Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.09769

Challenges in the simulation of enzymatic transition states with emerging multireference character

Valentin Kasper, Sanjoy Ray, Matthias Kaiser

On Aqora:Valentin KasperValentin Kasper
physics.chem-phquant-phSubmitted Jul 7, 2026• Announced Jul 8, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Highly successful drugs, such as transition-state inhibitors, were designed by mimicking the precise geometry of enzymatic transition states, a strategy that requires quantum chemistry accurate enough to specify molecular structure at sub-Å resolution. A central challenge during such a quantum chemistry simulation is that classical single-reference method can deviate substantially from the exact energy at strongly correlated transition states. We study the breakdown due to multireference character by studying a model system with a multireference transition state. In this work we present a proprietary PexMachina solver which reproduces the exact ground-state energy throughout the transition state scan, while single-reference methods struggle for certain geometries to achieve chemical accuracy.

Comments
6 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Multireference electron correlation methods with density matrix renormalisation group reference functions

Yuki Kurashige

Recent advances in quantum chemical density matrix renormalisation group (DMRG) theory are presented. The DMRG, originally devised as an alternative to the exact diagonalisation in condensed matter physics, has become a powerful quantum chemical method for molecular systems that exhibit a multireference character, e.g., excited states, π-conjugated systems, transition metal complexes, and in particular for large systems by combining it with conventional multireference electron correlation methods. The capability of the current quantum chemical DMRG is demonstrated for an application involving the potential energy curve of the chromium dimer, which is one of the most demanding multireference systems and thus requires the best electronic structure treatment for non-dynamical and dynamical correlation as well as large basis sets.

Molecular Physics•Sep 16, 2013•94 citations

Ab initio Density Matrix Renormalization Group Theory for Multireference Quantum Chemistry

Takeshi Yanai

A major challenge in molecular electronic structure theory arises from chemical systems where the mean-field picture based upon a single electronic configuration fails to properly describe mechanics of many electrons. Such complex electronic states should be accounted for using a correlated superposition of multiple determinants and are referred to as multireference in quantum chemistry. Application domain of traditional multireference methods is severely limited to systems containing a small number of correlated electrons because of their exponential complexity. In recent years, much attention has been drawn to the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) theory as a promising alternative. It has been introduced in ab initio quantum chemistry calculations and shown to be a highly-scalable multireference method that can handle full quantum degrees of freedom for the strongly-correlated wavefunction with unprecedented large configuration space. In this article, we provide an explicative introduction to the underlying theory and formalism built into the DMRG method and give a brief overview of our methodological extensions that combine DMRG and active-space correlation models.

Molecular Science•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Chemically decisive benchmarks on the path to quantum utility

Srivathsan Poyyapakkam Sundar, Vibin Abraham, Bo Peng +1 more

Progress towards quantum utility in chemistry requires not only algorithmic advances, but also the identification of chemically meaningful problems whose electronic structure fundamentally challenges classical methods. Here, we introduce a curated hierarchy of chemically decisive benchmark systems designed to probe distinct regimes of electronic correlation relevant to molecular, bioinorganic, and heavy-element chemistry. Moving beyond minimal toy models, our benchmark set spans multireference bond breaking (N$_2$), high-spin transition-metal chemistry (FeS), biologically relevant iron-sulfur clusters ([2Fe-2S]), and actinide-actinide bonding (U$_2$), which exhibits extreme sensitivity to active-space choice, relativistic treatment, and correlation hierarchy even within advanced multireference frameworks. As a concrete realization, we benchmark a recently developed automated and adaptive quantum algorithm based on generator-coordinate-inspired subspace expansion,ADAPT-GCIM, using a black-box workflow that integrates entropy-based active-space selection via the ActiveSpaceFinder tool. Across this chemically diverse problem set, ADAPT-GCIM achieves high accuracy in challenging correlation regimes. Equally importantly, these benchmarks expose general failure modes and design constraints-independent of any specific algorithm-highlighting the necessity of problem-aware and correlation-specific strategies for treating strongly correlated chemistry on quantum computers. To support systematic benchmarking and reproducible comparisons, the Hamiltonians for all systems studied are made openly available.

