Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.24448

Incorporating multi-qubit exchange coupling effects between transmon qubits in Maxwell-Schrödinger numerical methods

Ghazi Khan, Thomas E. Roth

quant-phSubmitted Dec 30, 2025• Announced Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Superconducting qubits have emerged as a leading platform for realizing quantum computers. Accurate modeling of these devices is essential for predicting performance, improving design, and optimizing control. Many modeling approaches currently rely on lumped circuit approximations or other simplified treatments that can be limited in resolving the interplay between the qubit dynamics and the electromagnetic circuitry, leading to significant experimental deviations from numerical predictions at times. To address many of these limitations, methods that self-consistently solve the Schrödinger equation for qubit dynamics with the classical Maxwell's equations have been developed and shown to accurately predict a wide range of effects related to superconducting qubit control and readout. Despite these successes, these methods have not been able to consider multi-qubit effects that give rise to qubit-qubit entanglement. Here, we address this by rigorously deriving how multi-qubit coupling effects between transmon qubits can be embedded into Maxwell-Schrödinger methods. To support this, we build on earlier first-principles derivations of Maxwell-Schrödinger methods for the specific case of two transmon qubits coupled together through a common electromagnetic system in the dispersive regime. To aid in validating aspects of the Maxwell-Schrödinger framework, we also provide a new interpretation of Maxwell-Schrödinger methods as an efficient simulation strategy to capture the class of non-Markovian open quantum system dynamics. Our results demonstrate that these effects can give rise to strong classical crosstalk that can significantly alter multi-qubit dynamics, which we demonstrate for the cross-resonance gate. These classical crosstalk effects have been noted in cross-resonance experiments, but previous quantum theory and device analysis could not explain their origin.

Comments
17 pages, 12 figures

Related papers

Field-based formalism for calculating multiqubit exchange-coupling rates for transmon qubits

Ghazi Khan, Thomas E. Roth

Superconducting qubits are one of the most mature platforms for achieving practical quantum computers, but significant performance improvements are still needed. To improve the engineering of these systems, three-dimensional (3D) full-wave computational electromagnetics analyses are increasingly being turned to. Unfortunately, existing analysis approaches often rely on full-wave simulations using eigenmode solvers that are typically cumbersome, not robust, and computationally prohibitive if devices with more than a few qubits are to be analyzed. To improve the characterization of superconducting circuits while circumventing these drawbacks, this work begins the development of an alternative modeling framework that we illustrate in the context of evaluating the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate between transmon qubits. This quantity is a key design parameter that determines the entanglement rate for fast multiqubit gate performance and also affects decoherence sources like qubit crosstalk. Our modeling framework uses a field-based formalism in the context of macroscopic quantum electrodynamics, which we use to show that the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate can be related to the electromagnetic dyadic Green's function linking the qubits together. We further show how the needed quantity involving the dyadic Green's function can be related to the impedance response of the system that can be easily and efficiently computed with classical computational electromagnetics tools. We demonstrate the validity and efficacy of this approach by simulating four practical multiqubit superconducting circuits and evaluating their qubit-qubit exchange coupling rates. We validate our results against a 3D numerical diagonalization method and against experimental data where available. We also demonstrate the impact of the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate on qubit crosstalk by simulating a multicoupler device and identifying operating points where the qubit crosstalk becomes zero.

arXiv:2406.05473•Physical Review Applied•Dec 23, 2024•6 citations

Hybrid 1D Maxwell-Schrödinger Modeling of Dispersive Regime Effects of a Transmon Qubit

Thomas E. Roth

Transmon qubits integrated into microwave circuitry are a leading quantum computing architecture. However, significant engineering improvements are still needed. General-purpose numerical methods are becoming of interest to tackle these challenges, but existing fully-quantum methods are highly inefficient. In this work, we formulate a semiclassical Maxwell-Schrödinger model as an alternative approach to efficiently analyze the interactions of transmons capacitively coupled to transmission line networks. Additionally, we present a suitable discretization and time marching strategy. We validate our approach by comparing it to theoretical models relevant to the dispersive operating regime used in most hardware implementations. Our results show that our method can accurately predict effects related to transmon state measurements that are typically derived using fully-quantum models. In the future, our approach can be used to rapidly explore broader design spaces to improve the speed and fidelity of qubit state measurements, which is a key obstacle toward achieving fault-tolerant quantum computation.

