Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.15046 · Physical Review Research

Graph-theoretical search for integrable multistate Landau-Zener models

Zixuan Li, Chen Sun

quant-phcond-mat.mes-hallmath-phmath.COnlin.SISubmitted Dec 17, 2025• Announced Dec 18, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The search for exactly solvable models is an evergreen topic in theoretical physics. In the context of multistate Landau-Zener models -- $N$-state quantum systems with linearly time-dependent Hamiltonians -- the theory of integrability provides a framework for identifying new solvable cases. In particular, it was proved that the integrability of a specific class known as the multitime Landau-Zener (MTLZ) models guarantees their exact solvability. A key finding was that an $N$-state MTLZ model can be represented by data defined on an $N$-vertex graph. While known host graphs for MTLZ models include hypercubes, fans, and their Cartesian products, no other families have been discovered, leading to the conjecture that these are the only possibilities. In this work, we conduct a systematic graph-theoretical search for integrable models within the MTLZ class. By first identifying minimal structures that a graph must contain to host an MTLZ model, we formulate an efficient algorithm to systematically search for candidate graphs for MTLZ models. Implementing this algorithm using computational software, we enumerate all candidate graphs with up to $N = 13$ vertices and perform an in-depth analysis of those with $N \le 11$. Our results corroborate the aforementioned conjecture for graphs up to $11$ vertices. For even larger graphs, we propose a specific family, termed descendants of ``$(0,2)$-graphs'', as promising candidates that may violate the conjecture above. Our work can serve as a guideline to identify new exactly solvable multistate Landau-Zener models in the future.

Journal reference
Phys. Rev. Research 8, 013006 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/1m6n-s7zn
Comments
15 pages, 10 figures; version accepted in Physical Review Research

Related papers

Multitime Landau–Zener model: classification of solvable Hamiltonians*

Vladimir Chernyak, Nikolai A. Sinitsyn, Chen Sun

Abstract We discuss a class of models that generalize the two-state Landau–Zener Hamiltonian to both the multistate and multitime evolution. It is already known that the corresponding quantum mechanical evolution can be understood in great detail. Here, we present an approach to classify such solvable models, namely, to identify all their independent families for a given number N of interacting states and prove the absence of such families for some types of interactions. We also discuss how, within a solvable family, one can classify the scattering matrices, i.e., the system’s dynamics. Due to the possibility of such a detailed classification, the multitime Landau–Zener model defines a useful special function of theoretical physics.

arXiv:1911.12219•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 13, 2020•12 citations

The quest for solvable multistate Landau-Zener models

Nikolai A Sinitsyn, Vladimir Y Chernyak

Abstract Recently, integrability conditions (ICs) in mutistate Landau-Zener (MLZ) theory were proposed [1]. They describe common properties of all known solved systems with linearly time-dependent Hamiltonians. Here we show that ICs enable efficient computer assisted search for new solvable MLZ models that span complexity range from several interacting states to mesoscopic systems with many-body dynamics and combinatorially large phase space. This diversity suggests that nontrivial solvable MLZ models are numerous. In addition, we refine the formulation of ICs and extend the class of solvable systems to models with points of multiple diabatic level crossing.

arXiv:1701.01870•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 24, 2017•37 citations

A large class of solvable multistate Landau–Zener models and quantum integrability

Vladimir Chernyak, Nikolai A. Sinitsyn, Chen Sun

Abstract The concept of quantum integrability has been introduced recently for quantum systems with explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians (Sinitsyn et al 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett . 120 190402). Within the multistate Landau–Zener (MLZ) theory, however, there has been a successful alternative approach to identify and solve complex time-dependent models (Sinitsyn and Chernyak 2017 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 50 255203). Here we compare both methods by applying them to a new class of exactly solvable MLZ models. This class contains systems with an arbitrary number of interacting states and shows quick growth with N number of exact adiabatic energy crossing points, which appear at different moments of time. At each N , transition probabilities in these systems can be found analytically and exactly but complexity and variety of solutions in this class also grow with N quickly. We illustrate how common features of solvable MLZ systems appear from quantum integrability and develop an approach to further classification of solvable MLZ problems.

arXiv:1707.04963•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 10, 2018•16 citations

Integrability in the multistate Landau-Zener model with time-quadratic commuting operators

Vladimir Chernyak, Nikolai A. Sinitsyn

Abstract All currently known exactly solvable multistate Landau–Zener (MLZ) models are associated with families of operators that commute with the MLZ Hamiltonians and depend on time linearly. There can also be operators that satisfy the integrability conditions with the MLZ Hamiltonians but depend on time quadratically. We show that, among the MLZ systems, such time-quadratic operators are much more common. We demonstrate then that such operators generally lead to constraints on the independent variables that parametrize the scattering matrix. Such constraints lead to asymptotically exact expressions for the transition probabilities in the adiabatic limit of a three-level MLZ model. New more complex fully solvable MLZ systems are also found.

arXiv:2006.15144•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 9, 2021•11 citations

A large class of solvable multistate Landau-Zener models and quantum integrability

