Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2606.07197

On the true low-energy excitations of the three-dimensional spin glass

Claudio Chilin, Enzo Marinari, Víctor Martín-Mayor, Giorgio Parisi A, Juan Jesus Ruiz-Lorenzo, David Yllanes

Published Jun 5, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the low-energy excitations of the three dimensional spin glass through a large-scale Monte Carlo simulation on lattices up to $L=18$. We find smooth extrapolations down to zero temperature, which, in the case of the energy and of the link overlap, can be directly -- and favourably -- compared with previous investigations featuring ground states (i.e., at zero temperature). The best fit for the fractal dimension of the excitations is provided by Replica-Symmetry Breaking theory, but we also consider the alternative TNT description. The $P(q)$ is found to verify the Parisi-Toulouse temperature scaling. Our data provides a spectacular confirmation of the overlap-equivalence hypothesis.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2606.07197

Related papers

Geometry of large-scale low-energy excitations in the one-dimensional Ising spin glass with power-law interactions

Helmut G. Katzgraber, A. P. Young

Results are presented for the geometry of low-energy excitations in the one-dimensional Ising spin chain with power-law interactions, in which the model parameters are chosen to yield a finite spin-glass transition temperature. Both finite-temperature and ground-state studies are carried out. For the range of sizes studied the data cannot be fitted to any of the standard spin-glass scenarios without including corrections to scaling. Incorporating such corrections we find that the fractal dimension of the surface of the excitations, is either equal to the space dimension, consistent with replica symmetry breaking, or very slightly less than it. The latter case is consistent with the droplet and ``trivial-nontrivial'' pictures.

arXiv:cond-mat/0307583•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 8, 2003•32 citations

Spin and Link Overlaps in Three-Dimensional Spin Glasses

Florent Krząkała, Olivier Martin

Excitations of three-dimensional spin glasses are computed numerically. We find that one can flip a finite fraction of an LxLxL lattice with an O(1) energy cost, confirming the mean-field picture of a nontrivial spin overlap distribution P(q). These low energy excitations are not domain-wall-like, rather they are topologically nontrivial and they reach out to the boundaries of the lattice. Their surface to volume ratios decrease as L increases and may asymptotically go to zero. If so, link and window overlaps between the ground state and these excited states become "trivial."

arXiv:cond-mat/0002055•Physical Review Letters•Oct 2, 2000•153 citations

Spin Glasses at Low Temperatures

Helmut G. Katzgraber, Matteo Palassini, A. P. Young

We report the results of Monte Carlo simulations on several spin glass models at low temperatures. By using the parallel tempering (Exchange Monte Carlo) technique we are able to equilibrate down to low temperatures, for moderate sizes, and hence the data should not be affected by critical fluctuations. Our results for short range models are consistent with a picture proposed earlier that there are large scale excitations which cost only a finite energy in the thermodynamic limit, and these excitations have a surface whose fractal dimension is less than the space dimension. For the infinite range Viana-Bray model, our results obtained for a similar number of spins are consistent with standard replica symmetry breaking.

arXiv:cond-mat/0007113•Jul 6, 2000•2 citations

Spin and link overlaps in 3-dimensional spin glasses

Florent Krząkała, Olivier Martin

Excitations of three-dimensional spin glasses are computed numerically. We find that one can flip a finite fraction of an LxLxL lattice with an O(1) energy cost, confirming the mean field picture of a non-trivial spin overlap distribution P(q). These low energy excitations are not domain-wall-like, rather they are topologically non-trivial and they reach out to the boundaries of the lattice. Their surface to volume ratios decrease as L increases and may asymptotically go to zero. If so, link and window overlaps between the ground state and these excited states become ``trivial\'\'.

•Jan 1, 2000•4 citations

Low-energy excitations in spin glasses from exact ground states

Matteo Palassini, Frauke Liers, Michael Juenger +1 more

We investigate the nature of the low-energy, large-scale excitations in the three-dimensional Edwards-Anderson Ising spin glass with Gaussian couplings and free boundary conditions, by studying the response of the ground state to a coupling-dependent perturbation introduced previously. The ground states are determined exactly for system sizes up to ${12}^{3}$ spins using a branch-and-cut algorithm. The data are consistent with a picture where the surface of the excitations is not space filling, such as the droplet or the trivial-non-trivial (TNT) picture, with only minimal corrections to scaling. When allowing for very large corrections to scaling, the data are also consistent with a picture with space-filling surfaces, such as replica symmetry breaking. The energy of the excitations scales with their size with a small exponent ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}},$ which is compatible with zero if we allow moderate corrections to scaling. We compare the results with data for periodic boundary conditions obtained with a genetic algorithm, and discuss the effects of different boundary conditions on corrections to scaling. Finally, we analyze the performance of our branch-and-cut algorithm, finding that it is correlated with the existence of large-scale, low-energy excitations.

arXiv:cond-mat/0212551•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Aug 13, 2003•21 citations