URSI International Symposium on Electromagnetic Theory•May 22, 2023•0 citations

Maxwell-Schrödinger Hybrid Simulation for Analyzing Control and Readout of Transmon Qubits

Thomas E. Roth, Samuel T. Elkin

The control and readout of a transmon qubit through applied microwave pulses is a key capability in operating many quantum technologies. Currently, the design of microwave pulses for these purposes is done through simple theoretical or numerical models that do not account for how the transmon modifies the applied microwave field. In this work, we present the formulation and discretization of a self-consistent semiclassical model that solves the Schrödinger equation describing qubit dynamics in tandem with a one-dimensional wave equation describing transmission line dynamics. Numerical results are presented using this Maxwell-Schrödinger method to characterize the control and readout of a transmon qubit. We show that our method matches simple theoretical predictions in relevant operating regimes and also look at situations where simplified models break down. In the future, our method can be used to explore these broader operating regimes to search for more effective control and readout protocols.

European Conference on Antennas and Propagation•Mar 26, 2023•1 citation

Maxwell-Schrödinger Modeling of Superconducting Qubits Coupled to Transmission Line Networks

Thomas E. Roth, Samuel T. Elkin

In superconducting circuit quantum information technologies, classical microwave pulses are applied to control and measure the qubit states. Currently, the design of these microwave pulses use simple theoretical or numerical models that do not account for the self-consistent interactions of how the qubit state modifies the applied microwave pulse. In this work, we present the formulation and finite element time domain discretization of a semiclassical Maxwell-Schrödinger method for describing these self-consistent dynamics for the case of a superconducting qubit capacitively coupled to a general transmission line network. We validate the proposed method by characterizing key effects related to common control and measurement approaches for transmon and fluxonium qubits in systems that are amenable to theoretical analysis. Our numerical results also highlight scenarios where including the self-consistent interactions are essential. By treating the microwaves classically, our method is substantially more efficient than fully-quantum methods for the many situations where the quantum statistics of the microwaves are not needed. Further, our approach does not require any reformulations when the transmission line system is modified. In the future, our method can be used to rapidly explore broader design spaces to search for more effective control and measurement protocols for superconducting qubits.

arXiv:2210.07923•Oct 14, 2022•0 citations

MACROSCOPIC QED FORMALISM FOR EVALUATING TRANSMON EXCHANGE COUPLING RATE IN PRACTICAL DEVICES

Ghazi Khan

Superconducting qubits are one of the leading platforms for creating practical quantum computers. However, these architectures face significant engineering challenges as they scale up and move towards devices capable of error correction. To aid these efforts, three-dimensional (3D) full-wave computational electromagnetics tools are increasingly being utilized to characterize these devices; however, standard approaches relying on eigenmode solvers are often computationally prohibitive and lack the scalability required to analyse devices beyond a few qubits. To overcome these limitations, this thesis introduces an efficient, alternative modeling framework for superconducting circuits, applied specifically to the evaluation of the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate in transmon architectures. This coupling rate is a key design parameter that governs the entanglement speed for multi-qubit gates and influences error channels such as qubit crosstalk. Leveraging a field-based formalism within the broader context of macroscopic quantum electrodynamics, we establish that the exchange coupling rate is directly related to the electromagnetic dyadic Green’s function. We then map the imaginary part of the Green’s function to the system’s classical impedance response. Since the impedance response can be evaluated quickly and accurately in standard full-wave solvers, this new formulation provides a scalable way to characterize large-scale superconducting devices. We validate this framework by simulating four practical multi-qubit circuits, benchmarking the extracted coupling rates against both 3D numerical diagonalization methods and experimental data. We also demonstrate how the exchange coupling rate impacts qubit crosstalk, and characterize a multi-coupler device to find operational sweet spots, where the crosstalk is minimized while maintaining strong enough qubit-qubit coupling to enable fast multi-qubit gates. We then conclude this thesis and outline some plans for future work.

