Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.00629 · Communications in Theoretical Physics

Quantum Monte Carlo study of the superfluid phase of 4 He

Massimo Boninsegni

Published Oct 29, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Detailed numerical results obtained with state-of-the-art Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations are presented for the superfluid phase of 4 He at saturated vapor pressure. The aim of this contribution is that of providing reliable, up-to-date estimates for this archetypal superfluid, reflecting the methodological progress that has taken place over the past two decades. We simulate a system comprising 2,048 helium atoms, i.e., an order of magnitude greater in size than those for which results currently regarded as standard references were originally obtained. We offer revised estimates for energetic and structural properties, as well as for the ground state condensate fraction.

DOI
10.1088/1572-9494/aebb13

Related papers

Path Integral Monte Carlo Simulations of Helium: From Superfluid Droplets to Quantum Crystals

Erik W. Draeger

Below Tλ = 2.17 K, bulk 4He is a superfluid and has a non-zero Bose-Einstein condensate fraction. This work will focus primarily on how phenomena such as superfluidity, Bose condensation and superfluid vortices are manifested in microscopic, inhomogeneous helium systems. Path Integral Monte Carlo is a powerful method for calculating the equilibrium properties of quantum systems at finite temperature. We have achieved linear scaling of computer time with number of particles through the use of neighbor lists, allowing us to simulate systems of several thousand atoms. We have derived a local superfluid estimator and used it to examine the microscopic superfluid response around a molecule rotating in a helium nanodroplet. We found that the first solvation layer is well-described by a two dimensional superfluid, with thermal excitations occuring at a lower temperature than in bulk helium. The effective moment of inertia of a linear impurity in a helium droplet is calculated, and compared with experimental scattering results. In addition, we calculated the vortex formation energy for both pure droplets and droplets doped with linear impurities, and found that the linear impurities had a negligible impact on the formation energy. A possible spectroscopic signature of vortices in doped helium droplets was suggested. After deriving a local estimator, we calculated the condensate fraction throughout the free helium surface of a semi-infinite slab. These results, along with densitydensity correlation functions, were used to characterize the surface excitations and calculate the extent to which ripplons are present. In addition, the ripplon dispersion relation was calculated using imaginary-time correlation functions, and found to be lll in good agreement with experimental results. Finally, we have calculated the Dey be-Waller factor in solid helium for a range of temperatures and densities, and compared the scaling behavior with the predictions of harmonic theory. The first non-Gaussian contribution to the density distribution was calculated.

•Jan 1, 2001•3 citations

Path Integral Monte Carlo and Bose-Einstein condensation in quantum fluids and solids

R. Rota

Several microscopic theories point out that Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC), i.e., a macroscopic occupation of the lowest energy single particle state in many-boson systems, may appear also in quantum fluids and solids and that it is at the origin of the phenomenon of superfluidity. Nevertheless, the connection between BEC and superfluidity is still matter of debate, since the experimental evidences indicating a non zero condensate fraction in superfluid helium are only indirect. In the theoretical study of BEC in quantum fluids and solids, perturbative approaches are useless because of the strong correlations between the atoms, arising both from the interatomic potential and from the quantum nature of the system. Microscopic Quantum Monte Carlo simulations provide a reliable description of these systems. In particular, the Path Integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) method is very suitable for this purpose. This method is able to provide exact results for the properties of the quantum system, both at zero and finite temperature, only with the definition of the Hamiltonian and of the symmetry properties of the system, giving an easy picture for superfluidity and BEC in many-boson systems. In this thesis, we apply PIMC methods to the study of several quantum fluids and solids. We describe in detail all the features of PIMC, from the sampling methods to the estimators of the physical properties. We present also the most recent techniques, such as the high-order approximations for the thermal density matrix and the worm algorithm, used in PIMC to provide reliable simulations. We study the liquid phase of condensed 4He, providing unbiased estimations of the one-body density matrix g1(r). We analyze the model for g1(r) used to fit the experimental data, highlighting its merits and its faults. In particular we see that, even if it presents some difficulties in the description of the overall behavior of g1(r), it can provide an accurate estimation of the kinetic energy K and of the condensate fraction n0 of the system. Furthermore, we show that our results for n0 as a function of the pressure are in a good agreement with the most recent experimental results. The study of the solid phase of 4He is the most significant part of this thesis. The recent observation of non classical rotational inertia (NCRI) effects in solid helium has generated big interest in the study of an eventual supersolid phase, characterized at the same time by crystalline order and superfluidity. Nevertheless, until now it has been impossible to give a theoretical model able to describe all the experimental evidences. In this work, we perform PIMC simulations of 4He at high densities, according to different microscopic configurations of the atoms. In commensurate crystals we see that BEC does not appear, our model being able to reproduce the momentum distribution obtained form neutron scattering experiments. In a crystal with vacancies, we have been able to see a transition to a superfluid phase at temperatures in agreement with experimental results if the vacancy concentration is low enough. In amorphous solids, superfluid effects are enhanced but appear at temperatures higher than the experimental estimation for the transition temperature. Finally, we study also metastable disordered configurations in molecular para-hydrogen at low temperature. The aim of this study is to investigate if a Bose liquid other than helium can display superfluidity. Choosing accurately a ¿quantum liquid¿ initial configuration and the dimensions of the simulation box, we have been able to frustrate the formation of the crystal and to calculate the temperature dependence of the superfluid density, showing a transition to a superfluid phase at temperatures close to 1 K.

