Macroscopic optomechanical systems offer a promising testbed for distinguishing whether gravity acts as a quantum interaction or as a classical field. Schrodinger-Newton (SN) theory is the nonrelativistic limit of semi-classical gravity where quantum matter couples to classical gravity. Based on SN theory, this work investigates how classical self-gravity affects continuous quantum state tomography of a macroscopic mechanical oscillator monitored by variable-angle homodyne detection. In the Schrodinger-Newton (SN) theory, the measurement record arises from a different conditional test mass dynamics from that in quantum-gravity (QG)/standard quantum mechanics, consequently, applying the QG-optimised reconstruction map introduces an additional state-dependent contribution. We show that this contribution makes the reconstructed covariance depend on the chosen set of tomography angles and can drive the SN covariance--after QG filtering--outside the standard Gaussian-covariance domain set by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. We quantify the resulting QG-SN distinguishability via the Hellinger distance and analyse its dependence on measurement strength and temperature. We then formulate the same issue in the broader setting of nonlinear quantum mechanics: when the system's conditional dynamics during the readout process depends on the state being inferred, the tomographic map acquires nonlinear, model-dependent corrections to the usual Radon or Gaussian reconstruction map.
Macroscopic optomechanical systems offer a promising testbed for distinguishing whether gravity acts as a quantum interaction or as a classical field. Schrodinger-Newton (SN) theory is the nonrelativistic limit of semi-classical gravity where quantum matter couples to classical gravity. Based on SN theory, this work investigates how classical self-gravity affects continuous quantum state tomography of a macroscopic mechanical oscillator monitored by variable-angle homodyne detection. In the Schrodinger-Newton (SN) theory, the measurement record arises from a different conditional test mass dynamics from that in quantum-gravity (QG)/standard quantum mechanics, consequently, applying the QG-optimised reconstruction map introduces an additional state-dependent contribution. We show that this contribution makes the reconstructed covariance depend on the chosen set of tomography angles and can drive the SN covariance--after QG filtering--outside the standard Gaussian-covariance domain set by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. We quantify the resulting QG-SN distinguishability via the Hellinger distance and analyse its dependence on measurement strength and temperature. We then formulate the same issue in the broader setting of nonlinear quantum mechanics: when the system's conditional dynamics during the readout process depends on the state being inferred, the tomographic map acquires nonlinear, model-dependent corrections to the usual Radon or Gaussian reconstruction map.
The semiclassical gravity sourced by the quantum expectation value of the matter's energy-momentum tensor will change the evolution of the quantum state of matter, which can be described by the Schr\"odinger-Newton (SN) equation. Understanding the phenomenology of the SN equation is important for experimentally testing the quantumness of gravity. In the SN theory, semiclassical gravity contributes a gravitational potential term depending on the matter's quantum state. This state-dependent potential introduces the complexity of the quantum state evolution and measurement in SN theory, which is different for different quantum measurement prescriptions. Previous theoretical investigations on the SN-theory phenomenology in the optomechanical experimental platform were carried out under the so-called post/preselection prescription. This work will focus on the phenomenology of SN theory under the causal-conditional prescription, which fits the standard intuition of the continuous quantum measurement process. We found that under the causal-conditional prescription, the quantum state of the test mass mirrors is conditionally prepared by the continuous projection of the outgoing light field in an optomechanical system. Hence a quantum-trajectory-dependent gravitational potential is created, which significantly changes the system evolution. This work provides an extensive analysis of this new picture of system evolution, and shows that various experimentally measurable signatures predicted by SN theory under causal-conditional prescription cannot be distinguished from that predicted by quantum gravity unless a very extreme experimental parameter region is assumed. Therefore, our new understanding of SN phenomenology provides an important caution toward the experimental verification of quantum gravity.
We propose an optomechanics experiment that can search for signatures of a fundamentally classical theory of gravity and in particular of the many-body Schr\"odinger-Newton (SN) equation, which governs the evolution of a crystal under a self-gravitational field. The SN equation predicts that the dynamics of a macroscopic mechanical oscillator's center-of-mass wave function differ from the predictions of standard quantum mechanics [H. Yang, H. Miao, D.-S. Lee, B. Helou, and Y. Chen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 170401 (2013)]. This difference is largest for low-frequency oscillators, and for materials, such as tungsten or osmium, with small quantum fluctuations of the constituent atoms around their lattice equilibrium sites. Light probes the motion of these oscillators and is eventually measured in order to extract valuable information on the pendulum's dynamics. Due to the nonlinearity contained in the SN equation, we analyze the fluctuations of measurement results differently than standard quantum mechanics. We revisit how to model a thermal bath, and the wave-function collapse postulate, resulting in two prescriptions for analyzing the quantum measurement of the light. We demonstrate that both predict features, in the outgoing light's phase fluctuations' spectrum, which are separate from classical thermal fluctuations and quantum shot noise, and which can be clearly resolved with state of the art technology.