physics.chem-phCross-listedarXiv:2601.10813•Jan 19, 2026•2 citations

Demonstrating Quantum Value on the Hydrogen Chain

Denise Holt, Denis Ovseyenko

Abstract Following the Governed Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation of molecular ground states in the companion work [1]—H₂, LiH, H₂O, and BeH₂ at equilibrium and its strong-multireference transition state, all committed inside chemical accuracy (the BeH₂ equilibrium commit, at ΔE = +0.595 µHa, sitting 7.7× inside wavenumber accuracy—1 cm⁻¹ ≈ 0.00456 mHa, the precision regime of high-resolution molecular spectroscopy—the only QPU chemistry commit on record inside that band)—we extend Governed Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing (GFTQC), executed under the governance of Seed IQ (the Adaptive Multiagent Autonomous Control platform of AIX Global), from chemical accuracy on those molecules to exact reproduction of a full-configuration-interaction benchmark: the linear hydrogen chain, the community's canonical test of strong electron correlation, established by Motta et al. [2] as a single full-configuration-interaction (FCI) equation of state of H₁₀ onto which fifteen-plus independent classical many-body methods were brought into agreement, and the accepted target any exact solver must hit.On Motta's own basis (STO-6G) the committed energy of H₁₀ reproduces his published FCI reference exactly, to twelve decimal places where his published precision is eight, at every point of the dissociation curve—at R = 1.8 bohr −5.424385376333 Ha against the published −5.42438538—each value internally certified exact. We then extend the benchmark in the two directions that turn a model system into chemistry: in length, carrying the exact energy from H₁₀ out to a chain of H₁₀₀; and in basis, computing it across four Gaussian bases from minimal to triple-zeta—STO-6G, 6-31G, cc-pVDZ, cc-pVTZ, the correlation-consistent sets of production electronic-structure theory—recovering progressively more correlation as the basis is enriched, each energy committed exact. Throughout, single-reference coupled cluster is exact near equilibrium but ceases to represent the state as the chain stretches and the dominant-determinant weight |c_HF|² collapses, whereas the governed commit stays exact at every length and every basis.These extensions lie beyond exact classical reach—the configuration space exceeds 10⁵⁸ determinants for H₁₀₀, unstorable on and unsolvable by any high-performance computer—and beyond any reported quantum method; to our knowledge the exact hydrogen-chain energies beyond Motta's classical H₁₀, in production bases and out to H₁₀₀, have not been computed before by any method. No error mitigation, post-selection, or classical fitting is used; every energy is read from the executed fault-tolerant state over qubit-wise-commuting measurement lanes on IBM Boston (Heron r3), accessed by AIX Global, and internally certified exact by a proprietary mechanism not disclosed here. This is the quantum value of fault tolerance made concrete on a strongly-correlated system: the exact answer, delivered where classical computing cannot store the problem and single-reference methods cannot represent the state at all. These results establish a new state of the art for exact electronic-structure computation on hardware: the first exact hydrogen-chain energies beyond H₁₀, by any method, classical or quantum.

•Aug 27, 2026•1 citation

An ab initio foundation model of wavefunctions that accurately describes chemical bond breaking

Adam Foster, Zeno Schätzle, P. Bernát Szabó +7 more

Reliable description of bond breaking remains a major challenge for quantum chemistry due to the multireference character of the electronic structure in dissociating species. Multireference methods in particular suffer from large computational cost, which under the normal paradigm has to be paid anew for each system at a full price, ignoring commonalities in electronic structure across molecules. Quantum Monte Carlo with deep neural networks uniquely offers to exploit such commonalities by pretraining transferable wavefunction models, but all such attempts were so far limited in scope. Here, we bring this paradigm to fruition with Orbformer, a transferable wavefunction model pretrained on 22,000 equilibrium and dissociating structures that can be fine-tuned on unseen molecules reaching an accuracy-cost ratio rivalling classical multireference methods. On established benchmarks as well as more challenging bond dissociations and Diels-Alder reactions, Orbformer is the only method that consistently converges to chemical accuracy (1 kcal/mol). This work turns the idea of amortizing the cost of solving the Schrödinger equation over many molecules into a practical approach in quantum chemistry.

arXiv:2506.19960•Nature Communications•Aug 21, 2026•31 citations

Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory Calculations of Low-lying States of Complex Chemical Systems with Quantum Computers