•Dec 20, 2011•5 citations

Structure and energetics of small helium clusters: Quantum simulations using a recent perturbational pair potential

Marius Lewerenz

We report accurate ground state energies and structural properties for small clusters of 4He computed with the diffusion quantum Monte Carlo (DMC) method combined with high quality trial wave functions and using the recent analytical pair potential of Tang, Toennies, and Yiu [Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 1546 (1995)]. Calculations based on the older HFD-B(He) potential are reported for comparison. The clusters are found to be extremely floppy and to be characterized by very diffuse wave functions. The DMC results for 4He2 and 4He3 are in excellent agreement with other calculations using conventional methods. 4He3 is found to have a noticeable contribution from nearly linear geometries. The internal structure of the clusters is described by a three particle correlation function which reveals a significantly non-spherical internal cluster structure. The energies for all cluster sizes are found to be slightly higher than those obtained with the HFD-B(He) pair potential. Exploratory calculations on the helium trimer indicate that the effects of three body interactions do not exceed the uncertainty margin provided by different state of the art pair potentials.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 15, 1997•134 citations

Bose condensate and structure of isotopic liquid-helium mixtures

Saverio Moroni, Massimo Boninsegni

The ground state of homogeneous, superfluid - 4 He–normal- 3 He mixtures is studied by Fixed-Node Diffusion Monte Carlo simulations. The condensate fraction of the 4 He component only depends on the 3 He concentration through its effect on the average density. Slight deviations of the structural properties from previous variational results, obtained within the Average Correlation Approximation (ACA), are discussed. The momentum distribution and effective mass of the Fermi ( 3 He) component are also calculated.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Nov 1, 1997•9 citations

Local superfluidity at the nanoscale

Bohdan Kulchytskyy, G. Gervais, Adrian Del Maestro

Motivated by the search for an experimentally realizable high density and strongly interacting one-dimensional quantum liquid, we have performed quantum Monte Carlo simulations of bosonic helium-4 confined inside a nanopore with cylindrical symmetry. By implementing two numerical estimators of superfluidity corresponding to capillary flow and the rotating bucket experiment, we have simultaneously measured the finite size and temperature superfluid response of ${}^{4}$He to the longitudinal and rotational motion of the walls of a nanopore. Within the two-fluid model, the portion of the normal liquid dragged along with the boundaries is dependent on the type of motion, and the resulting anisotropic superfluid density plateaus far below unity at $T=0.5\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\text{K}$. The origin of the saturation is uncovered by computing the spatial distribution of superfluidity, with only the core of the nanopore exhibiting any evidence of phase coherence. The superfluid core displays a scaling behavior consistent with Luttinger liquid theory, thereby providing an experimental test for the emergence of a one-dimensional quantum liquid.

