Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.06279

Bockstein Braiding Statistics Versus Three-Loop Braiding

Hanyu Xue

cond-mat.str-elquant-phSubmitted Jul 7, 2026• Announced Jul 8, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Braiding statistics of $p$- and $q$-dimensional topological excitations is conventionally defined in $p+q+2$ spatial dimensions. We find a novel statistical process $W_N(X,Y)=(Y^{-1}X^{-1})^N(YX)^N$ for two order-$N$ excitations in $p+q+1$ dimensions, detecting the Bockstein response $A\smile β(B)$. This new statistics and fermionic loop statistics exhaust all loop statistics in three dimensions whose fusion rules form an Abelian group $G$, classified by $H^5(B^2G,U(1))$. Surprisingly, conventional three-loop braiding goes beyond this classification, so it must have non-Abelian fusion rules. We suggest viewing three-loop braiding as particle-loop braiding together with exotic fusion rules between loops and point-like defects. We also try to clarify the relationship between statistics and symmetry anomaly.

Comments
20 pages, 2 figures

Related papers

Bockstein braiding statistics

Po-Shen Hsin, Yu-An Chen

Braiding phenomena, from the charge-flux Aharonov-Bohm effect to anyonic statistics in fractional quantum Hall systems, are paradigmatic manifestations of topology in quantum physics. Ordinary mutual braiding between $p$- and $q$-dimensional excitations occurs in $d=p+q+2$ spatial dimensions. In this work, we introduce a universal construction of mutual statistics in the adjacent dimension $d=p+q+1$, applicable to excitations obeying $\mathbb Z_N$ fusion for arbitrary $N$ and all excitation dimensions $p$ and $q$. The corresponding invariant is the Berry phase accumulated in a simple $4N$-step microscopic unitary process built from local excitation operators on lattices. This process measures the linking of one excitation with the $N$-fold fusion junction of the other, encompassing particle-particle statistics in one dimension, particle-loop statistics in two dimensions, and loop-loop or particle-membrane statistics in three dimensions. We establish the quantization and bilinearity of the invariant and show that its field-theory response is governed by the Bockstein homomorphism, motivating the name Bockstein braiding statistics. Interpreting the excitation operators as open symmetry operators turns the same invariant into a direct microscopic diagnostic of mixed anomalies between symmetries. We demonstrate this diagnostic in a (1+1)D spin chain, where the nontrivial Bockstein braiding phase proves the mixed anomaly between the spin-flip symmetry $\prod X$ and the nearest-neighbor controlled-$Z$ symmetry $\prod CZ$. We construct explicit (2+1)D and (3+1)D lattice analogs, yielding new anomalous symmetry pairs, and apply the framework to strongly coupled (3+1)D continuum gauge theories. Nontrivial Bockstein braiding rules out a fully symmetric gapped phase, obstructs simultaneous condensation of the two excitations, and implies fractionalization of higher-form symmetries.

quant-pharXiv:2607.02280•Jul 3, 2026•0 citations

Non-Abelian three-loop braiding statistics for 3D fermionic topological phases

Jing-Ren Zhou, Qing-Rui Wang, Chenjie Wang +1 more

Abstract Fractional statistics is one of the most intriguing features of topological phases in 2D. In particular, the so-called non-Abelian statistics plays a crucial role towards realizing topological quantum computation. Recently, the study of topological phases has been extended to 3D and it has been proposed that loop-like extensive objects can also carry fractional statistics. In this work, we systematically study the so-called three-loop braiding statistics for 3D interacting fermion systems. Most surprisingly, we discover new types of non-Abelian three-loop braiding statistics that can only be realized in fermionic systems (or equivalently bosonic systems with emergent fermionic particles). On the other hand, due to the correspondence between gauge theories with fermionic particles and classifying fermionic symmetry-protected topological (FSPT) phases with unitary symmetries, our study also gives rise to an alternative way to classify FSPT phases. We further compare the classification results for FSPT phases with arbitrary Abelian unitary total symmetry G f and find systematical agreement with previous studies.

