of the postselected output state. Total indistinguishability combines the internal degrees of freedom, such as polarization or arrival time, with the spatial degrees of freedom of their wave functions restricted to the measured output modes of the interferometer. This reformulation preserves the expected connection between boson bunching and total indistinguishability, while clarifying how anomalous bunching can arise. It also reveals several additional facets of the same phenomenon, which are captured within a unified framework. In particular, we exhibit situations in which adding an independent source of distinguishability, either internal or spatial, can enhance multimode or even single-mode bunching probabilities, offering new insights into the subtle role of distinguishability in multiphoton interference.

quant-pharXiv:2607.19499•Jul 23, 2026•0 citations

Large photon number semiclassical asymptotics of the HOM interferometer with partially indistinguishable photons

Miguel Villalobos, Alejandra Valencia, Alonso Botero

The classical correspondence of the HOM interferometer with n → ∞ partially indistinguishable photons is shown to arise from a concentration phenomenon of the quantum state in a Hilbert-space sector that can be associated with a well-defined macroscopic fraction of effectively indisistinguishable photons.

Latin America Optics and Photonics Conference•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Optimal interferometric certification of multi-photon indistinguishability

Marco Robbio, Michał Oszmaniec, Nicolas J. Cerf +2 more

Multiphoton indistinguishability is a key resource for photonic quantum technologies, yet its characterization typically relies on resource-intensive methods. In this work, we develop two efficient and experimentally friendly protocols to estimate or bound the fidelity $F_{\mathrm{ind}}$ of an $N$-photon state to the closest perfectly indistinguishable state. The first protocol applies to sources preparing separable states, uses a single Fourier interferometer together with photon-number-resolving detection, and yields tight two-sided bounds on $F_{\mathrm{ind}}$. The second protocol combines randomized implementations of linear-optical interferometers with photon counting, enabling direct estimation of $F_{\mathrm{ind}}$ for arbitrary $N$-photon states. Both protocols can certify $F_{\mathrm{ind}} = 1 - \mathcal{O}(ε)$ using provably optimal $\mathcal{O}(1/ε)$ samples, in contrast to previous approaches which required prior assumptions on the model of partial distinguishability. Our methods, based on a multiphoton generalization of the Hong-Ou-Mandel test, bring the rigorous and operationally meaningful certification of multiphoton indistinguishability within reach of current photonic technologies.

quant-pharXiv:2609.37620•Sep 30, 2026•0 citations

Bunching effect and quantum statistics of partially indistinguishable photons

Fang‐Wen Sun, Ao Shen, Yang Dong +2 more

The quantum statistics of particles is determined by both the spins and the indistinguishability of quantum states. Here we study the quantum statistics of partially distinguishable photons by defining the multiphoton indistinguishability. The photon-bunching coefficient is formulated based on the properties of permutation symmetry and a modified Bose-Einstein statistics is presented with an indistinguishability-induced photon-bunching effect. Moreover, the statistical transition of the photon state is studied for partially distinguishable photons and the results show that the indistinguishability exhibits the same role as that observed in the generation of laser. The results will fill the gap between Bose-Einstein and Poisson statistics for photons and a formula is presented for the study of multiphoton quantum information processes.