Chen Sun, Nikolai A. Sinitsyn

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 8, 2018•0 citations

Integrable Time-Dependent Quantum Hamiltonians

Nikolai A. Sinitsyn, Emil A. Yuzbashyan, Vladimir Chernyak +2 more

We formulate a set of conditions under which the nonstationary Schrödinger equation with a time-dependent Hamiltonian is exactly solvable analytically. The main requirement is the existence of a non-Abelian gauge field with zero curvature in the space of system parameters. Known solvable multistate Landau-Zener models satisfy these conditions. Our method provides a strategy to incorporate time dependence into various quantum integrable models while maintaining their integrability. We also validate some prior conjectures, including the solution of the driven generalized Tavis-Cummings model.

arXiv:1711.09945•Physical Review Letters•May 11, 2018•60 citations
The search for exactly solvable models is an evergreen topic in theoretical physics. In the context of multistate Landau-Zener models -- NNN-state quantum systems with linearly time-dependent Hamiltonians -- the theory of integrability provides a framework for identifying new solvable cases. In particular, it was proved that the integrability of a specific class known as the multitime Landau-Zener (MTLZ) models guarantees their exact solvability. A key finding was that an NNN-state MTLZ model can be represented by data defined on an NNN-vertex graph. While known host graphs for MTLZ models include hypercubes, fans, and their Cartesian products, no other families have been discovered, leading to the conjecture that these are the only possibilities. In this work, we conduct a systematic graph-theoretical search for integrable models within the MTLZ class. By first identifying minimal structures that a graph must contain to host an MTLZ model, we formulate an efficient algorithm to systematically search for candidate graphs for MTLZ models. Implementing this algorithm using computational software, we enumerate all candidate graphs with up to N=13N = 13N=13 vertices and perform an in-depth analysis of those with N≤11N \le 11N≤11. Our results corroborate the aforementioned conjecture for graphs up to 111111 vertices. For even larger graphs, we propose a specific family, termed descendants of ``(0,2)(0,2)(0,2)-graphs'', as promising candidates that may violate the conjecture above. Our work can serve as a guideline to identify new exactly solvable multistate Landau-Zener models in the future.
Abstract We discuss a class of models that generalize the two-state Landau–Zener Hamiltonian to both the multistate and multitime evolution. It is already known that the corresponding quantum mechanical evolution can be understood in great detail. Here, we present an approach to classify such solvable models, namely, to identify all their independent families for a given number N of interacting states and prove the absence of such families for some types of interactions. We also discuss how, within a solvable family, one can classify the scattering matrices, i.e., the system’s dynamics. Due to the possibility of such a detailed classification, the multitime Landau–Zener model defines a useful special function of theoretical physics.
Abstract Recently, integrability conditions (ICs) in mutistate Landau-Zener (MLZ) theory were proposed [1]. They describe common properties of all known solved systems with linearly time-dependent Hamiltonians. Here we show that ICs enable efficient computer assisted search for new solvable MLZ models that span complexity range from several interacting states to mesoscopic systems with many-body dynamics and combinatorially large phase space. This diversity suggests that nontrivial solvable MLZ models are numerous. In addition, we refine the formulation of ICs and extend the class of solvable systems to models with points of multiple diabatic level crossing.
Abstract The concept of quantum integrability has been introduced recently for quantum systems with explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians (Sinitsyn et al 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett . 120 190402). Within the multistate Landau–Zener (MLZ) theory, however, there has been a successful alternative approach to identify and solve complex time-dependent models (Sinitsyn and Chernyak 2017 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 50 255203). Here we compare both methods by applying them to a new class of exactly solvable MLZ models. This class contains systems with an arbitrary number of interacting states and shows quick growth with N number of exact adiabatic energy crossing points, which appear at different moments of time. At each N , transition probabilities in these systems can be found analytically and exactly but complexity and variety of solutions in this class also grow with N quickly. We illustrate how common features of solvable MLZ systems appear from quantum integrability and develop an approach to further classification of solvable MLZ problems.
Abstract All currently known exactly solvable multistate Landau–Zener (MLZ) models are associated with families of operators that commute with the MLZ Hamiltonians and depend on time linearly. There can also be operators that satisfy the integrability conditions with the MLZ Hamiltonians but depend on time quadratically. We show that, among the MLZ systems, such time-quadratic operators are much more common. We demonstrate then that such operators generally lead to constraints on the independent variables that parametrize the scattering matrix. Such constraints lead to asymptotically exact expressions for the transition probabilities in the adiabatic limit of a three-level MLZ model. New more complex fully solvable MLZ systems are also found.
We formulate a set of conditions under which the nonstationary Schrödinger equation with a time-dependent Hamiltonian is exactly solvable analytically. The main requirement is the existence of a non-Abelian gauge field with zero curvature in the space of system parameters. Known solvable multistate Landau-Zener models satisfy these conditions. Our method provides a strategy to incorporate time dependence into various quantum integrable models while maintaining their integrability. We also validate some prior conjectures, including the solution of the driven generalized Tavis-Cummings model.