arXiv:1912.13505•Nature Communications•May 27, 2021•8 citations

Non-Abelian fusion, shrinking, and quantum dimensions of Abelian gauge fluxes

Zhifeng Zhang, Qing-Rui Wang, Peng Ye

Braiding and fusion rules of topological excitations are indispensable topological invariants in topological quantum computation and topological orders. While excitations in two dimensions (2D) are always particlelike anyons, those in three dimensions (3D) incorporate not only particles but also loops, spatially nonlocal objects, making it novel and challenging to study topological invariants in higher dimensions. While 2D fusion rules have been well understood from bulk Chern-Simons field theory and edge conformal field theory, it is yet to be thoroughly explored for 3D fusion rules from higher-dimensional bulk topological field theory. Here, we perform a field-theoretical study on (i) how loops that carry Abelian gauge fluxes fuse and (ii) how loops are shrunk into particles in the path integral, which generates fusion rules, loop-shrinking rules, and descendent invariants, e.g., quantum dimensions. We first assign a gauge-invariant Wilson operator to each excitation and determine the number of distinct excitations through equivalence classes of Wilson operators. Then, we adiabatically shift two Wilson operators together to observe how they fuse and are split in the path integral; despite the Abelian nature of the gauge fluxes carried by loops, their fusions may be of non-Abelian nature. Meanwhile, we adiabatically deform world sheets of unknotted loops into world lines and examine the shrinking outcomes; we find that the resulting loop-shrinking rules are algebraically consistent to fusion rules. Interestingly, fusing a pair of loop and antiloop may generate multiple vacua, but fusing a pair of anyon and antianyon in 2D has one vacuum only. By establishing a field-theoretical ground for fusion and shrinking in 3D, this work leaves intriguing directions for future exploration, e.g., symmetry enrichment, quantum gates, and topological order of braided monoidal 2-category of 2-group.

arXiv:2208.09228•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 10, 2023•11 citations

Continuum field theory of three-dimensional topological orders with emergent fermions and braiding statistics

Zhifeng Zhang, Qing-Rui Wang, Peng Ye

Universal topological data of topologically ordered phases can be captured by topological quantum field theory in continuous space time by taking the limit of low energies and long wavelengths. While previous continuum field-theoretical studies of topological orders in three-dimensional (3D) real space focused on either self-statistics, braiding statistics, shrinking rules, fusion rules, or quantum dimensions, it has yet to systematically put all topological data together in a unified continuum field-theoretical framework. Here, we construct the topological $BF$ field theory with twisted terms (e.g., $AAdA$ and $AAB$) as well as a $K$-matrix $BB$ term to simultaneously explore all such topological data and reach anomaly-free topological orders. Following the spirit of the famous $K$-matrix Chern-Simons theory of two-dimensional topological orders, we present general formulas and systematically show how the $K$-matrix $BB$ term confines topological excitations, and how self-statistics of particles is transmuted between bosonic one and fermionic one. To reach anomaly-free topological orders, we explore, within the present continuum field-theoretical framework, how the principle of gauge invariance fundamentally influences possible realizations of topological data. More concretely, we present the topological actions of (i) particle-loop braidings with emergent fermions, (ii) multiloop braidings with emergent fermions, and (iii) Borromean rings braidings with emergent fermions, and calculate their universal topological data. Together with previous efforts, our paper paves the way toward a more systematic and complete continuum field-theoretical analysis of exotic topological properties of 3D topological orders. Several interesting future directions are also discussed.

arXiv:2307.09983•Physical Review Research•Nov 3, 2023•9 citations

Invariants of Sequential Circuits and Generalized Non-Abelian Statistics

Shintaro Sato, Yoshimasa Hidaka, Ryohei Kobayashi

Non-invertible symmetries in quantum many-body systems generally give rise to sequential unitary circuits that move symmetry defects. In this paper, we investigate invariants defined by sequences of such circuits, which move non-invertible defects and generate a Berry phase evaluated on quantum states with defects. We show that this Berry phase generally defines an invariant under local deformations, provided that the sequential circuits preserve the locality of those deformations. This invariant also rules out a short-range-entangled state that preserves the non-invertible symmetry, thereby signaling the 't Hooft anomaly of a non-invertible symmetry purely in terms of unitary operators acting on a state. We then apply this framework to loop excitations in three spatial dimensions and identify a new loop excitation in the (3+1)D $\mathbb{D}_4$ topological order, which we dub a non-Abelian fermionic loop. Using the invariant of sequential circuits, we characterize the statistics of non-Abelian fermionic loops. In addition, we find a new (3+1)D mixed topological order with a single non-Abelian fermionic loop, whose long-range entanglement is protected by an invariant of sequential circuits.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2606.11527•Jun 11, 2026•0 citations

Twisted lattice gauge theory: Membrane operators, three-loop braiding, and topological charge

Joe Huxford, Dung Xuan Nguyen, Yong Baek Kim

$(3+1)$-dimensional topological phases can support loop-like excitations in addition to point-like ones, allowing for nontrivial loop-loop and point-loop braiding statistics not permitted to point-like excitations alone. Furthermore, these loop-like excitations can be linked together, changing their properties. In particular, this can lead to distinct three-loop braiding, involving two loops undergoing an exchange process while linked to a third loop. In this work, we investigate the loop-like excitations in a $(3+1)$-dimensional Hamiltonian realization of Dijkgraaf-Witten theory through direct construction of their membrane operators, for a general finite Abelian group and 4-cocycle twist. Using these membrane operators, we find the braiding relations and fusion rules for the loop-like excitations, including those linked to another loop-like excitation. Furthermore, we use these membrane operators to construct projection operators that measure the topological charge and show that the number of distinct topological charges measured by the 2-torus matches the ground-state degeneracy of the model on the 3-torus, explicitly confirming a general expectation for topological phases. This direct construction of the membrane operators sheds significant light on the key properties of the loop-like excitations in $(3+1)$-dimensional topological phases.