Zhanou Liu, Yuhao Chen, Yingjin Ma +2 more

Accurately describing strong electron correlation in complex systems remains a prominent challenge in computational chemistry as near-term quantum algorithms treating total correlation often require prohibitively deep circuits. Here we present a hybrid strategy combining the Variational Quantum Eigensolver with Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory to efficiently decouple correlation effects. This approach confines static correlation to a compact multireference quantum state while recovering dynamic correlation through a classical on-top density functional using reduced-density information. By enabling self-consistent orbital optimization, the method significantly reduces quantum resource overheads without sacrificing physical rigor. We demonstrate chemical accuracy on standard benchmarks by reproducing C$_2$ equilibrium bond lengths and benzene excitation energies with mean absolute errors of 0.006 Å and 0.048 eV respectively. Most notably, for the strongly correlated Cr$_2$ dimer requiring a large complete active space (48e, 42o), the framework yields a bound potential-energy curve and recovers qualitative dissociation behavior despite realistic hardware noise. These results establish that separating correlation types provides a practical route to reliable predictions on near-term quantum hardware.

arXiv:2602.10435•Feb 11, 2026•0 citations
Highly successful drugs, such as transition-state inhibitors, were designed by mimicking the precise geometry of enzymatic transition states, a strategy that requires quantum chemistry accurate enough to specify molecular structure at sub-Å resolution. A central challenge during such a quantum chemistry simulation is that classical single-reference method can deviate substantially from the exact energy at strongly correlated transition states. We study the breakdown due to multireference character by studying a model system with a multireference transition state. In this work we present a proprietary PexMachina solver which reproduces the exact ground-state energy throughout the transition state scan, while single-reference methods struggle for certain geometries to achieve chemical accuracy.
Recent advances in quantum chemical density matrix renormalisation group (DMRG) theory are presented. The DMRG, originally devised as an alternative to the exact diagonalisation in condensed matter physics, has become a powerful quantum chemical method for molecular systems that exhibit a multireference character, e.g., excited states, π-conjugated systems, transition metal complexes, and in particular for large systems by combining it with conventional multireference electron correlation methods. The capability of the current quantum chemical DMRG is demonstrated for an application involving the potential energy curve of the chromium dimer, which is one of the most demanding multireference systems and thus requires the best electronic structure treatment for non-dynamical and dynamical correlation as well as large basis sets.
A major challenge in molecular electronic structure theory arises from chemical systems where the mean-field picture based upon a single electronic configuration fails to properly describe mechanics of many electrons. Such complex electronic states should be accounted for using a correlated superposition of multiple determinants and are referred to as multireference in quantum chemistry. Application domain of traditional multireference methods is severely limited to systems containing a small number of correlated electrons because of their exponential complexity. In recent years, much attention has been drawn to the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) theory as a promising alternative. It has been introduced in ab initio quantum chemistry calculations and shown to be a highly-scalable multireference method that can handle full quantum degrees of freedom for the strongly-correlated wavefunction with unprecedented large configuration space. In this article, we provide an explicative introduction to the underlying theory and formalism built into the DMRG method and give a brief overview of our methodological extensions that combine DMRG and active-space correlation models.
Progress towards quantum utility in chemistry requires not only algorithmic advances, but also the identification of chemically meaningful problems whose electronic structure fundamentally challenges classical methods. Here, we introduce a curated hierarchy of chemically decisive benchmark systems designed to probe distinct regimes of electronic correlation relevant to molecular, bioinorganic, and heavy-element chemistry. Moving beyond minimal toy models, our benchmark set spans multireference bond breaking (N2_22​), high-spin transition-metal chemistry (FeS), biologically relevant iron-sulfur clusters ([2Fe-2S]), and actinide-actinide bonding (U2_22​), which exhibits extreme sensitivity to active-space choice, relativistic treatment, and correlation hierarchy even within advanced multireference frameworks. As a concrete realization, we benchmark a recently developed automated and adaptive quantum algorithm based on generator-coordinate-inspired subspace expansion,ADAPT-GCIM, using a black-box workflow that integrates entropy-based active-space selection via the ActiveSpaceFinder tool. Across this chemically diverse problem set, ADAPT-GCIM achieves high accuracy in challenging correlation regimes. Equally importantly, these benchmarks expose general failure modes and design constraints-independent of any specific algorithm-highlighting the necessity of problem-aware and correlation-specific strategies for treating strongly correlated chemistry on quantum computers. To support systematic benchmarking and reproducible comparisons, the Hamiltonians for all systems studied are made openly available.
