Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.28538

From Hole Theory to Quantum Field Theory: Relativistic Fermions and the Role of Ettore Majorana (1933-1937)

Francesco Vissani

physics.hist-phhep-thquant-phSubmitted Mar 30, 2026• Announced Mar 31, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Between 1933 and 1937, the treatment of relativistic spin-1/2 particles, initially rooted in Hole theory, evolved into the modern framework of quantum field theory. This paper reconstructs the crucial stages of that transition by examining the formal and physical progress of the numerous authors who shaped the field's modern formalism. This historical study traces the development of fermionic field theory in full, beginning with the foundational work of the 1920s, focussing on the results of the 1930s, and concluding with the influential synthesis of Wolfgang Pauli in 1941, the content of which has shaped the subsequent tradition. Within this framework, particular emphasis is given to Ettore Majorana's 1937 quantisation procedure and argument for anti-commuting fermionic quantum fields. This study demonstrates that Majorana's work was not merely a technical variant, but the definitive rejection of the concept of negative energy solutions, whose conceptual clarity and educational value remain vital today.

Comments
34 pages, 3 tables. Includes a detailed and didactic analysis of Majorana's 1937 paper using modern notation and provides supplementary notes, designed for modern readers. Accepted for publication in EPJH

Related papers

How Pauli's rule became the exclusion principle: from Fermi–Dirac statistics to the spin–statistics theorem

Michela Massimi

Shortly after their introduction, the electron's Zweideutigkeit and Pauli's Ausschliessungsregel were embedded into a growing theoretical framework: from Fermi–Dirac statistics in 1926 (Section 4.2), to the non-relativistic quantum mechanics of the magnetic electron with Pauli's spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.3); from Wigner and von Neumann's group theoretical derivation of the spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.4), to Jordan's reinterpretation of Pauli's exclusion principle in terms of anticommutation relations for particle creation and annihilation operators in 1928 (Section 4.5), which paved the way for quantum field theory. The most important step in building up this theoretical framework was the transition from non-relativistic to relativistic quantum mechanics, with Dirac's equation for the electron in 1928 (Section 4.6), which finally allowed the derivation of the electron's spin with its anomalous magnetic moment and hence clarified in a conclusive way the origin of spectroscopic anomalies. The negative energy solutions of the Dirac equation, and Dirac's attempt to accommodate them via the hole theory in 1930, anticipated the experimental discovery of the antiparticle of the electron, the positron. Sections 4.7-4.9 reconstruct Pauli's sustained criticism of Dirac's hole theory. The history of this debate is intertwined with Pauli's search for a spin–statistics connection, which finally culminated in the spin–statistics theorem in 1940. With this theorem, the nomological shift from the status of a phenomenological rule to that of a fundamental scientific principle is finally completed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 4, 2005•0 citations

The Covariant Relativistic Derivation of De Broglie Relation

Samuel Bueno Soltau

This paper provides an examination of the de Broglie relation, tracing its historical development from the quantum hypotheses proposed by Planck and Einstein to its covariant relativistic derivation. The discussion begins by situating de Broglie's seminal insight within the early framework of quantum theory. We then reconstruct his original heuristic derivation. The primary focus of this work, however, is the derivation of the de Broglie relation directly from the principles of special relativity, employing the four-momentum formalism. A comparative analysis between the heuristic and relativistic approaches underscores the universality and conceptual coherence of the latter. The paper concludes by highlighting the significance of relativistic mechanics in establishing a consistent foundation for wave-particle duality, further reinforcing this through a quantum field theoretical perspective.

arXiv:2508.03908•Sitientibus Série Ciências Físicas•Nov 1, 2025•2 citations

Between Heisenberg and Feynman: Ettore Majorana's Reflections on the Meaning of Quantum Theory

