arXiv:2510.20971 · Physical Review Letters

No-Broadcasting of Non-Gaussian States

Kaustav Chatterjee, Ulrik L. Andersen

Published Apr 21, 2026• 0 citations

Abstract

Gaussian states are central to continuous-variable quantum systems, as they are experimentally accessible and admit a compact mathematical description. Nevertheless, many proposed quantum technologies require non-Gaussian elements. In resource-theoretic terms, non-Gaussian states are resources, while Gaussian states and operations are free. The task of broadcasting, then, asks whether the resource content of a state can be meaningfully cloned. In this Letter, we prove that broadcasting of non-Gaussian states via Gaussian operations is not possible. We first show that the relative entropy of non-Gaussianity is not superadditive, ruling it out for such no-go analyses. Our proof instead uses fixed points of Gaussian operations and relates to control theory. The theorem also implies that if two initially uncorrelated systems interact by Gaussian dynamics, and one subsystem gains non-Gaussianity, the other must lose it irreversibly. Keeping the set of free operations fixed to Gaussian operations, we also comment on the broadcasting of Wigner negativity and genuine quantum non-Gaussianity.

DOI: 10.1103/vvpt-4yn8

Related papers

Non-Gaussian Quantum States and Where to Find Them

Mattia Walschaers

Gaussian states have played an important role in the physics of continuous-variable quantum systems.They are appealing for the experimental ease with which they can be produced, and for their compact and elegant mathematical description.Nevertheless, many proposed quantum technologies require us to go beyond the realm of Gaussian states and introduce non-Gaussian elements.In this Tutorial, we provide a roadmap for the physics of non-Gaussian quantum states.We introduce the phase-space representations as a framework to describe the different properties of quantum states in continuous-variable systems.We then use this framework in various ways to explore the structure of the state space.We explain how non-Gaussian states can be characterized not only through the negative values of their Wigner function, but also via other properties such as quantum non-Gaussianity and the related stellar rank.For multimode systems, we are naturally confronted with the question of how non-Gaussian properties behave with respect to quantum correlations.To answer this question, we first show how non-Gaussian states can be created by performing measurements on a subset of modes in a Gaussian state.Then, we highlight that these measured modes must be correlated via specific quantum correlations to the remainder of the system to create quantum non-Gaussian or Wigner-negative states.On the other hand, non-Gaussian operations are also shown to enhance or even create quantum correlations.Finally, we demonstrate that Wigner negativity is a requirement to violate Bell inequalities and to achieve a quantum computational advantage.At the end of the Tutorial, we also provide an overview of several experimental realizations of non-Gaussian quantum states in quantum optics and beyond.

arXiv:2104.12596PRX QuantumSep 28, 2021311 citations

Resource theory of quantum non-Gaussianity and Wigner negativity

Francesco Albarelli, Marco G. Genoni, Matteo G. A. Paris +1 more

We develop a resource theory for continuous-variable systems grounded on operations routinely available within current quantum technologies. In particular, the set of free operations is convex and includes quadratic transformations and conditional coarse-grained measurements. The present theory lends itself to quantify both quantum non-Gaussianity and Wigner negativity as resources, depending on the choice of the free-state set---i.e., the convex hull of Gaussian states or the states with positive Wigner function, respectively. After showing that the theory admits no maximally resourceful state, we define a computable resource monotone---the Wigner logarithmic negativity. We use the latter to assess the resource content of experimentally relevant states---e.g., photon-added, photon-subtracted, cubic-phase, and cat states---and to find optimal working points of some resource concentration protocols. We envisage applications of this framework to subuniversal and universal quantum information processing over continuous variables.

arXiv:1804.05763Physical Review ANov 28, 2018249 citations

Convex resource theory of non-Gaussianity

Ryuji Takagi, Quntao Zhuang

Continuous-variable systems realized in quantum optics play a major role in quantum information processing, and it is also one of the promising candidates for a scalable quantum computer. We introduce a resource theory for continuous-variable systems relevant to universal quantum computation. In our theory, easily implementable operations---Gaussian operations combined with feed-forward---are chosen to be the free operations, making the convex hull of the Gaussian states the natural free states. Since our free operations and free states cannot perform universal quantum computation, genuine non-Gaussian states---states not in the convex hull of Gaussian states---are the necessary resource states for universal quantum computation together with free operations. We introduce a monotone to quantify the genuine non-Gaussianity of resource states, in analogy to the stabilizer theory. A direct application of our resource theory is to bound the conversion rate between genuine non-Gaussian states. Finally, we give a protocol that probabilistically distills genuine non-Gaussianity---increases the genuine non-Gaussianity of resource states---only using free operations and postselection on Gaussian measurements, where our theory gives an upper bound for the distillation rate. In particular, the same protocol allows the distillation of cubic phase states, which enable universal quantum computation when combined with free operations.

