Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.06929

Proton-Size Resolution of the Hyperfine Puzzle in Hydrogen

Gerald A. Miller

Published Feb 6, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Baym and Farrar (arXiv:2601.02300v1) have recently pointed out a puzzle in understanding the role of the hyperfine interaction in the ground state of a hydrogen atom. If one uses a variational wave function in which the Bohr radius, $a_0$ is replaced by a variational radius parameter, $R$, first-order perturbation theory can give a contribution to the energy proportional to $-1/R^3$. This raises the question of why the hyperfine interaction does not lead to collapse of hydrogen. I show that including the effects of the non-zero size of the proton leads to a resolution of the puzzle such that the variational procedure yields a value of $R$ that is indistinguishable from $a_0$.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2602.06929

Related papers

Hydrogen Atom

James W. Rohlf

The Bohr model is highly successful in explaining many features of the hydrogen atom. The ground state wave function does not have any angular dependence. The normalized hydrogen atom wave functions are directly accessible in Mathematica and can be readily verified as solutions of the Schrodinger equation. Get the hydrogen atom ground state wave function in terms of the Bohr radius a. The probability of finding the electron per volume at a given location is given by the square of the wave function. The electron has only a very tiny probability of being found inside the proton, whose size is about 1 fm.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 18, 2023•0 citations

Study the Ground State Perturbed Eigenfunction with Modified Order Parameters of Hydrogen Atom

Rajendra Prasad Kurmi, Suresh Prasad Gupta, Chitra Prasad Lamichhane +6 more

Studying the eigen value function of a perturbed hydrogen atom in its ground state with various orders is the goal of this investigation (1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th). The new equation is created using the theoretic way to investigate the nature of eigen function. At various perturbed order parameters, it is discovered that the nature rapidly decreases with distance from the Bohr’s radius. Additionally, the nature with perturbed order parameters was discovered to be linear at various separations beyond Bohr’s radius. This demonstrates that while a large amount of energy is needed to perturbed a system close to the Bohr’s radius, very little energy is needed to perturbed a system farther away from the Bohr’s radius.

European Journal of Applied Physics•Feb 8, 2023•0 citations

Hyperfine splitting in the ground state of hydrogen

David J. Griffiths

The hyperfine structure of atomic hydrogen is derived in a simple and self-contained way that makes the theory accessible to advanced undergraduates in a first course on quantum mechanics.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1982•99 citations

A Classical Description of the Hyperfine Structure of the Hydrogen Atom

Andrea Chaney, James M. Espinosa, James R. Woodyard

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Oct 23, 2010•0 citations

Hyperfine Interaction in the Hydrogen Atom

Ronald A. Lovett

•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations

Long-range interactions of hydrogen atoms in excited states. II. Hyperfine-resolved ( 2S−2S ) systems

Ulrich D. Jentschura, Vincent Debierre, Chandra Mani Adhikari +2 more

The interaction of two excited hydrogen atoms in metastable states constitutes a theoretically interesting problem because of the quasidegenerate $2{P}_{1/2}$ levels that are removed from the $2S$ states only by the Lamb shift. The total Hamiltonian of the system is composed of the van der Waals Hamiltonian, the Lamb shift, and the hyperfine effects. The van der Waals shift becomes commensurate with the $2S\ensuremath{-}2{P}_{3/2}$ fine-structure splitting only for close approach ($R<100{a}_{0}$, where ${a}_{0}$ is the Bohr radius) and one may thus restrict the discussion to the levels with $n=2$ and $J=1/2$ to a good approximation. Because each $S$ or $P$ state splits into an $F=1$ triplet and an $F=0$ hyperfine singlet (eight states for each atom), the Hamiltonian matrix a priori is of dimension 64. A careful analysis of the symmetries of the the problem allows one to reduce the dimensionality of the most involved irreducible submatrix to 12. We determine the Hamiltonian matrices and the leading-order van der Waals shifts for states that are degenerate under the action of the unperturbed Hamiltonian (Lamb shift plus hyperfine structure). The leading first- and second-order van der Waals shifts lead to interaction energies proportional to $1/{R}^{3}$ and $1/{R}^{6}$ and are evaluated within the hyperfine manifolds. When both atoms are metastable $2S$ states, we find an interaction energy of order ${E}_{h}\ensuremath{\chi}{({a}_{0}/R)}^{6}$, where ${E}_{h}$ and $\mathcal{L}$ are the Hartree and Lamb shift energies, respectively, and $\ensuremath{\chi}={E}_{h}/\mathcal{L}\ensuremath{\approx}6.22\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ is their ratio.