arXiv:2401.13042•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 8, 2024•0 citations
Braiding statistics of ppp- and qqq-dimensional topological excitations is conventionally defined in p+q+2p+q+2p+q+2 spatial dimensions. We find a novel statistical process WN(X,Y)=(Y−1X−1)N(YX)NW_N(X,Y)=(Y^{-1}X^{-1})^N(YX)^NWN​(X,Y)=(Y−1X−1)N(YX)N for two order-NNN excitations in p+q+1p+q+1p+q+1 dimensions, detecting the Bockstein response A⌣β(B)A\smile β(B)A⌣β(B). This new statistics and fermionic loop statistics exhaust all loop statistics in three dimensions whose fusion rules form an Abelian group GGG, classified by H5(B2G,U(1))H^5(B^2G,U(1))H5(B2G,U(1)). Surprisingly, conventional three-loop braiding goes beyond this classification, so it must have non-Abelian fusion rules. We suggest viewing three-loop braiding as particle-loop braiding together with exotic fusion rules between loops and point-like defects. We also try to clarify the relationship between statistics and symmetry anomaly.
Braiding phenomena, from the charge-flux Aharonov-Bohm effect to anyonic statistics in fractional quantum Hall systems, are paradigmatic manifestations of topology in quantum physics. Ordinary mutual braiding between ppp- and qqq-dimensional excitations occurs in d=p+q+2d=p+q+2d=p+q+2 spatial dimensions. In this work, we introduce a universal construction of mutual statistics in the adjacent dimension d=p+q+1d=p+q+1d=p+q+1, applicable to excitations obeying ZN\mathbb Z_NZN​ fusion for arbitrary NNN and all excitation dimensions ppp and qqq. The corresponding invariant is the Berry phase accumulated in a simple 4N4N4N-step microscopic unitary process built from local excitation operators on lattices. This process measures the linking of one excitation with the NNN-fold fusion junction of the other, encompassing particle-particle statistics in one dimension, particle-loop statistics in two dimensions, and loop-loop or particle-membrane statistics in three dimensions. We establish the quantization and bilinearity of the invariant and show that its field-theory response is governed by the Bockstein homomorphism, motivating the name Bockstein braiding statistics. Interpreting the excitation operators as open symmetry operators turns the same invariant into a direct microscopic diagnostic of mixed anomalies between symmetries. We demonstrate this diagnostic in a (1+1)D spin chain, where the nontrivial Bockstein braiding phase proves the mixed anomaly between the spin-flip symmetry ∏X\prod X∏X and the nearest-neighbor controlled-ZZZ symmetry ∏CZ\prod CZ∏CZ. We construct explicit (2+1)D and (3+1)D lattice analogs, yielding new anomalous symmetry pairs, and apply the framework to strongly coupled (3+1)D continuum gauge theories. Nontrivial Bockstein braiding rules out a fully symmetric gapped phase, obstructs simultaneous condensation of the two excitations, and implies fractionalization of higher-form symmetries.
Abstract Fractional statistics is one of the most intriguing features of topological phases in 2D. In particular, the so-called non-Abelian statistics plays a crucial role towards realizing topological quantum computation. Recently, the study of topological phases has been extended to 3D and it has been proposed that loop-like extensive objects can also carry fractional statistics. In this work, we systematically study the so-called three-loop braiding statistics for 3D interacting fermion systems. Most surprisingly, we discover new types of non-Abelian three-loop braiding statistics that can only be realized in fermionic systems (or equivalently bosonic systems with emergent fermionic particles). On the other hand, due to the correspondence between gauge theories with fermionic particles and classifying fermionic symmetry-protected topological (FSPT) phases with unitary symmetries, our study also gives rise to an alternative way to classify FSPT phases. We further compare the classification results for FSPT phases with arbitrary Abelian unitary total symmetry G f and find systematical agreement with previous studies.
Braiding and fusion rules of topological excitations are indispensable topological invariants in topological quantum computation and topological orders. While excitations in two dimensions (2D) are always particlelike anyons, those in three dimensions (3D) incorporate not only particles but also loops, spatially nonlocal objects, making it novel and challenging to study topological invariants in higher dimensions. While 2D fusion rules have been well understood from bulk Chern-Simons field theory and edge conformal field theory, it is yet to be thoroughly explored for 3D fusion rules from higher-dimensional bulk topological field theory. Here, we perform a field-theoretical study on (i) how loops that carry Abelian gauge fluxes fuse and (ii) how loops are shrunk into particles in the path integral, which generates fusion rules, loop-shrinking rules, and descendent invariants, e.g., quantum dimensions. We first assign a gauge-invariant Wilson operator to each excitation and determine the number of distinct excitations through equivalence classes of Wilson operators. Then, we adiabatically shift two Wilson