Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.00788 · Physical Review Letters

Super-Extensive Charging Power in the Absence of Global Operations

Anupam, Sheryl Mathew, Sibasish Ghosh

quant-phSubmitted Nov 30, 2025• Announced Dec 2, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum batteries have emerged as a platform for investigating whether quantum effects can accelerate energy storage beyond classical limits. Although a variety of charging schemes have reported signatures of quantum advantage, the fundamental physical requirements for achieving superextensive charging power remain insufficiently understood. Here, we show that, in addition to Hamiltonian locality, a key structural property, g-extensiveness, quantifying the distribution of interaction energy across lattice sites places a fundamental bound on charging performance in spin-lattice models. We prove that superextensive power scaling is possible only when the interaction-energy distribution becomes increasingly nonuniform, with the maximal local weight growing with system size. This criterion explains why many previously studied protocols fail to exhibit superextensive power, even when the Hamiltonians involve large participation numbers. We further demonstrate that this condition is realized in an experimentally relevant interacting model, where, despite fixed interaction order, the charging power scales superextensively. Our results establish g-extensiveness as a necessary resource for quantum advantage in direct-charging protocols and provide a systematic framework for identifying and engineering physically feasible quantum batteries capable of outperforming classical counterparts in charging power.

Related papers

Cumulative locality governs collective quantum charging

Sebastián V. Romero, Xi Chen, Yue Ban

Quantum batteries can outperform their classical counterparts through collective quantum effects, yet the conditions enabling such advantage remain unclear. Using a generic class of free-fermionic chargers we prove that global operators are insufficient for scalable superextensive charging and that a cumulative hierarchy of many-body operators is required, with the structure of the battery determining the degree of advantage. This is obtained by relating the charging power to the norm of the commutator between the battery and charger Hamiltonians and deriving an upper bound only capturing noncommuting terms. Moreover, we revisit the concept of participation number and propose an effective definition that accounts for the relative strength of the contributing terms, correlating it with the charging power scaling. Not limited to quadratic Hamiltonians, our results establish cumulative locality as a key resource for quantum charging advantage.

quant-pharXiv:2610.28614•Oct 21, 2026•0 citations

Upper bounds on charging power and tangible advantage in quantum batteries

Sreeram PG, J. Bharathi Kannan, M. S. Santhanam

A quantum battery is expected to outperform its classical counterpart due to quantum effects. Usually, in a quantum battery made of N cells, quantum advantage is demonstrated through super-extensive scaling of the upper bound to the charging power with N. In this work, we show that potential quantum advantage as measured by the power bounds need not translate to tangible advantage in practice. We demonstrate this by considering an all-to-all coupled spin-chain model of a quantum battery with 2-local interactions. It exhibits super-extensive charging when analyzed using the upper bound derived from the uncertainty principle. Unlike the previously studied models, the contribution to this apparent quantum advantage is twofold—arising from both the battery and the charger. The model is also experimentally friendly, as it does not require global couplings and yet generates genuine multipartite entanglement. However, we demonstrate that the potential quantum advantage in this scenario is not tangible by employing a tighter upper bound on power. Additionally, we show that even this tighter bound can fail in a range of physical situations and indicate a quantum enhancement that is intangible in practice. Hence, we argue that actual power transferred must be evaluated along with proper characterization of the resources before claiming quantum advantage.

arXiv:2510.19552•Applied Physics Letters•Mar 30, 2026•2 citations

Quantum Charging Advantage Cannot Be Extensive without Global Operations

Ju-Yeon Gyhm, Dominik Šafránek, Dario Rosa

Quantum batteries are devices made from quantum states, which store and release energy in a fast and efficient manner, thus offering numerous possibilities in future technological applications. They offer a significant charging speedup when compared to classical batteries, due to the possibility of using entangling charging operations. We show that the maximal speedup that can be achieved is extensive in the number of cells, thus offering at most quadratic scaling in the charging power over the classically achievable linear scaling. To reach such a scaling, a global charging protocol, charging all the cells collectively, needs to be employed. This concludes the quest on the limits of charging power of quantum batteries and adds to other results in which quantum methods are known to provide at most quadratic scaling over their classical counterparts.

arXiv:2108.02491•Physical Review Letters•Apr 4, 2022•208 citations

Enhancing the Charging Power of Quantum Batteries

Francesco Campaioli, Felix A. Pollock, Felix C. Binder +4 more

Can collective quantum effects make a difference in a meaningful thermodynamic operation? Focusing on energy storage and batteries, we demonstrate that quantum mechanics can lead to an enhancement in the amount of work deposited per unit time, i.e., the charging power, when N batteries are charged collectively. We first derive analytic upper bounds for the collective quantum advantage in charging power for two choices of constraints on the charging Hamiltonian. We then demonstrate that even in the absence of quantum entanglement this advantage can be extensive. For our main result, we provide an upper bound to the achievable quantum advantage when the interaction order is restricted; i.e., at most k batteries are interacting. This constitutes a fundamental limit on the advantage offered by quantum technologies over their classical counterparts.

