Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.07107

Continuous-variable two-dimensional cluster states in the microwave domain

Fabio Lingua, Michele Cortinovis, J. C. Rivera Hernández, David B. Haviland

quant-phSubmitted Apr 8, 2026• Announced Apr 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We demonstrate the experimental realization of two-dimensional, continuous variable (CV) cluster states between 191 microwave frequency modes. This result is obtained by exposing vacuum fluctuations to the input of a Josephson Parametric Amplifier, parametrically pumped by a sum of coherent tones around twice its resonant frequency. By carefully tuning pump frequencies, amplitudes, and phases we engineer the interference between mixing products and realize honeycomb and square lattice CV cluster states with three and four pump tones respectively. We prove the presence of the cluster states with a suitable nullifier test, reaching up to $-1.2$ dB of squeezing of the cluster state's nullifiers. We study hidden entanglement (HE) and show no hidden entanglement up to $\sim -1$ dB of squeezing and negligible HE at optimal squeezing.

Comments
11 pages, 8 figures + supplemental material

Related papers

Continuous-Variable Square-Ladder Cluster States in a Microwave Frequency Comb

Fabio Lingua, J. C. Rivera Hernández, Michele Cortinovis +1 more

We describe an experiment demonstrating the generation of three independent square-ladder continuous-variable cluster states with up to 94 qumodes of a microwave frequency comb. This entanglement structure at a large scale is realized by injecting vacuum fluctuations into a Josephson Parametric Amplifier pumped by three coherent signals around twice its resonance frequency, each having a particular well-defined phase relation. We reach up to 1.4 dB of squeezing of the nullifier that verifies the cluster state on the square ladder graph. Our results are consistent with a more familiar measure of two-mode squeezing, where we find up to 5.42 dB for one pump, and up to 1 dB for three pumps.

arXiv:2411.00599•Physical Review Letters•May 9, 2025•6 citations

Parametrisk generering av klustertillstånd i supraledande kretsar

Michele Cortinovis

This thesis demonstrates the experimental generation of two-dimensional Continuous Variable (CV) cluster states in a superconducting microwave frequency comb using parametric pumping. We develop the Pump Projection Method (PPM) to solve the inverse parametric problem: given a target multimode correlation structure, we determine the required pump configuration by exploiting the orthogonality of elementary coupling matrices in Hilbert-Schmidt space. We experimentally generate square-lattice and honeycomb-lattice cluster states with up to several tens of modes, verified through nullifier measurements showing squeezing below the vacuum level. The states exhibit scalability with respect to mode number and robustness against frequency spacing variations. A dissipative model explains the optimal pumping regime, while hidden entanglement analysis confirms negligible unwanted correlations. These results establish a systematic framework for engineering programmable multimode entanglement in superconducting circuits, providing a versatile platform for Measurement-Based Quantum Computation (MBQC) in the microwave domain.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Bipartite entanglement under frequency comb pumping in parametric Josephson circuits

Mikael Vartiainen, Ilari Lilja, Ekaterina Mukhanova +3 more

The creation of high-quality cluster states in superconducting microwave circuits is a relevant ingredient in continuous-variable quantum computing. Although large-scale cluster states have been established in optical systems, dissipation prevents their direct applicability to the microwave realm. Recent improvements in superconducting parametric circuits, in particular Josephson parametric amplifiers (JPA) and traveling wave parametric amplifiers (TWPA), have permitted substantial progress in producing entangled states using microwave photons. In this paper, we examine experimentally and theoretically the effects of numerous parametric pump tones on the degree of two-mode squeezing in a quantum circuit and apply it to the JPA. We find that additional pumps diminish the initial two-mode correlations achieved with a single pump by redistributing it among a larger network of modes and by introducing entanglement with additional idler frequencies. Taking into account the actual heterodyne measurement conditions, the experimental results are consistent with theoretical expectations.

quant-pharXiv:2604.21692•Apr 24, 2026•0 citations

Programmable microwave cluster states via Josephson metamaterials

Alessandro Alocco, Andrea Celotto, E. Palumbo +5 more

Cluster states are a fundamental resource for continuous-variable quantum computing, enabling measurement-based protocols that can scale beyond the limitations of qubit-based architectures. Here, we demonstrate on-demand generation of multimode entangled microwave cluster states using a programmable Josephson Traveling-Wave Parametric Amplifier (JTWPA) operated in the three-wave mixing regime. By injecting a tailored, non-equidistant set of pump tones via an arbitrary waveform generator, we engineer frequency-specific nonlinear couplings between multiple frequency modes. The entanglement structure is verified via frequency-resolved heterodyne detection of quadrature nullifiers, confirming the target graph topology of the cluster state. Our approach allows reconfigurability through the pumps spectrum and supports scalability by leveraging the wide bandwidth and spatial homogeneity of the JTWPA. This platform opens new avenues for scalable measurement-based quantum information processing in the microwave domain, compatible with superconducting circuit architectures.

arXiv:2507.22823•Nature Communications•Jun 18, 2026•0 citations

Ultracompact generation of continuous-variable cluster states

Nicolas C. Menicucci, Steven T. Flammia, Hussain Zaidi +1 more

We propose an experimental scheme that has the potential for large-scale realization of continuous-variable (CV) cluster states for universal quantum computation. We do this by mapping CV cluster-state graphs onto two-mode squeezing graphs, which can be engineered into a single optical parametric oscillator (OPO). The desired CV cluster state is produced directly from a joint squeezing operation on the vacuum, using a multifrequency pump beam. This method has potential for ultracompact experimental implementation. As an illustration, we detail an experimental proposal for creating a four-mode square CV cluster state with a single OPO.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703096•Physical Review A•Jul 12, 2007•105 citations