Andréa Oldofredi

Ettore Majorana is undoubtedly one of the most important figures in 20th-century Italian science. His contributions to nuclear physics and Quantum Mechanics (QM) included innovative ideas, and the search for Majorana-type neutrinos remains an ongoing experimental research question. However, very little is known about his perspective on the significance of the quantum state, the philosophical implications of the then-new mechanics, and the relationship between QM and other sciences. This chapter aims to address this gap. In more detail, here I present the standard interpretation of Majorana's view on the quantum state, according to which the Italian physicist anticipated the physical content of Feynman's path-integral formulation of quantum theory. In what follows, I critically examine this position and propose an alternative understanding of Majorana's beliefs on the nature of the quantum state and the wave function. Finally, I briefly discuss his reflections concerning the major conceptual revolutions introduced by QM, notably, in his view, the impossibility of extending the objectivity and determinism of classical mechanics to the quantum realm, and their consequences for the relation between physics and the social sciences, disciplines that Majorana deeply studied before his disappearance.

arXiv:2611.07143•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Towards a Relativistic Quantum Mechanics

J. Iliopoulos, Theodore N. Tomaras

Abstract The Klein–Gordon and the Dirac equations are studied as candidates for a relativistic generalisation of the Schrödinger equation. We show that the first is unacceptable because it admits solutions with arbitrarily large negative energy and has no conserved current with positive definite probability density. The Dirac equation on the other hand does have a physically acceptable conserved current, but it too suffers from the presence of negative energy solutions. We show that the latter can be interpreted as describing anti-particles. In either case there is no fully consistent interpretation as a single-particle wave equation and we are led to a formalism admitting an infinite number of degrees of freedom, that is a quantum field theory. We can still use the Dirac equation at low energies when the effects of anti-particles are negligible and we study applications in atomic physics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Oct 25, 2021•0 citations

Foundational Problems in and Methodological Lessons from Quantum Field Theory

James T. Cushing

Abstract One can consider the developments in quantum field theory from the point of view of foundational problems posed about physical reality at both the epistemological and ontological levels, or as a ‘laboratory’ to study the actual methodology of the scientific enterprise. I shall address both of these issues in this paper. My contention is that at the foundational level there is essentially nothing new in quantum field theory that is not already present in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. This is quite different in emphasis from the view expressed by Redhead (1983a). Even in quantum mechanics most of the difficulties which arise are generated by the realist’s inclination to take the formalism too literally as representing physical reality, often in a modified or distorted classical view. More serious consideration of Bohr’s philosophical framework of complementarity may prove fruitful for coping with this problem, which is not new to quantum field theory, being already the central interpretative problem of quantum mechanics. On the other hand, as a source to illustrate how theories arc constructed and established in actual scientific practice, quantum field theory does provide a wide range of useful examples. Here too, although there are many technically fascinating topics (such as renormalization), quantum field theory is pretty much (meth odological) business as usual. Much more interesting, essentially new, methodological departures are seriously proposed (with varying degrees of credibility) by some rival or alternative developments in modern theoretical physics, such as the S-matrix programme, with its bootstrap conjecture, or cosmology, with various forms of the anthropic principle (Gale 1983) and with the inflationary universe scenario (Guth 1981 ).

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 5, 1990•7 citations

Modern Physics From Relativity to Quantum Mechanics BY Dr. Karunakar Shakampally,Dr. Jyotsna Krishnarao Jumale ,Dr. Ritesh Krishnarao Jumale,Dr Onkar A. Ramdasi

Dr. Karunakar Shakampally,Dr. Jyotsna Krishnarao Jumale ,Dr. Ritesh Krishnarao Jumale,Dr Onkar A. Ramdasi

The field of modern physics represents one of the most profound intellectual revolutions in the history of science. From the groundbreaking insights of relativity to the fascinating and often counterintuitive principles of quantum mechanics, modern physics has reshaped our understanding of space, time, matter, and energy. The book Modern Physics: From Relativity to Quantum Mechanics is a collective effort to present these transformative ideas in a clear, structured, and accessible manner for students, educators, and researchers. This multi-author volume brings together the expertise and academic experience of distinguished scholars who have dedicated their careers to teaching and advancing the field of physics. Each contributor offers a unique perspective, ensuring that the topics are explored with both depth and clarity. The collaborative nature of this work allows for a comprehensive treatment of concepts ranging from the foundations of special and general relativity to the principles governing atomic and subatomic systems. The primary aim of this book is to bridge the gap between classical physics and contemporary scientific developments. It is designed to serve as a foundational text for undergraduate and postgraduate students, while also acting as a reference for researchers and educators. Care has been taken to present theoretical concepts alongside practical applications, enabling readers to appreciate both the elegance and utility of modern physics. The chapters are organized in a logical progression, beginning with the limitations of classical physics and the emergence of relativity, followed by an in-depth exploration of quantum theory, atomic structure, and advanced topics in modern physics. Mathematical rigor is balanced with conceptual explanations, making the content both challenging and approachable. We would like to express our sincere gratitude to all contributors for their dedication and scholarly input. Their combined efforts have made this book a rich and valuable resource. We also extend our appreciation to academic institutions, colleagues, and students whose feedback and encouragement have played a crucial role in shaping this work. It is our hope that this book will inspire curiosity, foster critical thinking, and serve as a stepping stone for further exploration in the fascinating world of modern physics. As the field continues to evolve, we trust that readers will find in these pages both a solid foundation and a source of inspiration for future discoveries.