operators together to observe how they fuse and are split in the path integral; despite the Abelian nature of the gauge fluxes carried by loops, their fusions may be of non-Abelian nature. Meanwhile, we adiabatically deform world sheets of unknotted loops into world lines and examine the shrinking outcomes; we find that the resulting loop-shrinking rules are algebraically consistent to fusion rules. Interestingly, fusing a pair of loop and antiloop may generate multiple vacua, but fusing a pair of anyon and antianyon in 2D has one vacuum only. By establishing a field-theoretical ground for fusion and shrinking in 3D, this work leaves intriguing directions for future exploration, e.g., symmetry enrichment, quantum gates, and topological order of braided monoidal 2-category of 2-group.
Universal topological data of topologically ordered phases can be captured by topological quantum field theory in continuous space time by taking the limit of low energies and long wavelengths. While previous continuum field-theoretical studies of topological orders in three-dimensional (3D) real space focused on either self-statistics, braiding statistics, shrinking rules, fusion rules, or quantum dimensions, it has yet to systematically put all topological data together in a unified continuum field-theoretical framework. Here, we construct the topological BFBFBF field theory with twisted terms (e.g., AAdAAAdAAAdA and AABAABAAB) as well as a KKK-matrix BBBBBB term to simultaneously explore all such topological data and reach anomaly-free topological orders. Following the spirit of the famous KKK-matrix Chern-Simons theory of two-dimensional topological orders, we present general formulas and systematically show how the KKK-matrix BBBBBB term confines topological excitations, and how self-statistics of particles is transmuted between bosonic one and fermionic one. To reach anomaly-free topological orders, we explore, within the present continuum field-theoretical framework, how the principle of gauge invariance fundamentally influences possible realizations of topological data. More concretely, we present the topological actions of (i) particle-loop braidings with emergent fermions, (ii) multiloop braidings with emergent fermions, and (iii) Borromean rings braidings with emergent fermions, and calculate their universal topological data. Together with previous efforts, our paper paves the way toward a more systematic and complete continuum field-theoretical analysis of exotic topological properties of 3D topological orders. Several interesting future directions are also discussed.
Non-invertible symmetries in quantum many-body systems generally give rise to sequential unitary circuits that move symmetry defects. In this paper, we investigate invariants defined by sequences of such circuits, which move non-invertible defects and generate a Berry phase evaluated on quantum states with defects. We show that this Berry phase generally defines an invariant under local deformations, provided that the sequential circuits preserve the locality of those deformations. This invariant also rules out a short-range-entangled state that preserves the non-invertible symmetry, thereby signaling the 't Hooft anomaly of a non-invertible symmetry purely in terms of unitary operators acting on a state. We then apply this framework to loop excitations in three spatial dimensions and identify a new loop excitation in the (3+1)D D4\mathbb{D}_4D4​ topological order, which we dub a non-Abelian fermionic loop. Using the invariant of sequential circuits, we characterize the statistics of non-Abelian fermionic loops. In addition, we find a new (3+1)D mixed topological order with a single non-Abelian fermionic loop, whose long-range entanglement is protected by an invariant of sequential circuits.
(3+1)(3+1)(3+1)-dimensional topological phases can support loop-like excitations in addition to point-like ones, allowing for nontrivial loop-loop and point-loop braiding statistics not permitted to point-like excitations alone. Furthermore, these loop-like excitations can be linked together, changing their properties. In particular, this can lead to distinct three-loop braiding, involving two loops undergoing an exchange process while linked to a third loop. In this work, we investigate the loop-like excitations in a (3+1)(3+1)(3+1)-dimensional Hamiltonian realization of Dijkgraaf-Witten theory through direct construction of their membrane operators, for a general finite Abelian group and 4-cocycle twist. Using these membrane operators, we find the braiding relations and fusion rules for the loop-like excitations, including those linked to another loop-like excitation. Furthermore, we use these membrane operators to construct projection operators that measure the topological charge and show that the number of distinct topological charges measured by the 2-torus matches the ground-state degeneracy of the model on the 3-torus, explicitly confirming a general expectation for topological phases. This direct construction of the membrane operators sheds significant light on the key properties of the loop-like excitations in (3+1)(3+1)(3+1)-dimensional topological phases.