Observation of Two-Mode Squeezing in the Microwave Frequency Domain

Christopher Eichler, Deniz Bozyigit, Claus Lang +5 more

Continuous variable entanglement between two modes of a radiation field is usually studied at optical frequencies. Here we demonstrate experiments that show the entanglement between microwave photons of different energy in a broadband squeezed beam. We use a Josephson parametric amplifier to generate the two-mode correlated state and detect all four quadrature components simultaneously in a two-channel heterodyne setup using amplitude detectors. Analyzing two-dimensional phase space histograms for all possible pairs of quadratures allows us to determine the full covariance matrix, which is in good agreement with the one expected for a two-mode squeezed state.

arXiv:1101.2136•Physical Review Letters•Sep 6, 2011•266 citations
We demonstrate the experimental realization of two-dimensional, continuous variable (CV) cluster states between 191 microwave frequency modes. This result is obtained by exposing vacuum fluctuations to the input of a Josephson Parametric Amplifier, parametrically pumped by a sum of coherent tones around twice its resonant frequency. By carefully tuning pump frequencies, amplitudes, and phases we engineer the interference between mixing products and realize honeycomb and square lattice CV cluster states with three and four pump tones respectively. We prove the presence of the cluster states with a suitable nullifier test, reaching up to −1.2-1.2−1.2 dB of squeezing of the cluster state's nullifiers. We study hidden entanglement (HE) and show no hidden entanglement up to ∼−1\sim -1∼−1 dB of squeezing and negligible HE at optimal squeezing.
We describe an experiment demonstrating the generation of three independent square-ladder continuous-variable cluster states with up to 94 qumodes of a microwave frequency comb. This entanglement structure at a large scale is realized by injecting vacuum fluctuations into a Josephson Parametric Amplifier pumped by three coherent signals around twice its resonance frequency, each having a particular well-defined phase relation. We reach up to 1.4 dB of squeezing of the nullifier that verifies the cluster state on the square ladder graph. Our results are consistent with a more familiar measure of two-mode squeezing, where we find up to 5.42 dB for one pump, and up to 1 dB for three pumps.
This thesis demonstrates the experimental generation of two-dimensional Continuous Variable (CV) cluster states in a superconducting microwave frequency comb using parametric pumping. We develop the Pump Projection Method (PPM) to solve the inverse parametric problem: given a target multimode correlation structure, we determine the required pump configuration by exploiting the orthogonality of elementary coupling matrices in Hilbert-Schmidt space. We experimentally generate square-lattice and honeycomb-lattice cluster states with up to several tens of modes, verified through nullifier measurements showing squeezing below the vacuum level. The states exhibit scalability with respect to mode number and robustness against frequency spacing variations. A dissipative model explains the optimal pumping regime, while hidden entanglement analysis confirms negligible unwanted correlations. These results establish a systematic framework for engineering programmable multimode entanglement in superconducting circuits, providing a versatile platform for Measurement-Based Quantum Computation (MBQC) in the microwave domain.
The creation of high-quality cluster states in superconducting microwave circuits is a relevant ingredient in continuous-variable quantum computing. Although large-scale cluster states have been established in optical systems, dissipation prevents their direct applicability to the microwave realm. Recent improvements in superconducting parametric circuits, in particular Josephson parametric amplifiers (JPA) and traveling wave parametric amplifiers (TWPA), have permitted substantial progress in producing entangled states using microwave photons. In this paper, we examine experimentally and theoretically the effects of numerous parametric pump tones on the degree of two-mode squeezing in a quantum circuit and apply it to the JPA. We find that additional pumps diminish the initial two-mode correlations achieved with a single pump by redistributing it among a larger network of modes and by introducing entanglement with additional idler frequencies. Taking into account the actual heterodyne measurement conditions, the experimental results are consistent with theoretical expectations.
Cluster states are a fundamental resource for continuous-variable quantum computing, enabling measurement-based protocols that can scale beyond the limitations of qubit-based architectures. Here, we demonstrate on-demand generation of multimode entangled microwave cluster states using a programmable Josephson Traveling-Wave Parametric Amplifier (JTWPA) operated in the three-wave mixing regime. By injecting a tailored, non-equidistant set of pump tones via an arbitrary waveform generator, we engineer frequency-specific nonlinear couplings between multiple frequency modes. The entanglement structure is verified via frequency-resolved heterodyne detection of quadrature nullifiers, confirming the target graph topology of the cluster state. Our approach allows reconfigurability through the pumps spectrum and supports scalability by leveraging the wide bandwidth and spatial homogeneity of the JTWPA. This platform opens new avenues for scalable measurement-based quantum information processing in the microwave domain, compatible with superconducting circuit architectures.
We propose an experimental scheme that has the potential for large-scale realization of continuous-variable (CV) cluster states for universal quantum computation. We do this by mapping CV cluster-state graphs onto two-mode squeezing graphs, which can be engineered into a single optical parametric oscillator (OPO). The desired CV cluster state is produced directly from a joint squeezing operation on the vacuum, using a multifrequency pump beam. This method has potential for ultracompact experimental implementation. As an illustration, we detail an experimental proposal for creating a four-mode square CV cluster state with a single OPO.
Continuous variable entanglement between two modes of a radiation field is usually studied at optical frequencies. Here we demonstrate experiments that show the entanglement between microwave photons of different energy in a broadband squeezed beam. We use a Josephson parametric amplifier to generate the two-mode correlated state and detect all four quadrature components simultaneously in a two-channel heterodyne setup using amplitude detectors. Analyzing two-dimensional phase space histograms for all possible pairs of quadratures allows us to determine the full covariance matrix, which is in good agreement with the one expected for a two-mode squeezed state.