arXiv:2605.18091 · Physical Review A

Quantum signatures and semiclassical limitations in the transmission of Fock states

Daniel Julian Nader

quant-phSubmitted May 18, 2026• Announced May 19, 2026• 0 citations

Abstract

Transmission through potential barriers is a fundamental problem in quantum mechanics. While semiclassical methods can approximate certain aspects of transmission, they fail to capture the intrinsically quantum interference associated with Wigner-function negativity. We numerically study the transmission of displaced Fock states through an inverted-oscillator barrier, with and without a Kerr nonlinearity that offers a potential route to experimental realization. These states allow only an approximate classical description, since their characteristic Wigner-function negativity is absent in phase space. The semiclassical simulation reproduces the overall transmission but deviate from exact results and fail to capture short-time plateaus that arise when regions of Wigner-function negativity cross the barrier. With the Kerr nonlinearity, reflections from nonlinear boundaries drive interference into classically forbidden regions, an effect that is inaccessible to semiclassical approaches. We find that these interference effects do not alter the maximum transmission probability, which is bounded by the initial positive-energy fraction and therefore already encoded in the phase-space structure of the Fock states. Because Fock states cannot be faithfully represented within classical phase space, the transmission through a barrier reveals fundamental limitations of semiclassical approaches.

Journal reference: Phys. Rev. A 112, 052221 November, 2025
DOI: 10.1103/2b9f-ygt3

Related papers

Semiclassical propagation of Wigner functions

T. Dittrich, E. A. Gómez, Leonardo A. Pachón

We present a comprehensive study of semiclassical phase-space propagation in the Wigner representation, emphasizing numerical applications, in particular as an initial-value representation. Two semiclassical approximation schemes are discussed. The propagator of the Wigner function based on van Vleck's approximation replaces the Liouville propagator by a quantum spot with an oscillatory pattern reflecting the interference between pairs of classical trajectories. Employing phase-space path integration instead, caustics in the quantum spot are resolved in terms of Airy functions. We apply both to two benchmark models of nonlinear molecular potentials, the Morse oscillator and the quartic double well, to test them in standard tasks such as computing autocorrelation functions and propagating coherent states. The performance of semiclassical Wigner propagation is very good even in the presence of marked quantum effects, e.g., in coherent tunneling and in propagating Schrodinger cat states, and of classical chaos in four-dimensional phase space. We suggest options for an effective numerical implementation of our method and for integrating it in Monte-Carlo-Metropolis algorithms suitable for high-dimensional systems.

arXiv:0911.3871The Journal of Chemical PhysicsJun 2, 201036 citations

Quantum dynamics of the parametric oscillator

Paul Kinsler, P. D. Drummond

We present dynamical calculations for the quantum parametric oscillator using both number-state and coherent-state bases. The coherent-state methods use the positive-P representation, which has a nonclassical phase space---an essential requirement in obtaining an exact stochastic representation of this nonlinear problem. This also provides a way to directly simulate quantum tunneling between the two above-threshold stable states of the oscillator. The coherent-state methods provide both analytic results at large photon numbers, and numerical results for any photon number, while our number-state calculations are restricted to numerical results in the low-photon-number regime. The number-state and coherent-state methods give precise agreement within the accuracy of the numerical calculations. We also compare our results with methods based on a truncated Wigner representation equivalent to stochastic electrodynamics, and find that these are unable to correctly predict the tunneling rate given by the other methods. An interesting feature of the results is the much faster tunneling predicted by the exact quantum-theory methods compared with earlier semiclassical calculations using an approximate potential barrier. This is similar to the faster tunneling found when comparing quantum penetration of a barrier to classical thermal activation. The quantum parametric oscillator, which has an exact steady-state solution, therefore provides a useful and accessible system in which nonlinear quantum effects can be studied far from thermal equilibrium.