•Apr 5, 2026•0 citations
Between 1933 and 1937, the treatment of relativistic spin-1/2 particles, initially rooted in Hole theory, evolved into the modern framework of quantum field theory. This paper reconstructs the crucial stages of that transition by examining the formal and physical progress of the numerous authors who shaped the field's modern formalism. This historical study traces the development of fermionic field theory in full, beginning with the foundational work of the 1920s, focussing on the results of the 1930s, and concluding with the influential synthesis of Wolfgang Pauli in 1941, the content of which has shaped the subsequent tradition. Within this framework, particular emphasis is given to Ettore Majorana's 1937 quantisation procedure and argument for anti-commuting fermionic quantum fields. This study demonstrates that Majorana's work was not merely a technical variant, but the definitive rejection of the concept of negative energy solutions, whose conceptual clarity and educational value remain vital today.
Shortly after their introduction, the electron's Zweideutigkeit and Pauli's Ausschliessungsregel were embedded into a growing theoretical framework: from Fermi–Dirac statistics in 1926 (Section 4.2), to the non-relativistic quantum mechanics of the magnetic electron with Pauli's spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.3); from Wigner and von Neumann's group theoretical derivation of the spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.4), to Jordan's reinterpretation of Pauli's exclusion principle in terms of anticommutation relations for particle creation and annihilation operators in 1928 (Section 4.5), which paved the way for quantum field theory. The most important step in building up this theoretical framework was the transition from non-relativistic to relativistic quantum mechanics, with Dirac's equation for the electron in 1928 (Section 4.6), which finally allowed the derivation of the electron's spin with its anomalous magnetic moment and hence clarified in a conclusive way the origin of spectroscopic anomalies. The negative energy solutions of the Dirac equation, and Dirac's attempt to accommodate them via the hole theory in 1930, anticipated the experimental discovery of the antiparticle of the electron, the positron. Sections 4.7-4.9 reconstruct Pauli's sustained criticism of Dirac's hole theory. The history of this debate is intertwined with Pauli's search for a spin–statistics connection, which finally culminated in the spin–statistics theorem in 1940. With this theorem, the nomological shift from the status of a phenomenological rule to that of a fundamental scientific principle is finally completed.
This paper provides an examination of the de Broglie relation, tracing its historical development from the quantum hypotheses proposed by Planck and Einstein to its covariant relativistic derivation. The discussion begins by situating de Broglie's seminal insight within the early framework of quantum theory. We then reconstruct his original heuristic derivation. The primary focus of this work, however, is the derivation of the de Broglie relation directly from the principles of special relativity, employing the four-momentum formalism. A comparative analysis between the heuristic and relativistic approaches underscores the universality and conceptual coherence of the latter. The paper concludes by highlighting the significance of relativistic mechanics in establishing a consistent foundation for wave-particle duality, further reinforcing this through a quantum field theoretical perspective.
Ettore Majorana is undoubtedly one of the most important figures in 20th-century Italian science. His contributions to nuclear physics and Quantum Mechanics (QM) included innovative ideas, and the search for Majorana-type neutrinos remains an ongoing experimental research question. However, very little is known about his perspective on the significance of the quantum state, the philosophical implications of the then-new mechanics, and the relationship between QM and other sciences. This chapter aims to address this gap. In more detail, here I present the standard interpretation of Majorana's view on the quantum state, according to which the Italian physicist anticipated the physical content of Feynman's path-integral formulation of quantum theory. In what follows, I critically examine this position and propose an alternative understanding of Majorana's beliefs on the nature of the quantum state and the wave function. Finally, I briefly discuss his reflections concerning the major conceptual revolutions introduced by QM, notably, in his view, the impossibility of extending the objectivity and determinism of classical mechanics to the quantum realm, and their consequences for the relation between physics and the social sciences, disciplines that Majorana deeply studied before his disappearance.