arXiv:1612.04991•Physical Review Letters•Apr 12, 2017•531 citations

Collective dynamics versus entanglement in quantum battery performance

Rohit Kumar Shukla, Sunil K. Mishra, Ujjwal Sen

We investigate charging dynamics in many-body quantum batteries by examining the relationship between instantaneous charging power and the emergence of bipartite, tripartite, and multipartite quantum correlations across different battery--charger configurations. We find that the charging power reaches its maximum before the correlation measures peak, revealing a temporal separation between rapid energy transfer and the buildup of quantum correlations. We further study the role of interaction structure using local and many-body charging Hamiltonians for both unconstrained and constrained charging protocols, in which the total available charging resources are fixed to scale proportionally with the number of spins, thereby isolating the influence of interaction geometry and particle participation on the charging dynamics. In the unconstrained case, the enhanced charging energy observed for higher-order interactions originates primarily from the larger energy scale of the corresponding charging Hamiltonian. Under constrained conditions, however, increasing the interaction order alone provides no advantage over parallel charging when interaction and local spin-flip contributions are balanced, whereas interaction-dominated protocols significantly enhance charging performance, highlighting the importance of collective many-body dynamics. Fully collective interactions yield the largest enhancement in charging power together with stronger multipartite correlations, while partially collective interactions provide only limited improvements. Finally, extending the interaction range through next-nearest-neighbor couplings suppresses the charging power, demonstrating that, under constrained energetic resources, charging performance is governed primarily by interaction structure, particle participation, and collective many-body dynamics rather than by interaction order alone.

quant-pharXiv:2601.03119•Jan 7, 2026•0 citations

Battery Locality Is Necessary in Noncommuting Quantum Charging Bounds

Sheryl Mathew

Bounds on the charging power of quantum batteries in direct charging protocols are often interpreted as charging-side constraints. Although the locality of the charging Hamiltonian is known to restrict attainable power in certain protocols, whether battery locality is itself operationally necessary has remained unresolved. Here we show that it is necessary for spin batteries whose interactions do not pairwise commute. We construct commuting and noncommuting high-locality batteries with identical interaction supports and local energy scale, driven by the same charging. The commuting battery saturates the battery-locality-independent bound, whereas the noncommuting battery exceeds it by a parametrically growing factor, demonstrating that this bound cannot apply generally. The enhanced norm of the commutator is dynamically attained from a suitable joint state supported entirely in the battery ground-energy sector, although this state may be correlated with the auxiliary fermionic degrees of freedom. Our results establish battery locality as an operational resource enabled by noncommuting battery interactions.