The evolution of quantum states influenced by semiclassical gravity is distinct from that in quantum gravity theory due to the presence of a state-dependent gravitational potential. This state-dependent potential introduces nonlinearity into the state evolution, of which the theory is named the Schr\"odinger-Newton (SN) theory. The formalism for understanding the continuous quantum measurement process on the quantum state in the context of semiclassical gravity theory has been previously discussed using the Schr\"odinger picture in Paper I [Semiclassical gravity phenomenology under the causal-conditional quantum measurement prescription, Phys. Rev. D 107, 024004 (2023).]. In this work, an equivalent formalism using the Heisenberg picture is developed and applied to the analysis of two optomechanical experiment protocols that targeted testing the quantum nature of gravity. This Heisenberg picture formalism of the SN theory has the advantage of helping the investigation of the covariance matrices of the outgoing light fields in these protocols and further the entanglement features. We found that the classical gravity between the quantum trajectories of two mirrors under continuous quantum measurement in the SN theory can induce an apparent entanglement of the outgoing light field (though there is no quantum entanglement of the mirrors), which could serve as a false alarm for those experiments designed for probing the quantum gravity induced entanglement.
In order to empirically test the quantum nature of gravity, it is essential to explore the construction of classical gravity theories that are as consistent with experiments as possible. In particular, the classical gravity field must receive input regarding matter distribution. Previously, such input has been constructed by taking expectation values of the matter density operator on the quantum state, or by using the outcomes of all measurements being performed on the quantum system---or by using information obtained by auxiliary observers (like those that lead to the continuous spontaneous localization and Diosi-Penrose collapses) that continuously monitor the quantum dynamics. We propose a framework that unifies these models, and argue that the Causal Conditional Formulation of Schr\"odinger-Newton (CCSN) theory, which takes classical inputs only from experimental and environmental channels---without auxiliary observers---is a minimum model within this framework. Since CCSN can be viewed as a quantum feedback control scheme, it can be made explicitly causal and free from pathologies that previously plagued Schr\"odinger-Newton theories. Since classical information from measurement results are used to generate classical gravity, CCSN can mimic quantum gravity better than one would naively expect for a classical theory---making it more subtle to perform tests of the quantum nature of gravity. We predict experimental signatures of CCSN in two concrete scenarios: (i) a single test mass continuously monitored by light, and (ii) two objects interacting via mutual gravity, each monitored separately. In case (i), we show that the mass-concentration effect of self classical gravity still makes CCSN much easier to test than testing the establishment of mutual entanglement, yet the signatures are more subtle than previously thought for classical gravity theories. Using time-delayed measurements and nonstationary measurements, which delay or suspend the flow of classical information into classical gravity, one can make CCSN more detectable. In case (ii), we show that mutual gravity generated by CCSN can lead to correlations that largely mimic signatures of quantum entanglement in steady-state measurements. Rigorous protocols that rule out local operation and classical communication channels, which are experimentally more challenging than simply testing steady-state entanglement, must be applied in order to completely rule out CCSN.
An interesting idea, dating back to Feynman [Report from Chapel Hill Conference, edited by C. M. DeWitt and D. Rickles (1957)], argues that quantum mechanics may break down for large masses if one entertains the possibility that gravity can be ``classical,'' thereby leading to predictions different from conventional low-energy quantum gravity. Despite the technical difficulty in testing such deviations, a large number of experimental proposals have been put forward due to the high level of fundamental interest. Here, we consider the Schr\"odinger-Newton (SN) theory and the correlated worldline (CWL) theory, and show that they can be distinguished from conventional quantum mechanics, as well as each other, by performing pulsed optomechanics experiments. For CWL specifically we develop a framework resembling the commonly used ``Heisenberg-picture'' treatment of coupled oscillators, allowing one to perform simple calculations for such systems without delving into the deeper path-integral formalism. We find that discriminating between the theories will be very difficult until experimental control over low frequency quantum optomechanical systems is pushed much further. However, the predicted departures of SN and CWL from quantum mechanics occur at the same scale, so both alternative models could in principle be probed by a single experiment.
Significant achievements in high-sensitivity measurements will soon allow us to probe quantum behaviors of macroscopic mechanical oscillators. In a recent work [Phys. Rev. A 80, 043802 (2009)], we formulated a general framework for treating preparation of Gaussian quantum states of macroscopic oscillators through linear position measurements. To outline a complete procedure for testing macroscopic quantum mechanics, here we consider a subsequent verification stage which probes the prepared macroscopic quantum state and verifies the quantum dynamics. By adopting an optimal time-dependent homodyne detection in which the phase of the local oscillator varies in time, the conditional quantum state can be characterized below the Heisenberg limit, thereby achieving a quantum tomography. In the limiting case of no readout loss, such a scheme evades measurement-induced back action, which is identical to the variational-type measurement scheme invented by Vyatchanin et al. [JETP 77, 218 (1993)] but in the context for detecting gravitational waves. To motivate macroscopic quantum mechanics experiments with future gravitational-wave detectors, we mostly focus on the parameter regime where the characteristic measurement frequency is much higher than the oscillator frequency and the classical noises are Markovian, which captures the main feature of a broadband gravitational-wave detector. In addition, we discuss verifications of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-type entanglement between macroscopic test masses in future gravitational-wave detectors, which enables us to test one particular version of gravity decoherence conjectured by Di\'osi [Phys. Lett. A120, 377 (1987)] and Penrose [Gen. Rel. Grav. 28, 581 (1996)].