Large-scale low-energy excitations in the two-dimensional Ising spin glass

Alexander K. Hartmann, A. P. Young

We study large-scale, low-energy excitations in the Ising spin glass with Gaussian interactions in two dimensions at zero temperature, using an optimization algorithm to determine exact ground states. Periodic boundary conditions are applied. Our results for the fractal dimension of the surface, ${d}_{s},$ and stiffness exponent, ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}},$ for ``droplet'' excitations, are in reasonable agreement with estimates from ``domain wall'' calculations, and so support the predictions of the ``droplet theory.'' Restricting our analysis to small lattices, we do not find an effective value of ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ close to $\ensuremath{-}0.47$ as has been recently proposed. The effects of averaging over droplets of different sizes are studied and are also found to be too small to give ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{\approx}\ensuremath{-}0.47$ for smaller sizes. Larger corrections to finite-size scaling would be needed in three and four dimensions in order for the numerical data used to support the ``TNT'' scenario to be compatible with the droplet theory prediction that the stiffness exponent is the same for droplets and domain walls.

arXiv:cond-mat/0205659•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 16, 2002•45 citations
We study the low-energy excitations of the three dimensional spin glass through a large-scale Monte Carlo simulation on lattices up to L=18L=18L=18. We find smooth extrapolations down to zero temperature, which, in the case of the energy and of the link overlap, can be directly -- and favourably -- compared with previous investigations featuring ground states (i.e., at zero temperature). The best fit for the fractal dimension of the excitations is provided by Replica-Symmetry Breaking theory, but we also consider the alternative TNT description. The P(q)P(q)P(q) is found to verify the Parisi-Toulouse temperature scaling. Our data provides a spectacular confirmation of the overlap-equivalence hypothesis.
Results are presented for the geometry of low-energy excitations in the one-dimensional Ising spin chain with power-law interactions, in which the model parameters are chosen to yield a finite spin-glass transition temperature. Both finite-temperature and ground-state studies are carried out. For the range of sizes studied the data cannot be fitted to any of the standard spin-glass scenarios without including corrections to scaling. Incorporating such corrections we find that the fractal dimension of the surface of the excitations, is either equal to the space dimension, consistent with replica symmetry breaking, or very slightly less than it. The latter case is consistent with the droplet and ``trivial-nontrivial'' pictures.
Excitations of three-dimensional spin glasses are computed numerically. We find that one can flip a finite fraction of an LxLxL lattice with an O(1) energy cost, confirming the mean-field picture of a nontrivial spin overlap distribution P(q). These low energy excitations are not domain-wall-like, rather they are topologically nontrivial and they reach out to the boundaries of the lattice. Their surface to volume ratios decrease as L increases and may asymptotically go to zero. If so, link and window overlaps between the ground state and these excited states become "trivial."
We report the results of Monte Carlo simulations on several spin glass models at low temperatures. By using the parallel tempering (Exchange Monte Carlo) technique we are able to equilibrate down to low temperatures, for moderate sizes, and hence the data should not be affected by critical fluctuations. Our results for short range models are consistent with a picture proposed earlier that there are large scale excitations which cost only a finite energy in the thermodynamic limit, and these excitations have a surface whose fractal dimension is less than the space dimension. For the infinite range Viana-Bray model, our results obtained for a similar number of spins are consistent with standard replica symmetry breaking.
Excitations of three-dimensional spin glasses are computed numerically. We find that one can flip a finite fraction of an LxLxL lattice with an O(1) energy cost, confirming the mean field picture of a non-trivial spin overlap distribution P(q). These low energy excitations are not domain-wall-like, rather they are topologically non-trivial and they reach out to the boundaries of the lattice. Their surface to volume ratios decrease as L increases and may asymptotically go to zero. If so, link and window overlaps between the ground state and these excited states become ``trivial\'\'.
We investigate the nature of the low-energy, large-scale excitations in the three-dimensional Edwards-Anderson Ising spin glass with Gaussian couplings and free boundary conditions, by studying the response of the ground state to a coupling-dependent perturbation introduced previously. The ground states are determined exactly for system sizes up to 123{12}^{3}123 spins using a branch-and-cut algorithm. The data are consistent with a picture where the surface of the excitations is not space filling, such as the droplet or the trivial-non-trivial (TNT) picture, with only minimal corrections to scaling. When allowing for very large corrections to scaling, the data are also consistent with a picture with space-filling surfaces, such as replica symmetry breaking. The energy of the excitations scales with their size with a small exponent ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}},$ which is compatible with zero if we allow moderate corrections to scaling. We compare the results with data for periodic boundary conditions obtained with a genetic algorithm, and discuss the effects of different boundary conditions on corrections to scaling. Finally, we analyze the performance of our branch-and-cut algorithm, finding that it is correlated with the existence of large-scale, low-energy excitations.
We study large-scale, low-energy excitations in the Ising spin glass with Gaussian interactions in two dimensions at zero temperature, using an optimization algorithm to determine exact ground states. Periodic boundary conditions are applied. Our results for the fractal dimension of the surface, ds,{d}_{s},ds​, and stiffness exponent, ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}},$ for ``droplet'' excitations, are in reasonable agreement with estimates from ``domain wall'' calculations, and so support the predictions of the ``droplet theory.'' Restricting our analysis to small lattices, we do not find an effective value of ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ close to $\ensuremath{-}0.47$ as has been recently proposed. The effects of averaging over droplets of different sizes are studied and are also found to be too small to give ${\ensuremath{\theta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{\approx}\ensuremath{-}0.47$ for smaller sizes. Larger corrections to finite-size scaling would be needed in three and four dimensions in order for the numerical data used to support the ``TNT'' scenario to be compatible with the droplet theory prediction that the stiffness exponent is the same for droplets and domain walls.