•Jul 23, 2026•0 citations

Supercomputer simulations of transmon quantum computers

Dennis Willsch

We develop a simulator for quantum computers composed of superconducting transmon qubits. The simulation model supports an arbitrary number of transmons and resonators. Quantum gates are implemented by time-dependent pulses. Nontrivial effects such as crosstalk, leakage to non-computational states, entanglement between transmons and resonators, and control errors due to the pulses are inherently included. The time evolution of the quantum computer is obtained by solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. The simulation algorithm shows excellent scalability on high-performance supercomputers. We present results for the simulation of up to 16 transmons and resonators. Additionally, the model can be used to simulate environments, and we demonstrate the transition from an isolated system to an open quantum system governed by a Lindblad master equation. We also describe a procedure to extract model parameters from electromagnetic simulations or experiments. We compare simulation results to experiments on several NISQ processors of the IBM Q Experience. We find nearly perfect agreement between simulation and experiment for quantum circuits designed to probe crosstalk in transmon systems. By studying common gate metrics such as the fidelity or the diamond distance, we find that they cannot reliably predict the performance of repeated gate applications or practical quantum algorithms. As an alternative, we find that the results from two-transmon gate set tomography have an exceptional predictive power. Finally, we test a protocol from the theory of quantum error correction and fault tolerance. We find that the protocol systematically improves the performance of transmon quantum computers in the presence of characteristic control and measurement errors.