quant-pharXiv:2609.06104•Sep 8, 2026•0 citations
Quantum batteries have emerged as a platform for investigating whether quantum effects can accelerate energy storage beyond classical limits. Although a variety of charging schemes have reported signatures of quantum advantage, the fundamental physical requirements for achieving superextensive charging power remain insufficiently understood. Here, we show that, in addition to Hamiltonian locality, a key structural property, g-extensiveness, quantifying the distribution of interaction energy across lattice sites places a fundamental bound on charging performance in spin-lattice models. We prove that superextensive power scaling is possible only when the interaction-energy distribution becomes increasingly nonuniform, with the maximal local weight growing with system size. This criterion explains why many previously studied protocols fail to exhibit superextensive power, even when the Hamiltonians involve large participation numbers. We further demonstrate that this condition is realized in an experimentally relevant interacting model, where, despite fixed interaction order, the charging power scales superextensively. Our results establish g-extensiveness as a necessary resource for quantum advantage in direct-charging protocols and provide a systematic framework for identifying and engineering physically feasible quantum batteries capable of outperforming classical counterparts in charging power.
Quantum batteries can outperform their classical counterparts through collective quantum effects, yet the conditions enabling such advantage remain unclear. Using a generic class of free-fermionic chargers we prove that global operators are insufficient for scalable superextensive charging and that a cumulative hierarchy of many-body operators is required, with the structure of the battery determining the degree of advantage. This is obtained by relating the charging power to the norm of the commutator between the battery and charger Hamiltonians and deriving an upper bound only capturing noncommuting terms. Moreover, we revisit the concept of participation number and propose an effective definition that accounts for the relative strength of the contributing terms, correlating it with the charging power scaling. Not limited to quadratic Hamiltonians, our results establish cumulative locality as a key resource for quantum charging advantage.
A quantum battery is expected to outperform its classical counterpart due to quantum effects. Usually, in a quantum battery made of N cells, quantum advantage is demonstrated through super-extensive scaling of the upper bound to the charging power with N. In this work, we show that potential quantum advantage as measured by the power bounds need not translate to tangible advantage in practice. We demonstrate this by considering an all-to-all coupled spin-chain model of a quantum battery with 2-local interactions. It exhibits super-extensive charging when analyzed using the upper bound derived from the uncertainty principle. Unlike the previously studied models, the contribution to this apparent quantum advantage is twofold—arising from both the battery and the charger. The model is also experimentally friendly, as it does not require global couplings and yet generates genuine multipartite entanglement. However, we demonstrate that the potential quantum advantage in this scenario is not tangible by employing a tighter upper bound on power. Additionally, we show that even this tighter bound can fail in a range of physical situations and indicate a quantum enhancement that is intangible in practice. Hence, we argue that actual power transferred must be evaluated along with proper characterization of the resources before claiming quantum advantage.
Quantum batteries are devices made from quantum states, which store and release energy in a fast and efficient manner, thus offering numerous possibilities in future technological applications. They offer a significant charging speedup when compared to classical batteries, due to the possibility of using entangling charging operations. We show that the maximal speedup that can be achieved is extensive in the number of cells, thus offering at most quadratic scaling in the charging power over the classically achievable linear scaling. To reach such a scaling, a global charging protocol, charging all the cells collectively, needs to be employed. This concludes the quest on the limits of charging power of quantum batteries and adds to other results in which quantum methods are known to provide at most quadratic scaling over their classical counterparts.
Can collective quantum effects make a difference in a meaningful thermodynamic operation? Focusing on energy storage and batteries, we demonstrate that quantum mechanics can lead to an enhancement in the amount of work deposited per unit time, i.e., the charging power, when N batteries are charged collectively. We first derive analytic upper bounds for the collective quantum advantage in charging power for two choices of constraints on the charging Hamiltonian. We then demonstrate that even in the absence of quantum entanglement this advantage can be extensive. For our main result, we provide an upper bound to the achievable quantum advantage when the interaction order is restricted; i.e., at most k batteries are interacting. This constitutes a fundamental limit on the advantage offered by quantum technologies over their classical counterparts.
We investigate charging dynamics in many-body quantum batteries by examining the relationship between instantaneous charging power and the emergence of bipartite, tripartite, and multipartite quantum correlations across different battery--charger configurations. We find that the charging power reaches its maximum before the correlation measures peak, revealing a temporal separation between rapid energy transfer and the buildup of quantum correlations. We further study the role of interaction structure using local and many-body charging Hamiltonians for both unconstrained and constrained charging protocols, in which the total available charging resources are fixed to scale proportionally with the number of spins, thereby isolating the influence of interaction geometry and particle participation on the charging dynamics. In the unconstrained case, the enhanced charging energy observed for higher-order interactions originates primarily from the larger energy scale of the corresponding charging Hamiltonian. Under constrained conditions, however, increasing the interaction order alone provides no advantage over parallel charging when interaction and local spin-flip contributions are balanced, whereas interaction-dominated protocols significantly enhance charging performance, highlighting the importance of collective many-body dynamics. Fully collective interactions yield the largest enhancement in charging power together with stronger multipartite correlations, while partially collective interactions provide only limited improvements. Finally, extending the interaction range through next-nearest-neighbor couplings suppresses the charging power, demonstrating that, under constrained energetic resources, charging performance is governed primarily by interaction structure, particle participation, and collective many-body dynamics rather than by interaction order alone.
Bounds on the charging power of quantum batteries in direct charging protocols are often interpreted as charging-side constraints. Although the locality of the charging Hamiltonian is known to restrict attainable power in certain protocols, whether battery locality is itself operationally necessary has remained unresolved. Here we show that it is necessary for spin batteries whose interactions do not pairwise commute. We construct commuting and noncommuting high-locality batteries with identical interaction supports and local energy scale, driven by the same charging. The commuting battery saturates the battery-locality-independent bound, whereas the noncommuting battery exceeds it by a parametrically growing factor, demonstrating that this bound cannot apply generally. The enhanced norm of the commutator is dynamically attained from a suitable joint state supported entirely in the battery ground-energy sector, although this state may be correlated with the auxiliary fermionic degrees of freedom. Our results establish battery locality as an operational resource enabled by noncommuting battery interactions.