arXiv:1303.6954•Physical Review B•Aug 26, 2013•32 citations

Study of helium droplets using quantum Monte Carlo techniques

E. Sola

Helium systems at zero temperature are strongly correlated neutral systems which can only be described by means of quantum mechanics. The existence of the two isotopes 4He and 3He allows the comparison between the quantum effects due to different statistics, bosonic and fermionic. In this Thesis, an analysis of Helium droplets has been done. Throughout this work, both energetic and structural properties of systems with different number of particles N are obtained by means of the Quantum Monte Carlo techniques (Variational and Diffusion Monte Carlo - VMC and DMC-). Several studies on Helium droplets have been published in the last years, most of them using the mean field theory (as the Density Functional) and variational approaches (as VMC). In the case of 4He, also exact DMC results have already been reported, actually, a great number of works have described with high accuracy the ground state of this bosonic system. The appearance of magic numbers from experimental point of view has motivated the study of 4He droplets, and one chapter of this Thesis is focused on this bosonic system. We have carried out a one-by-one energetic study in the range from 20 to 30 particles using the DMC technique to discuss the existence of magic numbers. On the other hand, a brief study about vortices is also done; using out code, one can calculate the energy of a droplet with one vortex inside (EV) and, therefore, the energy of a vortex (EV -E0). About 3He droplets, the sign problem makes their study quite more difficult, for this reason, the number of works is considerably smaller than in the bosonic case. One aim of this thesis was to write a DMC code using both Fixed and Released Node approximations (FN and RN) able to perform high accurate calculations of energetic and structural properties of these finite fermionic systems.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations
Abstract Detailed numerical results obtained with state-of-the-art Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations are presented for the superfluid phase of 4 He at saturated vapor pressure. The aim of this contribution is that of providing reliable, up-to-date estimates for this archetypal superfluid, reflecting the methodological progress that has taken place over the past two decades. We simulate a system comprising 2,048 helium atoms, i.e., an order of magnitude greater in size than those for which results currently regarded as standard references were originally obtained. We offer revised estimates for energetic and structural properties, as well as for the ground state condensate fraction.
Below Tλ = 2.17 K, bulk 4He is a superfluid and has a non-zero Bose-Einstein condensate fraction. This work will focus primarily on how phenomena such as superfluidity, Bose condensation and superfluid vortices are manifested in microscopic, inhomogeneous helium systems. Path Integral Monte Carlo is a powerful method for calculating the equilibrium properties of quantum systems at finite temperature. We have achieved linear scaling of computer time with number of particles through the use of neighbor lists, allowing us to simulate systems of several thousand atoms. We have derived a local superfluid estimator and used it to examine the microscopic superfluid response around a molecule rotating in a helium nanodroplet. We found that the first solvation layer is well-described by a two dimensional superfluid, with thermal excitations occuring at a lower temperature than in bulk helium. The effective moment of inertia of a linear impurity in a helium droplet is calculated, and compared with experimental scattering results. In addition, we calculated the vortex formation energy for both pure droplets and droplets doped with linear impurities, and found that the linear impurities had a negligible impact on the formation energy. A possible spectroscopic signature of vortices in doped helium droplets was suggested. After deriving a local estimator, we calculated the condensate fraction throughout the free helium surface of a semi-infinite slab. These results, along with densitydensity correlation functions, were used to characterize the surface excitations and calculate the extent to which ripplons are present. In addition, the ripplon dispersion relation was calculated using imaginary-time correlation functions, and found to be lll in good agreement with experimental results. Finally, we have calculated the Dey be-Waller factor in solid helium for a range of temperatures and densities, and compared the scaling behavior with the predictions of harmonic theory. The first non-Gaussian contribution to the density distribution was calculated.
Several microscopic theories point out that Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC), i.e., a macroscopic occupation of the lowest energy single particle state in many-boson systems, may appear also in quantum fluids and solids and that it is at the origin of the phenomenon of superfluidity. Nevertheless, the connection between BEC and superfluidity is still matter of debate, since the experimental evidences indicating a non zero condensate fraction in superfluid helium are only indirect. In the theoretical study of BEC in quantum fluids and solids, perturbative approaches are useless because of the strong correlations between the atoms, arising both from the interatomic potential and from the quantum nature of the system. Microscopic Quantum Monte Carlo simulations provide a reliable description of these systems. In particular, the Path Integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) method is very suitable for this purpose. This method is able to provide exact results for the properties of the quantum system, both at zero and finite temperature, only with the definition of the Hamiltonian and of the symmetry properties of the system, giving an easy picture for superfluidity and BEC in many-boson systems. In this thesis, we apply PIMC methods to the study of several quantum fluids and solids. We describe in detail all the features of PIMC, from the sampling methods to the estimators of the physical properties. We present also the most recent techniques, such as the high-order approximations for the thermal density matrix and the worm algorithm, used in PIMC to provide reliable simulations. We study the liquid phase of condensed 4He, providing unbiased estimations of the one-body density matrix g1(r). We analyze the model for g1(r) used to fit the experimental data, highlighting its merits and its faults. In particular