Abstract Following the Governed Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation of molecular ground states in the companion work [1]—H₂, LiH, H₂O, and BeH₂ at equilibrium and its strong-multireference transition state, all committed inside chemical accuracy (the BeH₂ equilibrium commit, at ΔE = +0.595 µHa, sitting 7.7× inside wavenumber accuracy—1 cm⁻¹ ≈ 0.00456 mHa, the precision regime of high-resolution molecular spectroscopy—the only QPU chemistry commit on record inside that band)—we extend Governed Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing (GFTQC), executed under the governance of Seed IQ (the Adaptive Multiagent Autonomous Control platform of AIX Global), from chemical accuracy on those molecules to exact reproduction of a full-configuration-interaction benchmark: the linear hydrogen chain, the community's canonical test of strong electron correlation, established by Motta et al. [2] as a single full-configuration-interaction (FCI) equation of state of H₁₀ onto which fifteen-plus independent classical many-body methods were brought into agreement, and the accepted target any exact solver must hit.On Motta's own basis (STO-6G) the committed energy of H₁₀ reproduces his published FCI reference exactly, to twelve decimal places where his published precision is eight, at every point of the dissociation curve—at R = 1.8 bohr −5.424385376333 Ha against the published −5.42438538—each value internally certified exact. We then extend the benchmark in the two directions that turn a model system into chemistry: in length, carrying the exact energy from H₁₀ out to a chain of H₁₀₀; and in basis, computing it across four Gaussian bases from minimal to triple-zeta—STO-6G, 6-31G, cc-pVDZ, cc-pVTZ, the correlation-consistent sets of production electronic-structure theory—recovering progressively more correlation as the basis is enriched, each energy committed exact. Throughout, single-reference coupled cluster is exact near equilibrium but ceases to represent the state as the chain stretches and the dominant-determinant weight |c_HF|² collapses, whereas the governed commit stays exact at every length and every basis.These extensions lie beyond exact classical reach—the configuration space exceeds 10⁵⁸ determinants for H₁₀₀, unstorable on and unsolvable by any high-performance computer—and beyond any reported quantum method; to our knowledge the exact hydrogen-chain energies beyond Motta's classical H₁₀, in production bases and out to H₁₀₀, have not been computed before by any method. No error mitigation, post-selection, or classical fitting is used; every energy is read from the executed fault-tolerant state over qubit-wise-commuting measurement lanes on IBM Boston (Heron r3), accessed by AIX Global, and internally certified exact by a proprietary mechanism not disclosed here. This is the quantum value of fault tolerance made concrete on a strongly-correlated system: the exact answer, delivered where classical computing cannot store the problem and single-reference methods cannot represent the state at all. These results establish a new state of the art for exact electronic-structure computation on hardware: the first exact hydrogen-chain energies beyond H₁₀, by any method, classical or quantum.
Reliable description of bond breaking remains a major challenge for quantum chemistry due to the multireference character of the electronic structure in dissociating species. Multireference methods in particular suffer from large computational cost, which under the normal paradigm has to be paid anew for each system at a full price, ignoring commonalities in electronic structure across molecules. Quantum Monte Carlo with deep neural networks uniquely offers to exploit such commonalities by pretraining transferable wavefunction models, but all such attempts were so far limited in scope. Here, we bring this paradigm to fruition with Orbformer, a transferable wavefunction model pretrained on 22,000 equilibrium and dissociating structures that can be fine-tuned on unseen molecules reaching an accuracy-cost ratio rivalling classical multireference methods. On established benchmarks as well as more challenging bond dissociations and Diels-Alder reactions, Orbformer is the only method that consistently converges to chemical accuracy (1 kcal/mol). This work turns the idea of amortizing the cost of solving the Schrödinger equation over many molecules into a practical approach in quantum chemistry.
Accurately describing strong electron correlation in complex systems remains a prominent challenge in computational chemistry as near-term quantum algorithms treating total correlation often require prohibitively deep circuits. Here we present a hybrid strategy combining the Variational Quantum Eigensolver with Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory to efficiently decouple correlation effects. This approach confines static correlation to a compact multireference quantum state while recovering dynamic correlation through a classical on-top density functional using reduced-density information. By enabling self-consistent orbital optimization, the method significantly reduces quantum resource overheads without sacrificing physical rigor. We demonstrate chemical accuracy on standard benchmarks by reproducing C2_22​ equilibrium bond lengths and benzene excitation energies with mean absolute errors of 0.006 Å and 0.048 eV respectively. Most notably, for the strongly correlated Cr2_22​ dimer requiring a large complete active space (48e, 42o), the framework yields a bound potential-energy curve and recovers qualitative dissociation behavior despite realistic hardware noise. These results establish that separating correlation types provides a practical route to reliable predictions on near-term quantum hardware.