arXiv:1701.08813•Physical Review A•Feb 2, 2017•17 citations
Baym and Farrar (arXiv:2601.02300v1) have recently pointed out a puzzle in understanding the role of the hyperfine interaction in the ground state of a hydrogen atom. If one uses a variational wave function in which the Bohr radius, a0a_0a0​ is replaced by a variational radius parameter, RRR, first-order perturbation theory can give a contribution to the energy proportional to −1/R3-1/R^3−1/R3. This raises the question of why the hyperfine interaction does not lead to collapse of hydrogen. I show that including the effects of the non-zero size of the proton leads to a resolution of the puzzle such that the variational procedure yields a value of RRR that is indistinguishable from a0a_0a0​.
The Bohr model is highly successful in explaining many features of the hydrogen atom. The ground state wave function does not have any angular dependence. The normalized hydrogen atom wave functions are directly accessible in Mathematica and can be readily verified as solutions of the Schrodinger equation. Get the hydrogen atom ground state wave function in terms of the Bohr radius a. The probability of finding the electron per volume at a given location is given by the square of the wave function. The electron has only a very tiny probability of being found inside the proton, whose size is about 1 fm.
Studying the eigen value function of a perturbed hydrogen atom in its ground state with various orders is the goal of this investigation (1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th). The new equation is created using the theoretic way to investigate the nature of eigen function. At various perturbed order parameters, it is discovered that the nature rapidly decreases with distance from the Bohr’s radius. Additionally, the nature with perturbed order parameters was discovered to be linear at various separations beyond Bohr’s radius. This demonstrates that while a large amount of energy is needed to perturbed a system close to the Bohr’s radius, very little energy is needed to perturbed a system farther away from the Bohr’s radius.
The interaction of two excited hydrogen atoms in metastable states constitutes a theoretically interesting problem because of the quasidegenerate 2P1/22{P}_{1/2}2P1/2​ levels that are removed from the 2S2S2S states only by the Lamb shift. The total Hamiltonian of the system is composed of the van der Waals Hamiltonian, the Lamb shift, and the hyperfine effects. The van der Waals shift becomes commensurate with the $2S\ensuremath{-}2{P}_{3/2}$ fine-structure splitting only for close approach (R<100a0R<100{a}_{0}R<100a0​, where a0{a}_{0}a0​ is the Bohr radius) and one may thus restrict the discussion to the levels with n=2n=2n=2 and J=1/2J=1/2J=1/2 to a good approximation. Because each SSS or PPP state splits into an F=1F=1F=1 triplet and an F=0F=0F=0 hyperfine singlet (eight states for each atom), the Hamiltonian matrix a priori is of dimension 64. A careful analysis of the symmetries of the the problem allows one to reduce the dimensionality of the most involved irreducible submatrix to 12. We determine the Hamiltonian matrices and the leading-order van der Waals shifts for states that are degenerate under the action of the unperturbed Hamiltonian (Lamb shift plus hyperfine structure). The leading first- and second-order van der Waals shifts lead to interaction energies proportional to 1/R31/{R}^{3}1/R3 and 1/R61/{R}^{6}1/R6 and are evaluated within the hyperfine manifolds. When both atoms are metastable 2S2S2S states, we find an interaction energy of order ${E}_{h}\ensuremath{\chi}{({a}_{0}/R)}^{6}$, where Eh{E}_{h}Eh​ and L\mathcal{L}L are the Hartree and Lamb shift energies, respectively, and $\ensuremath{\chi}={E}_{h}/\mathcal{L}\ensuremath{\approx}6.22\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ is their ratio.