we see that, even if it presents some difficulties in the description of the overall behavior of g1(r), it can provide an accurate estimation of the kinetic energy K and of the condensate fraction n0 of the system. Furthermore, we show that our results for n0 as a function of the pressure are in a good agreement with the most recent experimental results. The study of the solid phase of 4He is the most significant part of this thesis. The recent observation of non classical rotational inertia (NCRI) effects in solid helium has generated big interest in the study of an eventual supersolid phase, characterized at the same time by crystalline order and superfluidity. Nevertheless, until now it has been impossible to give a theoretical model able to describe all the experimental evidences. In this work, we perform PIMC simulations of 4He at high densities, according to different microscopic configurations of the atoms. In commensurate crystals we see that BEC does not appear, our model being able to reproduce the momentum distribution obtained form neutron scattering experiments. In a crystal with vacancies, we have been able to see a transition to a superfluid phase at temperatures in agreement with experimental results if the vacancy concentration is low enough. In amorphous solids, superfluid effects are enhanced but appear at temperatures higher than the experimental estimation for the transition temperature. Finally, we study also metastable disordered configurations in molecular para-hydrogen at low temperature. The aim of this study is to investigate if a Bose liquid other than helium can display superfluidity. Choosing accurately a ¿quantum liquid¿ initial configuration and the dimensions of the simulation box, we have been able to frustrate the formation of the crystal and to calculate the temperature dependence of the superfluid density, showing a transition to a superfluid phase at temperatures close to 1 K.
We report accurate ground state energies and structural properties for small clusters of 4He computed with the diffusion quantum Monte Carlo (DMC) method combined with high quality trial wave functions and using the recent analytical pair potential of Tang, Toennies, and Yiu [Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 1546 (1995)]. Calculations based on the older HFD-B(He) potential are reported for comparison. The clusters are found to be extremely floppy and to be characterized by very diffuse wave functions. The DMC results for 4He2 and 4He3 are in excellent agreement with other calculations using conventional methods. 4He3 is found to have a noticeable contribution from nearly linear geometries. The internal structure of the clusters is described by a three particle correlation function which reveals a significantly non-spherical internal cluster structure. The energies for all cluster sizes are found to be slightly higher than those obtained with the HFD-B(He) pair potential. Exploratory calculations on the helium trimer indicate that the effects of three body interactions do not exceed the uncertainty margin provided by different state of the art pair potentials.
The ground state of homogeneous, superfluid - 4 He–normal- 3 He mixtures is studied by Fixed-Node Diffusion Monte Carlo simulations. The condensate fraction of the 4 He component only depends on the 3 He concentration through its effect on the average density. Slight deviations of the structural properties from previous variational results, obtained within the Average Correlation Approximation (ACA), are discussed. The momentum distribution and effective mass of the Fermi ( 3 He) component are also calculated.
Motivated by the search for an experimentally realizable high density and strongly interacting one-dimensional quantum liquid, we have performed quantum Monte Carlo simulations of bosonic helium-4 confined inside a nanopore with cylindrical symmetry. By implementing two numerical estimators of superfluidity corresponding to capillary flow and the rotating bucket experiment, we have simultaneously measured the finite size and temperature superfluid response of 4{}^{4}4He to the longitudinal and rotational motion of the walls of a nanopore. Within the two-fluid model, the portion of the normal liquid dragged along with the boundaries is dependent on the type of motion, and the resulting anisotropic superfluid density plateaus far below unity at T=0.5KT=0.5\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\text{K}T=0.5K. The origin of the saturation is uncovered by computing the spatial distribution of superfluidity, with only the core of the nanopore exhibiting any evidence of phase coherence. The superfluid core displays a scaling behavior consistent with Luttinger liquid theory, thereby providing an experimental test for the emergence of a one-dimensional quantum liquid.
Helium systems at zero temperature are strongly correlated neutral systems which can only be described by means of quantum mechanics. The existence of the two isotopes 4He and 3He allows the comparison between the quantum effects due to different statistics, bosonic and fermionic. In this Thesis, an analysis of Helium droplets has been done. Throughout this work, both energetic and structural properties of systems with different number of particles N are obtained by means of the Quantum Monte Carlo techniques (Variational and Diffusion Monte Carlo - VMC and DMC-). Several studies on Helium droplets have been published in the last years, most of them using the mean field theory (as the Density Functional) and variational approaches (as VMC). In the case of 4He, also exact DMC results have already been reported, actually, a great number of works have described with high accuracy the ground state of this bosonic system. The appearance of magic numbers from experimental point of view has motivated the study of 4He droplets, and one chapter of this Thesis is focused on this bosonic system. We have carried out a one-by-one energetic study in the range from 20 to 30 particles using the DMC technique to discuss the existence of magic numbers. On the other hand, a brief study about vortices is also done; using out code, one can calculate the energy of a droplet with one vortex inside (EV) and, therefore, the energy of a vortex (EV -E0). About 3He droplets, the sign problem makes their study quite more difficult, for this reason, the number of works is considerably smaller than in the bosonic case. One aim of this thesis was to write a DMC code using both Fixed and Released Node approximations (FN and RN) able to perform high accurate calculations of energetic and structural properties of these finite fermionic systems.