arXiv:2008.13490•Jan 1, 2020•4 citations
Superconducting qubits have emerged as a leading platform for realizing quantum computers. Accurate modeling of these devices is essential for predicting performance, improving design, and optimizing control. Many modeling approaches currently rely on lumped circuit approximations or other simplified treatments that can be limited in resolving the interplay between the qubit dynamics and the electromagnetic circuitry, leading to significant experimental deviations from numerical predictions at times. To address many of these limitations, methods that self-consistently solve the Schrödinger equation for qubit dynamics with the classical Maxwell's equations have been developed and shown to accurately predict a wide range of effects related to superconducting qubit control and readout. Despite these successes, these methods have not been able to consider multi-qubit effects that give rise to qubit-qubit entanglement. Here, we address this by rigorously deriving how multi-qubit coupling effects between transmon qubits can be embedded into Maxwell-Schrödinger methods. To support this, we build on earlier first-principles derivations of Maxwell-Schrödinger methods for the specific case of two transmon qubits coupled together through a common electromagnetic system in the dispersive regime. To aid in validating aspects of the Maxwell-Schrödinger framework, we also provide a new interpretation of Maxwell-Schrödinger methods as an efficient simulation strategy to capture the class of non-Markovian open quantum system dynamics. Our results demonstrate that these effects can give rise to strong classical crosstalk that can significantly alter multi-qubit dynamics, which we demonstrate for the cross-resonance gate. These classical crosstalk effects have been noted in cross-resonance experiments, but previous quantum theory and device analysis could not explain their origin.
Superconducting qubits are one of the most mature platforms for achieving practical quantum computers, but significant performance improvements are still needed. To improve the engineering of these systems, three-dimensional (3D) full-wave computational electromagnetics analyses are increasingly being turned to. Unfortunately, existing analysis approaches often rely on full-wave simulations using eigenmode solvers that are typically cumbersome, not robust, and computationally prohibitive if devices with more than a few qubits are to be analyzed. To improve the characterization of superconducting circuits while circumventing these drawbacks, this work begins the development of an alternative modeling framework that we illustrate in the context of evaluating the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate between transmon qubits. This quantity is a key design parameter that determines the entanglement rate for fast multiqubit gate performance and also affects decoherence sources like qubit crosstalk. Our modeling framework uses a field-based formalism in the context of macroscopic quantum electrodynamics, which we use to show that the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate can be related to the electromagnetic dyadic Green's function linking the qubits together. We further show how the needed quantity involving the dyadic Green's function can be related to the impedance response of the system that can be easily and efficiently computed with classical computational electromagnetics tools. We demonstrate the validity and efficacy of this approach by simulating four practical multiqubit superconducting circuits and evaluating their qubit-qubit exchange coupling rates. We validate our results against a 3D numerical diagonalization method and against experimental data where available. We also demonstrate the impact of the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate on qubit crosstalk by simulating a multicoupler device and identifying operating points where the qubit crosstalk becomes zero.
Transmon qubits integrated into microwave circuitry are a leading quantum computing architecture. However, significant engineering improvements are still needed. General-purpose numerical methods are becoming of interest to tackle these challenges, but existing fully-quantum methods are highly inefficient. In this work, we formulate a semiclassical Maxwell-Schrödinger model as an alternative approach to efficiently analyze the interactions of transmons capacitively coupled to transmission line networks. Additionally, we present a suitable discretization and time marching strategy. We validate our approach by comparing it to theoretical models relevant to the dispersive operating regime used in most hardware implementations. Our results show that our method can accurately predict effects related to transmon state measurements that are typically derived using fully-quantum models. In the future, our approach can be used to rapidly explore broader design spaces to improve the speed and fidelity of qubit state measurements, which is a key obstacle toward achieving fault-tolerant quantum computation.
The control and readout of a transmon qubit through applied microwave pulses is a key capability in operating many quantum technologies. Currently, the design of microwave pulses for these purposes is done through simple theoretical or numerical models that do not account for how the transmon modifies the applied microwave field. In this work, we present the formulation and discretization of a self-consistent semiclassical model that solves the Schrödinger equation describing qubit dynamics in tandem with a one-dimensional wave equation describing transmission line dynamics. Numerical results are presented using this Maxwell-Schrödinger method to characterize the control and readout of a transmon qubit. We show that our method matches simple theoretical predictions in relevant operating regimes and also look at situations where simplified models break down. In the future, our method can be used to explore these broader operating regimes to search for more effective control and readout protocols.
In superconducting circuit quantum information technologies, classical microwave pulses are applied to control and measure the qubit states. Currently, the design of these microwave pulses use simple theoretical or numerical models that do not account for the self-consistent interactions of how the qubit state modifies the applied microwave pulse. In this work, we present the formulation and finite element time domain discretization of a semiclassical Maxwell-Schrödinger method for describing these self-consistent dynamics for the case of a superconducting qubit capacitively coupled to a general transmission line network. We validate the proposed method by characterizing key effects related to common control and measurement approaches for transmon and fluxonium qubits in systems that are amenable to theoretical analysis. Our numerical results also highlight scenarios where including the self-consistent interactions are essential. By treating the microwaves classically, our method is substantially more efficient than fully-quantum methods for the many situations where the quantum statistics of the microwaves are not needed. Further, our approach does not require any reformulations when the transmission line system is modified. In the future, our method can be used to rapidly explore broader design spaces to search for more effective control and measurement protocols for superconducting qubits.
Superconducting qubits are one of the leading platforms for creating practical quantum computers. However, these architectures face significant engineering challenges as they scale up and move towards devices capable of error correction. To aid these efforts, three-dimensional (3D) full-wave computational electromagnetics tools are increasingly being utilized to characterize these devices; however, standard approaches relying on eigenmode solvers are often computationally prohibitive and lack the scalability required to analyse devices beyond a few qubits. To overcome these limitations, this thesis introduces an efficient, alternative modeling framework for superconducting circuits, applied specifically to the evaluation of the qubit-qubit exchange coupling rate in transmon architectures. This coupling rate is a key design parameter that governs the entanglement speed for multi-qubit gates and influences error channels such as qubit crosstalk. Leveraging a field-based formalism within the broader context of macroscopic quantum electrodynamics, we establish that the exchange coupling rate is directly related to the electromagnetic dyadic Green’s function. We then map the imaginary part of the Green’s function to the system’s classical impedance response. Since the impedance response can be evaluated quickly and accurately in standard full-wave solvers, this new formulation provides a scalable way to characterize large-scale superconducting devices. We validate this framework by simulating four practical multi-qubit circuits, benchmarking the extracted coupling rates against both 3D numerical diagonalization methods and experimental data. We also demonstrate how the exchange coupling rate impacts qubit crosstalk, and characterize a multi-coupler device to find operational sweet spots, where the crosstalk is minimized while maintaining strong enough qubit-qubit coupling to enable fast multi-qubit gates. We then conclude this thesis and outline some plans for future work.
We develop a simulator for quantum computers composed of superconducting transmon qubits. The simulation model supports an arbitrary number of transmons and resonators. Quantum gates are implemented by time-dependent pulses. Nontrivial effects such as crosstalk, leakage to non-computational states, entanglement between transmons and resonators, and control errors due to the pulses are inherently included. The time evolution of the quantum computer is obtained by solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. The simulation algorithm shows excellent scalability on high-performance supercomputers. We present results for the simulation of up to 16 transmons and resonators. Additionally, the model can be used to simulate environments, and we demonstrate the transition from an isolated system to an open quantum system governed by a Lindblad master equation. We also describe a procedure to extract model parameters from electromagnetic simulations or experiments. We compare simulation results to experiments on several NISQ processors of the IBM Q Experience. We find nearly perfect agreement between simulation and experiment for quantum circuits designed to probe crosstalk in transmon systems. By studying common gate metrics such as the fidelity or the diamond distance, we find that they cannot reliably predict the performance of repeated gate applications or practical quantum algorithms. As an alternative, we find that the results from two-transmon gate set tomography have an exceptional predictive power. Finally, we test a protocol from the theory of quantum error correction and fault tolerance. We find that the protocol systematically improves the performance of transmon quantum computers in the presence of characteristic control and measurement errors.