Physical Review AJun 1, 1991142 citations

Tunneling of Bound Systems at Finite Energies: Complex Paths Through Potential Barriers

Gian Franco Bonini, Andrew G. Cohen, Claudio Rebbi B +1 more

We adapt the semiclassical technique, as used in the context of instanton transitions in quantum field theory, to the description of tunneling transmissions at finite energies through potential barriers by complex quantum mechanical systems. Even for systems initially in their ground state, not generally describable in semiclassical terms, the transmission probability has a semiclassical (exponential) form. The calculation of the tunneling exponent uses analytic continuation of degrees of freedom into a complex phase space as well as analytic continuation of the classical equations of motion into the complex time plane. We test this semiclassical technique by comparing its results with those of a computational investigation of the full quantum mechanical system, finding excellent agreement.

arXiv:quant-ph/9901062Jan 21, 19992 citations

A semiclassical description of nonlocal effects on barrier transmission

D. Galetti, M A Cândido Ribeiro

A quantum treatment for nonlocal factorizable potentials is presented in which the Weyl-Wigner quantum phase space description plays an essential role. The nonlocality is treated in an approximated form and allows for a Feynman propagator that can be handled in standard way. The semiclassical limit of the propagator is obtained which permits the calculation of the transmission factor in quantum tunnelling processes. An application in nuclear physics is also discussed.

Physica ScriptaMay 1, 19926 citations

Quantum tunneling, global phases and the limits of classical action reconstructions

Chong Qi, Mário B. Amaro

It was proposed recently that the Schrödinger wave function can be reconstructed exactly from a discrete superposition of classical action branches weighted by associated classical densities, without semiclassical approximations. We examine this construction for quantum tunneling through finite potential barriers and for quantum phase phenomena. Although formally consistent when the Hamilton-Jacobi equation admits globally defined real branches, the construction breaks down in classically forbidden regions where no real classical action exists. Using rectangular and Coulomb barrier tunneling in alpha decay and nuclear fusion, we show that the wave function requires either a non-vanishing quantum potential or complex-valued action. The growing barrier component fixed by global boundary conditions is essential for transmission and cannot arise from local real classical trajectories alone. Berry phase, flux quantization, Josephson tunneling, and dc SQUID interference likewise impose global phase constraints absent from local classical action transport.

quant-pharXiv:2605.11252May 13, 20260 citations

Non-classical and chaotic motion of two-dimensional light

Violetta Sharoglazova

Understanding how classical and quantum descriptions of nature connect remains one of the central challenges in physics. Classical mechanics provides a deterministic picture for macroscopic systems, while quantum mechanics is governed by probabilistic behavior at microscopic scales. In the intermediate regime — where quantum effects clash with classical intuition, such as tunneling through forbidden regions or the appearance of chaos-like features in quantum systems — new experimental insight is essential. This thesis investigates two questions: How fast can a particle move within a classically forbidden region? and In what ways can classical chaos leave signatures in quantum systems? Both problems are explored experimentally using an optical microcavity filled with dye, in which confined photons behave as massive particles. This platform provides offers high-resolution spatial and temporal access to quantities that are difficult to measure in traditional quantum systems. In the first part of this thesis, we examine the kinematics of classically forbidden motion, where the particle energy is lower than the potential energy of a barrier or a potential step. While classical mechanics forbids such motion, quantum mechanics allows particles to explore these regions due to an effectively negative local kinetic energy, raising the long-standing question of tunneling time: How long does it take to traverse a barrier? We address this by engineering a system in which the speed associated with forbidden motion can be derived and directly measured. Different theoretical approaches to tunneling time are compared, and we discuss how our results relate to and challenge existing models, with particular attention to Bohmian mechanics. The second half of this thesis focuses on the emergence of classical chaos signatures in quantum systems. While the correspondence principle suggests that quantum behavior should resemble classical physics in certain limits, quantum systems are fundamentally linear and therefore cannot exhibit chaos in the classical sense. Nonetheless, under specific conditions – such as non-resonant optical pumping leading to lasing – we observe sensitivity to initial conditions in a billiard-shaped potential. By combining novel experimental techniques with foundational theoretical questions, this thesis contributes to the ongoing dialogue between classical and quantum physics.

Sep 9, 20250 citations