arXiv:1707.09137•Physical Review A•Aug 9, 2017•4 citations
We propose a framework for computing multiphotonic scattering probabilities in a lossless multiport interferometer for arbitrary photon numbers and degrees of indistinguishability. By exploiting a toroidal expansion of multiphotonic states in tensor powers of single-particle states, the framework defines a map from a torus of relative phases to the probability simplex that governs the asymptotic behavior of scattering probabilities in the large-photon limit. Specifically, the probabilities concentrate on the "classically allowed region" defined by the map, and the slowly-varying part of the multiphotonic distribution reproduces a classical measure induced by the map. As a result, we are able to establish a new asymptotic formula for the multiphotonic probabilities in a general scenario of partially indistinguishable photons, while also providing a single-particle picture to explain the asymptotics of known multiphotonic transition amplitudes in the fully indistinguishable case. More broadly, our framework yields new, directly testable consequences in relation to asymptotic photon bunching patterns: it translates features of the classical map -- such as caustics and voids -- into direct predictions about regions of large or exponentially suppressed photon-distribution probability.
The paper studies multiphoton scattering in a lossless MMM-port interferometer as N→∞N\to\inftyN→∞ with MMM and normalized input/output occupations fixed. It treats “correlated mode states”: photons entering each port share a pure internal state, while states associated with different ports have overlaps encoded by a Gram matrix Γ\GammaΓ.
A Fourier projection expands the input state into tensor powers of single-particle states parametrized by relative phases. This yields an exact double-torus integral for scattering probabilities and a classical map ϕ↦Diag⁡(Utϕρtϕ†U†)\phi\mapsto\operatorname{Diag}(Ut_\phi\rho t_\phi^\dagger U^\dagger)ϕ↦Diag(Utϕ​ρtϕ†​U†), where ρ=[nˉ]1/2Γ[nˉ]1/2\rho=[\bar n]^{1/2}\Gamma[\bar n]^{1/2}ρ=[nˉ]1/2Γ[nˉ]1/2. Its image R\mathcal RR controls the large-NNN distribution. In particular, P(n′∣U,n,Γ)≤(N+1)Me−Nmin⁡ν∈RD(nˉ′∥ν)P(n'|U,n,\Gamma)\leq(N+1)^M e^{-N\min_{\nu\in\mathcal R}D(\bar n'\|\nu)}P(n′∣U,n,Γ)≤(N+1)Me−Nminν∈R​D(nˉ′∥ν), establishing exponential suppression outside the classically allowed region.
At regular points, complex Laplace analysis shows that NM−1PslowN^{M-1}P_{\mathrm{slow}}NM−1Pslow​ converges to the pushforward of uniform phase measure, with density given by a sum of inverse absolute Jacobian determinants. For generic interferometers and full-rank ρ\rhoρ, off-diagonal interference contributions vanish asymptotically, so this density describes the full probability. Perfect indistinguishability instead recovers known semiclassical amplitude formulas with interference phases. Three-port examples at N=24N=24N=24 and 484848 illustrate suppressed-probability voids, enhanced-probability caustics, and interference fringes.
The analysis excludes caustics from its pointwise asymptotic formulas. Stated open extensions include sharp forbidden-region exponential rates, uniform treatment of caustics and allowed–forbidden transitions, intermediate-rank Gram matrices, and higher-port geometry. The fixed-MMM regime and restricted input family do not cover general partially distinguishable boson-sampling inputs.
We generalize an approach for description of multiphoton experiments with multiport unitary linear optical devices, started in Phys. Rev. A 89, 022333 (2014) with single photons in mixed spectral states, to arbitrary (multiphoton) input and arbitrary photon detectors. We show that output probabilities are always given in terms of the matrix permanents of the Hadamard product of a matrix built from the network matrix and matrices built from the spectral state of photons and spectral sensitivities of detectors. Moreover, in the case of input with up to one photon per mode, the output probabilities are given by a sum (or integral) with each term being the absolute value squared of such a matrix permanent. We conjecture that, for an arbitrary multiphoton input, zero output probability of an output configuration is always the result of an exact cancellation of quantum transition amplitudes of completely indistinguishable photons (a subset of all input photons) and, moreover, is independent of coherence between only partially indistinguishable photons. The conjecture is supported by examples. Furthermore, we propose a measure of partial indistinguishability of photons which generalizes Mandel's observation, and find the law of degradation of quantum coherence in a realistic boson-sampling device with increase of the total number of photons and/or their ``classicality parameter.''
We present the asymptotic analysis of the quantum two-port interferometer in the n→∞n \rightarrow \inftyn→∞ limit of nnn partially indistinguishable photons. Using the unitary-unitary duality between port and inner-mode degrees of freedom, the probability distribution of output port counts can be decomposed as a sum of contributions from independent channels, each associated to a spin-jjj representation of SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) and, in this context, to 2j2 j2j effectively indistinguishable photons in the channel. Our main result is that the asymptotic output distribution is dominated by the O(n)O(\sqrt{n})O(n​) channels around a certain j∗j^*j∗ that depends on the degree of indistinguishability. The asymptotic form is essentially the doubly-humped semi-classical envelope of the distribution that would arise from 2j∗2 j^*2j∗ indistinguishable photons, and which reproduces the corresponding classical intensity distribution.
Anomalous bunching is a paradoxical quantum interferometric phenomenon in which partially distinguishable photons exhibit a higher probability of bunching into two or more modes than fully indistinguishable photons [Nat. Photonics 17, 702 (2023)]. While this effect is directly linked to violations of certain conjectures on matrix permanents, the mechanism underlying the anomaly is not yet fully understood. Here, we show that boson bunching is governed not by internal indistinguishability alone, but by the total indistinguishability of the postselected output state. Total indistinguishability combines the internal degrees of freedom, such as polarization or arrival time, with the spatial degrees of freedom of their wave functions restricted to the measured output modes of the interferometer. This reformulation preserves the expected connection between boson bunching and total indistinguishability, while clarifying how anomalous bunching can arise. It also reveals several additional facets of the same phenomenon, which are captured within a unified framework. In particular, we exhibit situations in which adding an independent source of distinguishability, either internal or spatial, can enhance multimode or even single-mode bunching probabilities, offering new insights into the subtle role of distinguishability in multiphoton interference.
Multiphoton indistinguishability is a key resource for photonic quantum technologies, yet its characterization typically relies on resource-intensive methods. In this work, we develop two efficient and experimentally friendly protocols to estimate or bound the fidelity FindF_{\mathrm{ind}}Find​ of an NNN-photon state to the closest perfectly indistinguishable state. The first protocol applies to sources preparing separable states, uses a single Fourier interferometer together with photon-number-resolving detection, and yields tight two-sided bounds on FindF_{\mathrm{ind}}Find​. The second protocol combines randomized implementations of linear-optical interferometers with photon counting, enabling direct estimation of FindF_{\mathrm{ind}}Find​ for arbitrary NNN-photon states. Both protocols can certify Find=1−O(ε)F_{\mathrm{ind}} = 1 - \mathcal{O}(ε)Find​=1−O(ε) using provably optimal O(1/ε)\mathcal{O}(1/ε)O(1/ε) samples, in contrast to previous approaches which required prior assumptions on the model of partial distinguishability. Our methods, based on a multiphoton generalization of the Hong-Ou-Mandel test, bring the rigorous and operationally meaningful certification of multiphoton indistinguishability within reach of current photonic technologies.
The quantum statistics of particles is determined by both the spins and the indistinguishability of quantum states. Here we study the quantum statistics of partially distinguishable photons by defining the multiphoton indistinguishability. The photon-bunching coefficient is formulated based on the properties of permutation symmetry and a modified Bose-Einstein statistics is presented with an indistinguishability-induced photon-bunching effect. Moreover, the statistical transition of the photon state is studied for partially distinguishable photons and the results show that the indistinguishability exhibits the same role as that observed in the generation of laser. The results will fill the gap between Bose-Einstein and Poisson statistics for photons and a formula is presented for the study of multiphoton quantum information processes.