arXiv:1804.04669Physical Review AJun 25, 2018194 citations

Deterministic Gaussian conversion protocols for non-Gaussian single-mode resources

Oliver Hahn, Patric Holmvall, Pascal Stadler +2 more

In the context of quantum technologies over continuous variables, Gaussian states and operations are typically regarded as freely available, as they are relatively easily accessible experimentally. In contrast, the generation of non-Gaussian states, as well as the implementation of non-Gaussian operations, pose significant challenges. This divide has motivated the introduction of resource theories of non-Gaussianity. As for any resource theory, it is of practical relevance to identify free conversion protocols between resources, namely, Gaussian conversion protocols between non-Gaussian states. Via systematic numerical investigations, we address the approximate conversion between experimentally relevant single-mode non-Gaussian states via arbitrary deterministic one-to-one mode Gaussian maps. First we show that cat and binomial states are approximately equivalent for finite energy, while this equivalence was previously known only in the infinite-energy limit. Then we consider the generation of cat states from photon-added and photon-subtracted squeezed states, improving over known schemes by introducing additional squeezing operations. The numerical tools that we develop also allow one to devise conversions of trisqueezed into cubic-phase states beyond previously reported performances. Finally, we identify various other conversions which instead are not viable.

arXiv:2204.03373Physical Review AJun 27, 20226 citations

All non-Gaussian states are advantageous for channel discrimination: robustness of non-convex continuous variable quantum resources

Leah Turner, Mădălin Guţǎ, Gerardo Adesso

Abstract Which quantum phenomena are advantageous for information processing tasks? By classifying quantum states and operations as resourceful versus non-resourceful, or free, the mathematical formalism of quantum resource theories helps to address such questions. For the task of discriminating channels applied to a probe state, it has been shown that under certain conditions—namely, the set of free states being convex in any dimension or possibly non-convex but finite dimensional—every resourceful probe state can provide an advantage, quantified by a resource monotone known as generalized robustness. In this work, bypassing the limitations of previous studies, we define the generalized robustness for an arbitrary resource theory and show that it admits two operational interpretations. Firstly, it provides an upper bound on the maximal advantage in channel discrimination tasks implemented on multiple copies of the probe states. Secondly, in many physically relevant theories, it quantifies the advantage in single-copy channel discrimination tasks in a worst case scenario. We further present a general construction of multi-copy resource witnesses and provide practical methods to bound the generalized robustness in experiments. Finally, we apply our results to a key case study in continuous variable quantum information: the resource theory of non-Gaussianity. This theory is naturally defined by a set of free states (Gaussian states) that is non-convex and infinite-dimensional. Our work then shows conclusively that all non-Gaussian states can provide an advantage in some channel discrimination task, even those that are simply mixtures of Gaussian states and are typically disregarded for other quantum information tasks. To illustrate our findings, we provide exact formulas for the robustness of non-Gaussianity of Fock states, along with an analysis of the robustness for a family of non-Gaussian states within the convex hull of Gaussian states.

arXiv:2412.13011New Journal of PhysicsSep 1, 20251 citation

The role of non-Gaussian entanglement of continuous variable quantum states in quatum technologies

Michal Matulík

We present an effort to find a measure of non-Gaussianity of non-Gaussian states. We compute the difference between the logarithmic negativities of a non-Gaussian state and its Gaussified form as a non-Gaussian entanglement resource. We use the latter to assess the resource content of non-Gaussianity of experimentally relevant state - two- mode squeezed vacuum with a subtracted photon. We also used symplectic analysis to discard the Gaussian entanglement. Therefore the measure is reduced to the logarithmic negativity of a non-Gaussian state only. We compare the measure with the Wigner distribution and its negativity and discuss the results. 1

Jan 1, 20230 citations