Abstract The Klein–Gordon and the Dirac equations are studied as candidates for a relativistic generalisation of the Schrödinger equation. We show that the first is unacceptable because it admits solutions with arbitrarily large negative energy and has no conserved current with positive definite probability density. The Dirac equation on the other hand does have a physically acceptable conserved current, but it too suffers from the presence of negative energy solutions. We show that the latter can be interpreted as describing anti-particles. In either case there is no fully consistent interpretation as a single-particle wave equation and we are led to a formalism admitting an infinite number of degrees of freedom, that is a quantum field theory. We can still use the Dirac equation at low energies when the effects of anti-particles are negligible and we study applications in atomic physics.
Abstract One can consider the developments in quantum field theory from the point of view of foundational problems posed about physical reality at both the epistemological and ontological levels, or as a ‘laboratory’ to study the actual methodology of the scientific enterprise. I shall address both of these issues in this paper. My contention is that at the foundational level there is essentially nothing new in quantum field theory that is not already present in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. This is quite different in emphasis from the view expressed by Redhead (1983a). Even in quantum mechanics most of the difficulties which arise are generated by the realist’s inclination to take the formalism too literally as representing physical reality, often in a modified or distorted classical view. More serious consideration of Bohr’s philosophical framework of complementarity may prove fruitful for coping with this problem, which is not new to quantum field theory, being already the central interpretative problem of quantum mechanics. On the other hand, as a source to illustrate how theories arc constructed and established in actual scientific practice, quantum field theory does provide a wide range of useful examples. Here too, although there are many technically fascinating topics (such as renormalization), quantum field theory is pretty much (meth odological) business as usual. Much more interesting, essentially new, methodological departures are seriously proposed (with varying degrees of credibility) by some rival or alternative developments in modern theoretical physics, such as the S-matrix programme, with its bootstrap conjecture, or cosmology, with various forms of the anthropic principle (Gale 1983) and with the inflationary universe scenario (Guth 1981 ).
The field of modern physics represents one of the most profound intellectual revolutions in the history of science. From the groundbreaking insights of relativity to the fascinating and often counterintuitive principles of quantum mechanics, modern physics has reshaped our understanding of space, time, matter, and energy. The book Modern Physics: From Relativity to Quantum Mechanics is a collective effort to present these transformative ideas in a clear, structured, and accessible manner for students, educators, and researchers. This multi-author volume brings together the expertise and academic experience of distinguished scholars who have dedicated their careers to teaching and advancing the field of physics. Each contributor offers a unique perspective, ensuring that the topics are explored with both depth and clarity. The collaborative nature of this work allows for a comprehensive treatment of concepts ranging from the foundations of special and general relativity to the principles governing atomic and subatomic systems. The primary aim of this book is to bridge the gap between classical physics and contemporary scientific developments. It is designed to serve as a foundational text for undergraduate and postgraduate students, while also acting as a reference for researchers and educators. Care has been taken to present theoretical concepts alongside practical applications, enabling readers to appreciate both the elegance and utility of modern physics. The chapters are organized in a logical progression, beginning with the limitations of classical physics and the emergence of relativity, followed by an in-depth exploration of quantum theory, atomic structure, and advanced topics in modern physics. Mathematical rigor is balanced with conceptual explanations, making the content both challenging and approachable. We would like to express our sincere gratitude to all contributors for their dedication and scholarly input. Their combined efforts have made this book a rich and valuable resource. We also extend our appreciation to academic institutions, colleagues, and students whose feedback and encouragement have played a crucial role in shaping this work. It is our hope that this book will inspire curiosity, foster critical thinking, and serve as a stepping stone for further exploration in the fascinating world of modern physics. As the field continues to evolve, we trust that readers will find in these pages both a solid foundation and a source of inspiration for future discoveries.